Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
4. Neither do we mean with aSuarez and other Schoolmen, that excommunication doth not so cut off a member as it removeth not that baptismal character, or that passive power to receive the Sacraments; or that the prayers of the Church are not offered of direct intention, for the inwardly humbled and repenting excommunicated person, while the sentence of absolution be pronounced by the Church, as bSoto, cAdrianus, dand Alanus thinketh, because forsooth fInnocentius 111. saith, the excommunicated person, though repenting, and doing what he can to be reconciled to the Church, yet without absolution from the censure, he is mortuus Ecclesiasticè dead Ecclesiastically, and so in Heaven also. Though gNavarre, hTurrecremata, iRichard, kAnton. think the penitent excommunicated person is included in the general desires of the Church in their prayers, because it is not the intention of the Church to exclude a true and living member of Christs body from a communion spiritual with Christ. But our meaning is, that the excommunicated person is deprived of actual fellowship with Christ in the Seals of the Covenant, as the lCouncil of Arausican, A gremio […] matris Ecclesiae & consortio totius Christianitatis climina•us. His sin is bound in Heaven, yet so as the salvation of his spirit is intended by the Church, see for this
Augustine. We understand not a baptismal character, except regeneration and […] of sins, which cannot be taken away by excommunication, and therefore a moral claim to the holy things of God,
⟨p. 276⟩
and that for that time and state is rather removed, then any internal right to Christ. Therefore some say, in this he loseth rather possessionem quam jus, possession then right. As a Nobleman, for some offence, of three dwelling houses that he hath, is confined to one of the three, so as he may not remove from that one; yet doth he not lose right to the other two.
4. Neither doe we meane with aSuarez and other Schoolmen, that excommunication doth not so cut off a member as it removeth not that baptismall character, or that passive power to receive the Sacraments; or that the prayers of the Church are not offered of direct intention, for the inwardly humbled and repenting excommunicated person, while the sentence of absolution be pronounced by the Church, as bSoto, cAdrianus, dand Alanus thinketh, because forsooth fInnocentius 111. saith, the excommunicated person, though repenting, and doing what he can to be reconciled to the Church, yet without absolution from the censure, he is mortuus Ecclesiasticè dead Ecclesiastically, and so in Heaven also. Though gNavar, hTurrecremata, iRichard, kAnton. thinke the penitent excommunicated person is included in the generall desires of the Church in their prayers, because it is not the intention of the Church to exclude a true and living member of Christs body from a communion spirituall with Christ. But our meaning is, that the excommunicated person is deprived of actuall fellowship with Christ in the Seales of the Covenant, as the lCouncell of Arausican, A gremio 〈…〉 matris Ecclesiae & consortio totius Christianitatis climina•us. His sin is bound in Heaven, yet so as the salvation of his spirit is intended by the Church, see for this mAugustine. We understand not a baptismall character, except regeneration and 〈…〉 of sins, which cannot be taken away by excommunication, and therefore a morall claime to the holy things of God, ⟨p. 276⟩and that for that time and state is rather removed, then any internall right to Christ. Therfore some say, in this he loseth rather possessionem quam jus, possession then right. As a Nobleman, for some offence, of three dwelling houses that he hath, is confined to one of the three, so as he may not remove from that one; yet doth he not lose right to the other two.
aSuarez to•. 5. ad tert. part. Thom. de censur. disp. 5. sect. 1. de excom. not. 3.
5. Our brethren's doctrine is, that none can be judged and excommunicated, but those who are within the visible Church; nnow none are within to them but such as are supposed to be regenerated and saints; yea and more, faithful brethren, not only in profession (saith our oAuthor) but also in some measure of sincerity and truth. Hence none are to be excommunicated and delivered to Satan, but regenerated persons; then it cannot be the Churches mind, that the excommunicated persons are wholly cut off from the visible Church, since they being the true matter of the Church, as our brethren teach, remains therefore a part of Christs body in covenant with God, having right to the promises of the Covenant, and so these to whom the keys are given, by our brethren's grounds, and are regenerated, can only be excommunicated, and none else can be excommunicated, by their way also, for the unregenerated are without, and so cannot be cast out.
5. Our brethrens doctrine is, that none can be judged and excommunicated, but those who are within the visible Church; nnow none are within to them but such as are supposed to be regenerated and saints; yea and more, faithfull brethren, not onely in profession (saith our oAuthour) but also in some measure of sincerity and truth. Hence none are to be excommunicated and delivered to Satan, but regenerated persons; then it cannot be the Churches mind, that the excommunicated persons are wholy cut off from the visible Church, since they being the true matter of the Church, as our brethren teach, remains therefore a part of Christs body in covenant with God, having right to the promises of the Covenant, and so these to whom the keyes are given, by our brethrens grounds, and are regenerated, can onely be excommunicated, and none else can be excommunicated, by their way also, for the unregenerated are without, and so cannot be cast out.
I know not what Mr. Robinson can mean pthat the Church cannot cast out (as he saith) any part or parcel of her true matter. The Church cannot excommunicate the regenerated, 1. Because (saith he) the true matter of the Church, hath the form and essence of the Church, and the Church cannot cast out her own essence. 2. The Church should deliver to Satan the true members of Christs body, which he abhorreth to write.
I know not what Mr. Robinson can meane pthat the Church cannot cast out (as he saith) any part or parcell of her true matter. The Church cannot excommunicate the regenerated, 1. Because (saith he) the true matter of the Church, hath the forme and essence of the Church, and the Church cannot cast out her owne essence. 2. The Church should deliver to Satan the true members of Christs body, which he abhorreth to write.
pRobin. justif. of separate. p. 248.Robin. justif. of separat. p. 248.
