A47602:78
Pedo-baptism disproved being an answer to two printed papers (put forth by some gentlemen called the Athenian Society, who pretend to answer all questions sent to them of what nature soever) called the Athenian Mercury, one put forth November 14, the other November 28, 1691 : in which papers they pretend to answer eight queries about the lawfulness of infant-baptism : likewise divers queries sent to them about the true subjects of baptism, &c.
London : Printed for the author, and sold by John Harris ..., 1691
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
If so, I query, Whether Circumcision was an Ordinance that appertained to the Covenant of Grace, and was the Seal of it? 1. Because 'tis contradistinguished from the Covenant of Grace, or free Promise of God, Rom. 4. 2. And 'tis also called a Yoke of Bondage. And, 3. 'Tis said also, that he that was circumcised, was a Debtor to keep the whole Law. And, 4. Because Ishmael, who was not a Child of the Covenant of Grace with Esau, and many others, yet were required to be circumcised as well as Isaac. And, 5. Since 'tis positively said Faith was imputed to Abraham for Righteousness not in Circumcision, How was it imputed then, when he was circumcised, or uncircumcise•• not when he was circumcised, but when he was uncircumcised. Rom. 4. 10.
If so, I query, Whether Circumcision was an Ordinance that appertained to the Covenant of Grace, and was the Seal of it? 1. Because 'tis contradistinguished from the Covenant of Grace, or free Promise of God, Rom. 4. 2. And 'tis also called a Yoke of Bondage. And, 3. 'Tis said also, that he that was circumcised, was a Debter to keep the whole Law. And, 4. Because Ishmael, who was not a Child of the Covenant of Grace with Esau, and many others, yet were required to be circumcised as well as Isaac. And, 5. Since 'tis positively said Faith was imputed to Abraham for Righteousness not in Circumcision, How was it imputed then, when he was circumcised, or uncircumcise•• not when he was circumcised, but when he was uncircumcised. Rom. 4. 10.
Secondly; Whether the being the Male-Children of Believers, as such, gave them right to Circumcision, or not rather the nicer positive Command of God to Abraham; since we do not read of any other Godly Man's Seed in Abraham's days, or since, had any right thereto, but only such who were born in his House, or bought with his Money?
Secondly; Whether the being the Male-Children of Believers, as such, gave them right to Circumcision, or not rather the nicer positive Command of God to Abraham; since we do not read of any other Godly Man's Seed in Abraham's days, or since, had any right thereto, but only such who were born in his House, or bought with his Mony?
Thirdly; Whether Circumcision could be said to be the Seal of any Man's Faith save Abraham's only, seeing 'tis said, he received the Sign of Circumcision, a Seal of the Righteousness of the Faith he had [mark] yet being uncircumcised, that he might be the Father of all that believe; which was the Privilege of Abraham ••ly: for how could Circumcision be a Seal to Children of that Faith they had before circumcised, seeing they had no Faith at all, as had Abraham their Father, they being obliged by the Law of God to be circumcised at eight days old •
Thirdly; Whether Circumcision could be said to be the Seal of any Man's Faith save Abraham's only, seeing 'tis said, he received the Sign of Circumcision, a Seal of the Righteousness of the Faith he had [mark] yet being uncircumcisied, that he might be the Father of all that believe; which was the Priviledg of Abraham ••ly: for how could Circumcision be a Seal to Children of that Faith they had before circumcised, seeing they had no Faith at all, as had Abraham their Father, they being obliged by the Law of God to be circumcised at eight days old •
Fourthly; What is it which you conceive Circumcision did, or Baptism doth seal to Children, or make sure; since a Seal usually makes firm all the Blessings or Privileges contained in that Covenant 'tis prefixed to? Doubtless if the Fleshly Seed of Believers, as such, are in the Covenant of Grace, and have the Seal of it, they shall be saved; because we are agreed, that the Covenant of Grace is well ordered in all things, and sure, there is no final falling, therefore how should any of them miss of eternal Life? and yet we see many of them prove wicked and ungodly, and so live and die. If you say it seals only the external Part and Privileges of the Covenant of Grace:
Fourthly; What is it which you conceive Circumcision did, or Baptism doth seal to Children, or make sure; since a Seal usually makes firm all the Blessings or Priviledges contained in that Covenant 'tis prefix'd to? Doubtless if the Fleshly Seed of Believers, as such, are in the Covenant of Grace, and have the Seal of it, they shall be saved; because we are agreed, that the Covenant of Grace is well ordered in all things, and sure, there is no final falling, therefore how should any of them miss of eternal Life? and yet we see many of them prove wicked and ungodly, and so live and die. If you say it seals only the external Part and Priviledges of the Covenant of Grace:
Fifthly; I demand to know what those External Privileges are, seeing they are denied the Sacrament of the Lord's-Supper, and all other External Rites whatsoever? if you say when they believe that shall partake of […] Blessings; so, say I, shall the […] believers as well as they.
