Answ. 1. The strength of my argument is close mistaken, for I did not argue simply from the Apostles borrowing light one from another, to prove they act not here as Apostles but as Elders, neither did I argue simply from this, James saith more then Peter doth, Ergo, Peter is not immediately inspired in what he saith: for I grant the Apostles borrow •ight from the Prophets, and their writings, one saith and writeth what another saith not, and cannot write, and yet all are immediately inspired, in what they write. But I argued thus; when ever the Apostles are consulted with to resolve a question as Apostles & do convene Synodically & intend to resolve the question if the Apostles in that case, or any one of them come short of the resolution, & do not see the conclusion they intend to see, but in so far as they are helped on by another in a way of disputation, in that they do not act as Apostles, but the case is so here; 1. all were consulted with, Act. 15. 2. (2) all intended to resolve the question, and did meet together for that end to resolve it fully, v. 6. ⟨p. 407⟩(3) yet divers of the Apostles, as Peter, Paul and Barnabas see not the resolution fully that they aimed at, but determine the question imperfectly, and so, as if James had been absent, or if he had seen no more in resolving the question, then Paul and Barnabas and Peter said, which was only that the Law of Moses was not to be kept by either Jew or Gentile, upon the Necessity of salvation, but that both Jews and Gentiles are saved by the grace of Jesus Christ; if James (I say) had seen no more then this, the consciences of both sides had not been satisfied, and the question not resolved, but the Jews should have gone on in a total abstinence from all ceremonies, which because of the indifference of the ceremonies, was then dangerously scandalous, and spiritual homicide, and the Gentiles should freely have eaten blood, meats offered to idols, and things strangled, which also was scandalous in a high measure to the weak Jews, and so the matter should have been worse after this Synod, and the controversy hotter, the fire bolder, and the scandal more dangerous then it was before the Synod, which I cannot believe that the Apostles as Apostles could have done;
Answ. 1. The strength of my argument is close mistaken, for I did not argue simply from the Apostles borrowing light one from another, to prove they act not here as Apostles but as Elders, neither did I argue simply from this, James saith more then Peter doth, Ergo, Peter is not immediatly inspired in what hee saith: for I grant the Apostles borrow •ight from the Prophets, and their writings, one saith and writeth what another saith not, and cannot write, and yet all are immediatly inspired, in what they write. But I argued thus; when ever the Apostles are consulted with to resolve a question as Apostles & do conveen• Synodically & intend to resorve the question if the Apostles in that case, or any one of them come short of the resolution, & do not see the conclusion they intend to see, but in so sarre as they are helped on by another in a way of disputation, in that they doe not act as Apostles, but the case is so here; 1. all were consulted with, Act. 15. 2. (2) all intended to resolve the question, and did meet together for that end to resolve it fully, v. 6. ⟨p. 407⟩(3) yet divers of the Apostles, as Peter, Paul and Barnabas see not the resolution fully that they aimed at, but determine the question imperfectly, and so, as if Iames had beene absent, or if hee had seene no more in resolving the question, then Paul and Barnabas and Peter said, which was onely that the Law of Moses was not to bee kept by either Iew or Gentile, upon the Necessitie of salvation, but that both Jewes and Gentiles are saved by the grace of Jesus Christ; if James (I say) had seene no more then this, the consciences of both sides had not beene satisfied, and the question not resolved, but the Jewes should have gone on in a totall abstinence from all ceremonies, which because of the indifference of the ceremonies, was then dangerously scandalous, and spirituall homicide, and the Gentiles should freely have eaten blood, meates offered to idols, and things strangled, which also was scandalous in a high measure to the weake Jewes, and so the matter should have beene worse after this Synod, and the controversie hotter, the fire bolder, and the scandall more dangerous then it was before the Synod, which I cannot beleeve that the Apostles as Apostles could have done;