But I have learned of qMr. Coachman that only the converted are to be excommunicated, because they have a spirit to be saved in the day of the Lord, 1 Cor. 5. The non-converted are flesh▪ but truly this is strange, Paul speaketh of the incestuous person according to the judgement of charity, as supposing hi• to have flesh and Spirit, as he professeth himself to be a member of the Church; but truly this is weak: for in the same Chapter Paul will have drunkards, railers, extortioners, idolaters, to be excommunicated. Peter did really excommunicate Simon ⟨p. 277⟩Magus excluding him from part and portion in the visible Church. Act. 8. 21. and are such not to be excommunicated because they cannot be cast out, who were never within? See into what inconveniences our brethren are fallen, while they agree (I speak with reverence of those godly men) with Anabaptists in the nature of the visible Church. But truly hypocrites are within the Church, and when their hypocrisy doth break out into grievous scandals, they are to be cast out of the visible Church; but they cannot indeed be cast out of the invisible Church, because they were never within the same, but our brethren still do confound the visible and invisible Church, which in nature 2and essence are opposed by way of contradiction, if Augustine say right, multae oves extra visiblem Ecclesiam, & multi lupi intra. For the Church invisible as it is such and essentially, is not the Church visible; and the Church visible is not essentially invisible. But to return to Robinson, if the regenerate cannot be excommunicated, they cannot fall into such grievous sins as incest, murder, and contumacy to the Church, which deserveth excommunication. But this latter none can say but Novatians. Ergo, neither can the former be said. The major is undeniable, whosoever can, and may commit sins deserving excommunication, are to be excommunicated, as Christ saith, Matth. 18. 17. 18. and Paul, 1 Cor. 5. 4, 5. Now if the converted cannot fall into grievous sins against the Church, such as contumacy; neither can they fall into grievous sins against God, 2. By this doctrine no professors are to be excommunicated at all, for all within the visible Church are either converted or non-converted; the converted are not to be excommunicated, saith Robinson, because they are the true members of the Church, and of Christs body;
But I have learned of qMr. Coachman that onely the converted are to be excommunicated, because they have a spirit to be saved in the day of the Lord, 1 Cor. 5. The non-converted are flesh▪ but truely this is strange, Paul speaketh of the incestuous person according to the judgement of charity, as supposing hi• to have flesh and Spirit, as he professeth himselfe to be a member of the Church; but truely this is weake: for in the same Chapter Paul will have drunkards, railers, extortioners, idolaters, to be excommunicated. Peter did really excommunicate Simon ⟨p. 277⟩Magus excluding him from part and portion in the visible Church. Act. 8. 21. and are such not to be excommunicated because they cannot be cast out, who were never within? See into what inconveniences our brethren are fallen, while they agree (I speake with reverence of those godly men) with Anabaptists in the nature of the visible Church. But truely hypocrites are within the Church, and when their hypocrisie doth breake out into grievous scandals, they are to be cast out of the visible Church; but they cannot indeed be cast out of the invisible Church, because they were never within the same, but our brethren still doe confound the visible and invisible Church, which in nature 2and essence are opposed by way of contradiction, if Augustine say right, multae oves extra visiblem Ecclesiam, & multi lupi intra. For the Church invisible as it is such and essentially, is not the Church visible; and the Church visible is not essentially invisible. But to returne to Robinson, if the regenerate cannot be excommunicated, they cannot fall into such grievous sinnes as incest, murder, and contumacy to the Church, which deserveth excommunication. But this latter none can say but Novatians. Ergo, neither can the former be said. The major is undeniable, whosoever can, and may commit sins deserving excommunication, are to be excommunicated, as Christ saith, Matth. 18. 17. 18. and Paul, 1 Cor. 5. 4, 5. Now if the converted cannot fall into grievous sins against the Church, such as contumacy; neither can they fall into grievous sins against God, 2. By this doctrine no professors are to be excommunicated at all, for all within the visible Church are either converted or non-converted; the converted are not to be excommunicated, saith Robinson, because they are the true members of the Church, and of Christs body;
qCoachman, cry of the stone sect. 4. p. 12.
2August. de doct. Christi, l. 3. c. 32. Contra cresoen. l. 2. c. 21.
now the non-converted far less can be excommunicated, because those cannot be cast out who are not within, as our brethren teach. For they are the false matter of the Church, and no part of it, yea (and as our Author saith,) have no measure of sincerity and truth; and therefore cannot be members of the Church. Now the Church (say our brethren) cannot judge those which are without, 1 Cor. 5. 12. 3 This opinion is just the opinion of the Anabaptists, that the true members of the visible Church are only regenerate persons, and they only have the essence of the true membership, which is false; they are within ⟨p. 278⟩the visible Church, and truly within the net, and a part of the ground called the Kingdom of God, Matth. 13. 4. Though they be not members of the invisible Church of believers and the redeemed in Christ. 4. The Nicolaitans, Jezebel, the false Apostles, the spreaders of Balaam's doctrine, Revel. 2. and those who offend in Christs Kingdom are all necessarily either not to be excommunicated at all, or necessarily they are all unconverted, by Robinsons doctrine, or all converted, by Mr. Coachman's way. And the Church then shall not bind and loose in Heaven, but clave errant, except they be all known certainly to be converted who are excommunicated, or certainly known not to be converted. But this were ridiculous; the object of excommunication by Christ is one which refuseth to hear the Church, whether he be converted, or not converted. 5. All our Divines standing for the certainty of the perseverance of the regenerated, answer Papists and Arminians alleging for the apostasy of the Saints, the example of the regenerated who may be excommunicated, that excommunication doth never evince that the person excommunicated is out of the state of grace, but only that he hath fallen into a scandalous external fact, which deserveth that he should be delivered to Satan, and that one may be a member of the visible Church and converted to God, who is excommunicated. Lastly, Robinsons arguments do bewray great Ignorance in the doctrine of the true Church; to wit, that first it should follow, that if the Church excommunicate a converted person, it should destroy its own essence; for conversion is the essence of the invisible Church, not of the visible Church, and is not destroyed by excommunication.
