A44973:33
An humble apology for non-conformists with modest and serious reflections on the Friendly debate…
An humble apology for non-conformists with modest and serious reflections on the Friendly debate and the continuation thereof / by a lover of truth and peace.
S.l. : s.n., 1669
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
What Reason can be given, if there be no guilt in the Nonconformists, that no Answer was given to the Friendly Debate, for so long a time?
WHat Reason can be given, if there be no guilt in the Nonconformists, that no Answer was given to the Friendly Debate, for so long a time?
Answ. Bishop Bramhal, that learned Prelate, may be their Advocate in this Case; (I hope the Sons of the Church will not disdain to hearken to a Father of the Church) Those who have composed minds, free from distracting cares, and Means to maintain them, and Friends to assist them, and their Books and Notes about them; do little imagine with what difficulty poor Exiles struggle, whose minds are more intent on what they should eat to morrow, than what they should write. Bishop Bramhal of Schism, pag. 275. Besides, if an Answer had stolen forth without License, would it not have been arrested for a seeming breach of a late Act about Printing; and the Author of it, according to the Divinity and Logic of the Friendly Debate, ⟨p. 2⟩pag. 3. concluded to be neither a good Subject, nor a good Christian? (vide Deb. pag. 2. Edit. 4.)
Answ. Bishop Bramhal, that learned Prelate, may be their Advocate in this Case; (I hope the Sons of the Church will not disdain to hearken to a Father of the Church) Those who have composed minds, free from distracting cares, and Means to maintain them, and Friends to assist them, and their Books and Notes about them; do little imagine with what difficulty poor Exiles struggle, whose minds are more intent on what they should eat to morrow, than what they should write. Bishop Bramhal of Schism, pag. 275. Besides, if an Answer had stolen forth without License, would it not have been arrested for a seeming breach of a late Act about Printing; and the Author of it, according to the Divinity and Logick of the Friendly Debate, ⟨p. 2⟩pag. 3. concluded to be neither a good Subject, nor a good Christian? (vide Deb. pag. 2. Edit. 4.)
Quest. Whit Answer then can be made for printing this present Answer and Apology?
Answ. The Intent and Design of Laws, is the Conservation of the Public Peace. The Law is Just, Uniform, and no Respectre of Persons, whether Conformists, or Non-Conformists, but binds all to the Peace and Good Behaviour alike, doth not hold one Mans Hands, whilst Another cuts his Throat, or stabs him under the fifth Rib. If a Man be once and again violently assaulted, he may lawfully defend himself. The Author of the Debate hath smitten us on the one Cheek, and on the other also; hath reviled us, and with his Pen persecuted us, and said all manner of evil against us falsely. In this case, a dead and stupid silence, might argue we were verily guilty concerning the Crimes laid against us. If a man that is Charged, Indicted, and Arraigned, refuseth to plead, the Law adjudgeth him to be pressed to death. Our blessed Saviour himself Apologized for himself and his Disciples. So did Justin Martyr and Tertullian, for the Primitive Christians. The great and soul Blots which have been cast upon our Names by that Author, would not soon out, if no means or endeavours should be used to wipe them off.
Answ. The Intent and Design of Laws, is the Conservation of the Publick Peace. The Law is Just, Uniform, and no Respecter of Persons, whether Conformists, or Non-Conformists, but binds all to the Peace and Good Behaviour alike, doth not hold one Mans Hands, whilst Another cuts his Throat, or stabs him under the fifth Rib. If a Man be once and again violently assaulted, he may lawfully defend himself. The Author of the Debate hath smitten us on the one Cheek, and on the other also; hath reviled us, and with his Pen persecuted us, and said all manner of evil against us falsly. In this case, a dead and stupid silence, might argue we were verily guilty concerning the Crimes laid against us. If a man that is Charged, Indicted, and Arraigned, refuseth to plead, the Law adjudgeth him to be pressed to death. Our blessed Saviour himself Apologized for himself and his Disciples. So did Justin Martyr and Tertullian, for the Primitive Christians. The great and soul Blots which have been cast upon our Names by that Author, would not soon out, if no means or endeavors should be used to wipe them off.
Quest. But is every Transgression of a Humane Law, though but penal, so culpable of criminous as is pretended?
