A53736:174
A vindication of some passages in a discourse concerning communion with God from the…
A vindication of some passages in a discourse concerning communion with God from the exceptions of William Sherlock, rector of St. George Buttolph-Lane / by the author of the said discourse, John Owen.
London: printed for N. Ponder, 1674
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I yet suppose that he observed not the Inconsistencies of this Discourse, and therefore shall a little mind him of them, although I am no way concerned in it or them. For, First he tells us, That a Mediator is one who interposeth between two differing Parties, to accommodate the Difference; and then gives us an Instance in Moses, who is called a Mediator in receiving the Law, but did therein no way interpose himself between differing Parties, to reconcile them. Secondly, from the Nature of the Mediation of Moses, he would describe the Nature of the Mediation of Christ; which Socinian Fiction I could direct him to a sufficient Confutation of; but that, Thirdly, He rejects it himself in his next words, that Christ as a Mediator was to dye as a Sacrifice, and Propitiation for the Sins of the World, which renders his Mediation utterly of another Kind and Nature than that of Moses. The mistake of this Discourse is, that he supposeth that men do argue from the general Nature of the Office of a Mediator and the Work of ⟨p. 212⟩Mediation in this Matter; when that which they do intend hence to prove, and what he intends to oppose, is from the special Nature of the Mediatory Office and Work of Christ, which is peculiar, and hath sundry things essentially belonging unto it, that belong not unto any other kind of Mediation whatever, whereof himself gives one signal Instance.
In his ensuing pages, he wonderfully perplexeth himself in gathering up sayings backward and forward in my discourse to make some advantage to his purpose, and hopes that he is arrived at no less success than a discovery of I know not what Contradictions in what I have asserted. As I said before, so I say again, that I refer the determination and judgement of this whole matter unto any one who will but once read over the discourse excepted against. But for his part, I greatly pity him, as really supposing him at a loss in the sense of what is yet plainly delivered. And I had rather continue to think so, than to be relieved ⟨p. 213⟩by supposing him guilty of such gross prevarications, as he must be, if he understands what he treats about. Plainly I have showed, that there was an especial Law of Mediation which Christ was subject unto, as the Commandment of the Father. That he should be incarnate, that he should be the King, Priest, and Prophet of his Church, that he should bear our Iniquities, make his Soul an offering for sin, and give his life a ransom for many; were the principal parts of this Law. The whole of it I have lately explained in my Exercitations unto the second part of the Exposition on the Epistle to the Hebrews, whereon if he please he may exercise and try his Skill, in a way of opposition. This Law our Lord Jesus Christ did not yield obedience to in our stead, as though we had been obliged originally unto the duties of it, which we neither were nor could be; although what he suffered penally in any of them was in our stead, without which consideration, he could not have righteously suffered in any kind. And the following trivial Exception of this Author