now the non-converted far lesse can be excommunicated, because those cannot be cast out who are not within, as our brethren teach. For they are the false matter of the Church, and no part of it, yea (and as our Authour saith,) have no measure of sincerity and truth; and therefore cannot be members of the Church. Now the Church (say our brethren) cannot judge those which are without, 1 Cor. 5. 12. 3 This opinion is just the opinion of the Anabaptists, that the true members of the visible Church are onely regenerate persons, and they onely have the essence of the true membership, which is false; they are within ⟨p. 278⟩the visible Church, and truely within the net, and a part of the ground called the Kingdome of God, Matth. 13. 4. Though they be not members of the invisible Church of believers and the redeemed in Christ. 4. The Nicolaitans, Iezabel, the false Apostles, the spreaders of Balaams doctrine, Revel. 2. and those who offend in Christs Kingdome are all necessarily either not to be excommunicated at all, or necessarily they are all unconverted, by Robinsons doctrine, or all converted, by Mr. Coachmans way. And the Church then shall not bind and loose in Heaven, but clave errante, except they be all known certainly to be converted who are excommunicated, or certainly knowne not to be converted. But this were ridiculous; the object of excommunication by Christ is one which refuseth to heare the Church, whether he be converted, or not converted. 5. All our Divines standing for the cerainty of the perseverance of the regenerated, answer Papists and Arminians alledging for the apostacy of the Saints, the example of the regenerated who may be excommunicated, that excommunication doth never evince that the person excommunicated is out of the state of grace, but onely that he hath fallen into a scandalous externall fact, which deserveth that he should be delivered to Satan, and that one may be a member of the visible Church and converted to God, who is excommunicated. Lastly, Robinsons arguments doe bewray great Ignorance in the doctrine of the true Church; to wit, that first it should follow, that if the Church excommunicate a converted person, it should destroy its own essence; for conversion is the essence of the invisible Church, not of the visible Church, and is not destroyed by excommunication.
But the believer is edified thereby, for he is delivered to Satan for the destruction of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord; but that he is cut off from the visible Church is no more inconvenient, then to cut off a rotten apostume of excrescent carnosity of the body, which hurteth the physical integrity of the body, but doth not take away any part of the essence, so as it should not thereafter be a living body. His mixed argument hath a cry, but no force; It should follow that the member of Christs body (saith he) should be delivered to Satan; which is not inconvenient, for this is the Ordinance of Christ to save the mens spirit, and to teach him not to blaspheme, 1 Cor. 5. 5. 2 Tim. 1. 20. It were an inconvenience to deliver a ⟨p. 279⟩member of Christ to Satan morally, as 1 Cor. 6. 15. This is a sinful deliverance, when one is given over to Satan, that Satan may work in him as in his work-house, and as in a child of disobedience, Ephes. 2. 2. a converted soul cannot thus be delivered to Satan, and this we abhor to write, no less then Robinson. But to deliver to Satan penally, as to a penal torturer who worketh sorrow and fear in the conscience for sin, to humble the offender, and to save his spirit in the day of Christ, is neither horror by word nor by writ, but the Word of God, 1 Cor. 5. 5.
But the beleever is edified thereby, for he is delivered to Satan for the destruction of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord; but that he is cut off from the visible Church is no more inconvenient, then to cut off a rotten apostume of excrescent carnosity of the body, which hurteth the physicall integrity of the body, but doth not take away any part of the essence, so as it should not thereafter be a living body. His mixt argument hath a cry, but no force; It should follow that the member of Christs body (saith he) should be delivered to Satan; which is not inconvenient, for this is the Ordinance of Christ to save the mens spirit, and to teach him not to blasph•me, 1 Cor. 5. 5. 2 Tim. 1. 20. It were an inconvenience to deliver a ⟨p. 279⟩member of Christ to Satan morally, as 1 Cor. 6. 15. This is a sinfull deliverance, when one is given over to Satan, that Satan may worke in him as in his work-house, and as in a childe of disobedience, Ephes. 2. 2. a converted soule cannot thus be delivered to Satan, and this we abhor to write, no lesse then Robinson. But to deliver to Satan penally, as to a penall tortuter who worketh sorrow and feare in the conscience for sinne, to humble the offender, and to save his spirit in the day of Christ, is neither horrour by word nor by writ, but the Word of God, 1 Cor. 5. 5.
Now to say something of the sorts and nature of excommunication. We acknowledge not what aNavarrus and bGregory say, That excommunication, whether just or unjust, is to be feared; for, the curse causelessly doth not fall. The sentence is either given out, a jure, vel ab homine by the Law, or the persons. Secondly, it is either just or unjust. Thirdly, and that three ways; Exanimo, good or ill zeal; secondly, Ex causa, a just or unjust cause; thirdly, Ex ordine, when order of Law is kept. An unjust sentence is either valid or null. That which is invalid is either invalid through defect of the good mind of the excommunicators, and this is not essential to the excommunications validity. That which is invalid this way only, ligat, it bindeth in fo•o exteriore. But that which is unjust through want of a just cause, it only bindeth from external communion; but because Gods Ordinances are to be measured from their own nature, and the general intention of the Catholic Church, and not from abuses and particular intentions of such excommunicators; therefore they do not exclude from the general Church-desires. The fourth Council of Carthage, cas also dGerson saith, an unjust sentence neminem gravare debet; should affright no man. I see not a warrant for division of excommunication into penal and not penal excommunication. The ancients made some excommunication not penal, as the efifth Council of Carthage, and fConcilium Arelatense. gTurraconense, hConcilium Agathense. As if one should culpably absent himself from a Synod, erat privatus Episcoporum communion; He was for a space excommunicated from the communion of other Bishops. The Canonists iinfer, that this excommunication was no Church censure; and kM. Antonius of Spalato defendeth them in this. ⟨p. 280⟩But since Christ for scandals appointed only public rebuking; or secondly, confessing; or thirdly, excommunication from the Church, not only of Church guides, but of professing believers; lwe see not how any are to be excommunicated from the fellowship of the Clergy, or Church-guides only. For Christ ordained no such excommunication. and therefore we are to repute this a popish device. Zosimus msaith Zancbius, nCelestinus, oHormisda and Pelagius 2. pdid threaten to excommunicate John of Constantinople from the communion of the Apostolic seat, and of all Bishops.