Answ. I humbly conceive not. And there are thousands of good Subjects, and good Christians (many of them good Sons and Daughters of the Church of England) who did eat Flesh last Lent, or last Friday, asking no Question for Conscience-sake, in reference to any penal Law or Statute in that Case; and who have not scrupled to bury their Dead in Linen, though contrary to a late Act of Parliament. And if you lay so great a Burden upon every breach of a penal Statute, how shall the Carrier long keep his Cart on Wheels, or the Citizen long stand on his Legs for want of Trading, by reason of an Act of Parliament requiring the Tire of the Wheels to be four Inches wide, under the penalty of forty Shillings for each offence?
Answ. I humbly conceive not. And there are thousands of good Subjects, and good Christians (many of them good Sons and Daughters of the Church of England) who did eat Flesh last Lent, or last Fryday, asking no Question for Conscience-sake, in reference to any penal Law or Statute in that Case; and who have not scrupled to bury their Dead in Linen, though contrary to a late Act of Parliament. And if you lay so great a Burthen upon every breach of a penal Statute, how shall the Carrier long keep his Cart on Wheels, or the Citizen long stand on his Legs for want of Trading, by reason of an Act of Parliament requiring the Tire of the Wheels to be four Inches wide, under the penalty of forty Shillings for each offence?
Quest. Is it not therefore enough to satisfy the Law to pay the Mulct or Penalty required in such Cases? (Vide Contin. pag. 22.)
Quest. Is it not therefore enough to satisfie the Law to pay the Mulct or Penalty required in such Cases? (Vide Contin. pag. 22.)
Answ. Mr. Perkins, famous both at Home and Abroad, for his great Piety and Learning, hath amongst his Cases of Conscience, this Case: Whether Students in Colleges, and Members of Corporations, are tied to observance of their Local Statutes, under pain of Perjury? In resolving whereof, he hath something useful, and pertinent to our purpose: He saith, That Statutes are of two sorts, Principal and Fundamental, or less principal; the first sort, belonging to the Being of the Society, are necessary to be kept under pain of Perjury: As ⟨p. 4⟩to the lest principal, namely, Statutes that are for Order and Decency, the Founder er Law-Maker exacts not Obedience simply, but either Obedience or the Penalty; because the Penalty is as much beneficial to the state of the Body, as the other, that is, as actual Obedience: And in this Case, he doth not charge the Breach of any Local Statute with the crime of Perjury. And Bishop Taylor, in his Rule of holy Living, Chap. 3. pag. 183. saith thus: As long as the Law is obligatory, so long our Obedience is due; and he that begins a contrary Custom without reason, sinneth: But he that breaks the Law when the Custom is entered and fixed, is excused; because 'tis supposed the Legislative Power consents, when by not punishing, it suffers Disobedience to grow up to a Custom. And I have formerly learnt it for good Divinity, That every mere or bare Omission to do a thing required by Law, is not a sin, (extra casum scandali & contemptus) provided it be not done scandalously and contemptuously, or with offence to our weak Brother, and in contempt of the Magistrate.
Answ. Mr. Perkins, famous both at Home and Abroad, for his great Piety and Learning, hath amongst his Cases of Conscience, this Case: Whether Students in Colledges, and Members of Corporations, are tied to observance of their Local Statutes, under pain of Perjury? In resolving whereof, he hath something useful, and pertinent to our purpose: He saith, That Statutes are of two sorts, Principal and Fundamental, or less principal; the first sort, belonging to the Being of the Society, are necessary to be kept under pain of Perjury: As ⟨p. 4⟩to the lest principal, namely, Statutes that are for Order and Decency, the Founder er Law-Maker exacts not Obedience simply, but either Obedience or the Penalty; because the Penalty is as much beneficial to the state of the Body, as the other, that is, as actual Obedience: And in this Case, he doth not charge the Breach of any Local Statute with the crime of Perjury. And Bishop Taylor, in his Rule of holy Living, Chap. 3. pag. 183. saith thus: As long as the Law is obligatory, so long our Obedience is due; and he that begins a contrary Custom without reason, sinneth: But he that breaks the Law when the Custom is entred and fixed, is excused; because 'tis supposed the Legislative Power consents, when by not punishing, it suffers Disobedience to grow up to a Custom. And I have formerly learnt it for good Divinity, That every meer or bare Omission to do a thing required by Law, is not a sin, (extra casum scandali & contemptus) provided it be not done scandalously and contemptuously, or with offence to our weak Brother, and in contempt of the Magistrate.