Fifthly; I demand to know what those External Priviledges are, seeing they are denied the Sacrament of the Lord's-Supper, and all other External Rites whatsoever? if you say when they believe that shall partake of 〈…〉 Blessings; so, say I, shall the 〈…〉 believers as well as they.
Sixthly; If the Fleshly Seed, or Children of believing Gentiles, as such, are to be accounted the Seed of Abraham; I query, Whether they are his Natural Seed, or his Spiritual Seed? if not his Natural Seed, nor his Spiritual Seed, what right can they have to Baptism, or Church-Membership, from any Covenant-Transactions God made with Abraham?—
Seventhly; Whether those different grounds upon which the Right of Infant-Baptism is pretended by the Fathers of old, and the Modern Divines, doth well agree with an Institution that is a mere positive Rite, depending wholly on the Will of the Legislator, ⟨p. 15⟩doth not give just cause to all to question its Authority?
Seventhly; Whether those different grounds upon which the Right of Infant-Baptism is pretended by the Fathers of old, and the Modern Divines, doth well agree with an Institution that is a meer positive Rite, depending wholly on the Will of the Legislator, ⟨p. 15⟩doth not give just cause to all to question its Authority?
1. Some Pedo-Baptists asserted, It took away Original Sin, and such who denied it were anathematized. 2. Some affirm, That Children are in the Covenant; and being the Seed of Believers, are federally Holy, therefore ought to be Baptized. 3. Another so•• of Pedo Baptists say, They ought to be Bapt•••, by virtue of their Parents Faith. 4. Others affirm, They have Faith themselves, and are Disciples, and therefore must be baptized. 5. Another sort Baptize them upon the Faith of the•• Surety 6. And […] of Pedo Baptists say, It […] Power and Authori•• 7. […] that, […] affirm▪ […] the Word […] God […] Institution, the […] divided and […] themselves.
1. Some Pedo-Baptists asserted, It took away Original Sin, and such who denied it were anathematized. 2. Some affirm, That Children are in the Covenent; and being the Seed of Believers, are federally Holy, therefore ought to be Baptized. 3. Another so•• of Pedo Baptists say, They ought to be Bapt•••, by virtue of their Parents Faith. 4. Others affirm, They have Faith themselves, and are Disciples, and therefore must be baptized. 5. Another sort Baptize them upon the Faith of the•• Sureti• 6. And 〈…〉 of Pedo Baptists say, It 〈…〉 Power and Authori•• 7. 〈…〉 that, 〈…〉 affirm▪ 〈…〉 the Word 〈…〉 God 〈…〉 Institution, the 〈…〉 divided and 〈…〉 themselves.
Eighthly; Is it not an evil thing, and very absurd for any to say▪ Baptism is a Symbol of present Regeneration, and yet apply it to Babes, in whom nothing of the things signified thereby doth or can appear? And also to say, I Baptize thee in the Name, &c. when indeed he doth not Baptize, but only Rantize the Child? and to say Baptism is a lively Figure of Christ's Death, Burial, and Resurrection, and yet only sprinkle or pour a little Water upon the Face of the Child?
Ninthly; Whether that can be an Ordinance of Christ, for which there is neither Command nor Example in all the Word of God, no••• Promise ••de to such who do it, nor Th•••s denounced on such who neglect it or do it […]? For though there are both Promises made to Believers Baptized, and Threa•• denounced on such who neglect it, yet where are there any such in respect of Infant-Baptism?
Ninthly; Whether that can be an Ordinance of Christ, for which there is neither Command nor Example in all the Word of God, no••• Promise ••de to such who do it, nor Th•••s denounced on such who neglect it or do it 〈…〉? For though there are both Promises made to Believers Baptized, and Threa•• denounced on such who neglect it, yet where are there any such in respect of Infant-Baptism?
Tenthly; Whether a Pagan, or Indian, who should attain to the knowledge of the Greek Tongue, or of the English, or any other Tongue into which the Original should be translated, by reading over the New Testament a thousand times he could ever find Infants ought to be Baptized; if not, how doth it appear the Faith of People about Pedo-Baptism stands in the Power of God, and knowledge of his Word, and not rather in the Wisdom of Men, who having endeavoured, with all the Art and Cunning they can, to draw pretended Consequences for it, tho after all they do not naturally and genuinely follow […] the Premises to which they refer?
