A47602:90
Pedo-baptism disproved being an answer to two printed papers (put forth by some gentlemen called the Athenian Society, who pretend to answer all questions sent to them of what nature soever) called the Athenian Mercury, one put forth November 14, the other November 28, 1691 : in which papers they pretend to answer eight queries about the lawfulness of infant-baptism : likewise divers queries sent to them about the true subjects of baptism, &c.
London : Printed for the author, and sold by John Harris ..., 1691
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
[…]; Whether it doth not reflect up•• the Care, Wisdom, and Faithfulness of Jesus Christ, who as a Son over his own House, exceeded the Care and Faithfulness of Moses, to affirm, Infants ought to be Baptized, and yet it cannot be found in all the Ne• […] an it be […] should be a Gospe•• receipt, nay, a […], and yet Christ speak nothing of it? or could it be in the Commission, and yet the Apostlet never to mention it, but contrariwise, require Faith••• all they admitted to Baptism? Paul says, He declared the whole Counsel of God, and said nothing of it in any of his Epistles, nor any where else. How many thousands of Children were born to baptized •••ievers, from the time of Christ's Ascension, to the time John ••••e the Revelations, but not one word of […] one Child Baptized?
〈…〉; Whether it doth not reflect up•• the Care, Wisdom, and Faithfulness of Jesus Christ, who as a Son over his own House, exceeded the Care and Faithfulness of Moses, to affirm, Infants ought to be Baptized, and yet it cannot be found in all the Ne• 〈…〉 an it be 〈…〉 should be a Gospe•• recept, nay, a 〈…〉, and yet Christ speak nothing of it? or could it be in the Commission, and yet the Apostlet never to mention it, but contrariwise, require Faith••• all they admitted to Baptism? Paul says, He declared the whole Counsel of God, and said nothing of it in any of his Epistles, nor any where else. How many thousands of Children were born to baptized •••ievers, from the time of Christ's Ascension, to the time John ••••e the Revelations, but not one word of 〈…〉 one Child Baptized?
Thirteen; Whether in matter of positive Right, such as Baptism is, we ought not •• keep expressly and punctually to the Revelation of the Will of the Law-giver?
Thirteen; Whether in matter of positive Right, such as Baptism is, we ought not •• keep expresly and punctually to the Revelation of the Will of the Law-giver?
Fourteen; Whether the Baptism of Infants be not a dangerous […] since it tends to deceive and blind the Ey•• of poor ignorant People, who think they are thereby made ⟨p. 16⟩Christians, and so never look after Regeneration, nor true Baptism, which represents or signifies that inward Work of Grace upon the Heart?
Fourteen; Whether the Baptism of Infants be not a dangerous 〈…〉 since it tends to deceive and blind the Ey•• of poor ignorant People, who think they are thereby made ⟨p. 16⟩Christians, and so never look after Regeneration, nor true Baptism, which represents or signifies that inward Work of Grace upon the Heart?
Fifteen; Whether the Ancient Church, who gave the Lord's Supper to Infants, as well as Baptism, might n•• •e allowed as well to do the one as the other, since Faith and Holy Habits are as much required in those who are to be Baptized, as in such who come to the Lord's Table? And all such in the Apostolic Church, who were Baptized, were immediately admitted to break Bread, &c. And also the Arguments taken from the Covenant, and because said to be Holy, and to belong to the Kingdom of Heaven, are as strong for them to receive the Lord's Supper, there being no Command nor Example for either, and human Tradition carrying it equally for both for several Centuries.
Fifteen; Whether the Ancient Church, who gave the Lord's Supper to Infants, as well as Baptism, might n•• •e allowed as well to do the one as the other, since Faith and Holy Habits are as much required in those who are to be Baptized, as in such who come to the Lord's Table? And all such in the Apostolick Church, who were Baptized, were immediately admitted to break Bread, &c. And also the Arguments taken from the Covenant, and because said to be Holy, and to belong to the Kingdom of Heaven, are as strong for them to receive the Lord's Supper, there being no Command nor Example for either, and human Tradition carrying it equally for both for several Centuries.
Sixteen; Whether Nadab, Abih•, and […] Transgressions were not as much Circumstantials, and so as small Errors, as to alter Dipping in •o Sprinkling; and from an understanding Believer, to a poor ignorant Babe? And whether to allow the Church a Power to make such Alterations, be not dangerous? see R••, 22. And doth […] open a Door to other innovations?
