I answer, 2. to that: That which is inchoate sinfully defective, and incomplete, that the righteous and unchangeable God cannot account perfect and complete, or that which is sinfully defective, or that which is sinful, God cannot account not sinful; It is true, it were an erroneous and unjust account; now the proposition is true; but the assumption most false; the good works of the regenerate and justified are sinful. But Gods accounting of them perfect▪ putteth no contradiction on them to account them not sinful: God accounts not Davids adultery to be an act of chastity; This is the Papists argument against the imputed righteousness of Christ, which Antinomians being▪ utterly ignorant of the nature of justification, bring against us; the other part of the distinction is, That which is sinful and defective in it self, and inherently, or really and physically, that God cannot account perfect, that is, God cannot account it and the doer, legally free from obligation to eternal wrath, for the satisfaction of another, the surety of sinners, who has paid and suffered for it; that is most false, and should destroy the Protestant justification, when we say God accounteth the good works of believers good and perfect, so as the imperfection and sin of them is removed; we mean not by removing of the sin of these works, the total annihilation of sin, in its essence ⟨p. 597⟩root and branch, it dwelleth in us in its complete essence while we are here, Rom. 7.17.23. Prov. 20.9. 1 Joh. 1.8.10. only the dominion, by sanctification, is abated, and the guilt or obligation to eternal wrath is removed in justification; and this Argument may well be retorted: Who ever is a sinner, the righteous and immutable God whose judg•ment is according to verity, and cannot suffer the loss of the least title of his righteousness, Matth. 5.18. cannot esteem him just, and perfectly righteous: But all men even the regenerate, are sinners: No answer, no distinction can be accommodated to this Argument, which may not be applied to their argument; for God is no less, just, righteous, immutable, true, no respectre of persons, and his Law inviolable in his accounting of persons righteous and perfect, then in accounting of works righteous and perfect.
I answer, 2. to that: That which is inchoat sinfully defective, and imcompleat, that the righteous and unchangeable God cannot account perfect and compleat, or that which is sinfully defective, or that which is sinfull, God cannot account not sinfull; It is true, it were an erroneous and unjust account; now the proposition is true; but the assumption most false; the good works of the regenerate and justified are sinfull. But Gods accounting of them perfect▪ putteth no contradiction on them to account them not sinfull: God accounts not Davids adultery to bee an act of chastity; This is the Papists argument against the imputed righteousnesse of Christ, which Antinomians being▪ utterly ignorant of the nature of justification, bring against us; the other part of the distinction is, That which is sinfull and defective in it selfe, and inherently, or really and physically, that God cannot account perfect, that is, God cannot account it and the doer, legally free from obligation to eternall wrath, for the satisfaction of another, the surety of sinners, who has payd and suffered for it; that is most false, and should destroy the Protestant justification, when we say God accounteth the good works of believers good and perfect, so as the imperfection and sinne of them is removed; we meane not by removing of the sinne of these works, the totall annihilation of sinne, in its essence ⟨p. 597⟩root and branch, it dwelleth in us in its compleat essence while we are here, Rom. 7.17.23. Prov. 20.9. 1 Ioh. 1.8.10. only the dominion, by sanctification, is abated, and the guilt or obligation to eternall wrath is removed in justification; and this Argument may well be retorted: Who ever is a sinner, the righteous and immutable God whose judg•ment is ac•ording to verity, and cannot suffer the losse of the least titl• of his righteousnesse, Matth. 5.18. cannot esteeme him just, and perfectly righteous: But all men even the regenerate, are sinners: No answer, no distinction can be accommodated to this Argument, which may not be applyed to their argument; for God is no lesse, just, righteous, immutable, true, no respecter of persons, and his Law inviolable in his accounting of persons righteous and perfect, then in accounting of works righteous and perfect.