A53704:127
An enquiry into the original, nature, institution, power, order and communion of evangelical churches.…
An enquiry into the original, nature, institution, power, order and communion of evangelical churches. The first part with an answer to the discourse of the unreasonableness of separation written by Dr. Edward Stillingfleet, Dean of Pauls, and in defence of the vindication of non-conformists from the guilt of schism / by John Owen.An enquiry into the original, nature, institution, power, order and communion of evangelical churches. The first part with an answer to the discourse of the unreasonableness of separation written by Dr. Edward Stillingfleet, Dean of Pauls, and in defence of the vindication of non-conformists from the guilt of schisme / by John Owen.
London: printed by J. Richardson for Nath. Ponder, 1681
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Our Reverend Author will hardly find an Instance before this of Schism among any Churches that retained the Substance of the Doctrine of Faith, unless it be in those Divisions which fell out in some particular Churches, among the Members of them. And this we affirm to be in general the Case of the Non-conformists at this day. For admitting such Variations as Time and other Circumstances must necessarily infer, and they are rejected from Communion on the same grounds, that Victor proceeded on in the Excommunication of the Churches of Asia. Neither will there be any End of Differences whilst the same Principle is retained. Before this, Schism was only esteemed a defect in Love and breach of the Rule of Christs Appointment, for the Communion and walking together of Believers in the same Church.
Our Reverend Author will hardly find an Instance before this of Schisme among any Churches that retained the Substance of the Doctrine of Faith, unless it be in those Divisions which fell out in some particular Churches, among the Members of them. And this we affirm to be in general the Case of the Non-conformists at this day. For admitting such Variations as Time and other Circumstances must necessarily infer, and they are rejected from Communion on the same grounds, that Victor proceeded on in the Excommunication of the Churches of Asia. Neither will there be any End of Differences whilst the same Principle is retained. Before this, Schisme was only esteemed a defect in Love and breach of the Rule of Christs Appointment, for the Communion and walking together of Believers in the same Church.
But this Notion of Schism is in the Judgment of Dr. Still. Pref. p. 46. so mean, so jejune, so narrow a Notion ⟨p. 59⟩of it, that I cannot, saith he, but wonder that men of Understanding should be satisfied with it. But in my Judgement, the Author of it, was a Man of Good Understanding; indeed I have heard him spoken of, as one of abstruse Speculations, that did not advantage Christian Religion. And one hath published in Print, that he is one of the Obscurest Writers that ever he read, but never heard him before charged with mean and jejune Notions. Now this was St Paul, who expressly chargeth Schism on the Church of Corinth, because of the Divisions that were among them, namely, the Members of the same particular Church; so as they could not come together in one place, in a due manner. Nor in all his Writings, doth he any where give us any other Notion of Schism. But, saith he, this is short of that care of the Churches Peace, which Christ hath made so great a Duty of his followers. But if thre be no other Rule, no other Duty for the Preservation of the Churches Peace, but only, that no separation be made from it, which is called Schism, we might have been all quiet in the Church of Rome. Let no Man think to persuade us, but that for the Preservation of the Churches Peace, it is required of us, that we do and observe all things that Christ requireth of us, and that we enjoin not the Observation of what he hath not Commanded, on Victors Penalty of being excluded from Communion; that Faith and Love and Holiness, be Kept and promoted in the Church, by all the ways of his Appointment; And when these things are attended unto, St. Paul's mean and jejune Notion of Schism, will be of good use also.