Christ dying and drawing sinners to himself, or, A survey of our Saviour in his soul-suffering, his loveliness in his death, and the efficacy thereof in which some cases of soul-trouble in week believers ... are opened ... delivered in sermons on the Evangel according to S. John Chap. XII, vers. 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33 ... / by Samuel Rutherford.Christ dying and drawing sinners to himself, or, A survey of our Saviour in his soule-suffering, his lovelynesse in his death, and the efficacie thereof in which some cases of soule-trouble in weeke beleevers ... are opened ... delivered in sermons on the Evangel according to S. John Chap. XII, vers. 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33 ... / by Samuel Rutherford.
Samuel Rutherford 1600?–1661London: printed by J.D. for Andrew Crooke, 1647
[34], 598 p. · 287k words · Wing R2373 · ESTC R28117
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. That love cannot be a general, confused, antecedent, conditional love, offered to all the world, on condition they believe; for that the Scripture freeth thousands of the sin of unbelief of that love, if Christ come not to them, and speak not, Joh. 15.22. and Paul saith Rom. 1.14. How shall they believe in him, of whom they have not heard? Now the loved world, Joh. 3.16. is obliged to believe.
1. That love cannot bee a generall, confused, antecedent, conditionall love, offered to all the world, on condition they beleeve; for that the Scripture freeth thousands of the sinne of unbeliefe of that love, if Christ come not to them, and speake not, Ioh. 15.22. and Paul saith Rom. 1.14. How shall they beleeve in him, of whom they have not heard? Now the loved world, Ioh. 3.16. is obliged to beleeve.
2. That love that is the cause of Christs death, is Joh. 15.13. the greatest love that is; it is such a giving love, whereby Christ gives his Son, 1that with him he cannot but give his Holy Spirit, faith and salvation, yea, and all things, Rom. 8.32. But the conditional general love is not the greatest love, for the Lord beareth not the greatest love to all and every man, nor gives he faith and salvation to all and every man; yea, the known and believed love of God in sending his Son to die for us is proper to the believer,
and believed the love God hath to us, God is love, and he that dwelleth in love, (its a noble Princely palace to lodge in) dwelleth in God, and God in him. This cannot be said of the love that God beareth to the Reprobate, yea, and to the fallen Angels; for Arminians say that God loved them with such a love; but that love to Devils, is now dried up long ago, and so that to Pharaoh, Judas, Cain, now in hell, but this love is gone; so dream they, that love in God is like summer brooks that go dry in time of drought; but the truth is, Gods general love to Arminians,
is a faint desire, and a wish that all and every one, men and Angels be saved, and a bestowing on them means, 1. Which the Lord knows shall plunge them deeper in hell, and make their everlasting chains heavier and more fiery; better he love them not. 2. Such means as can be demonstrated free will without God, or any determination or bowing to one hand, rather then to another, can, and may absolutely master and over-master equally to conversion, or obstinacy, or to final rebellion, to salvation, or damnation, to make themselves free Princes and Lords of the book of life, and the writing pen of eternal Election, and Artists, causes, and masters of the decrees of Election, or Reprobation. For, 1. Let God do what he can, or omnipotency, or sweetness of free grace, all that is possible, free will hath the free and absolute casting of the balance to will, receive Christ, open to the King of glory, and be converted,
or to the contrary. 2. In Election and Reprobation from eternity, (as Arminians in their last Apology go no higher then time, coepta est in temporo electio, contra quam creditum est, &c.) God doth no more in his general decree for choosing of Jacob or Peter, then of Pharaoh, Esau or Judas;
2. That love that is the cause of Christs death, is Ioh. 15.13. the greatest love that is; it is such a giving love, whereby Christ gives his Sonne, 1that with him hee cannot but give his Holy Spirit, faith and salvation, yea, and all things, Rom. 8.32. But the conditionall generall love is not the greatest love, for the Lord beareth not the greatest love to all and every man, nor gives he faith and salvation to all and every man; yea, the known and beleeved love of God in sending his Son to die for us is proper to the beleever, 1 Ioh. 4.16.9, 10. We have known ⟨p. 410⟩and beleeved the love God hath to us, God is love, and he that dwelleth in love, (its a noble Princely pallace to lodge in) dwelleth in God, and God in him. This cannot be said of the love that God beareth to the Reprobate, yea, and to the fallen Angels; for Arminians say that God loved them with such a love; but that love to Devils, is now dried up long agoe, and so that to Pharaoh, Iudas, Cain, now in hell, but this love is gone; so dream they, that love in God is like summer brooks that go dry in time of drought; but the truth is, Gods generall love to Arminians, 2is a faint desire, and a wish that all and every one, men and Angels be saved, and a bestowing on them means, 1. Which the Lord knowes shall plunge them deeper in hell, and make their everlasting chaines heavier and more fiery; better he love them not. 2. Such meanes as can be demonstrated free will without God, or any determination or bowing to one hand, rather then to another, can, and may absolutely master and over-master equally to conversion, or obstinacy, or to finall rebellion, to salvation, or damnation, to make themselves free Princes and Lords of the book of life, and the writing pen of eternall Election, and Artists, causes, and masters of the decrees of Election, or Reprobation. For, 1. Let God doe what he can, or omnipotency, or sweetnesse of free grace, all that is possible, free will hath the free and absolute casting of the ballance to will, receive Christ, open to the King of glory, and be converted,3 or to the contrary. 2. In Election and Reprobation from eternity, (as Arminians in their last Apology goe no higher then time, coepta est in temporo electio, contra quam creditum est, &c.) God doth no more in his generall decree for chusing of Jacob or Peter, then of Pharaoh, Esau or Judas;
