Answ. 1. I deny, that Liberty of contradiction belongeth to the essence and nature of liberty. 1Its enough to make liberty, that 1. It proceeds not from a principle determined by nature, to one kind of action, so the Sun is not free to give light. 2. That the principle be free of all foreign force, the malefactor goeth not freely to the place of execution, when hailed to it. 3. That it proceed from deliberation, reason, election, and wisdom, seeing no essential connection, or necessary, or natural relation, between the action, and the end thereof of themselves, but such as may be dispensed with; if these three be, though there be a necessity, in some respect, from a free decree, and a free promise, though there be not liberty of contradiction, simply to do, or not to do, yet is not any degree, of the essence of liberty removed. I well remember, Dr. Jackson, denying all decrees in God, that setteth the Almighty to one side of the contradiction, resembleth God to the Pope, whose wisdom he commendeth in that the Popes decrees, grants, laws, promises, are fast and loose, and all made with a reserve of after-wit, so as if the morrows illumination be better,2 then the days; whiles his life breatheth in, and out, he may change and retract his will; so saith he, Papa nunquam sibi ligat manus, the Pope ties all the world to himself by oaths, laws, promises; but that lawless beast is tied to none. Now the Scripture teacheth us, that the decrees and counsels of God are surer, then mountains of brass and unchangeable, and that his promise cannot fail. But who dare say, when he executes his decrees, and fulfilleth his promise, ⟨p. 267⟩that he forfeiteth or loseth one inch, degree, or part of his essential liberty, God should then be less free to create the world, then if we suppose he had never decreed to create it, and yet doth create it; as if the Lords free decree lavished away, and should drink up, and waste any part of his natural freedom in his actions: or as if his faithfulness to make good what he promised, should render him lame, and dismember him of the fullness and freedom of his grace, and so the more faithful and true, the less gracious; and the more unchangeable in his counsels; the more fettered and chained, and the less free in all these actions, that he doth according to the counsel of his will. A gross mis-conception:
Answ. 1. I deny, that Libertie of contradiction belongeth to the essence and nature of libertie. 1Its enough to make libertie, that 1. It proceeds not from a principle determined by nature, to one kind of action, so the Sunne is not free to give light. 2. That the principle be free of all forraigne force, the malefactor goeth not freely to the place of execution, when hailed to it. 3. That it proceed from deliberation, reason, election, and wisdome, seeing no essentiall connexion, or necessary, or naturall relation, between the action, and the end thereof of themselves, but such as may bee dispensed with; if these three be, though there be a necessity, in some respect, from a free decree, and a free promise, though there bee not liberty of contradiction, simply to doe, or not to doe, yet is not any degree, of the essence of libertie removed. I well remember, Dr. Jackson, denying all decrees in God, that setteth the Almighty to one side of the contradiction, resembleth God to the Pope, whose wisdome he commendeth in that the Popes decrees, grants, lawes, promises, are fast and loose, and all made with a reserve of after-wit, so as if the morrowes illumination be better,2 then the dayes; whiles his life breatheth in, and out, he may change and retract his will; so saith he, Papa nunquam sibi ligat manus, the Pope tyes all the world to himselfe by oathes, lawes, promises; but that lawlesse beast is tyed to none. Now the Scripture teacheth us, that the decrees and counsels of God are surer, then mountaines of brasse and unchangeable, and that his promise cannot faile. But who dare say, when he executes his decrees, and fulfilleth his promise, ⟨p. 267⟩that he forfeiteth or loseth one inch, degree, or part of his essentiall libertie, God should then bee lesse free to create the world, then if we suppose he had never decreed to create it, and yet doth create it; as if the Lords free decree lavished away, and should drinke up, and waste any part of his naturall freedome in his actions: or as if his faithfulnesse to make good what he promised, should render him lame, and dismember him of the fulnesse and freedome of his grace, and so the more faithfull and true, the lesse gracious; and the more unchangeable in his counsels; the more fettered and chained, and the lesse free in all these actions, that he doth according to the counsell of his will. A grosse mis-conception:
- 1The nature of liberty, not in a liberty of contradiction but in other three things.The nature of liberty, not in a liberty of contradiction but in other •hree things.
- 2The Lords decrees and promises diminish nothing of his liberty and freedom of grace in his working.The Lords decrees and promises d•minish nothing of his liberty and freedome of grace in his working.