A47602:46
Pedo-baptism disproved being an answer to two printed papers (put forth by some gentlemen…
Pedo-baptism disproved being an answer to two printed papers (put forth by some gentlemen called the Athenian Society, who pretend to answer all questions sent to them of what nature soever) called the Athenian Mercury, one put forth November 14, the other November 28, 1691 : in which papers they pretend to answer eight queries about the lawfulness of infant-baptism : likewise divers queries sent to them about the true subjects of baptism, &c.
London : Printed for the author, and sold by John Harris ..., 1691
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Thus both your Arguments from universal Consent and Antiquity, the Learned Doctor hath sufficiently answered. And I rather let him answer you, than to answer you in my own words, thinking what he says, may be more regarded by some than what I say▪ But to prove from Antiquity, that Infant-Baptism was practised in the first, second and third Centuries, you say you are able to demonstrate, and that there was never any particular Congregation of Anabaptists till about three hundred years after Christ; and seem to build much upon these three last Arguments.
Reply. If you had said there were no Baptized Congregations, i. e. such who only baptized Believers, you had asserted a great Untruth, sith all the Primitive Apostolical Churches were such, none being admitted to Baptism for the first and second Centuries, but the Adult, i. e. such who professed their Faith, as in due time may be sufficiently proved, notwithstanding all your Flourish and Pretences; but suppose it be granted there were no Congregations till then called Anabaptists, what doth that signify? it was because there were not till about that time any (as […] […] and divers others say) who practised Pedo-baptism. Baptists could not be called Anabaptists, or Re-baptizers, till there were some who […] for Infant-Baptism; so that this directly makes against you. Moreover, many Rites which you disown as human Traditions, crept very early into the World, and were practised generally too in the Apostasy of the Church.
Reply. If you had said there were no Baptized Congregations, i. e. such who only baptized Believers, you had asserted a great Untruth, sith all the Primitive Apostolical Churches were such, none being admitted to Baptism for the first and second Centuries, but the Adult, i. e. such who professed their Faith, as in due time may be sufficiently proved, notwithstanding all your Flourish and Pretences; but suppose it be granted there were no Congregations till then called Anabaptists, what doth that signify? it was because there were not till about that time any (as 〈…〉 〈…〉 and divers others say) who practised Pedo-baptism. Baptists could not be called Anabaptists, or Re-baptizers, till there were some who for Infant-Baptism; so that this directly makes against you. Moreover, many Rites which you disown as human Traditions, crept very early into the World, and were practised generally too in the Apostacy of the Church.