Sixteen; Whether Nadab, Abih•, and 〈…〉 Transgressions were not as much Circumstantials, and so as small Errors, as to alter Dipping in •o Sprinkling; and from an understanding Believer, to a poor ignorant Babe? And whether to allow the Church a Power to make such Alterations, be not dangerous? see R••, 22. And doth 〈…〉 open a Door to other innovations?
Seventeen; Whether there is any just Cause for Men to vilify and reproach the People called Anabaptists, for their baptizing Believers, and denying infants to be Subjects thereof, seeing they have the plain and direct Word of God to warrant their practice, i. e. not only the Commission, but also the continual usage of the Apostles and Ministers of the Gospel all along in the New Testament, who Baptized none but such who made profession of their Faith? And the Ch•••• of England also saith, Faith and Repentance. are required of such who are to be Baptized. We •••e not Baptize our Children, because we cannot find it written; 'tis from the holy Fear of God, lest we should offend and sin against him, by adding […] his Word.
Seventeen; Whether there is any just Cause for Men to vilify and reproach the People called Anabaptists, for their baprizing Believers, and denying infants to be Subjects thereof, seeing they have the plain and direct Word of God to warrant their practice, i. e. not only the Commission, but also the continual usage of the Apostles and Ministers of the Gospel all along in the New Testament, who Baptized none but such who made profession of their Faith? And the Ch•••• of England also saith, Faith and Repentance. are required of such who are to be Baptized. We •••e not Baptize our Children, because we cannot find it written; 'tis from the holy Fear of God, lest we should offend and sin against him, by adding 〈…〉 his Word.
Eighteen; What should be the reason that our faithful Translators of the Bible should leave the Greek word Baptism, or Baptisma, and not turn it into English, seeing the Dutch have not done so, but contrariwise translate, for John the Baptist, John the Dooper; and for he Baptized, he doped, or dipped them?
Eighteen; What should be the reason that our faithful Translators of the Bible should leave the Greek word Baptism, or Baptisma, and not turn it into English, seeing the Dutch have not done so, but contrariwise translate, for John the Baptist, John the Dooper; and for he Baptized, he dooped, or dipped them?
Nineteen; Whether those who translate out of one Language into another, ought not to translate every word into the same Language into which they turn it, and not leave any word in the same Original Tongue, which the People understand not, and for whose sakes they undertook that Work; and not to translate every word, but also to give the right, literal, genuine and proper signification of each word, and not the remote, improper, or collateral signification of it? Which if our Translators of the Bible had so done, I query whether the Doubt among the Unlearned, concerning what the word Baptisma signifies, […]?
Nineteen; Whether those who translate out of one Language into another, ought not to translate every word into the same Language into which they turn it, and not leave any word in the same Original Tongue, which the People understand not, and for whose sakes they undertook that Work; and not to translate every word, but also to give the right, literal, genuine and proper signification of each word, and not the remote, improper, or collateral signification of it? Which if our Translators of the Bible had so done, I query whether the Doubt among the Unlearned, concerning what the word Baptisma signifies, 〈…〉?
Twenty; Seeing the Greek Church uses Immersion & not Aspersion▪ may it not be looked upon as a great Argument against Sprinkling, especially seeing they disown the Baptism of the Latin Church, beca••• they use Sprinkling; for doubtless the Greeks best knew the genuine and proper signification of that word, that Tongue being their own natural Language in which the New Testament was wrote?
Twenty; Seeing the Greek Church uses Immersion & not Aspersion▪ may it not be look'd upon as a great Argument against Sprinkling, especially seeing they disown the Baptism of the Latin Church, beca••• they use Sprinkling; for doubtless the Greeks best knew the genuine and proper signification of that word, that Tongue being their own natural Language in which the New Testament was wrote?
21. Whether if a Minister should administer the Lord's Supper in one kind only and so doing, it cannot answer the great Design of Christ the Law-giver, i. e. the breaking of his Body, and shedding of his Blood, would not profane that Holy Institution? If so, whether such, who instead of dipping the whole Body, do but sprinkle or pour a little Water on the Face, do not also profane the holy Sacrament of Baptism, since it is not so done to represent in a lively Figure the Death, Burial and Resurrection of Christ, with our Death unto Sin, and vivification unto newness of Life? Rom. •. Col. 2. 11, 12.