1The […] John 3.16. dis•••ssed, that love •s a particular love proper to the […] only.The 〈…〉Iohn 3.16. dis•••ssed, that love •s a particular love proper to the 〈…〉 only.
2What the love of God is.
3Arminian election faint and weak for the salvation of one more then another.
but chooseth all indefinitely who shall believe. But for the Assumption that Peter, John, Pharaoh, Judas, Esau, believe, or not believe, the eternal decree of God does nothing, his means, Gospel, his inward grace (such grace as they can grant) do no more, nor can do any more to determine the will to either side, to believing, or not believing; then he can work contradictions, or make free will, and free obedience to be no free will, and no obedience, for its repugnant (say they) to the nature of free-will that it should be determined by God; And […], such as is required of us now who are under comm•••ements, threatenings, promises, were no obedience at all, for if the Lord ⟨p. 411⟩should determine the will (say they) and therefore Gods last decree of choosing those to life, whom he foresees shall expire in faith, and persevere to the end, and of rejecting such, as he foresees shall go on, in final obstinacy against the Gospel, is not any Scriptural decree of Election or Reprobation, nor hath God any liberty in this, to choose this man, not this man, but all men choose God, and are foreseen finally to believe, or not believe, before, and without any free decree of God; so that the number of chosen Angels or men is in the power of the creatures free will; not in the liberty of the former of all things; so as we choose God, but God chooseth not us. But 2. So none are within the compass of Election or Reprobation, but such as hear the Gospel; and so all the Heathen are saved or damned by chance, or without any will or decree of God, or they must be neither capable of salvation, nor damnation, contrary to Scripture and experience, for terrible judgements temporal, and great external favours befall Indians, Americans, and such as never heard of Christ, and not without the counsel of Gods will, if there be a providence that rules the world. 2. God doth nothing in the Election of Peter, more then of Judas; nor can grace and mercy have place in the choosing of the one, rather then the other; but as free will is foreseen to play the game ill, or well, so go the eternal decrees of Election and Reprobation, and there can be no such thing as that grace and the free pleasure of God, who hath mercy on whom he will, or because he will, and hardens whom he will, can have any place here.
but chuseth all indefinitely who shall beleeve. But for the Assumption that Peter, Iohn, Pharaoh, Judas, Esau, beleeve, or not beleeve, the eternall decree of God does nothing, his means, Gospel, his inward grace (such grace as they can grant) doe no more, nor can doe any more to determine the will to either side, to beleeving, or not beleeving; then he can work contradictions, or make free will, and free ob•dience to be no free will, and no obedience, for its repugnant (say they) to the nature of free-will that it should be determined by God; And 〈…〉, such as is required of us now who are under comm•••ements, threatnings, promises, were no obedience at all, for if the Lord ⟨p. 411⟩should determine the will (say they) and therefore Gods last decree of chusing those to life, whom he foresees shall expire in faith, and persevere to the end, and of rejecting such, as he foresees shall goe on, in finall obstinacy against the Gospel, is not any Scripturall decree of Election or Reprobation, nor hath God any liberty in this, to chuse this man, not this man, but all men chuse God, and are foreseen finally to beleeve, or not beleeve, before, and without any free decree of God; so that the number of chosen Angels or men is in the power of the creatures free will; not in the liberty of the former of all things; so as we chuse God, but God chuseth not us. But 2. So none are within the compasse of Election or Reprobation, but such as hear the Gospel; and so all the Heathen are saved or damned by chance, or without any will or decree of God, or they must be neither capable of salvation, nor damnat•on, contrary to Scripture and experience, for terrible judgements temporall, and great externall favours befall Indians, Americans, and such as never heard of Christ, and not without the counsell of Gods will, if there be a provid•nce that rules the world. 2. God doth nothing in the Election of Peter, more then of Iudas; nor can grace and mercy have place in the chusing of the one, rather then the other; but as free will is foreseen to play the game ill, or well, so goe the eternall decrees of Election and Reprobation, and there can be no such thing as that grace and the free pleasure of God, who hath mercy on whom he will, or because he will, and hardens whom he will, can have any place here.
