A48160:37
A letter to a friend concerning a postscript to the Defence of Dr. Sherlock's…A letter to a friend concerning a postscript to the Defense of Dr. Sherlock's…
A letter to a friend concerning a postscript to the Defence of Dr. Sherlock's notion of the Trinity in unity, relating to the Calm and sober enquiry upon the same subjectA letter to a friend concerning a postscript to the Defense of Dr. Sherlock's notion of the Trinity in unity, relating to the Calm and sober enquiry upon the same subject
London: printed by J. Astwood for Tho. Parkhurst, 1694
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And indeed is this a new notion? as new as the Creation? Let him show me an Instance through the whole created universe of Beings (And for the uncreated Being the Defender (now at this time) disputes against any composition there, and the Enquirer denies any) first, where there hath been a compositum without a pre-existing component, or next the compounded parts whereof, if substantial did not in order of nature pre-exist separate; i. e. whether esse simplicitèr do not naturally precede esse tale, or which is all one, to our present purpose, whether they were not capable hereof if the Creator pleased: Let any ⟨p. 28⟩man, I say, tell me where was there ever a compositum made by substantial union, that did not consist of once separate or of separable parts.
And indeed is this a new notion? as new as the Creation? Let him shew me an Instance through the whole created universe of Beings (And for the uncreated Being the Defender (now at this time) disputes against any composition there, and the Enquirer denies any) first, where there hath been a compositum without a pre-existing component, or next the compounded parts whereof, if substantial did not in order of nature pre-exist separate; i. e. whether esse simplicitèr do not naturally precede esse tale, or which is all one, to our present purpose, whether they were not capable hereof if the Creator pleased: Let any ⟨p. 28⟩man, I say, tell me where was there ever a compositum made by substantial union, that did not consist of once separate or of separable parts.
But note his admirable following supposition, that is to say, that if a man, suppose, who consists of body and soul, had been from eternity, without a maker, and his soul, and body had never subsisted a part, he could not have been said to have been a compounded Creature? This is said with design most groundlessly (as we shall see) to fasten an absurd consequence upon the Enquirer, and see how it lucks: Did ever any man undertake to reprove an absurdity with greater absurdity? a Creature without a Maker! what sort of Creature must this be! we have a pretty saying quoted in the Defender's Letter; He that writes lies down; and we are apt enough too, when we write to trip and fall down, and ought in such Cases to be merciful to one another, even tho' he that falls should be