A57969:1329
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But what ground for so needless a conjecture, that the Apostolic Church did celebrate the Lords Supper in the Temple, never in private houses? The contrary is, Act. 20. 7. And upon the first day of the week the Disciples came together to break bread, Paul preached unto them, v. 8. And there were many lights in an upper Chamber, where they were convened, so the Text is clear, the first day of the week, 1 Cor. 16. 1. was the day of the Christians public worship, and aAugustine, bCalvin, cLu•her, dMelanchthon, Bullinger, eDiodatus; and so fLorinus and gSanchius say this was the Lords Supper, who can imagine that the Apostles did bring so many thousand Christians after Supper to the Temple, to celebrate a new Evangelic feast, and that immediately after Peters first Sermon, Act. 2. 42 ? 1. Before the Apostles had informed the Jews, that all their typical and ceremonial feasts were now abolished, yea while they stood in vigour, and the Apostles themselves kept them in a great part? was this like the Spirit of the Gospel, which did bear with Moses his ceremonies for forty years?
But what ground for so needlesse a conjecture, that the Apostolick Church did celebrate the Lords Supper in the Temple, never in private houses? The contrary is, Act. 20. 7. And upon the first day of the weeke the Disciples came together to breake bread, Paul preached unto them, v. 8. And there were many lights in an upper Chamber, where they were conveened, so the Text is cleare, the first day of the weeke, 1 Cor. 16. 1. was the day of the Christians publick worship, and aAugustine, bCalvin, cLu•her, dMelancthon, Bullinger, eDiodatus; and so fLorinus and gSanchius say this was the Lords Supper, who can imagine that the Apostles did bring so many thousand Christians after Supper to the Temple, to celebrate a new Evangelick feast, and that immediatly after Peters first Sermon, Act. 2. 42 ? 1. Before the Apostles had informed the Jewes, that all their typicall and ceremoniall feasts were now abolished, yea while they stood in vigor, and the Apostles themselves kept them in a great part? was this like the Spirit of the Gospel, which did beare with Moses his ceremonies for fortie yeares?
2. The Apostles, Act. 4. 1. are indited before the Synedry, that they taught, in the Temple, Jesus Christ: if they had with so many thousands, gone to the Temple with a new extraordinary ceremonial ordinance as a new Sacrament, so contrary in humane reason, to all the sacred Feasts, Sacrifices, and ceremonies, should not this with the first have been put in their indictment, that they were shouldering Moses out of the Temple? yet are they only accused for teaching the people; yea Christ the Law-giver, who preached the Gospel daily in the Temple, would not take the last Supper to the Temple, but celebrated ⟨p. 431⟩it in a private Chamber; and Paul being accused always as an enemy to Moses and the Temple, his enemies the Jews who watched him heedfully, could never put on him, that he celebrated a Sacrament in the Temple: as for Baptism it being a sort of washing, (whereof the Pharisees used many, Matth. 15. Mark. 7.) it was performed often sub di• in rivers, never in the Temple; we desire any author, father, (Ocecumenius doubteth only) Doctor, Divine, Protestant, or Papist, late or old, who said the Apostles celebrated the Supper in the Temple.
2. The Apostles, Act. 4. 1. are indited before the Synedry, that they taught, in the Temple, Jesus Christ: if they had with so many thousands, gone to the Temple with a new extraordinary ceremoniall ordinance as a new Sacrament, so contrary in humane reason, to all the sacred Feasts, Sacrifices, and ceremonies, should not this with the first have beene put in their inditement, that they were shouldering Moses out of the Temple? yet are they onely accused for teaching the people; yea Christ the Law-giver, who preached the Gospell daily in the Temple, would not take the last Supper to the Temple, but celebrated ⟨p. 431⟩it in a private Chamber; and Paul being accused alwayes as an enemy to Moses and the Temple, his enemies the Jewes who watched him heedfully, could never put on him, that hee celebrated a Sacrament in the Temple: as for Baptisme it being a sort of washing, (whereof the Pharisees used many,
3. Our brethren say all, These did convene [Greek or Hebrew], for Act. 4. 31. When they had prayed the place was shaken where they were assembled together, [Greek or Hebrew], Act. 2. 46. and they continued daily with one accord in the Temple, and breaking bread from house to house, did eat their meat with gladness.
