But I have learned of qMr. Coachman that only the converted are to be excommunicated, because they have a spirit to be saved in the day of the Lord, 1 Cor. 5. The non-converted are flesh▪ but truly this is strange, Paul speaketh of the incestuous person according to the judgement of charity, as supposing hi• to have flesh and Spirit, as he professeth himself to be a member of the Church; but truly this is weak: for in the same Chapter Paul will have drunkards, railers, extortioners, idolaters, to be excommunicated. Peter did really excommunicate Simon ⟨p. 277⟩Magus excluding him from part and portion in the visible Church. Act. 8. 21. and are such not to be excommunicated because they cannot be cast out, who were never within? See into what inconveniences our brethren are fallen, while they agree (I speak with reverence of those godly men) with Anabaptists in the nature of the visible Church. But truly hypocrites are within the Church, and when their hypocrisy doth break out into grievous scandals, they are to be cast out of the visible Church; but they cannot indeed be cast out of the invisible Church, because they were never within the same, but our brethren still do confound the visible and invisible Church, which in nature 2and essence are opposed by way of contradiction, if Augustine say right, multae oves extra visiblem Ecclesiam, & multi lupi intra. For the Church invisible as it is such and essentially, is not the Church visible; and the Church visible is not essentially invisible. But to return to Robinson, if the regenerate cannot be excommunicated, they cannot fall into such grievous sins as incest, murder, and contumacy to the Church, which deserveth excommunication. But this latter none can say but Novatians. Ergo, neither can the former be said. The major is undeniable, whosoever can, and may commit sins deserving excommunication, are to be excommunicated, as Christ saith, Matth. 18. 17. 18. and Paul, 1 Cor. 5. 4, 5. Now if the converted cannot fall into grievous sins against the Church, such as contumacy; neither can they fall into grievous sins against God, 2. By this doctrine no professors are to be excommunicated at all, for all within the visible Church are either converted or non-converted; the converted are not to be excommunicated, saith Robinson, because they are the true members of the Church, and of Christs body;
But I have learned of qMr. Coachman that onely the converted are to be excommunicated, because they have a spirit to be saved in the day of the Lord, 1 Cor. 5. The non-converted are flesh▪ but truely this is strange, Paul speaketh of the incestuous person according to the judgement of charity, as supposing hi• to have flesh and Spirit, as he professeth himselfe to be a member of the Church; but truely this is weake: for in the same Chapter Paul will have drunkards, railers, extortioners, idolaters, to be excommunicated. Peter did really excommunicate Simon ⟨p. 277⟩Magus excluding him from part and portion in the visible Church. Act. 8. 21. and are such not to be excommunicated because they cannot be cast out, who were never within? See into what inconveniences our brethren are fallen, while they agree (I speake with reverence of those godly men) with Anabaptists in the nature of the visible Church. But truely hypocrites are within the Church, and when their hypocrisie doth breake out into grievous scandals, they are to be cast out of the visible Church; but they cannot indeed be cast out of the invisible Church, because they were never within the same, but our brethren still doe confound the visible and invisible Church, which in nature 2and essence are opposed by way of contradiction, if Augustine say right, multae oves extra visiblem Ecclesiam, & multi lupi intra. For the Church invisible as it is such and essentially, is not the Church visible; and the Church visible is not essentially invisible. But to returne to Robinson, if the regenerate cannot be excommunicated, they cannot fall into such grievous sinnes as incest, murder, and contumacy to the Church, which deserveth excommunication. But this latter none can say but Novatians. Ergo, neither can the former be said. The major is undeniable, whosoever can, and may commit sins deserving excommunication, are to be excommunicated, as Christ saith, Matth. 18. 17. 18. and Paul, 1 Cor. 5. 4, 5. Now if the converted cannot fall into grievous sins against the Church, such as contumacy; neither can they fall into grievous sins against God, 2. By this doctrine no professors are to be excommunicated at all, for all within the visible Church are either converted or non-converted; the converted are not to be excommunicated, saith Robinson, because they are the true members of the Church, and of Christs body;
- qCoachman, cry of the stone sect. 4. p. 12.
- 2August. de doct. Christi, l. 3. c. 32. Contra cresoen. l. 2. c. 21.