21. Whether if a Minister should administer the Lord's Supper in one kind only and so doing, it cannot answer the great Design of Christ the Law-giver, i. e. the breaking of his Body, and shedding of his Blood, would not prophane that Holy Institution? If so, whether such, who instead of dipping the whole Body, do but sprinkle or pour a little Water on the Face, do not also prophane the holy Sacrament of Baptism, since it is not so done to represent in a lively Figure the Death, Burial and Resurrection of Christ, with our Death unto Sin, and vivification unto newness of Life? Rom. •. Col. 2. 11, 12.
22. Whether all such who have only been sprinkled, ought not to be deemed Unbaptized Persons, since Aspersion is not Immersion, ⟨p. 17⟩or Rantizing not Baptizing? for though the Greek word Baptizo, in a remote and improper sense may signify to wash, yet, as the Learned confess, it is such a washing as is done by dipping, swilling, or plunging the Person or Thing all over in the Water.
23. Since you say Children have Faith potentia: I query, Whether Unbelievers, and all ungodly Persons, have▪ not also the like Faith potentia as well as Children, and so the same Right to Baptism? We grant they may have Faith hereafter; what tho?
There is one Assertion and Argument laid down by you, that I omitted in my Answer; which as it is New, so it must needs expose you, viz. If God be pleased to radiate or shine upon the Souls of Children in Heaven, and they do behold the Face of God, as our Saviour says; then it follows that they have Faith in Heaven, and why not on Earth? see Heb. 11. 27. These are your very words▪ […]
There is one Assertion and Argument laid down by you, that I omitted in my Answer; which as it is New, so it must needs expose you, viz. If God be pleased to radiate or shine upon the Souls of Children in Heaven, and they do behold the Face of God, as our Saviour says; then it follows that they have Faith in Heaven, and why not on Earth? see Heb. 11. 27. These are your very words▪ 〈…〉
Reply; I had thought that in Heaven the Faith of the Adult ceases, i. e. the strong and saving Faith of Believers: Doth not the Apostle say, Then we come to receive the End of our Faith? And is not Faith turned there into Vision? Is not Faith the Evidence of Things not seen, and the Substance of Things hoped for? Heb. 11. […]. Divines say, Faith, Hope, &c. cease then, and that 'tis only Love that continues. What is it they have not received in Heaven, which they trust in God for? Nor is your Conclusion good, Had they Faith there, they may have it here. The Text you cite, Heb. 11. 27. refers to that Faith Moses had on Earth, who saw him that was Invisible. God seems so to us here; but what a sight we shall have of him in Heaven, we know not. Doth not the Apostle say, we shall behold Face to Face; and the pure in Heart shall see God? Shall that be such a sight that Moses had whilst on Earth?
Reply; I had thought that in Heaven the Faith of the Adult ceases, i. e. the strong and saving Faith of Believers: Doth not the Apostle say, Then we come to receive the End of our Faith? And is not Faith turned there into Vision? Is not Faith the Evidence of Things not seen, and the Substance of Things hoped for? Heb. 11. 〈…〉. Divines say, Faith, Hope, &c. cease then, and that 'tis only Love that continues. What is it they have not received in Heaven, which they trust in God for? Nor is your Conclusion good, Had they Faith there, they may have it here. The Text you cite, Heb. 11. 27. refers to that Faith Moses had on Earth, who saw him that was Invisible. God seems so to us here; but what a sight we shall have of him in Heaven, we know not. Doth not the Apostle say, we shall behold Face to Face; and the pure in Heart shall see God? Shall that be such a sight that Moses had whilst on Earth?
First; What reason can be given why Nazianzen, an eminent Greek Father, should counsel the deferring the Baptism of Infants, until the third or fourth Year of their Age, (except in danger of Death), if it were in Nazianzen's Time, as some suppose it-was, the Opinion of the whole Church, as also his own, that Infants, by an Apostolical Tradition, were to be baptized as such, that is, as soon as born?
First; WHat reason can be given why Nazianzen, an eminent Greek Father, should counsel the deferring the Baptism of Infants, until the third or fourth Year of their Age, (except in danger of Death), if it were in Nazianzen's Time, as some suppose it-was, the Opinion of the whole Church, as also his own, that Infants, by an Apostolical Tradition, were to be baptized as such, that is, as soon as born?