4. The Scripture no where speaks of any love of God in Christ to man, but such as is efficacious in saving;1 any other love is lip-love, not real; and so to allege this one place, without authority of the Word, is petitio principii, a begging of the question; for the love Ezech. 16.8. Called the time of loves, was such as saved, all that were to b• saved, amongst the people of God; and cannot be understood of such a love as God did bear to the Heathen, and the Canaanites, for it separates them from all the world: so Deut. 7.7. Psal. 146.19.20 Isai. 51.1, 2, 3. Isai. 52.3, 4. Psal. 132.1•. Psal. 1•5.4. Zech. 3.2. 1 King. 1.13. 2 Chron. 6.6. Isai. 4•.8, 9. Deut. 14.2. Isai. 43 20. Dan. 1•. 15. 1 Chron. 16.13. Ezech. 20.5. Act. 13.17. Ye shall not find that the love of God in Christ can consist ⟨p. 412⟩with Reprobation, or Damnation, in all the Scripture; but by the contrary, it is a love that Christ hath to his wife, in giving himself for her; sanctifying, washing and presenting her, without spot or wrinkle before […] a husband-love, Ephes. 5.25, 26. a love saving, b• the washing of Regeneration, and renewing of the Holy Ghost •i•us 3.4, 5, 6. a great love, quickening us together with Christ, saving us by grace, raising us up, and making us •it together with Jesus Christ, in heavenly places. Ephes. 2.4.5. a love causing washing of us, and advancing us to be Kings and Priests to God, Revel. 1.5, 6. a love to Paul in particular, and working life in Paul, Gal. 2.20. I live no more, but Christ liveth in me, and the life which I now live in the flesh; I live by the faith of the Son of God, who loved me, and gave himself for me. It is the love of God our Father, who hath loved us, and hath given us everlasting consolation, and good hope through grace. 2 Thes. 2.16. an everlasting love. Jer. 31.3. a love before the foundation of the world, Ephes. 1.3, 4, before we do good or evil, Rom. 9.11. Not a love that falls to nothing; by a consequent act of hatred, nor a love to which the hatred of reprobation may succeed every hour, and out of which we may be decourted; a love that puts the honour of sons on us, 1 Joh. 3.1. It is a saving and a pitying love Isai. 63.9. a love which the Lord rests in, Zeph. 3.17. a love continuing to the end, Joh. 13.1. a love that makes us more then conquerors. R•m. 8.37.
4. The Scripture no where speakes of any love of God in Christ to man, but such as is efficacious in saving;1 any other love is lip-love, not reall; and so to alledge this one place, without authoritie of the Word, is petitio principii, a begging of the question; for the love Ez•ch. 16.8. Called the time of loves, was such as saved, all that were to b• saved, amongst the people of God; and cannot be understood of such a love as God did bear to the Heathen, and the Cannanits, for it separates them from all the world: so Deut. 7.7. Psal. 146.19.20 Isai. 51.1, 2, 3. Isai. 52.3, 4. Psal. 132.1•. Psal. 1•5.4. Zech. 3.2. 1 King. 1.13. 2 Chron. 6.6. Isai. 4•.8, 9. Deut. 14.2. Isai. 43 20. Dan. 1•. 15. 1 Chron. 16.13. Ezech. 20.5. Act. 13.17. Yee shall not finde that the love of God in Christ can consist ⟨p. 412⟩with Reprobation, or Damnation, in all the Scripture; but by the contrary, it is a love that Christ hath to his wife, in giving himselfe for her; sanctifying, washing and presenting her, without spot or wrinkle before a husband-love,
It is a separating love that differenceth the loved of God, from all others, Psal. 87.2. Psal. 1.6.8. otherwise all the world, should in regard of this general, and antecedent, and conditional love of God, be so the beloved of God; as Christ in the song of Solomon, esteemeth the Spouse his love, his well beloved: Its a love better then life, Psal. 6•.3. and the dowry Christ bestoweth on his spouse, Hos. 2.19. now the Scripture no where speaketh of that conditional love, which the Lord beareth to Heathens,1 Reprobates, and to all Men and Angels.