Now to say something of the sorts and nature of excommunication. We acknowledge not what aNavarrus and bGregory say, That excommunication, whether just or unjust, is to be feared; for, the curse causl•sly doth not fall. The sentence is either given out, a jure, vel ab homine by the Law, or the persons. Secondly, it is either just or unjust. Thirdly, and that three wayes; Exanimo, good or ill zeal; secondly, Ex causa, a just or unjust cause; thirdly, Ex ordine, when order of Law is kept. An unjust sentence is either valid or null. That which is invalid is either invalid through defect of the good minde of the excommunicators, and this is not essentiall to the excommuncations validitie. That which is invalid this way onely, ligat, it bindeth in fo•o exteriore. But that which is u•just through want of a just cause, it onely bindeth from externall communion; but because Gods Ordinances are to be measured from their own nature, and the generall intention of the Catholike Church, and not from abuses and particular intentions of such excommunicators; therefore they doe not exclude from the generall Church-desires. The fourth Councell of Carthage, cas also dGerson saith, an unjust sentence neminem gravare debet; should affright no man. I see not a warrant for division of excommunication into penall and not penall excommunication. The ancients made some excommunication not penall, as the efifth Councell of Carthage, and fConcilium Arelatense. gTurraconense, hConcilium Agathense. As if one should culpably absent himselfe from a Synod, erat privatus Episcoporum communione; He was for a space excommunicated from the communion of other Bishops. The Canonists iinfer, that this excommunication was no Churchcensure; and
aNavarre. Enc••r. c. 27. n. 13.Navar. Enc••r. c. 27. n. 13.
bG••g. n. q. 3. c. 1.
cConcil 4. Carthag.
dGerson de excom. cons. 4.
eConcil. Carthag. 5. c. 10.
fConcil. Arelatens. 2. c. 19.
gConcil. Turraconens. c. 6.
hConcil. Agathens c. 35.
iStephan. Qu. in summa. Bulla 5. con. provinc. n. 7. q. 18.
kM Antonius de Dom. Arch. Spalat. de repub. eccles. l. 5 c 9 n. 6, 7.
Spalato his argument qfor this sort of excommunication is, 2 Thessalonians 3. 15. which commandeth all Thessalonians to forbear any fellowship with such as obeyeth not the Apostles doctrine, and doth not insinuate any excommunication from the society of Church-guides only. Nay, such an excommunication is not in Gods Word. Cajetan rcalleth it excommunicatio claustralis, whereby some were interdicted the company of some other Church-orders. It is true, that in the ancient Church the excommunicated person was debarred from coming to the Church to hear divine Service. And Sylvester appointeth three degrees of excommunication; first, Debarring of the contumacious from entering into the Church; secondly, A suspending of them from communion with the Church; thirdly, An anathema or imprecation by cursing them. So the fifth Synod under Symmachus appointed first that the contumacious should be deprived of the Communion; and if he should not repent, it was ordained, •• anathemate feriatur, that he should be cursed. So say diverse of the Schoolmen and Casuists, as sSoto, tPaludanus, uCajetanus, xSylvester, yNavarrus, that it is not lawful to heart service, or to be present at a Mass with an excommunicated person. But in the zfourth Council of Carthage, as aPapists acknowledge, no excommunicated person is debarred from hearing the Word. But it is to be observed carefully, that for the same reasons Papists think the excommunicated persons should hear Sermons and the Word preached, that our brethren say, Because preaching is an act of jurisdiction and authority, but not an act of order; and therefore preaching is not an act of Church-communion, but common to any who have not received ⟨p. 281⟩orders, and may be performed, as the reading of the Word by Deacons, and those who have Priest-hood or power to administrate the Sacraments. And bInnocentius the third saith, Preaching is proper to Priests, who have received orders by no divine Law. cIndeed Leo the first made a Law of it, for which cause dSuarez saith, That Christ in these words, John 21. Feed m•sheep; and Matth. 28. Preach the Gospel; gave power of jurisdiction, but not of order only: It is given commonly (saith he) to the Clergy to preach, and to Deacons, because decentius, it is more fi•ly and decently performed by them then by Laics.
Spalato his argument qfor this sort of excommunication is, 2 Thessalonians 3. 15. which commandeth all Thessalonians to forbeare any fellowship with such as obeyeth not the Apostles doctrine, and doth not infinuate any excommunication from the society of Church-guides onely. Nay, such an excommunication is not in Gods Word. Cajetan rcalleth it excommunicatio claustralis, whereby some were interdicted the company of some other Church-orders. It is true, that in the ancient Church the excommunicated person was debarred from comming to the Church to heare divine Service. And Sylvester appointeth three degrees of excommunication; first, Debarring of the contumacious from entring into the Church; secondly, A suspending of them from communion with the Church; thirdly, An anathema or imprecation by cursing them. So the fifth Synod under Symmachus appointed first that the contumacious should be deprived of the Communion; and if he should not repent, it was ordained, •• anathemate feriatur, that he should be cursed. So say diverse of the Schoolmen and Casuists, as sSoto, tPaludanus, uCajetanus, xSylvester, yNavarrus, that it is not lawfull to heart service, or to be present at a Masse with an excommunicated person. But in the zfourth Councell of Carthage, as aPapists acknowledge, no excommunicated person is debarred from hearing the Word. But it is to bee observed carefully, that for the same reasons Papists think the excommunicated persons should heare Sermons and the Word preached, that our brethren say, Because preaching is an act of jurisdiction and authority, but not an act of order; and therefore preaching is not an act of Church-communion, but common to any who have not received ⟨p. 281⟩
yNavarre. in summ• 27. n. 19.Navar. in summ• 27. n. 19.
zConcil. Car. •hag. 4. c. 84. Ep•scopus nullum pre•ibeat ingredi Ecclesiam, & audi• verbum 'Dei sive gentilem, sive h•reticum, sive JudaemnConcil. Car. •hag. 4. c. 84. Ep•scopus nullum pre•ibeat ingredi Ecclesiam, & audi• verbum 'Dei sive gentilem, sive h•reticum, sive Iudaemn
a'De consestat. dist. 1. c. 67
bInnocent. 3. verb. excom.
cLeo 1. cp 63 cap. adjicimus ib q. 1.
dSuarez. to. 5. disp. 12. de excom sect. 2. n. 4. Christus hic Joan. 21.