Tenthly; Whether a Pagan, or Indian, who should attain to the knowledg of the Greek Tongue, or of the English, or any other Tongue into which the Original should be translated, by reading over the New Testament a thousand times he could ever find Infants ought to be Baptized; if not, how doth it appear the Faith of People about Pedo-Baptism stands in the Power of God, and knowledg of his Word, and not rather in the Wisdom of Men, who having endeavoured, with all the Art and Cunning they can, to draw pretended Consequences for it, tho after all they do not naturally and genuinely follow 〈…〉 the Premises to which they refer?
[…]; Whether Christ having […] the Qualifications •• such as […] Baptized, viz. actual Repentance, […] and the Answer of a good Consci[…] ▪ doth not thereby exclude all those […] not capable of those Qualifications?
〈…〉; Whether Christ having 〈…〉 the Qualifications •• such as 〈…〉 Baptized, viz. actual Repentance, 〈…〉 and the Answer of a good Consci〈…〉 ▪ doth not thereby exclude all those 〈…〉 not capable of those Qualifications?
[…]; Whether it doth not reflect up•• the Care, Wisdom, and Faithfulness of Jesus Christ, who as a Son over his own House, exceeded the Care and Faithfulness of Moses, to affirm, Infants ought to be Baptized, and yet it cannot be found in all the Ne• […] an it be […] should be a Gospe•• receipt, nay, a […], and yet Christ speak nothing of it? or could it be in the Commission, and yet the Apostlet never to mention it, but contrariwise, require Faith••• all they admitted to Baptism? Paul says, He declared the whole Counsel of God, and said nothing of it in any of his Epistles, nor any where else. How many thousands of Children were born to baptized •••ievers, from the time of Christ's Ascension, to the time John ••••e the Revelations, but not one word of […] one Child Baptized?
〈…〉; Whether it doth not reflect up•• the Care, Wisdom, and Faithfulness of Jesus Christ, who as a Son over his own House, exceeded the Care and Faithfulness of Moses, to affirm, Infants ought to be Baptized, and yet it cannot be found in all the Ne• 〈…〉 an it be 〈…〉 should be a Gospe•• recept, nay, a 〈…〉, and yet Christ speak nothing of it? or could it be in the Commission, and yet the Apostlet never to mention it, but contrariwise, require Faith••• all they admitted to Baptism? Paul says, He declared the whole Counsel of God, and said nothing of it in any of his Epistles, nor any where else. How many thousands of Children were born to baptized •••ievers, from the time of Christ's Ascension, to the time John ••••e the Revelations, but not one word of 〈…〉 one Child Baptized?
Thirteen; Whether in matter of positive Right, such as Baptism is, we ought not •• keep expressly and punctually to the Revelation of the Will of the Law-giver?
Thirteen; Whether in matter of positive Right, such as Baptism is, we ought not •• keep expresly and punctually to the Revelation of the Will of the Law-giver?
Fourteen; Whether the Baptism of Infants be not a dangerous […] since it tends to deceive and blind the Ey•• of poor ignorant People, who think they are thereby made ⟨p. 16⟩Christians, and so never look after Regeneration, nor true Baptism, which represents or signifies that inward Work of Grace upon the Heart?
Fourteen; Whether the Baptism of Infants be not a dangerous 〈…〉 since it tends to deceive and blind the Ey•• of poor ignorant People, who think they are thereby made ⟨p. 16⟩Christians, and so never look after Regeneration, nor true Baptism, which represents or signifies that inward Work of Grace upon the Heart?
Fifteen; Whether the Ancient Church, who gave the Lord's Supper to Infants, as well as Baptism, might n•• •e allowed as well to do the one as the other, since Faith and Holy Habits are as much required in those who are to be Baptized, as in such who come to the Lord's Table? And all such in the Apostolic Church, who were Baptized, were immediately admitted to break Bread, &c. And also the Arguments taken from the Covenant, and because said to be Holy, and to belong to the Kingdom of Heaven, are as strong for them to receive the Lord's Supper, there being no Command nor Example for either, and human Tradition carrying it equally for both for several Centuries.
Fifteen; Whether the Ancient Church, who gave the Lord's Supper to Infants, as well as Baptism, might n•• •e allowed as well to do the one as the other, since Faith and Holy Habits are as much required in those who are to be Baptized, as in such who come to the Lord's Table? And all such in the Apostolick Church, who were Baptized, were immediately admitted to break Bread, &c. And also the Arguments taken from the Covenant, and because said to be Holy, and to belong to the Kingdom of Heaven, are as strong for them to receive the Lord's Supper, there being no Command nor Example for either, and human Tradition carrying it equally for both for several Centuries.