It is a separating love that differenceth the loved of God, from all others, Psal. 87.2. Psal. 1.6.8. otherwise all the world, should in regard of this generall, and antecedent, and conditionall love of God, bee so the beloved of God; as Christ in the song of Solomon, esteemeth the Spouse his love, his welbeloved: Its a love better then life, Psal. 6•.3. and the dowrie Christ bestoweth on his spouse, Hos. 2.19. now the Scripture no where speaketh of that conditionall love, which the Lord beareth to Heathens,1 Reprobates, and to all Men and Angels.
1All redeemed from w•ath to come, are redeeme• from all iniquity and this present evil world.All redeemed from w•ath to come, are redeeme• from all iniquitie and this present evill world.
5. Such as the Lord so loved, as he hath redeemed them from perishing, he hath redeemed them from sin and Gentilism; to wit, from this present evil world, Gal. 1.4. yea, the blood of the Lamb, unspotted, and undefiled, hath bought them from their vain conversation, received by tradition, from their fathers, 1 Pet. 1.18. yea, from fornication, that they should ⟨p. 413⟩be members of Christ, temples of the Holy Ghost, 1 Cor. 6.20. yea, Christ bare their sins in his own body on the tree, that they should live to righteousness. Now all and every one of mankind, Heathen and Turks, are not thus bought with a price, and deliv•••d from idolatry, blasphemy, killing of child••• to their god, from the world of Gentilism. 1. Th•y live in these sins, as serving God in them; the Gospel nev•• forbade them any such si•n•s, in regard th•y never heard the Gospel. 2 They cannot sin on a n•w score, or a new reckoning; these being to them, no sins against the Gospel; but against the law written in their heart. 3. There is a p•ice then given: for all the reprobate vice reproborum, it is […] as they had payed the price to redeem them from sin, and unbelief; yea, from final impenitency against the Gospel: If this be a sin, as it is the sin of sins, Christ must bear it on the tree, 1 Pet. 1.24. The lamb of God must take it away. Joh. 1.29. Except it were possible final unbelief were pardonable without shedding of blood. Heb. 10. Now here the ransom payed, but the captive is never delivered, for the reprobate die in their sins Joh. 8.21. There be some say, there is a ransom given for these Gospel-sins of the reprobate, conditionally, so they believe.
5. Such as the Lord so loved, as hee hath redeemed them from perishing, he hath redeemed them from sinne and Gentilisme; to wit, from this present evill world, Gal. 1.4. yea, the blood of the Lambe, unspoted, and undefiled, hath bought them from their vaine conversation, received by tradition, from their fathers, 1 Pet. 1.18. yea, from fornication, that they should ⟨p. 413⟩bee members of Christ, temples of the Holy Ghost, 1 Cor. 6.20. yea, Christ bare their sinnes in his owne body on the tree, that they should live to righteousnesse. Now all and every one of mankinde, Heathen and Turks, are not thus bought with a price, and deliv•••d from idolatry, blasphemy, killing of child••• to th•ir god, from the world of Gentilisme. 1. Th•y liv• in these sinnes, as serving God in them; the Gospel nev•• forbade th•m any such si•n•s, in regard th•y never heard the Gospel. 2 They cannot sinne on a n•w score, or a new reckning; these being to them, no sinnes against the Gospel; but against the law written in their heart. 3. There is a p•ice then given: for all the reprobate vice reproborum, it is 〈…〉 as they had payed the price to redeeme them from sinne, and unbeliefe; yea, from finall impenitencie against the Gospel: If this bee a sinne, as it is the sinne of sinnes, Christ must beare it on the tree, 1 Pet. 1.24. The lambe of God must take it away. Ioh. 1.29. Except it were possible finall unbeliefe were pardonable without shedding of blood. Heb. 10. Now here the ransome payed, but the captive is never delivered, for the reprobate die in their sinnes
Anew. That is, they are freed from final impenitency, so they be freed from final impenitency: is this a wife bargain? 2. Where is there is all the Word, a warrant that Christ laid down his life for his sheep conditionally; so he foresaw they would be his sheep; so they would believe and repent? Now this he could not do: for Christ out of deliberation, and his Fathers eternal counsel, absolutely, gratis, freely di•d for these; he died not for those, that he foresaw would never fulfil the condition, nunquam positâ conditione, nunquam ponitur conditionatum.