Though it be true that two Cardinals, eToletus and fCajetanus be against Suarez in this, and say, that, John 21. Peter is made the head and universal Pastor over sheep and lambs to feed and govern them. And gNavarrus saith, Preaching (solely sacerdotio institution divina adjuncta est) is by divine institution proper to the Priesthood. Yet this excluding of them from coming into the Church, was from coming in to the holy place only where the Lords Supper was celebrated; and they stood at the Church door where they might hear the Word, and therefore were called [Greek or Hebrew] and [Greek or Hebrew] hearers and murmurers, as hBas•lius saith, and iField, Excommunication doth not wholly (saith he) cut off men from the visible Church, and his reason is good, because they may and often do retain, first, The profession of pure truth; secondly, The character of Baptism; thirdly, They profess obedience to their Pastors; fourthly, They will not join to any other communion. And therefore to say with our Author kwe dare not, to wit, That though the seed of faith may remain in the excommunicated person; yet to the society of the faithful joined in a particular visible Church, they are not knit, but wholly cut off from their communion. Also, he is delivered unto Satan, and therefore wholly cut off from the communion of the Church; and so from the seals, he and his seed, as heathen and heathens seed are. We condemn Novatians, because (as lCyprian saith) they denied mercy to the repenting excommunicated person, and because (as mSocrates said of them) God only can forgive sins. And we condemn the Donatists, who would not (as nAugustine saith) receive into the Churches communion again such as had delivered to persecutors the Bible and other holy things. ⟨p. 282⟩So we are to condemn these who are more rigorous toward such as are excommunicated, then Christ is: for Christ keepeth them, as sick children, within his visible Church, and useth Satan as the Physicians servant who boileth Herbs and dresseth Drugs for them, while he by Gods permission, tormente•hthes spirit with the conscience of sin. As when a child is sick (saith worthy oCartwright) the Father calleth a College of physicians to consult about medicine, to be given to the child. So i• the contumacious person under the medicine of excommunication administered by the Church-presbytery.
Though it be true that two Cardinals, eToletus and fCajetanus be against Suarez in this, and say, that, Iohn 21. Peter is made the head and universall Pastor over sheep and lambs to feed and governe them. And gNavarrus saith, Preaching (soli sacerdotio institutione divina adjuncta est) is by divine institution proper to the Priesthood. Yet this excluding of them from comming into the Church, was from comming in to the holy place only where the Lords Supper was celebrated; and they stood at the Church doore where they might heare the VVord, and therefore were called 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 hearers and murmurers, as hBas•lius saith, and iField, Excommunication doth not wholly (saith he) cut off men from the visible Church, and his reason is good, because they may and often doeretaine, first, The profession of pure truth; secondly, The character of Baptisme; thirdly, They professe obedience to their Pastors; fourthly, They will not joyne to any other communion. And therefore to say with our Author kwe dare not, to wit, That though the seed of faith may remaine in the excommunicated person; yet to the society of the faithfull joyned in a particular visible Church, they are not knit, but wholly cut off from their communion. Also, he is delivered unto Satan, and therefore wholly cut off from the communion of the Church; and so from the seals, he and his seed, as heathen and heathens seed are. We condemne Novatians, because (as lCyprian saith) they denied mercy to the repenting excommunicated person, and because (as mSocrates said of them) God onely can forgive sins. And we condemne the Donatists, who would not (as n
eToll. come. in Joan. 21. an 7.Tol. com. in Joan. 21. an 7.
fCajet. come. in. Joan. 21. v. ib.Cajet. com. in. Joan. 21. v. ib.
gNavarre. sum. 26 c. 11. 163.Navar. sum. 26 c. 11. 163.
hBasil, cp. 3. ad Amph. c. 58.
iField book 3 of the Church. cap. 15.
kThe Way of the Churches of Christ in N. E. ch. 4. sect. 6.
lCyprianl. 4. cp. 2.
mSocrates l. 7. c. 25.
nAugust. contra Donatistas de bapt. lib. 5. cap. 1.
And therefore pAugustine saith excellently, excommunicated persons non esse Ethnicos, sed tanquam ethnicos; are not heathen, but esteemed as heathen. c. 6. and qChrysostom saith the same in sense. Yea, I gather this necessary distinction out of the Fathers: as Chrysostom rTheophylactus sHilarius tthat they are not members of the visible Church actu pleno, in a full act, because they want external communion with the Church, yet actu imperfecto, imperfectly they are members. A second distinction I collect from wIreneus xGregorius yHieronim. zOptatus aAugustine, that they are exclusi ab ecclesia quoad communionem, non ab ecclesia ipsa. They are excluded from the visible communion of the Church, rather then from the Church. A third distinction may be drawn from bEugenius cChrysostom dGregor. Nazianz••, while they call Baptism januam spiritualem, and lavacrum animae, the door of our entry to the Church (for which cause papists, though fondly, place their Font at the Church-door) as the Lavat•r of the soul. So as excommunicated persons are within the door of the visible Church, though not admitted to the Kings Table. 4. The Schoolmen do allow to the excommunicated persons, jus, non consortium; right, but not fellowsh •• 5. eTurr•cremaeta fVega. gSoto hCanus insin••• distinctionem inter parts & membra Ecclesiae visibilis, because of some external communion that they have, as Teeth are parts of the body in a new borne Infant; but they are not members, but they deny them to be members because they are cut off. 6. iSuarez excellently, pr•vantur quoad communicationemcum ⟨p. 283⟩al•s membris, non quoad esse membri. They are deprived according to the act of communion with other members, not as if they ceased to be members; as a member which cannot receive nourishment is yet still a member.