3. Our brethren say all, These did conve•ne 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, for Act. 4. 31. When they had prayed the place was shaken where they were assembled together, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Act. 2. 46. and they continued daily with one accord in the Temple, and breaking bread from house to house, did eate their meat with gladnesse.
Answ. The place, Act. 4. 31. saith not, that all the five thousand believers were in that one place, which was shaken, for v. 21. that when the Apostles were let go by the Priests and Captains of the Temple they returned to their own company [Greek or Hebrew], to their own, but no circumstance in the Text doth infer that they came back to the whole five thousand, but only to some few of the first believers, that were converted before the first Sermon of Peter was made, cap. 2, they returned, Lyra and Hugo Cardinalis, to their own company, ad domesticos suos, and so saith Lorinus, who citeth the Syriac [Greek or Hebrew] hachaiehin ad fratres suos. Salmeron, ad suos •apostolos, sive condiscipulos & domesticos fidei, and [Greek or Hebrew] doth not signify the whole Church, but friends and domestics, as, Mark. 5. 19. Go home to thy own house and show thy friends, Luke, [Greek or Hebrew] compared with, Luk. 8. 39. and Gal. 6. 10, [Greek or Hebrew], and 1 Tim. 5. 8. therefore the place saith that the five thousand were gathered together in this one place which was shaken. 2. Giving and not granting that they were all convened to prayer, it doth not follow that they did meet ordinarily in one place, for partaking of Word and Sacraments, as one Congregation, for •oe might convene to prayer and hearing the Word, then could meet ordinarily in a Congregational-way. Neither will any Text enforce us to ⟨p. 432⟩expone [Greek or Hebrew], collectively, but distributively, as we say, all the Congregations in Scotland met, [Greek or Hebrew], in one, every Lords day, that is, every one of the Congregations is in one place, but the sense is not that all the Congregations collectively are in one place. And we may justly ask what this place was which was shaken, it is not like that it was the Temple, that which should have been more prodigious like, and presaged a ruin to the Temple, would not have been concealo by the holy Ghost, for it would have more terrified the Jews, and the Temple is never called [Greek or Hebrew] sine adjecto, without some other thing to make it be known to be the holy place, if it was a private house, give us leave to say it could not contain five thousand to hear prayer, far less a more numerous multitude.
We re•it it to the judgement of the wise, if the Apostles were so lazy to propagate the Gospel, that where twelve of them were present undoubtedly, Act. 4. 23 31. Act. 6. 2. and (as many of the learned think, the seventy Disciples) that eleven Apostles did hear the Word only, and one did speak to one Congregation only, which consisted of so many thousands, for to the five thousand, if there were no moe, c. 5. 14. mere believers were added to the Lord, multitudes both of men and women, who could not conveniently hear? This I think not imaginable; for 1. now the harvest was large, thousands were to be converted. 2. The Spirit was now poured upon all flesh. 3. Christ, when he sent the twelve but to Jude•, he sent them two and two, and would have every man at work, and the Apostles went out in twos, Act. 13. Paul and Barnabas and sometimes but one Peter was sent to the Jews, Paul to the Gentiles, and the world divided amongst them, 1. of other officers Timothy is sent to Ephesus, Titus to Crete, that so they might the more swiftly spread the Gospel to all the world. What wisdom could we imagine would lead the twelve Apostles to speak to one single Congregation met in one place, at one time? the rest, to wit the eleven and the seventy Disciples being silent? for in the Church the God of order will have one to speak at once, 1 Cor. 14. 31.
Wee re•it it to the judgement of the wise, if the Apostles were so lazie to propagate the Gospell, that where twelve of them were present undoubtedly, Act. 4. 23 31. Act. 6. 2. and (as many of the learned thinke, the seventie Disciples) that eleven Apostles did heare the Word onely, and one did speake to one Congregation onely, which consisted of so many thousands, for to the five thousand, if there were no moe, c. 5. 14. mere beleevers were added to the Lord, multitudes both of men and women, who could not conveniently heare? This I thinke not imaginable; for 1. now the harvest was large, thousands were to bee converted. 2. The Spirit was now powred upon all flesh. 3. Christ, when hee sent the twlve but to Jude, hee sent them two and two, and would have every man at worke, and the Apostles went out in twoes,
But our reverend brethren seeing and considering well that ⟨p. 433⟩the Church at Jerusalem could not all meet in one Congregational way, and that they were a Christian Church, and so behooved to be a Presbyterial Church, they do therefore betake themselves to another Answer, for they say that this Church at […] an extraordinary constituted Church, and 1. wanted an Eldership, and presbytery, as Christian Churches have now: 2. the government was merely Apostolical: 3. the constitution was somewhat Jewish, rather then Christian, for their service was mixed with legal ordinances and Jewish observances for many years, and therefore cannot be a pattern of the Christian visible Church which we now seek.