An•w. That is, they are freed from finall impenitencie, so they bee freed from finall impenitencie: is this a wife bargain? 2. Where is there is all the Word, a warrant that Christ layd downe his life for his sheep conditionally; so he foresaw they would be his sheep; so they would beleeve and repent? Now this hee could not doe: for Christ out of deliberation, and his Fathers eternall counsell, absolutely, gratis, freely di•d for these; he died not for those, that he foresaw would never fulfill the condition, nunquam positâ conditione, nunquam ponitur conditionatum.
6. Christ bought by his blood of the eternal Covenant, all the Jewels of the Covenant, all things that belong to life and godliness, and all spiritual blessings, 2 Pet. 1.3. Ephes. 1.3. A new heart and a new Spirit, 1Ezech. 36.26. Jer. 31.33, 34, 35, 36. Ezek. 11, 19, 20. He bought all that God giveth to us, then he must have purchased faith, Phil. 1.29. Joh. 6.29. and if he was made a Prince to give repentance and remission, then to give faith, for it is a grace above nature, and out of this ⟨p. 414⟩fountain, we have grace for grace, Joh. 1.14. Now this is not given to all men.
6. Christ bought by his blood of the eternall Covenant, all the Jewels of the Covenant, all things that belong to life and go•linesse, and all spirituall blessings, 2 Pet. 1.3. Ephes. 1.3. A new heart and a new Spirit, 1Ezech. 36.26. Jer. 31.33, 34, 35, 36. Ezek. 11, 19, 20. He bought all that God giveth to us, then he must have purchased faith, Phil. 1.29. Joh. 6.29. and if he was made a Prince to give repentance and remission, then to give faith, for it is a grace above nature, and out of this ⟨p. 414⟩fountain, we have grace for grace, Ioh. 1.14. Now this is not given to all men.
7. All these graces are particular, 1. Election to glory is particular, Few are chosen, Mat. 22.14. Joh. 10.26.29. Ephes. 1.4. Rom. 9.11. The promise is particular to the sons of the promise, Rom. 9.8, 9. made to Christ, and his seed only, Gal. 3.16, 17, 18.1Gal. 4.22, 23, &c. the calling particular, Isai. 55.1, 2. Matth. 11.27, 28. Acts 2.39. the Covenant particular, and takes in only the House of Judah, the elect and such as cannot fall away, Jer. 31.34, 35, &c. and 32.39, 40. Isai. 54.10. and 59.19, 20. The surety of the Covenant, Christ, Heb. 7.22. promised to be King over the House of David, over his people only; the intention of God particular to a foreknown people only, Rom. 11.1. The circumference and extent of Grace then cannot be so wide, as to take in all, nor can Redemption be universal, because conditional. For 1. Arminians make Election conditional, but they deny it in words to be universal; further glorification is conditional, justification conditional, upon condition of Faith, but because the condition never is, all men have not faith; therefore glorification and justification is particular, and redemption on the same ground must be particular; none are actually redeemed but the believers, so as glorification actual (the decree of glorifying is another thing, and absolute) and Election to glory are commensurable, the one not larger then the other, Rom. 8.29, 30. how can Redemption, which is a mid-link between both, be of a wider Sphere to take in all? for 1 Thes. 5.9. Gods counsel set us on Christ as Redeemer, and gives us to Christ.
