Sol. 1. It is a very hard matter to speak any evil of another without sin: for if it be without cause, then it is downright slander, and is against truth: if it be for a light and small cause, then it is against Charity: if it be for things indifferent, or for lesser failings, indiscretions, or weaknesses, still 'tis against Charity, Jam. 4. 11. Speak not evil one of another, brethren. It is worse in brethren. Many take liberty to traduce Gods choice servants that are in difference. ⟨p. 141⟩For a Soldier to speak evil of Soldiers, or a Scholar of Scholars, is worse than for those that hate these Functions: so for you, Christians, to speak evil one of another, you gratify the triumphs of Hell, and bring a reproach upon the ways of Christ. In things doubtful, judg the best: in things hidden and secret, we can take no cognizance: when the fact is open, we do not know the aim nor the intent of the heart. It is the Devils work to judg thus, Doth Job serve God for nought? when he could not traduce his action. If the practice be open and public, we do not know what alleviating circumstances it may bear, what grievous temptations they had, or whether they have repented yea or no. The Devil is called a slanderer, because he doth accuse the Saints. It is too true many times what he accuseth them of; I, but he accuseth them when they are pardoned; he rakes up the filth God hath covered; he accuseth the brethren after repentance, after they are acquitted by the Lords grace; and so you may incur the like: and therefore it's a very hard matter to avoid sin; in one way or other we shall dash upon the Command; better let it alone.
Sol. 1. It is a very hard matter to speak any evil of another without sin: for if it be without cause, then it is downright slander, and is against truth: if it be for a light and small cause, then it is against Charity: if it be for things indifferent, or for lesser failings, indiscretions, or weaknesses, still 'tis against Charity, Jam. 4. 11. Speak not evil one of another, brethren. It is worse in brethren. Many take liberty to traduce Gods choice servants that are in difference. ⟨p. 141⟩For a Soldier to speak evil of Soldiers, or a Scholar of Scholars, is worse than for those that hate these Functions: so for you, Christians, to speak evil one of another, you gratifie the triumphs of Hell, and bring a reproach upon the ways of Christ. In things doubtful, judg the best: in things hidden and secret, we can take no cognizance: when the fact is open, we do not know the aim nor the intent of the heart. It is the Devils work to judg thus, Doth Iob serve God for nought? when he could not traduce his action. If the practice be open and publick, we do not know what alleviating circumstances it may bear, what grievous temptations they had, or whether they have repented yea or no. The Devil is called a slanderer, because he doth accuse the Saints. It is too true many times what he accuseth them of; I, but he accuseth them when they are pardoned; he rakes up the filth God hath covered; he accuseth the brethren after repentance, after they are acquitted by the Lords grace; and so you may incur the like: and therefore it's a very hard matter to avoid sin; in one way or other we shall dash upon the Command; better let it alone.