And therefore pAugustine sayth excellently, excommunicated persons non esse Ethnicos, sed tanquam ethnicos; are not heathen, but estemed as heathen. c. 6. and qChrysostome saith the same in sense. Yea, I gather this necessary distinction out of the Fathers: as Chrysostome rTheophylactus sHilarius tthat they are not members of the visible Church actu pleno, in a full act, because they want externall communion with the Church, yet actu imperfecto, imperfectly they are members. A second distinction I collect from wIreneus xGregorius yHieronim. zOptatus aAugustine, that they are exclusi ab ecclesia quoad communionem, non ab ecclesia ipsa. They are excluded from the visible communion of the Church, rather then from the Church. A third distinction may be drawen from bEugenius cChrysostome dGregor. Nazianz••, while they call Baptisme januam spiritualem, and lavacrum animae, the doore of our entry to the Church (for which cause papists, though fondly, place their Font at the Church-doore) as the Lavat•r of the soule. So as excommunicated persons are within the doore of the visible Church, though not admitted to the Kings Table. 4. The Schoolemen do allow to the excommunicated persons, jus, non consortium; right, but not fellowsh •• 5.
Our Divines from Scripture make three degrees of excommunication. 1. A debarring from the Lords Supper, Mat. 5. 24. but it is not indeed a delivering to Satan or excommunication: this is called the lesser excommunication. 2. A delivering to Satan, the greater excommunication. 1 Cor. 5. 3. 4. of this we speak here especially. 3. Maran-atha in the Syriac an is utter cursing till Christs second coming.
Our Divines from Scripture make three degrees of excommunication. 1. A debarring from the Lords Supper, Mat. 5. 24. but it is not indeed a delivering to Satan or excommunication: this is called the lesser excommunication. 2. A delivering to Satan, the greater excommunication. 1 Cor. 5. 3. 4. of this we speake here especially. 3. Maran-atha in the Syriack an is utter cursing till Christs second comming.
3. Conclus. We hold the preaching of the word to be an essentia note of the visible Church. Our Brethren as kMr. Coachman lRobinson mour present Author, deny that the profession or preaching of the Word is a true note of the visible Church. Because, Acts 17, Paul preached to the scoffing Athenians, who were not for that a visible Church. 2. Papists have some of Gods Ordinances, and heretics also, as baptism; and the Old and New Testament as the Philistines had the Ark of God amongst them. 3. The word may be preached, where Christ is but gathering a Church, and so is a mean of gathering a Church, and therefore not an essential note of a gathered and constituted Church. But herein our Brethren say no more against the Reformed Churches, then nStapleton; to wit, that truth of doctrine is no note of the Church, because it is not perpetual and constant. 2. Truth of Doctrine concurs to give being to the Church and to the constitution of it. oBellarm. This note may be found in other societies and companies beside the Church, a• amongst Schismatics and Heretics. More of this please the Reader to see in pCosterus qin the Jesuit Gordonius, Huntlaeus. And this is the doctrine of Socinians, as may be seen in the Catechism of rRaccovia sin Theo. Nicolaides, and tFrancis. Smalcius, and Arminians second both in their wconfession: because they think with Socinians, that there is no ministry now necessary, and so public preaching is not a note of the Church, especially since every gifted man may preach the Word. Socinus in his tractate De Ecclesiâ, and his Catechism of Raccovia, saith. Notae evangelicorum nihil valent; ⟨p. 284⟩'Doctrina pura est Ecclesiae natura & essentia quae dat ei esse, ad•óque signum ejus esse non potest; cum signum ipsum, a re c•jus est signum, differre oporteat. But the truth is, the preaching of the Word hath diverse relations. 1. As the members of the visible Church are in fi•ri, in the way to be gathered, the Word preached and believed is a way of gathering a Church, Rom. 10. 14. 1 Cor. 1. 23. 1 Cor. 3. 5. Acts 16. 14. 2. That same word preached, believed, and outwardly professed is a sign of the visible Church. For where Gods pastors and shepherds are, there be flocks of redeemed ones, Cant. 1. 8. John 10. 12, 13, 14. 3 The Word simply preached and professed in a settled way of a fixed ministry is a note of a ministerial Church;
3. Conclus. Wee hold the preaching of the word to be an essentia note of the visible Church. Our Brethren as kMr. Coachman lRobinson mour present Author, deny that the profession or preaching of the Word is a true note of the visible Church. Because, Acts 17, Paul preached to the scoffing Athenians, who were not for that a visible Church. 2. Papists have some of Gods Ordinances, and hereticks also, as baptisme; and the Old and New Testament as the Philistins had the Arke of God amongst them. 3. The word may be preached, where Christ is but gathering a Church, and so is a meane of gathering a Church, and therefore not an essentiall note of a gathered and constituted Church. But herein our Brethren say no more against the Reformed Churches, then nStapleton; to wit, that truth of doctrine is no note of the Church, because it is not perpetuall and constant. 2. Truth of Doctrine concurs to give being to the Church and to the constitution of it. oBellarm. This note may be found in other societies and companies beside the Church, a• amongst Scismaticks and Hereticks. More of this please the Reader to see in pCosterus qin the Jesuite Gordonius, Huntlaeus. And this is the doctrine of Socinians, as may be seene in the Cathechisme of rRaccovia sin Theo. Nicolaides, and tFrancis. Smalcius, and Arminians second both in their wconfession: because they think with Socinians, that there is no ministery now necessary, and so publick preaching is not a note of the Church, especially since every gifted man may preach the Word. Socinus in his tractate De Ecclesiâ, and his Catechisme of Raccovia, saith. Notae evangelicorum nihil valent;
kCoachman. the cry of a stone sect. 3 p 8.