7. All these graces are particular, 1. Election to glory is particular, Few are chosen, Mat. 22.14. Joh. 10.26.29. Ephes. 1.4. Rom. 9.11. The promise is particular to the sons of the promise, Rom. 9.8, 9. made to Christ, and his seed only, Gal. 3.16, 17, 18.1Gal. 4.22, 23, &c. the calling particular, Isai. 55.1, 2. Matth. 11.27, 28. Acts 2.39. the Covenant particular, and takes in only the House of Judah, the elect and such as cannot fall away, Ier. 31.34, 35, &c. and 32.39, 40. Isai. 54.10. and 59.19, 20. The surety of the Covenant, Christ, Heb. 7.22. promised to be King over the House of David, over his people only; the intention of God particular to a foreknown people only, Rom. 11.1. The circumference and extent of Grace then cannot be so wide, as to take in all, nor can Redemption be universall, because conditionall. For 1. Arminians make Election conditionall, but they deny it in words to be universall; further glorification is conditionall, justification conditionall, upon condition of Faith, but because the condition never is, all men have not fa•th; therefore glorification and justification is particular, and redemption on the same ground must be particular; none are actually redeemed but the beleevers, so as glorification actuall (the decree of glorifying is another thing, and absolute) and Election to glory are commensurable, the one not larger then the other,
1All graces in Christ are peculiar to the elect only, how can then Redemption be universal?All graces in Christ are peculiar to the el•ct •nly, how can then Redemption be universall?
8. These two (Christ redeemeth all) and (Christ intendeth to redeem all) are most different: Now Gods intention to redeem all if they believe, suspendeth either redemption, or the intention of God to redeem: If the former be said, redemption of all, is no Redemption, except all believe, but all do not believe: If the latter, God must wave and hang by his intention in millions of souls, and cannot fix his foot to be peremptory in his intentions except they believe, and he seeth they shall never believe, for he knoweth what is in man, and beholdeth the thoughts a far off.
8. These two (Christ redeemeth all) and (Christ intendeth to redeem all) are most different: Now Gods intention to redeem all if they beleeve, suspendeth either redemption, or the intention of God to redeem: If the former be said, redemption of all, is no Redemption, except all beleeve, but all doe not beleeve: If the latter, God must wave and hang by his intention in millions of soules, and cannot fixe his foot to be peremptory in his intentions except they beleeve, and he seeth they shall never beleeve, for he knoweth what is in man, and beholdeth the thoughts a far off.
Yea, as I said elsewhere, if we speak properly in reference to ⟨p. 415⟩God, the very promises of the Gospel are not conditional; because both the condition,1 and the thing that falls under the condition, depend on his own absolute will, and free gift; if a father promise to his child an inheritance upon condition the child pay him ten thousand crowns, and the Father only do give, and can give the child these ten thousand crowns; we cannot say, this is a bargain between the father and the son, that leans upon conditions, especially if we suppose, as the case is between God and the creature, that this father can and doth indeclinably determine the will of his son to consent, and to give back again to his father this sum of money, and to consent to the bargain; there is here no condition relating to the father, but he does all freely. Believing is a condition, and life eternal is conditionatum, a thing that falleth under promise, but both depend upon the absolute, free and irresistible will of the Lord; as there is no condition here properly so called, either laid upon the will, or limiting the external action of God.
Yea, as I said elsewhere, if we speak properly in reference to ⟨p. 415⟩God, the very promises of the Gospel are not conditionall; because both the condition,1 and the thing that falls under the condition, depend on his owne absolute will, and free gift; if a father promise to his child an inheritance upon condition the child pay him ten thousand crowns, and the Father only do give, and can give the child these ten thousand crownes; we cannot say, this is a bargain between the father and the son, that leans upon conditions, especially if we suppose, as the case is between God and the creature, that this father can and doth indeclinably determine the will of his son to consent, and to give back againe to his father this sum of money, and to consent to the bargain; there is here no condition relating to the father, but he does all freely. Beleeving is a condition, and life eternall is conditionatum, a thing that falleth under promise, but both d•pend upon the absolute, free and irresistible will of the Lord; as there is no condition here properly so called, either laid upon the will, or limiting the externall action of God.
1The promises of the Gospel not properly conditional in relation to God.The promises of the Gospel not properly conditionall in relation to God.