But our reverend brethren seeing and considering well that ⟨p. 433⟩the Church at Jerusalem could not all meet in one Congregationall way, and that they were a Christian Church, and so behoo•ed to bee a Presbyteriall Church, they doe therefore betake themselves to another Answer, for they say that this Church at 〈…〉 an extraordinary constituted Church, and 1. wanted an Eldership, and presbytery, as Christian Churches have now: 2. the government was meerely Apostolicall: 3. the constitution was somewhat Jewish, rather then Christian, for their service was mixed with legall ordinances and Jewish observances for many yeares, and therefore cannot bee a patterne of the Christian visible Church which wee now seeke.
To which I answer. 1. Because our brethren consider that the Church of Jerusalem will not be their independent Congregation, before we obtain it, for us, as a mould of a presbyterial Church, they had rather quit their part of it, and permit the Jews to have it, for us both, but we are content that their Congregations in some good sense be given to them, and not to Jews. 2. There is no reason, but the Church of Jerusalem be a Christian Church; 1. The external profession of a visible Church maketh it a visible Christian Church, but this Church professeth faith in Christ already come in the flesh and the Sacraments of the New Testament, baptism, and the Sacramental breaking of bread, Act. 22. 41, 42. we desire to know how saving faith in a multitude constituteth an invisible Church, and the external and blameless profession of that same saving faith doth not constitute a visible Church also? and how this is not a Christian visible Church not differing in essence and nature from the […] Churches that now are, to which the essential note of a visible Church agreeth, to wit the preaching or profession of the sound faith: if it be called an Apostolic and so an extraordinary Christian Church because the Apostles doth govern •it, that is not enough, if the Apostles govern it, according to the rule of the word framing the visible Churches of the New Testament, this way the Church of Corinth, 1 Cor. 5. shall be an Apostolic and so an extraordinary Church, which our brethren cannot say. But we desire to know wherein the frame of this first pattern Christian Church at Jerusalem is so extraordinary, ⟨p. 434⟩that it cannot be a rule to us to draw the mould of our Churches according to it, for if the Apostles make it a pattern of an ordinary Christian Church in Word and Sacraments, to say it was extraordinary in the government, except you show that that government was different from the rule that now is in government, is petitio principii, to beg what is in question, for these same keys both of knowledge and jurisdiction that by your grant, were given to the Church, Matth. 18. 15, 16, 17. were given to the Apostles, Matth. 16, 17, 18. and
that was given to the Deacons by office, and so they had not Elders, nor Doctors, nor Pastors as we now ha•e, but the Apostles were both Pastors, Ruling Elders, Doctors, and Deacons, and they were the only governing Eldership, and this was extraordinary that they had no Eldership, and so they were for that same cause no presbyterial Church, whence it followeth that you cannot make this Church which had no presbytery, a pattern of a presbyterial Church.
that was given to the Deacons by office, and so they had not Elders, nor Doctors, nor Pastors as we now ha•e, but the Apostles were both Pastors, Ruling Elders, Doctors, and Deacons, and they were the onely governing Eldership, and this was extraordinary that they had no Eldership, and so they were for that same cause no presbyteriall Church, whence it followeth that you cannot make this Church which had no presbytery, a patterne of a presbyteriall Church.
But I answer, this will not take off the argument, if we shall prove that after they were more then could meet in one Congregation, and so after they were so numerous that they were moe Congregations then one, they had one common government, and 1. we say though the Apostles had power to govern all the Churches of the world, and so many Congregations, yet if they did rule many Congregations as Elders, and not as Apostles, we prove our point. Now we say where baptism and the Lords Supper was, there behoved to be some government, else the Apostles admitted promiscuously to baptism and the Lords Supper any the most scandalous and profane, which we cannot think of the Apostles: it is true say you, they admitted not all, but according to the rule of right government, but this right government was extraordinary, in that it was not in a settled Eldership of a Congregation, which was obliged to reside and personally to watch over that determinate flock, and no other flock, but it was in the hands of the Apostles, who might go through all the world to preach the Gospel, and were not tied to any particular flock: and so from this neither can you draw your classical ⟨p. 435⟩Eldership, nor we our Congregational Eldership.
