A55303:25
A discourse of schism
A discourse of schism by that learned gentleman Edward Polhill, Esq. ...
London: printed for Thomas Cockerill, 1694
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Austin saith, that Episcopacy is greater than Presbytery, Secundum honorum vocabula, 1quae jam Ecclesiae usus obtinuit, according to the Titles of Honour which are now used in the Church. Thus it appears that a Diocesan Episcopacy is but Humane, and by consequence Church-unity doth not stand in it. The Reformed Churches which are without Episcopacy, are not without Unity. I conclude this with the Judgment ⟨p. 17⟩of the Learned Dr. Ward, 2who (speaking of the difference in Ecclesiastical Government which is between our Church and those beyond Sea) saith, that it may, and ought to be tolerated, absque fraternae unitatis laesione, without any breach of Brotherly unity.
- 1Epist. 19.
- 2Determ. 109.
4thly. It doth not stand in the Civil Laws of Princes. When Magistrates were Pagans, there was yet a Church, and an Unity in it. When they became Christians, the Unity was the same, the Joints and the Bands were as before, sacred, not civil; from Christ the Head, not from the Magistrate. It's true, the Church hath an external help and guard from good Laws, but its Unity doth not consist in them. Neque quia regna dividuntur, 1ideo & Christiana unitas dividitur, cum in utraque part inveniatur Catholica Ecclesia, saith St. Austin, Kingdoms may be divided, but Christian Unity is not; in both parts the Catholic Church is found. Should the Unity of the Church consist in the Laws of Magistrates, ⟨p. 18⟩then the Laws being dissolved, there would be no Unity; the Laws being altered, the Unity must vary, and turn about to every point, as the Laws do. That which now is Unity, under a contrary Law must be Schism; that which now is a Schism, under a contrary Law may be Unity. Under the Emperor Valentinian, the Orthodox may be the Church; under Valens, the Arians may be it. Nay, as the Magistrate may be, you shall not know by him where the Church or the Truth is. In that great Schism, when the Bishops of the East and West fell out about the Council of Chalcedon, some would not part with a syllable of it, some utterly rejected it: The Emperor Anastasius,