Quest. What's all this to the Case of the present Nonconformists? Do not they scandalously and contemptuously break the Laws, in dwelling in and neat London, and holding Religious Meetings, commonly called Conventicles? (Vide Debate, page 2.)
Answ. Many of them have taken the Oxford Oath, and are legally qualified to live in Corporations. ⟨p. 5⟩Others cannot possibly live in the Countries, for want of a Livelihood. I have heard of a Reverend Minister, that going abroad to seek maintenance from well-disposed Christians, being benighted, lost his Way and his Life both, being through cold starved to death. Others perhaps will plead they cannot live peaceably in the Country: I heard one, and a principal one, say, He never looked towards the City, nor ever should, if he had not been driven out of the Country. The Law of Nature teaches the Hart, the Hare, and all Creatures that are pursued, to fly to the nearest and thickest Covert, or hiding place. I have heard Huntsmen talk of giving the Hare Law; I do not well understand Forrest Law: but I believe this is not meant by it, That she shall have no mercy if she seeks to hide or to save her self by flight from those that pursue her. There are also some amongst the Nonconformists, that think themselves bound to preach the Gospel; and though they will not intrude into Churches, which are at the Magistrates disposal, yet they look upon it as their Duty to preach in private Houses: And for that in London and other Cities, the multitude of those that desire to hear, are greater than in other places, and their Meetings here may be least taken notice of, therefore probably they repair to these places of concourse. And what Fowler had not rather shoot at a Flock, than at two or three single Birds? ⟨p. 6⟩And what Fisherman would not choose father to cast his Net into the main Sea, than into a small Brook? The Quarrel of Fimbria against Scevola, was, That he would not receive the Weapon of Death far enough into his Body; and the same is the Quarrel that some of our Brethren have against us, That there being such sharp Laws made against us, we are not willing to present our naked Breasts to the point of them, and let our Brethren gage us with their Weapons, but choose rather to fly from Country to City, and from City to City, to hide our selves. Some there are, who can say they hold no Meetings contrary to Law. There are that hold some private Meetings, but first they and their Auditors go to Church, and hear Common-Prayer and Sermon there.
Answ. Many of them have taken the Oxford Oath, and are legally qualified to live in Corporations. ⟨p. 5⟩Others cannot possibly live in the Countries, for want of a Livelihood. I have heard of a Reverend Minister, that going abroad to seek maintenance from well-disposed Christians, being benighted, lost his Way and his Life both, being through cold starved to death. Others perhaps will plead they cannot live peaceably in the Country: I heard one, and a principal one, say, He never looked towards the City, nor ever should, if he had not been driven out of the Country. The Law of Nature teaches the Hart, the Hare, and all Creatures that are pursued, to fly to the nearest and thickest Covert, or hiding place. I have heard Huntsmen talk of giving the Hare Law; I do not well understand Forrest Law: but I believe this is not meant by it, That she shall have no mercy if she seeks to hide or to save her self by flight from those that pursue her. There are also some amongst the Nonconformists, that think themselves bound to preach the Gospel; and though they will not intrude into Churches, which are at the Magistrates disposal, yet they look upon it as their Duty to preach in private Houses: And for that in London and other Cities, the multitude of those that desire to hear, are greater than in other places, and their Meetings here may be least taken notice of, therfore probably they repair to these places of concourse. And what Fowler had not rather shoot at a Flock, than at two or three single Birds? ⟨p. 6⟩And what Fisherman would not chuse father to cast his Net into the main Sea, than into a small Brook? The Quarrel of Fimbria against Scevola, was, That he would not receive the Weapon of Death far enough into his Body; and the same is the Quarrel that some of our Brethren have against us, That there being such sharp Laws made against us, we are not willing to present our naked Brests to the point of them, and let our Brethren gage us with their Weapons, but chuse rather to fly from Country to City, and from City to City, to hide our selves. Some there are, who can say they hold no Meetings contrary to Law. There are that hold some private Meetings, but first they and their Auditors go to Church, and hear Common-Prayer and Sermon there.
