A55308:435
Speculum theologiæ in Christo, or, A view of some divine truths which are either…
Speculum theologiæ in Christo, or, A view of some divine truths which are either practically exemplified in Jesus Christ, set forth in the Gospel, or may be reasonably deduced from thence / by Edward Polhill ..., Esq.
London: printed by A.M. and R.R. for Tho. Cockerill, 1678
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
and where there is no sin at all, there can be no such thing as punishment: We are therefore under a necessity to say, that sin was in tantum, so far imputed to Christ as to render his sufferings penal, and withal we see an accident passing to another by imputation; only here it will be objected, that sin was only imputed to Christ in the effects; but, I take it, this suffices not; for the effect of sin is punishment; and punishment cannot be, where no sin is imputed; a punishment without a why or a wherefore, is a punishment for nothing; that is, it is no punishment; and where there is no punishment, sin is not so much as imputed in the effect. So that if it be imputed in the effect, it self must be so far imputed, as to render the sufferings penal, which makes good the instance.
Object. 2. If Christ's Righteousness be indeed imputed to us, then it is imputed in the full latitude; we are reputed by God to have satisfied Divine Justice, we are then imputatively our own Saviours and Redeemers; ⟨p. 368⟩Nay, as Bellarmine saith, Redemptores & Salvatores Mundi, Redeemers and Saviours of the World.
Ans. If this Principle, That all Imputation is in the full latitude, be true, I yield up the cause for ever. I am sure I am not my own Saviour or Redeemer; I never satisfied Divine Justice for my sins; but that this Principle is not true, I shall endeavour to manifest. Non-imputation and Imputation must needs have the same Rules to be governed by: this, I suppose, must not be denied by those who say, That the Non-imputation of sin, is the Imputation of Righteousness, Rom. 4.1. Sin is not imputed to Believers: But how what, totally and in every respect? No, surely; still the culpa abides, the sin will be a sin, the Sinner a Sinner; that is, one who sinned; but it is not imputed as to punishment: If Sin may be Non-imputed in some respects, then Righteousness may be imputed in a limited sense also; if all Imputation be in the full latitude, then there is no Imputation of a thing at all (save only to the proper doer of it) neither according to Principles of mere Nature, nor according to Principles of Justice, nor yet according to a Divine Constitution: Not according to Principles of mere Nature; according to these sin internal in the Will is imputed to the Members of the Body, as being in conjunction with the Soul; else the Body should not rise and suffer for it: But how is it imputed? what, in the full latitude? Doth God account that the sin properly did issue from the Members, and reside there? It is not true, or possible, yet in a lower and diminutive manner is it to them imputed; nor according to Principles of Justice; our sin (and that, as but now was proved) not in the effect only, but in some sense in it self, was imputed to