This Opinion to me is a very impious one; it highly disparages Divine Providence: it is in effect as much as to say, God hath nothing to rule over but the Brutal World, the Rational is lost out of his dominions. It takes away the glory and crown of Providence, which rules over free Agents in so rare and admirable a manner, that they, though moving upon the wings of liberty, do infallibly hit the mark. It subverts the certainty of Providence, and that in those things which were positively decreed by God, and of the highest moment to men. What more positively decreed, or more highly momentous to the Jewish Church, than those two famous deliverances from Egypt and Babylon? Or what more positively decreed, or more highly momentous to the whole world, than the sufferings of our Saviour? Yet these things being to come to pass by the free acts of men, and those free acts not being under Providence, the event must needs be pendulous and uncertain, as those free acts upon which the event depends, ⟨p. 180⟩are. Providence, having no sovereign dominion over those free acts, doth not ascertain the Event, but leave it dubious and fluctuating till the human Will determines it self: And what is this, but to make Providence nothing, and man an independent Agent? And whither doth this tend, but to the utter subversion of Piety? We should say in piety, If the Lord will, 1we will do this or that, Jam. 4.15; but according to this opinion, God himself may say, If man will, I will do this or that. This made the famous Bradwardine justly cry out,2 Quis enim Theologicus aut Catholicus, imo vel Haereticus, Schismaticus aut Paganus audeat se praeponere Deo suo, dicere seipsum Dominum, Deum suum servum, seipsum superiorem, Deum inferiorem, seipsum architectum & principalem artificem, Deum vero subservientem & suum quodammodo instrumentum? What Divine or Catholic, yea, what Heretic, Schismatic, or Pagan, dares prefer himself before his God, to say, that he is Lord, God the servant; he Superior, God inferior; he the Architect and principal Artificer, God subservient, and a kind of instrument under him? Moreover, it directly contradicts Scripture. God touched their hearts, and Saul had a band, 1 Sam. 10.26. God opened the heart of Lydia, and the Gospel had entrance, Acts 16.14. God turneth the Kings heart, and that whither he will, Prov. 21.1. God draws men, and they come to Christ, John 6.44.
This Opinion to me is a very impious one; it highly disparages Divine Providence: it is in effect as much as to say, God hath nothing to rule over but the Brutal World, the Rational is lost out of his dominions. It takes away the glory and crown of Providence, which rules over free Agents in so rare and admirable a manner, that they, though moving upon the wings of liberty, do infallibly hit the mark. It subverts the certainty of Providence, and that in those things which were positively decreed by God, and of the highest moment to men. What more positively decreed, or more highly momentous to the Jewish Church, than those two famous deliverances from Egypt and Babylon? Or what more positively decreed, or more highly momentous to the whole world, than the sufferings of our Saviour? Yet these things being to come to pass by the free acts of men, and those free acts not being under Providence, the event must needs be pendulous and uncertain, as those free acts upon which the event depends, ⟨p. 180⟩are. Providence, having no soveraign dominion over those free acts, doth not ascertain the Event, but leave it dubious and fluctuating till the human Will determines it self: And what is this, but to make Providence nothing, and man an independent Agent? And whither doth this tend, but to the utter subversion of Piety? We should say in piety, If the Lord will, 1we will do this or that, Jam. 4.15; but according to this opinion, God himself may say, If man will, I will do this or that. This made the famous Bradwardine justly cry out,2 Quis enim Theologicus aut Catholicus, imo vel Haereticus, Schismaticus aut Paganus audeat se praeponere Deo suo, dicere seipsum Dominum, Deum suum servum, seipsum superiorem, Deum inferiorem, seipsum architectum & principalem artificem, Deum vero subservientem & suum quodammodo instrumentum? What Divine or Catholick, yea, what Heretick, Schismatick, or Pagan, dares prefer himself before his God, to say, that he is Lord, God the servant; he Superior, God inferior; he the Architect and principal Artificer, God subservient, and a kind of instrument under him? Moreover, it directly contradicts Scripture. God touched their hearts, and Saul had a band, 1 Sam. 10.26. God opened the heart of Lydia, and the Gospel had entrance, Acts 16.14. God turneth the Kings heart, and that whither he will,
- 1Ames. Bell. Ener. de lib. Arb. c. 2.
- 2De Causa Dei, l. 2. c. 30.