9. Hence the promises of the Gospel are indefinite, not universal, and in the Lords purpose and intention made with the Elect only, not with the Reprobate at all, for when God saith, if Judas, Cain, Pharaoh, believe they shall be saved, the Lords purpose being •o deny to them the grace of believing, without which it is unpossible they can believe, the promise in Gods purpose is not made with them: He that so willeth what he promiseth upon a condition, which he that so willeth, only can do and work, and yet will not do or work the condition; he doth indeed not will to the party, what is so promised, if John send Peter to work in his garden upon condition, that if he work, he shall give him a talent a day, and in the mean while John only can give to Peter strength of legs, and arms, and body to work, can determine his consent to the work, and yet refuse to give strength, and to win his consent to the work; Sure he never wi•led either to give him a talent for his work, nor intended he should work at all. Hence I ar•ue, it is against the wisdom of God to intend and will that the Reprobate be redeemed, pardoned, saved, upon a condition, which he himself only can work by his grace, and absolutely and irresistibly will not work.1 Now in Scripture such a thing is argued not to be done, because the Scripture must be fulfill•• ; and the decree of God and his will fulfilled, as Christs bones upon this ground, ⟨p. 416⟩could not be broken, and such a thing is done that the Scripture, and so the will and decree of God might be fulfilled, so that which is never done, is simply Gods will it shall never be done; that which is done is simply Gods will it must be; I mean either his permissive or approving will;2 and the will of God revealing, what is the duty of Reprobates though it never be done, argues it was not simply the will of God; hence that voluntas signi, in which God reveals what is our duty, and what we ought to do; not what is his decree, or what he either will, or ought to do, is not Gods will properly, but by a figure only, for commands, and promises, and threatenings revealed, argue not the will and purpose, decree or intention of God, which are properly his will.
9. Hence the promises of the Gospel are indefinite, not universall, and in the Lords purpose and intention made with the Elect onely, not with the Reprobate at all, for when God saith, if Iudas, Cain, Pharaoh, beleeve they shall be saved, the Lords purpose being •o deny to them the grace of beleeving, without which it is unpossible they can beleeve, the promise in Gods purpose is not made with them: He that so willeth what he promiseth upon a condition, which he that so willeth, only can doe and work, and yet will not do or work the condition; he doth indeed not will to the party, what is so promised, if John send Peter to work in his garden upon condition, that if he worke, he shall give him a talent a day, and in the mean while Iohn onely can give to Peter strength of legs, and armes, and body to work, can determine his consent to the work, and yet refuse to give strength, and to win his consent to the work; Sure he never wi•led either to give him a talent for his work, nor intended hee should work at all. Hence I ar•ue, it is against the wisedome of God to intend and will that the Reprobate be redeemed, pardoned, saved, upon a condition, which he himself only can work by his grace, and absolutely and irresistibly will not work.1 Now in Scripture such a thing is argued not to bee done, because the Scripture must be fulfill•• ; and the decree of God and his will ful••lled, as Christs bones upon this ground, ⟨p. 416⟩could not be broken, and such a thing is done that the Scripture, and so the will and decree of God might be fulfilled, so that which is never done, is simply Gods will it shall never be done; that which is done is simply Gods will it must be; I mean either his permissive or approving will;2 and the will of God revealing, what is the duty of Reprobates though it never be done, argu•s it was not simply the will of God; hence that voluntas signi, in which God reveales what is our dutie, and what we ought to doe; not what is his decree, or what he either wil, or ought to doe, is not Gods will properly, but by a figure only, for commands, and promises, and threatnings revealed, argue not the will and purpose, decree or intention of God, which are properly his will.
1What is neve• done is not Gods will simply.
2The revealed will of God called voluntas signi, is not simply Gods will, but only so called by a figure.The revealed will of God called voluntas signi, is not simply Gods will, but onely so called by a figure.
10. It is against the wisdom of God to intend the actual Redemption and salvation of all, and every one, and not to will, nor work such conditions, which only he himself can work, and are in his power only, and without the which the creature cannot be redeemed and saved, but he neither will, nor doth work faith in all; then he never intended the actual redemption and salvation of all and every one.
10. It is against the wisedome of God to intend the actuall Redemption and salvation of all, and every one, and not to will, nor work such conditions, which onely he himself can work, and are in his power only, and without the which the creature cannot be redeemed and saved, but he neither will, nor doth work faith in all; then he never intended the actuall redemption and salvation of all and every one.
