A55308:192
Speculum theologiæ in Christo, or, A view of some divine truths which are either…
Speculum theologiæ in Christo, or, A view of some divine truths which are either practically exemplified in Jesus Christ, set forth in the Gospel, or may be reasonably deduced from thence / by Edward Polhill ..., Esq.
London: printed by A.M. and R.R. for Tho. Cockerill, 1678
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Christs sufferings, however we call them, were not such as were properly and truly penal. He would not have them properly penal, lest they should be properly satisfactory. But I answer, Where sin is not the impulsive cause, there sufferings are not penal. Sin is the foundation of punishment; there cannot be poena sine fundamento; a punishment without a why or a wherefore, is a punishment for nothing, that is, no punishment. But in Christs sufferings there wanted not an impulsive, our sins were laid upon him, Isa. 53.6. they were condemned in his flesh, Rom. 8.3. he bore them in his body, 1 Pet. 2.24. he was wounded and bruised for them, Isa. 53.5. His sufferings were for sin, and therefore penal. Where mere Sovereignty inflicts, there sufferings are not penal. What is penal is from Justice, not Power. What is from Power is mere suffering, not punishment. But our Saviours sufferings were inflicted by Justice. Indeed the relaxation of the Law, the introduction of a Sponsor, were acts of Prerogative and Supreme Power; but the inflicting of sufferings upon our Sponsor, the punishing of our sins in him, were acts of Rectoral Justice. Jesus Christ was set forth to be a propitiation, [Greek or Hebrew], Rom. 3.25, to declare, not the Dominion, but Justice of God. His sufferings were inflicted by Justice, and therefore penal. But if they were penal, might they not have been somewhat less ⟨p. 142⟩than a death and a curse? No, he bore both; God had a respect to his threatening: his sufferings were, as much as might be, to comply with the terms of the Law. Though the threatening was not executed in a strict rigorous manner in the first debtor, yet in an equitable way it was in a sort executed in the Sponsor; he did undergo the essentials of punishment, though not the accidentals. Thus the truth of both parts of the Law was manifested in our Saviour.
Christs sufferings, however we call them, were not such as were properly and truly penal. He would not have them properly penal, lest they should be properly satisfactory. But I answer, Where sin is not the impulsive cause, there sufferings are not penal. Sin is the foundation of punishment; there cannot be poena sine fundamento; a punishment without a why or a wherefore, is a punishment for nothing, that is, no punishment. But in Christs sufferings there wanted not an impulsive, our sins were laid upon him,