A Letter concerning the Subject of Baptism, written by that eminent Minister of Christ Mr Jonathan Mitchel, late Pastor of the Church in Cambridge in New England.
Reverend and dear Sir,
I have deliberately read over Mr. D•. Essay and Epistle to the Reader, which I now return to you with thanks for the Loan of it, If I should say, I see not matter of Conviction in it, his Answer is already given me, (pag. 35) If men shut their eyes, when the light is held out to them, they may truly say they see not, or in pag. 6. they that Enquire of God with an Idol in their hearts, shall be penally answered by being left to their own Counsels, &c. we had need Labour to approve our selves to God, when we meet with such sharp Censures from men But the R. A. can hardly expect, we should find Conviction here, seeing he builds all upon this distinction of Immediate and mediate membership, which with the Consectaries He deduceth from it, is the prora & puppis of his whole discourse: and for the proof of the distinction, himself, in (pag. 34, 35.) refers the Reader to his former Essays; neither have I observed much more in this writing, toward the proof of it, then we have had before. And therefore if we did not see it (as by him explained and Improved) to be evident before, it is not strange, if we do not see it now. If it must be imputed to our blindness (yea, wilful and penal blindness) that we see it not, we must be Content, to bear it as we may. Also when he affirms over and over (pag. 75, 83, 92, 103, 131, 145, 152.) that we our selves Confess the Parents in Question have not Faith, or are not visible Believers, the Contrary whereunto we have plainly asserted. And how many times over does he say it, [we call them mere members] which we have disclaimed, and do not so call them but, [members not in full Communion] yea, he says, in pag. 49.) we grant that the persons in Question, are not to be accounted Church members, &c. How should we receive Conviction from such discourses? If his meaning be by so often reflecting on [our mere members as he calls them] to deny that distinction of members into [such as are in full Communion, and such as are not in full Communion] that would seem strange, for how can that be denied by any Pad•baptists, and he seems to approve it in pag. 35.
A Letter concerning the Subject of Baptisme, written by that eminent Minister of Christ Mr Ionathan Mitchel, late Pastor of the Church in Cambridg in New England.
Reverend and dear Sir,
I have deliberately read over Mr. D•. Essay and Epistle to the Reader, which I now return to you with thanks for the Loan of it, If I should say, I see not matter of Conviction in it, his Answer is already given me, (pag. 35) If men shut their eyes, when the light is held out to them, they may truly say they see not, or in pag. 6. they that Enquire of God with an Idol in their hearts, shall be paenally answered by being left to their own Counsels, &c. we had need Labour to approve our selves to God, when we meet with such sharp Censures from men But the R. A. can hardly expect, we should find Conviction here, seeing he builds all upon this distinction of Immediate and mediate membership, which with the Consectaries He deduceth from it, is the prora & puppis of his whole discourse: and for the proof of the distinction, himself, in (pag. 34, 35.) refers the Reader to his former Essays; neither have I observed much more in this writing, toward the proof of it, then we have had before. And therefore if we did not see it (as by him explained and Improved) to be evident before, it is not strange, if we do not see it now. If it must be imputed to our blindness (yea, wilful and paenal blindness) that we see it not, we must be Content, to bear it as we may. Also when he affirms over and over (pag. 75, 83, 92, 103, 131, 145, 152.) that we our selves Confess the Parents in Question have not Faith, or are not visible Believers, the Contrary whereunto we have plainly asserted. And how many times over does he say it, [we call them meer members] which we have disclaimed, and do not so call them but, [members not in full Communion] yea, he sayes, in pag. 49.) we grant that the persons in Question, are not to be accounted Church members, &c. How should we receive Conviction from such discourses? If his meaning be by so often reflecting on [our meer members as he calls them] to deny that distinction of members into [such as are in full Communion, and such as are not in full Communion] that would seem strange, for how can that be denyed by any Pad•baptists, and he seems to approve it in pag. 35.