lRobinson. Justis. of separate. p. 8.Robinson. Justis. of separat. p. 8.
this is clear from Gods intention, for he sendeth it of purpose to save his own, as Rom. 10. 14. Acts 20. 28. For a man lighteth not a Candle in his house for nothing. So this word preached, as it is Gods Word, is not properly the form and essence of the Church, but as believed and received, it is the form of the Church invisible. 2. But to profess this word savingly, est signum Ecclesiae, non not A, it is a sign, that doth not infallibly notify to us that such is for this time an invisible Church of redeemed ones: for I have not infallible certainty what one man, or what determinate number of men by name are true believers, profession may beguile me, as also the invisible Church (as such) is believed, and not known infallibly by any note or external mark that incurreth into the senses. Neither is the preaching of the Word a note or infallible mark of the Church ministerial to all, or in relation to Infidels; for the Word preached actu primo & ex naturâ suâ, essentially and of its own nature, is more known and more sensible then the Church: because the preached word is a Doctrine expounding what the true Church is, and we do not expound ignotum per ignotius, vel per aequè ignotum. Darkness cannot let us see darkness, or colours; only light doth reveal things. But the word preached in relation to unbelievers cannot be an infallible note of the Church, for to a blind man the morning as not a sensible mark that the sun is rising; nor is smoke to a dead man, a sensible mark of fire, because he hath no senses to discern either. So to the infidel though the word as a sound, or in a literal evidence ⟨p. 285⟩be clearer then the Church, and in a confused knowledge he knoweth the one better than the other; yet is the true word, in respect of certain knowledge and spiritual evidence, as dark to him as the Church: for he hath not Ears to hear, nor eyes to see any of the things of God, either the word preached, or the Church; and therefore the word is both by nature and to us, & naturâ & nobis, in respect of distinct knowledge, more known, but not simply as the word, actu primo, but actu secundo, as it both striketh upon outward and inward senses and as i• revealeth and discovereth the things of God, according to that, 1 Cor. 14. 24.
this is cleare from Gods intention, for he sendeth it of purpose to save his own, as Rom. 10. 14. Acts 20. 28. For a man lighteth not a Candle in his house for nothing. So this word preached, as it is Gods Word, is not properly the forme and essence of the Church, but as believed and received, it is the forme of the Church invisible. 2. But to professe this word savingly, est signum Ecclesiae, non not A, it is a signe, that doth not infallibly notifie to us that such is for this time an invisible Church of redeemed ones: for I have not infallible certainty what one man, or what determinate number of men by name are true believers, profession may beguile me, as also the invisible Church (as such) is believed, and not knowen infallibly by any note or externall marke that incurreth into the senses. Neither is the preaching of the Word a note or infallible marke of the Church ministeriall to all, or in relation to Infidels; for the Word preached actu primo & ex naturâ suâ, essentially and of its own nature, is more knowen and more sensible then the Church: because the preached word is a Doctrine expounding what the true Church is, and we do not expound ignotum per ignotius, vel per aequè ignotum. Darknesse cannot let us see darknesse, or colours; only light doth reveale things. But the word preached in relation to unbelievers cannot be an infallible note of the Church, for to a blind man the morning as not a sensible marke that the sun is rising; nor is smoake to a dead man, a sensible marke of fire, because he hath no senses to discerne either. So to the infidell though the word as a sound, or in a literall evidence ⟨p. 285⟩be clearer then the Church, and in a confused knowledge he knoweth the one better than the other; yet is the true word, in respect of certaine knowledge and spirituall evidence, as darke to him as the Church: for he hath not Eares to heare, nor eyes to see any of the things of God, either the word preached, or the Church; and therefore the word is both by nature and to us, & naturâ & nobis, in respect of distinct knowledge, more knowen, but not simply as the word, actu primo, but actu secundo, as it both striketh upon outward and inward senses and as i• revealeth and discovereth the things of God, according to that, 1 Cor. 14. 24.
But if all prophecy, and there come one who is an unbeliever, and an unlearned, he is convinced of all and judged of all. v. 25. and thus are the secrets of his heart made manifest, and so falling down on his face, he will worship God and report that God is in you, of a truth. So here is Gods order how the word preached is a notifying mark discovering to an unbeliever the true Church. It I would point out one of the Kings Courtiers by this, that he hath a purple cloak and a blew scarf, if the man to whom I notify the Courtier, do neither know what a purple garment is, nor what a blew scarf is, the mark shall be no mark to him: yet are these sufficient marks in their own nature, if we suppose that no other Courtiers are in that manner apparelled. Therefore I would difference betwixt notam notificantem & notam notificativam, a note that of its own nature doth make a thing known, or that which actually maketh a thing known to some.
But if all prophecy, and there come one who is an unbeliever, and an unlearned, he is convinced of all and judged of all. v. 25. and thus are the secrets of his heart made manifest, and so falling downe on his face, he will worship God and report that God is in you, of a truth. So here is Gods order how the word preached is a notifying marke discovering to an unbeliever the true Church. It I would poynt out one of the Kings Courtiers by this, that he hath a purple cloak and a blew scarf, if the man to whom I notifie the Courtier, do neither know what a purple garment is, nor what a blew scarf is, the marke shall be no marke to him: yet are these sufficient markes in their owne nature, if we suppose that no other Courtiers are in that manner apparelled. Therefore I would difference betwixt notam notificantem & notam notificativam, a note that of its owne nature doth make a thing knowen, or that which actually maketh a thing knowen to some.