Most of those that do otherwise may be supposed to be in and about London, where, by reason of the burning of above fourscore Parish Churches, the Churches that remain may not be capacious enough to receive or hold all the Inhabitants, and besides may possibly be at inconvenient distances from their present Habitations. If you say, That the Old Nonconformists, when they were silenced by the Bishops, forbore to preach, and justified their silence against the Brownists who accused them for it. To this may be replied, That the number of Ejected Ministers formerly, were not comparable to what i• is now; usually not one to one hundred, to wha• ⟨p. 7⟩it is in our days. Besides, the People that are dissatisfied with the Liturgy or Ceremonies now, are ten, if not a hundred to one, to what they were formerly. What shall Ministers do in this Case? Our Saviour when he saw the multitudes, had compassion on them, because they were as Sheep Without a Shepherd. Had you rather that Quakers and Romish Seducers should gather up Multitudes; and that Taverns, Alehouses, and worse places, should on the Lords day be filled with the number of those that absent themselves from the public Assemblies, rather than that they should be tolerated to hear a Sermon of Faith and Repentance, and other Duties towards God, and of Loyalty to the King, of Love and Charity one towards another, in a private house? For my own part, I confess in this Case, I would much rather go learn what that means, The Harvest truly is great, and the Labourers are few: pray ye therefore the Lord of the Harvest, that he would send forth Labourers into his Harvest. Again, it is to be considered, that Mr. Dod, Mr. Hildersham, and others, were silenced formerly but in some Dioceses, and for some time; afterwards they got diverse times liberty to preach. Mr. Cotton had a License to preach, under the Broad Seal of England, procured by Bishop Williams, then Lord Keeper, notwithstanding his inconformity. Mr. Cartwright notwithstanding he had writ so much, and so sharply against Conformity, was suffered ⟨p. 8⟩to preach, and enjoyed a place of Master of an Hospital at Warwick to his dying day. Yea, Mr. Brown, the Father of the Brownists, if we believe the Historian, was suffered to keep a Living, and that no mean one, (A church in Northamptonshire) to his Death.
Most of those that do otherwise may be supposed to be in and about London, where, by reason of the burning of above fourscore Parish Churches, the Churches that remain may not be capacious enough to receive or hold all the Inhabitants, and besides may possibly be at inconvenient distances from their present Habitations. If you say, That the Old Nonconformists, when they were silenc'd by the Bishops, forbore to preach, and justified their silence against the Brownists who accused them for it. To this may be replied, That the number of Ejected Ministers formerly, were not comparable to what i• is now; usually not one to one hundred, to wha• ⟨p. 7⟩it is in our days. Besides, the People that are dissatisfied with the Liturgy or Ceremonies now, are ten, if not a hundred to one, to what they were formerly. What shall Ministers do in this Case? Our Saviour when he saw the multitudes, had compassion on them, because they were as Sheep Without a Shepherd. Had you rather that Quakers and Romish Seducers should gather up Multitudes; and that Taverns, Alehouses, and worse places, should on the Lords day be filled with the number of those that absent themselves from the publick Assemblies, rather than that they should be tolerated to hear a Sermon of Faith and Repentance, and other Duties towards God, and of Loyalty to the King, of Love and Charity one towards another, in a private house? For my own part, I confess in this Case, I would much rather go learn what that means, The Harvest truly is great, and the Labourers are few: pray ye therefore the Lord of the Harvest, that he would send forth Labourers into his Harvest. Again, it is to be considered, that Mr. Dod, Mr. Hildersham, and others, were silenced formerly but in some Diocesses, and for some time; afterwards they got diverse times liberty to preach. Mr. Cotton had a License to preach, under the Broad Seal of England, procured by Bishop Williams, then Lord Keeper, notwithstanding his inconformity. Mr. Cartwright notwithstanding he had writ so much, and so sharply against Conformity, was suffered ⟨p. 8⟩to preach, and enjoyed a place of Master of an Hospital at Warwick to his dying day. Yea, Mr. Brown, the Father of the Brownists, if we believe the Historian, was suffered to keep a Living, and that no mean one, (Achurch in Northamptonshire) to his Death.
The Bishops in those days, if they turned Men out of their Pulpits, let them have a Livelihood; either some way from their Livings, or else permitted them, or connived at least, at their teaching of School. My Schoolmaster at a Grammar-School, was one that had left a Living, rather man he would Conform. And 'tis storied of old Mr. John Fox, by Doctor Heplin, that though he refused to subscribe to any thing but the Greek Testament, yet he enjoyed his Prebends place in Salisbury till his dying day.