But I answer, this will not take off the argument, if wee shall prove that after they were more then could meet in one Congregation, and so after they were so numerous that they were moe Congregations then one, they had one common government, and 1. wee say though the Apostles had power to governe all the Churches of the world, and so many Congregations, yet if they did rule many Congregations as Elders, and not as Apostles, wee prove our point. Now we say where baptisme and the Lords Supper was, there behoved to bee some government, else the Apostles admitted promiscuously to baptisme and the Lords Supper any the most scandalous and prophane, which wee cannot thinke of the Apostles: it is true say you, they admitted not all, but according to the rule of right government, but this right government was extraordinary, in that it was not in a setled Eldership of a Congregation, which was oblieged to reside and personally to watch over that determinate flock, and no other flock, but it was in the hands of the Apostles, who might goe through all the world to preach the Gospell, and were not tied to any particular flock: and so from this neither can you draw your classicall ⟨p. 435⟩Eldership, nor wee our Congregationall Eldership.
But I answer, yet the question is begged, for though it be unlawful for a settled Eldership not to reside where their charge is, yet the question is now of a government in the hands of those who are obliged to reside and give personal attendance to the flock, and the government in the hands of the Apostles, who were not obliged to personal attendance over this and this particular flock, which they did govern; were governments so different in nature, as the one is a pattern to us, not the other, and the one followeth rules different in nature and spirit from the other; for though it were granted that the Apostles did govern many Congregations as Apostles, not as Elders, yet there was no extraordinary reason why these many Congregations should be called one Church, and the believers added to them, said to be added to the Church, as it is said, Act. 2. 47. And the Lord added to the Church daily such as should be saved, except this Church be one entire body governed and ruled according to Christs Laws. 2. There be seven Deacons chosen to this Church, Act. 6. and Deacons are officers of the Church of Philippi which our brethren calleth Phil. 1. 1. a Congregational Church, and Phebe was a Deaconess (say they) of the Church of Cenchrea, Rom. 16. 1. and if they had Deacons, they could not want Elders, who are as necessary. 3. This Church could not be so extraordinary as that it cannot be a pattern to us of the constant government of Churches by Elders, which we call Aristocratical, seeing it is brought as a pattern of the Churches government by the voices of the people, which is called by Divines, in some respect, democratical, and this place is alleged by our brethren, and by all Protestant Divines against Bishops and Papists to prove that the people have some hand in government, to wit, in election of officers, and so the words are clear, Act. 6. 5. And this saying pleased the whole multitude, and they chose Steven, &c. so this multitude did not make one Congregational Church, but it was a company of the multiplied disciples, both of Grecians and Hebrews, as is clearly related to these spoken of, v. 1. c. 6. Now Hebrews and Grecians were directly one Church having one government, and seven Deacons, ⟨p. 436⟩
If the constitution of this Church at Jerusalem be sewish, because of some Jewish observations, and so no pattern of the frame of ordinary visible Churches Christian; I say 1. this is no good argument, seeing the Christian visible Church, and the Jewish visible Church is of that same frame and constitution, having that same faith, s•all grant, except Papists, Socinians and Armini•ns, and so that same profession of that same faith. 2. If this were a good reason, then all the Churches of the Gentiles which are commanded for a time, in the case of scandal, to observe some Jewish Laws, to abstain from eating meats offered to Idols, and from blood, and from things strangled, Act. 15. 29. Act. 16. 4. shall be also Churches in their constitution Jewish, and so no pattern to us; and the Church of Rome and of Corinth shall be Jewish also, and no pattern to us, because in case of scandal they are to abstain from meats forbidden in the Law of Moses, Rom. 14. 1 Cor. 8. c. 10. but this our brethren cannot teach. 5. Though Apostles did govern all these Congregations, yet we are not to thinke• that seeing there were such abundance of gifted men in this Church, on which the Spirit, according to Joels prophecy, was poured in so large a measure, that they did not appoint Elders who did personally watch over the converted flock, especially seeing Apostles use never this Apostolical and extraordinary power, but in case of necessity, where ordinary helps are wanting, else this answer might clude all reasons drawn from the first moulded Churches which were planted by the Apostles and watered by their helpers. But I have heard some say, that multitude of Pastors at Jerusalem doth not prove that the Apostles were idle, if they did all attend me Congregation, because they had work enough in the Synagogues […] convert the unconverted Jews, all the twelve did not labour in preaching to the one single new converted Congregation.
