A57969:1300
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the…
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Object. 17. From the power of jurisdiction, in a Synod, you may infer a power of jurisdiction, in a national Church, and a power of jurisdiction in the whole Christian world, and we know not any Political Church Catholic and visible in Scripture, and if then were any such Church Catholic, then might they convene and swear a Catholic-covenant for uniformity of doctrine, worship, and government of the Church, as we have done in Britain, and this Catholic Church might impose it, upon a national Church, even by that same Law of proportion, by which the national Church may impose it on particular Churches which are parts of the National Church.
Object. 17. From the power of jurisdiction, in a Synod, you may inferre a power of jurisdiction, in a nationall Church, and a power of jurisdiction in the whole Christian world, and wee know not any Politicall Church Catholick and visible in Scripture, and if then were any such Church Catholick, then might they conveene and sweart a Catholick-covenant for uniformitie of doctrine, worship, and government of the Church, as wee have done in Britaine, and this Catholick Church might impose it, upon a nationall Church, even by that same Law of proportion, by which the nationall Church may impose it on particular Churches which are parts of the Nationall Church.
Answ. I see not how the consequence holdeth every way ⟨p. 417⟩good, that as we infer from a juridical power in a presbytery, the same power juridical in a Synod, and the same in a national Assembly, that therefore we may infer the same juridical power in an Ecumenic council: and the reasons of the disparity I take to be these; 1. The farther remote in local distance of place that Churches be, (as it falleth out in the Catholic visible Church) the danger of scandalizing one another, by visible communion, and so the opportunity of edifying one another is the less, and so the communion visible is the less, and consequently the power of jurisdiction is the less. 2. An universal and ecumenic council of all the visible Churches on earth, is an act of the visible Church which supposeth all the visible Churches on earth to be in that moral perfection of soundness of faith, of concord and unity, that some one Congregation or classical presbytery of Elders according to Gods heart may be in, which moral perfection perhaps is not de facto attainable, (though it be not physically impossible) in this life, except we suppose the heavenly days of Christs visible reign on earth a thousand years, when yet there shall be no Temple nor external ministry, of which state I cannot now dispute, and therefore I conceive these sixteen hundred years there never was an integral and perfect ecumenic council of all the Churches on earth, and therefore if we should dispute of the juridical power of such a Catholic assembly whether it may impose an ecumenic and Catholic oath on a national Church against their will, and excommunicate a national Church, is but a needless and a Chimerical dispute, and it includeth two contradictory suppositions. 1. That all the Churches on earth are of one sound faith, worship, doctrine and Church-government, and yet one national Church is supposed to be heterodox, scandalous, and obstinate, so that that whole national Church must be constrained to take a lawful oath and must be excommunicated; such an hypothesis is not possible where the Gospel is preached, for even the whole Romish Church in all its members deserveth not excommunication, in respect we are sure God hath thousands in the bosom of that Church;