The Bishops in those dayes, if they turned Men out of their Pulpits, let them have a Livelihood; either some way from their Livings, or else permitted them, or connived at least, at their teaching of School. My Schoolmaster at a Grammar-School, was one that had left a Living, rather man he would Conform. And 'tis storied of old Mr. John Fox, by Doctor Heplin, that though he refused to subscribe to any thing but the Greek Testament, yet he enjoyed his Prebends place in Salisbury till his dying day.
'Tis worthy our notice, that these mens Yoke was more easy than ours: And that notwithstanding they are thought to be of different Principles from the present Nonconformists, yet certain it is, that they held it lawful to preach and pray, and keep days of Humiliation in private Houses. And I was told by one Mr. W. That he never had any other Ordination but Prayers and Imposition of hand• by old Mr. Dod, and some other Ministers his Friends, in a private House.
'Tis worthy our notice, that these mens Yoak was more easie than ours: And that notwithstanding they are thought to be of different Principles from the present Nonconformists, yet certain it is, that they held it lawful to preach and pray, and keep days of Humiliation in private Houses. And I was told by one Mr. W. That he never had any other Ordination but Prayers and Imposition of hand• by old Mr. Dod, and some other Ministers his Friends, in a private House.
Upon the consideration of the Premises, my hearts desire is, That the present Age may labour to imitate and surpass the Age past; the Right Reverend the Bishops, their Predecessors, ⟨p. 9⟩in their Forbearance and Moderation; and the Nonconformists theirs, in their Meekness and Peaceableness: That the Bishops would endeavour to be Reconcilers, and Repairers of out Breaches, and Restorers of our Pulpits to preach in; and that the Nonconformists would desire nothing but what may become Sons of Peace, and such as earnestly long after Unity, and had much rather, as becomes Labourers, be admitted to work in the Vineyard, than to stand any longer idle in the Market-place: Or, as becomes Fishers of Men, to be casting their Nets on the right side of the Ship, than to sit any longer mending their Nets on the Shore. That so the Ages to come, when they shall read the History of this Generation, when we all (Conformists and Nonconformists) are laid down to rest quietly together in our Graves, may have no occasion to rise up and say, That whereas the late War had made its thousands of Separatists, Rigid Conformity had made its ten thousands; And all this too, during the peaceable Reign of our most Gracious Sovereign, (a Son of Peace) CHARLES the Clement; as he hath manifested himself, by his Royal Letters and Declaration from Breda, his Royal Declarations since, and his present Princely Clemency: And this too, notwithstanding great Animosities, Exasperations, and Irritations of some, on the one hand, out of an inordinate Zeal; and many Weaknesses, Follies, and Provocations ⟨p. 10⟩of some on the other, for lack of Knowledge.
Upon the consideration of the Premises, my hearts desire is, That the present Age may labour to imitate and surpass the Age past; the Right Reverend the Bishops, their Predecessors, ⟨p. 9⟩in their Forbearance and Moderation; and the Nonconformists theirs, in their Meekness and Peaceableness: That the Bishops would endeavour to be Reconcilers, and Repairers of out Breaches, and Restorers of our Pulpits to preach in; and that the Nonconformists would desire nothing but what may become Sons of Peace, and such as earnestly long after Unity, and had much rather, as becomes Labourers, be admitted to work in the Vineyard, than to stand any longer idle in the Market-place: Or, as becomes Fishers of Men, to be casting their Nets on the right side of the Ship, than to sit any longer mending their Nets on the Shore. That so the Ages to come, when they shall read the History of this Generation, when we all (Conformists and Nonconformists) are laid down to rest quietly together in our Graves, may have no occasion to rise up and say, That whereas the late War had made its thousands of Separatists, Rigid Conformity had made its ten thousands; And all this too, during the peaceable Reign of our most Gracious Soveraign, (a Son of Peace) CHARLES the Clement; as he hath manifested himself, by his Royal Letters and Declaration from Breda, his Royal Declarations since, and his present Princely Clemency: And this too, notwithstanding great Animosities, Exasperations, and Irritations of some, on the one hand, out of an inordinate Zeal; and many Weaknesses, Follies, and Provocations ⟨p. 10⟩of some on the other, for lack of Knowledge.
Quest. Are not the Non-conforming-Ministers, who hold Private Meetings, Schismatics, and Sectaries, and Breakers of the Peace and Unity of the Church? Vide Deb. p. 211.
