A47605:111
The rector rectified and corrected, or, Infant-baptism unlawful being a sober answer to a…
The rector rectified and corrected, or, Infant-baptism unlawful being a sober answer to a late pamphlet entitled An argumentative and practical discourse of infant-baptism, published by Mr. William Burkit, rector of Mildin in Suffolk : wherein all his arguments for pedo-baptism are refuted and the necessity of immersion, i.e. dipping, is evidenced, and the people falsely called Anabaptists are cleared from those unjust reproaches and calumnies cast upon them : together with a reply to the Athenian gazette added to their 5th volume about infant-baptism : with some remarks upon Mr. John Flavel's last book in answer to Mr. Philip Cary / by Benjamin Keach.The rector rectified and corrected, or, Infant-baptism unlawful being a sober answer to a late pamphlet entituled An argumentative and practical discourse of infant-baptism, published by Mr. William Burkit, rector of Mildin in Suffolk : wherein all his arguments for pedo-baptism are refuted and the necessity of immersion, i.e. dipping, is evidenced, and the people falsly called Anabaptists are cleared from those unjust reproaches and calumnies cast upon them : together with a reply to the Athenian gazette added to their 5th volume about infant-baptism : with some remarks upon Mr. John Flavel's last book in answer to Mr. Philip Cary / by Benjamin Keach.
London: printed by John Harris, 1692
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
5. Lastly, take what a worthy and learned Author of your own Communion hath said in Confutation of this foolish and absurd Argument for Pedo-baptism, 'tis Sir Norton Knatchbull Knight and Baronet. The thing, saith he, is uncertain, that it cannot be said of the Rabbins, that there were not several among them who differed very much about this matter; for Rabbi Eliezar expressly contradicts Rabbi Joshua, who was the first that I know of who asserted this sort of Baptism among the Jews; for Rabbi Eliezar, who was contemporary with Rabbi Joshua, if he did not live before him, asserts that a Proselyte circumcised, and not baptized, was a true Proselyte; for so we read of the Patriarchs Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, that they were circumcised, but not baptized. But Rabbi Joshua affirms, that he who was baptized, not he that was circumcised, was a true Proselyte. To whom shall I give Credit, to Eliezar, who asserts what the Scripture confirms; or to Joshua, who affirms what is no where to be found in Scripture? But the Rabbins upheld Joshua's side, and what wonder was it? for it made for their business; that is, for the Honour of the Jewish Religion, that the Christians should borrow their Ceremonies from them. But when I see Men of great Learning in these times fetching the Foundations of Truth from the Rabbins, I cannot but hesitate a little: ⟨p. 25⟩For whence was the Talmud sent us, they are the words of Buxtorf in his Synagoga Judaica, that we should give Credit thereto, that from thence we should believe that the Law of Moses either can or ought to be understood? much less the Gospel, to which they were professed Enemies. For the Talmud is called a Labyrinth of Errors, and the Foundation of Jewish Fables; it was brought to Perfection and held for authentic five hundred Years after Christ: therefore it is unreasonable to rest upon the Testimony of it. And that which moves me most, Josephus (to omit all the Fathers that lived before the Talmud was finished) who was a Jew, and contemporary with Rabbi Eliezar, who also wrote in particular of the Rites, Customs and Acts of the Jews, is altogether silent in this matter. So that it is an Argument to me next to a Demonstration, that two such eminent Persons, both Jews, and living at the same time, the one should positively deny, and the other makes mention of Baptism among the Jews.
5. Lastly, take what a worthy and learned Author of your own Communion hath said in Confutation of this foolish and absurd Argument for Pedo-baptism, 'tis Sir Norton Knatchbull Knight and Baronet. The thing, saith he, is uncertain, that it cannot be said of the Rabbins, that there were not several among them who differed very much about this matter; for Rabbi Eliezar expresly contradicts Rabbi Joshua, who was the first that I know of who asserted this sort of Baptism among the Jews; for Rabbi Eliezar, who was contemporary with Rabbi Joshua, if he did not live before him, asserts that a Proselyte circumcised, and not baptized, was a true Proselyte; for so we read of the Patriarchs Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, that they were circumcised, but not baptized. But Rabbi Joshua affirms, that he who was baptized, not he that was circumcised, was a true Proselyte. To whom shall I give Credit, to Eliezar, who asserts what the Scripture confirms; or to Joshua, who affirms what is no where to be found in Scripture? But the Rabbins upheld Joshuah's side, and what wonder was it? for it made for their business; that is, for the Honour of the Jewish Religion, that the Christians should borrow their Ceremonies from them. But when I see Men of great Learning in these times fetching the Foundations of Truth from the Rabbins, I cannot but hesitate a little: