A48160:46
A letter to a friend concerning a postscript to the Defence of Dr. Sherlock's…A letter to a friend concerning a postscript to the Defense of Dr. Sherlock's…
A letter to a friend concerning a postscript to the Defence of Dr. Sherlock's notion of the Trinity in unity, relating to the Calm and sober enquiry upon the same subjectA letter to a friend concerning a postscript to the Defense of Dr. Sherlock's notion of the Trinity in unity, relating to the Calm and sober enquiry upon the same subject
London: printed by J. Astwood for Tho. Parkhurst, 1694
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
This is the only thing that ever came under my notice among the School-men, that hath any appearing strength in it, against the Hypothesis which I have proposed as possible for ought I knew. They generally dispute against many sorts of Compositions in the Being of God, which I am not concerned in. That of Matter and Form, which is alien from this affair, of quantitative parts, which is as alien. Of subject and accident, which touches us not. Of act and power, which doth it as little. Each subsistent, being eternally in utmost actuality. And by sundry sorts and methods of argument, whereof only this can seem to signify any thing against the present supposition. And it wholly resolves into the Notion of Infinity, about which I generally ⟨p. 39⟩spoke my sense in that first Letter to Dr. Wallis. 1And as I there intimated how much easier it is to puzzle another upon that subject than to satisfy one self, so I here say, that I doubt not to give any man as much trouble about it in respect of quantitative extension, as he can me, in this. I think it demonstrable that one Infinite can never be from another by voluntary production, that it cannot by necessary Emanation, I think not so. In the mean time when we are told so plainly by the Divine Oracles, of a sacred three, that are each of them God, and of some one whereof some things are spoken that are not nor can be of the others. I think it easier to count three than to determine of Infiniteness: And accordingly to form ones Belief. But of this more when we come to compare him with himself. And for what he discourses of the aspect this supposition hath upon the Trinity, and the Homo-ousion. 2It ⟨p. 40⟩all proceeds still upon his own fiction of parts, and upon the invidious straining of that similitude of the union of soul and body, as he himself doth tantum non confess; except that he lessens it by saying most untruly that he (the Enquirer) doth expressly own the Consequence. Therefore if he do not own the Consequence, then the Defender confesses himself to have invidiously devised it; and what is it? That if all three by this composition are but one God, neither of them by himself is true and perfect God. The Divinity is like the English. But both his own. The Enquirer denies both antecedent (which he knows) and consequent too.