A47602:24
Pedo-baptism disproved being an answer to two printed papers (put forth by some gentlemen…
Pedo-baptism disproved being an answer to two printed papers (put forth by some gentlemen called the Athenian Society, who pretend to answer all questions sent to them of what nature soever) called the Athenian Mercury, one put forth November 14, the other November 28, 1691 : in which papers they pretend to answer eight queries about the lawfulness of infant-baptism : likewise divers queries sent to them about the true subjects of baptism, &c.
London : Printed for the author, and sold by John Harris ..., 1691
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But alas, this it seems is not the thing; 'tis not so much to prove Baptism to be the Antitype of Circumcision, as 'tis to prove Baptism to be the continuation of a Jewish Custom: for to speak more properly, you intimate, that to this purpose, you mention these things. Sure all understanding Men, as well Pedo-Baptists as others, must needs loath your Notion; but I know you are not alone herein, there are some others who have asserted the same thing; which perhaps encouraged you thus to write: But to correct your Rashness, and silence you and them too, consider what I and the fore-mentioned Gentleman have said. Is it not enough that Infant-Baptism should be built upon no better a Foundation than the Tradition of the Apostate Gentile Church, and the Decrees of Popes and General Councils, but that it must also be grounded on the erroneous Customs of the Jewish Talmud? But to proceed, that ⟨p. 5⟩Circumcision may answer, or run Parallel with Baptism, you bring in the Practice of some Heathen Nations who circumcised their Females. We shall have it anon; The truth is, the Proof and Explanation of Infant-Baptism shall be sufficiently made out before you have done; if fabulous and erroneous Traditions of Jews, Heathens, and Apostate Christians will do it: but if no better Authority or Proof can be brought for it than what is contained in your Mercury, 'tis time for all good Christians with Shame enough to cast it off. Should I tell my Reader why some Heathens circumcised their Females, it might greatly expose you. But to close with your first Question, take what Dr. Jer. Taylor, la•e Bishop of Down, hath said upon this Conceit, i. e. that Circumcision figured Baptism; these are his words, viz. The Argument, saith he, from Circumcision is invalid upon infinite Considerations: Figures and Types prove nothing, unless a Command go along with them, or some Express to signify such to be their purpose: for the Deluge of Waters, and the Ark of Noah, were Figures of Baptism, saith Peter. If therefore the Circumstances of the one should be drawn to the other, we should make Baptism a Prodigy rather than a Rite. The Paschal Lamb was a Figure of the Eucharist, which succeeds the other, as Baptism doth to Circumcision:
But alas, this it seems is not the thing; 'tis not so much to prove Baptism to be the Antitype of Circumcision, as 'tis to prove Baptism to be the continuation of a Jewish Custom: for to speak more properly, you intimate, that to this purpose, you mention these things. Sure all understanding Men, as well Pedo-Baptists as others, must needs loath your Notion; but I know you are not alone herein, there are some others who have asserted the same thing; which perhaps incouraged you thus to write: But to correct your Rashness, and silence you and them too, consider what I and the fore-mentioned Gentleman have said. Is it not enough that Infant-Baptism should be built upon no better a Foundation than the Tradition of the Apostate Gentile Church, and the Decrees of Popes and General Councils, but that it must also be grounded on the erronious Customs of the Jewish Talmud? But to proceed, that