A44670:155
A calm and sober enquiry concerning the possibility of a Trinity in the Godhead…
A calm and sober enquiry concerning the possibility of a Trinity in the Godhead in a letter to a person of worth : occasioned by the lately published considerations on the explications of the doctrine of the Trinity by Dr. Wallis, Dr. Sherlock, Dr. S--th, Dr. Cudworth, &c. ...
London: printed by J. Astwood for Tho. Parkhurst, 1694
Postscript › LETTERS TO Dr. WALLIS, Sent in 1691. › Letter 1: LETTER I.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But now may we not suppose (as that which is possible, and actually is, (for ought we know) what may be fundamental to both Consciousness and Consent, a natural union even of the numerical natures? Such an union would not infer an Unity, or Identity of these Natures, Essences, Substances, or Beings themselves. For as W. J. hath well argued, Letter, p. 5, 6. Substances upon Union are not confounded or identified, or brought to unity of Substance, but ⟨p. 113⟩continuing numerically distinct Substances acquire some mutual community or communication of operations, &c. And deferring the consideration a while what this would signify towards the unity, notwithstanding, of the Godhead, shall take notice how accommodately to our present purpose W. J. speaks in what follows, where instancing in the chief unions that are known to us, he says, Our Soul and Body are two substances really distinct, and in close union with one another. But notwithstanding this, they continue distinct substances under that union. In like manner the humane soul of Christ is in union with the Logos, or second Person of the Trinity, which we call an hypostatical Union. But neither doth this union make an unity of substance. For the two substances of the divine and humane natures continue distinct under that union. 'Tis true, he adds, which must not be allowed in the Unity of the Godhead, where there can be no plurality or multiplicity of substances. Nor do I say that it must, I only say ⟨p. 114⟩Do we know, or are we sure there is no sort of Plurality?
But now may we not suppose (as that which is possible, and actually is, (for ought we know) what may be fundamental to both Consciousness and Consent, a natural union even of the numerical natures? Such an union would not infer an Unity, or Identity of these Natures, Essences, Substances, or Beings themselves. For as W. J. hath well argued, Letter, p. 5, 6. Substances upon Union are not confounded or identify'd, or brought to unity of Substance, but ⟨p. 113⟩continuing numerically distinct Substances acquire some mutual community or communication of operations, &c. And deferring the consideration a while what this would signifie towards the unity, notwithstanding, of the Godhead, shall take notice how accommodately to our present purpose W. J. speaks in what follows, where instancing in the chief unions that are known to us, he says, Our Soul and Body are two substances really distinct, and in close union with one another. But notwithstanding this, they continue distinct substances under that union. In like manner the humane soul of Christ is in union with the Logos, or second Person of the Trinity, which we call an hypostatical Union. But neither doth this union make an unity of substance. For the two substances of the divine and humane natures continue distinct under that union. 'Tis true, he addes, which must not be allowed in the Unity of the Godhead, where there can be no plurality or multiplicity of substhaces. Nor do I say that it must, I only say