Quest. Are not the Non-conforming-Ministers, who hold Private Meetings, Schismaticks, and Sectaries, and Breakers of the Peace and Unity of the Church? Vide Deb. p. 211.
Answ. 'Tis a sign of exasperation (saith my Lord Bacon, upon the like difference) to condemn the contrary part as a Sect; yea, and some indiscreet persons have been bold in open preaching, to use dishonourable and derogative speech and censure of the Churches abroad; and that so far, at that some of our Men (as I have heard) ordained in foreign Parts, have been pronounced to be no lawful Ministers So he. And further, Let's remember (saith the same judicious Author) that the ancient and true Bonds of Unity, are, One Faith, one Baptism; and not, One Ceremony, one Policy: And endeavour to comprehend that saying, Differentia Rituum commendat unitatem Doctrinae; Christs Coat was indeed without Seam, yet the Churches Garment was of divers Colours. The Presbyterian and Congregational Nonconformists do profess to agree in the main Doctrine with the Church of England, contained in her Articles of Religion, so as fully to embrace, and constantly to adhere unto what is purely Doctrinal in them. Besides, the Presbyterians do not separate from the Church, so as to set up Church against Church, Altar against Altar; but being thrust out of the Church themselves, and the number of men and women dissatisfied ⟨p. 11⟩about either some passages or Ceremonies in the Liturgy, so that they dare not receive the Sacrament in the way required in the public Assemblies, being very great; they take occasion to meet for Religious Exercises in private, for a time only, till a door be opened for them in the Church, by the removal of some supposed or real Corruptions in the public Worship. And the reason why some (whilst they continue in the City) do not frequent the Public Assemblies, may be this; Because they are here by connivance only, and dare not be seen openly to out-face a Law: But when they are in the Country, they join with the Congregation where they reside pro tempore, to show their Union with the Church, and Conformity to the Laws. Nor are they therefore to be judged Schismatics, because they still hold internal Communion with all Christians, and so with the Church of England, with whom in some things they conceive they cannot communicate externally. And there is not (saith a Learned Bishop) so great Conformity to be expected in Ceremonies, as in the Essentials of Sacraments. The Separation of the N.C. from the Ch. of Engl. is not total, nor perpetual;
Answ. 'Tis a sign of exasperation (saith my Lord Bacon, upon the like difference) to condemn the contrary part as a Sect; yea, and some indiscreet persons have been bold in open preaching, to use dishonourable and derogative speech and censure of the Churches abroad; and that so far, at that some of our Men (as I have heard) ordained in forraign Parts, have been pronounced to be no lawful Ministers So he. And further, Let's remember (saith the same judicious Author) that the ancient and true Bonds of Unity, are, One Faith, one Baptism; and not, One Ceremony, one Policy: And endeavour to comprehend that saying, Differentia Rituum commendat unitatem Doctrinae; Christs Coat was indeed without Seam, yet the Churches Garment was of divers Colours. The Presbyterian and Congregational Nonconformists do profess to agree in the main Doctrine with the Church of England, contained in her Articles of Religion, so as fully to embrace, and constantly to adhere unto what is purely Doctrinal in them. Besides, the Presbyterians do not separate from the Church, so as to set up Church against Church, Altar against Altar; but being thrust out of the Church themselves, and the number of men and women dissatisfied ⟨p. 11⟩about either some passages or Ceremonies in the Lyturgy, so that they dare not receive the Sacrament in the way required in the publick Assemblies, being very great; they take occasion to meet for Religious Exercises in private, for a time onely, till a door be opened for them in the Church, by the removal of some supsosed or real Corruptions in the publick Worship. And the reason why some (whilst they continue in the City) do not frequent the Publick Assemblies, may be this; Because they are here by connivance onely, and dare not be seen openly to out-face a Law: But when they are in the Countrey, they joyn with the Congregation where they reside protempore, to shew their Union with the Church, and Conformity to the Laws. Nor are they therefore to be judged Schismaticks, because they still hold internal Communion with all Christians, and so with the Church of England, with whom in some things they conceive they cannot communicate externally. And there is not (saith a Learned Bishop) so great Conformity to be expected in Ceremonies, as in the Essentials of Sacraments. The Separation of the N.C. from the Ch. of Engl. is not total, nor perpetual;