The settled professed preaching of the Word is a note of the visible Church Ministerial, and that there either is, or in Gods own time shall be some invisible Church of sanctified ones there. 1. Because, Deut. 4. 6 the hearing and doing of Gods Word maketh the Church of the Jews a renowned and wise people in the fight of the Nations. 2. The preaching of the Word and administration of the Sacraments are proper to the Church and distinguish them from other Nations, Psal. 147. 19. He showeth his word unto Jacob, and to Israel his statutes and his judgments, 20. He hath not dealt so with any Nation. So Deut. 17. 29. 30 31 32. The Lords worship is so peculiar to his Church as it differenceth them from all others. So Esd. 2. 8. 3. Esa. 59. ⟨p. 286⟩last verse. 3. The Church is defined, Acts 2. 42. a company of these who profess truly, and continue in the Apostles doctrine and breaking of bread. 4. The planting and gathering of Churches is expounded to be teaching and baptizing, Mat. 28. 19. 20. 5. Christs sheep hear his voice in his own sent shepherds, Joh. 10. 27. 28. 6 The Church is a company built upon the Doctrine of the Prophets and Apostles, Eph. 2. 20. 7 The Church is the pillar and ground of truth, 1 Tim. 3. 15. because the Church teacheth, professeth, and keepeth the truth. So aAugustine bTertullian cHierom. dand Chrysostom will have us to seek the true Church by the true Word of God, and not by mens word. eRobinson objecteth first; Profession of the truth made by men of lewd conversation maketh them not the Church; because they deserve to be cast out of the Church, but by men visibly and externally holy, Mat. 3. 6. Acts 1. 38. Act. 2. 37, 38. 1 Cor. 15. 1. Mat. 10. 40. 41. Acts 8. 12, 13.
The settled professed preaching of the Word is a note of the visible Church Ministeriall, and that there either is, or in Gods own time shall be some invisible Church of sanctified ones there. 1. Because, Deut. 4. 6 the hearing and doing of Gods Word maketh the Church of the Jewes a renowned and wise people in the fight of the Nations. 2. The preaching of the Word and administration of the Sacraments are proper to the Church and distinguish them from other Nations, Psal. 147. 19. Hee sheweth his word unto Iacob, and to Israel his statutes and his judgments, 20. He hath not dealt so with any Nation. So Deut. 17. 29. 30 31 32. The Lords worship is so peculiar to his Church as it differenceth them from all others. So Esd. 2. 8. 3. Esa. 59. ⟨p. 286⟩last verse. 3. The Church is defined, Acts 2. 42. a company of these who professe truly, and continue in the Apostles doctrine and breaking of bread. 4. The planting and gathering of Churches is expounded to be teaching and baptizing, Mat. 28. 19. 20. 5. Christs sheep heare his voyce in his own sent shepheards, Joh. 10. 27. 28. 6 The Church is a company built upon the Doctrine of the Prophets and Apostles, Eph. 2. 20. 7 The Church is the pillar and ground of truth, 1 Tim. 3. 15. because the Church teacheth, professeth, and keepeth the truth. So aAugustine bTertullian cHierom. dand Chrysostome will have us to seeke the true Church by the true Word of God, and not by mens word. e
But since Christ for scandals appointed onely publike rebuking; or secondly, confessing; or thirdly, excommunication from the Church, not onely of Church guides, but of professing beleevers;
we see not how any are to be excommunicated from the fellowship of the Clergy, or Church-guides onely. For Christ ordained no such excommunication. and therefore wee are to repute this a popish device. Zosimus
Suarez saith, That Christ in these words, Iohn 21. Feed m•sheep; and Matth. 28. Preach the Gospel; gave power of jurisdiction, but not of order onely: It is given commonly (saith he) to the Clergy to preach, and to Deacons, because decentius, it is more fi•ly and decently performed by them then by Laicks.
Mat. 28
Non dedit po•estatem ordinis sed jurisdictionis. Neque jure divino hic actus requirit ordinem, se• authoritatem pasloris.
Augustine saith) receive into the Churches commmunion againe such as had delivered to persecuters the Bible and other holy things.
⟨p. 282⟩
So we are to condemne these who are more rigorous toward such as are excommunicated, then Christ is: for Christ keepeth them, as sick children, within his visible Church, and useth Satan as the Physitians servant who boyleth Herbs and dresseth Drugs for them, while he by Gods permission, tormente•hthes spirit with the conscience of sinne. As when a child is sick (saith worthy
Cartwright) the Father calleth a Colledge of physicians to consult about medicine, to be given to the child. So i• the contumacious person under the medicine of excommunication administred by the Church-presbytery.
Canus insin••• distinctionem inter partes & membra Ecclesiae visibilis, because of some externall communion that they have, as Teeth are parts of the body in a new borne Infant; but they are not members, but they deny them to be members because they are cut off. 6.
al•s membris, non quoad esse membri. They are deprived acording to the act of communion with other members, not as if they ceased to be members; as a member which cannot receive nourishment is yet still a member.
gPet. a Scto. • part. defens••n. B•ent.
hCan. loc. come. 4.Can. loc. com. 4.
iSuarez. de ••ipl. virtute Theolig•d. 9. sect. 1. n. 14.
⟨p. 284⟩
'Doctrina pura est Ecclesiae natura & essentia quae dat ei esse, ad•óque signum ejus esse non potest; cum signum ipsum, a re c•jus est signum, differre oporteat. But the truth is, the preaching of the Word hath diverse relations. 1. As the members of the visible Church are in fi•ri, in the way to be gathered, the Word preached and believed is a way of gathering a Church, Rom. 10. 14. 1 Cor. 1. 23. 1 Cor. 3. 5. Acts 16. 14. 2. That same word preached, believed, and outwardly professed is a signe of the visible Church. For where Gods pastors and shepheards are, there be flocks of redeemed ones, Cant. 1. 8. Iohn 10. 12, 13, 14. 3 The Word simply preached and professed in a setled way of a fixed ministery is a note of a ministeriall Church;
Robinson objecteth first; Profession of the truth made by men of lewd conversation maketh them not the Church; because they deserve to be cast out of the Church, but by men visibly and externally holy,