Hence what ever wanton and lascivious reason can object against absolute Reprobation, the absolute Redemption of some few, a particular atonement of some few, equally fighteth with the opinion of adversaries, as against ours, they say;
Hence what ever wanton and lascivious reason can object against absolute Reprobation, the absolute Redemption of some few, a particular atton•ment of some few, equally fighteth with the opinion of adversaries, as against ours, they say;
2. Mercy, bowels of compassion, by your particular, absolute Redemption is extended to few; 1and all the rest of the lost world, left to sink eternally, notwithstanding of the infinite and boundless love and man-kindness of God. Its answered, these fall with equal strength of wanton reason, upon conditional and universal Redemption, or Gods conditional and universal will to save all, and every one; for say that a father did foresee, if he beget twenty sons, that eighteen of them shall be cast in a river of fire, to be burnt quick, where they shall be tormented ten thousand years, ever dying, and not able to find death, to end their miseries, and that they may be Kings in great riches and honour, upon a condition of such and such a carriage of them in their education, and young years, which this father can easily work with one word; yet he willingly ⟨p. 417⟩begets these children, he can work such a condition in them, as they may all be kings, yet deliberately this he will not do, but acts so upon the will of these children, as he knows indeclinably the greatest part of them all sh•ll be tormented for ten thousand years in this extreme fire. Who can say, 1. that this father, quantum in se, as far as he can, hath redeemed all, and every one of his children from ten thousand years pain? Who can say, this father intended and willed the life and honour of these eighteen children, when as he might with no pain to himself, most easily have wrought the condition in them, which he wrought in others, and would not? Hence, if there must be a mystery in the Gospel, and the Lords ways and thoughts must be above ours, as far as the heaven is above the earth, if the Lord did foresee the greatest part of mankind, and many legions of Angels should be cast in chains of darkness, and in a lake of fire and brimstone for ever and ever. 1. Vain reason would say, why did he create them? if he fore-saw their misery would be so deplorable; and how can he earnestly and ardently, with prayers, obtestations, wishes, threatenings, precepts, promises, desire their eternal salvation? 2.
2. Mercie, bowels of compassion, by your particular, absolute Redemption is extended to few; 1and all the rest of the lost world, left to sincke eternally, notwithstanding of the infinite and boundlesse love and man-kindnesse of God. Its answered, these fall with equall strength of wanton reason, upon conditionall and universall Redemption, or Gods conditionall and universall will to save all, and every one; for say that a father did foresee, if he beget twenty sonnes, that eighteen of them shall be cast in a river of fire, to be burnt quick, where they shall bee tormented ten thousand yeares, ever dying, and not able to finde death, to end their miseries, and that they may be Kings in great riches and honour, upon a condition of such and such a carriage of them in their education, and young yeares, which this father can easily worke with one word; yet hee willingly ⟨p. 417⟩begets these children, hee can worke such a condition in them, as they may all be kings, yet deliberatly this he will not doe, but acts so upon the will of these children, as he knowes indeclinably the greatest part of them all sh•ll be tormented for ten thousand yeares in this extreme fire. Who can say, 1. that this father, quantum in se, as farre as he can, hath redeemed all, and every one of his children from ten thousand yeares paine? Who can say, this father intended and willed the life and honour of these eighteene children, when as hee might with no paine to himselfe, most easily have wrought the condition in them, which he wrought in others, and would not? Hence, if there must bee a mystery in the Gospel, and the Lords waies and thoughts must be above ours, as farre as the heaven is above the earth, if the Lord did foresee the greatest part of mankind, and many legions of Angels should be cast in chaines of darknesse, and in a lake of fire and brimstone for ever and ever. 1. Vaine reason would say, why did hee create them? if hee fore-saw their misery would bee so deplorable; and how can he earnestly and ardently, with prayers, obtestations, wishes, threatnings, precepts, promises, desire their eternall salvation? 2.
1What can, in shadow of vain reason, be objected against absolute election, and reprobation, and particular redemption, fall with equal strength, upon conditional, & universal election and redemption.What can, in shaddow of vain reason, be objected against absolute el•ction, and reprobation, and particular redemption, fall with equal strength, upon conditionall, & universall •l•ction and redemption.
Samuel Rutherford
1600?–1661
PuritansScotland
Scottish theologian and commissioner to the Westminster Assembly.
. a love saving, b• the washing of Regeneration, and renewing of the Holy Ghost •i•us 3.4, 5, 6. a great love, quickning us together with Christ, saving us by grace, raising us up, and making us •it together with Jesus Christ, in heavenly places.
. I live no more, but Christ liveth in mee, and the life which I now live in the flesh; I live by the faith of the Sonne of God, who loved mee, and gave himselfe for me. It is the love of God our Father, who hath loved us, and hath given us everlasting consolation, and good hope through grace.
. Not a love that fals to nothing; by a consequent act of hatred, nor a love to which the hatred of reprobation may succeed every hour, and out of which wee may bee decourted; a love that puts the honour of sonnes on us,