A48160:15
A letter to a friend concerning a postscript to the Defence of Dr. Sherlock's…A letter to a friend concerning a postscript to the Defense of Dr. Sherlock's…
A letter to a friend concerning a postscript to the Defence of Dr. Sherlock's notion of the Trinity in unity, relating to the Calm and sober enquiry upon the same subjectA letter to a friend concerning a postscript to the Defense of Dr. Sherlock's notion of the Trinity in unity, relating to the Calm and sober enquiry upon the same subject
London: printed by J. Astwood for Tho. Parkhurst, 1694
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And now the Defender will have the Dean to have done no more. And with all my Heart let him have done no more, if he and his Animadverter, and the rest of the World will so agree it: But he will have the Enquirer to have done more, and to be much more exposed to the Charge of Tritheism, by asserting three distinct Essences, three individual Natures, and three spiritual Beings in the Godhead. This is indeed very marvellous, that the Enquirer should expose himself to the Charge of Tritheism by asserting all this, when but a few Lines before upon the same Page, he is said to have asserted nothing! But he may as well make the Enquirer in asserting nothing to have asserted all this, as the Dean in asserting all this to have asserted nothing.
And where the Enquirer hath said in express words that the Sacred Three are three distinct substances I can't find: And we must in great part alter the common Notion of Substance to make it affirmable of God at all, viz. that it doth substare accidentibus, which I believe the Dean will no more than the Enquirer suppose the Divine Being to admit. But 'tis true, that there is somewhat more considerable in the Notion of Substance, according whereto, if the Dean can make a shift to avoid the having of any inconvenient thing proved upon him by consequence, I hope the Enquirer may find a way to escape as well.
But whereas he says the Dean allows but one Divine Essence, and one individual Nature in the Godhead repeated in three Persons, but without multiplication, as he says he had already explained it. This hath occasioned me to look back to that explanation, and if he thinks the allowing ⟨p. 8⟩but one Divine Essence, and one individual Nature in the Godhead, will agree with what the Dean hath said in his Vindication, I shall not envy him, nor (now) go about to disprove it. But I confess I see not how it can agree with what the Defender says in this his explanation it self, when p. 23. he tells us the Son is the living subsisting Image of the Father, and the Image and the Prototype can not be the same but must be two. No man is his own Image, nor is an Image the Image of it self. And he adds, this is so self evident, &c. But whereas the distinction all this while might be understood to be but modal, and that appears to be the Defenders present (what ever was the Deans former) meaning, that the three subsistences differ only in their different manner of subsisting, yet with this meaning his other words do little agree, for he plainly asserts a real distinction of three in the same individual numerical nature. And who did ever make a real