If the con•titution of this Church at Jerusalem bee sewish, because of some Jewish observations, and so no patterne of the frame of ordinary visible Churches Christian; I say 1. this is no good argument, seeing the Christian visible Church, and the Jewish visible Church is of that same frame and constitution, having that same faith, sall grant, except Papists, Socinians and Arminins, and so that same profession of that same faith. 2. If this were a good reason, then all the Churches of the Gentiles which are commanded for a time, in the case of scandall, to observe some Jewish Lawes, to abstaine from eating meates offered to Idls, and from blood, and from things strangled,
Answ. But if you lay down our brethren's supposition, that the Apostles had no public meetings for the Word and Sacraments of the Christian Church, but the Temple, and that they ceased not daily in the Temple, and from house to house to teach and preach Christ, as is said, Act. 5. 42. then consider that they ⟨p. 437⟩preached not daily in the Synagogues, but in the Temple and i• houses, and their first conquest of five thousand was above three Congregations, beside those who daily came In: and certainly it the first was but one Congregation, yet one of the twelve preached to that Congregation, the other eleven b•hoor•d to have a Congregation also. 6. Our brethren acknowledge the Church of Jerusalem to be one Church, for it is called, even before the dispersion, one Church in the singular number, Act. 2. 47. And the Lord added to the Church daily. […] as should be saved, Act. 5. 11. Great fear came upon all the Church, and Act. 8 1. A• that time there was a great persecution […] Church. 2. They grant before the dispersion that it had a government, but they deny this government to be presbyterial, thy s•y it was Apostolic and extraordinary, and that it had not in Eldership, nor read we of any Elders till after the dispersion, Act. 8 1. When their number was diminished, so as it is clear they […] meet in one Congregation. 3. You must prove this government be one if you prove a Presbyterial Church at Jerusalem. 4. […] must prove divers formed and organical and several Con•••nions at Jerusalem, if you prove such presbyterial Churches as […] have in Scotland; but I pray you, The Apostles (you say) […] the Church of Jerusalem as Apostles, and so as extraordinary Elders, not as an ordinary Eldership and Presbytery, but give me leave to say this is a mere shift. 1. What reason to call the Apostles governing of the Church extraordinary, more then their preaching the Word and their administration of the Sacraments is extraordinary? and if Word and Sacraments do prove that this was the first visible Church and a type and pattern to all visible Churches, why should its government be extraordinary? 2. Why should the government be extraordinary, because the Apostles did govern it, in respect they were extraordinary officers, and should not the government be by the Apostles;
and exercised by them as a common ordinary presbytery, seeing this Church in its goods, was governed by seven ordinary and constant Church-officers, the seven Deacons? Act. 6. and seeing the people did exercise an act of ordination (say our brethren) but an act of popular election (say we) which cannot be denied ⟨p. 438⟩to be a politic act of divers Churches, Hebrews and Grecians choosing their own ordinary officers in relation to which they made one governed Church, under one common government, which is not congregational; because not of one Congregation, but of moe Congregations convened in their principal members (for they could not all meet in one, as we have proved) Ergo, it must be presbyterial. And that this government is one to me is evident, because these seven Deacons were officers in ordinary to them all. 3. We see not how we need to prove that the several Congregations were several formed, fixed and organical bodies; 1. Because it shall be hard to our brethren to prove a Parishionall Church in its local circuit in the Apostolic Church, and when Churches were moulded and framed first in local circuits of parishes, I will not undertake to determine. 2. Ten Congregations in a great City, though not moulded locally and formally in ten little distinct Churches organical, yet if sixteen or twenty Elders in common feed them all, with Word, Seals and common government, they differ not in nature from ten formed and fixed Congregations, and the government is as truly Aristocratical, and presbyterial, as if every one of them had their own fixed Eldership out of these sixteen Elders, for fixing of this or this Elder to this or this Congregation is but accidental to the nature of an organical Church; if ten little Cities have ten magistrates who ruleth them all in common, they are ten perfect political incorporations and societies, no less then if to every one of these ten were a fixed magistrate, to this or this city; Because the King and State might accuse them all for any misgovernment or act of unjustice done by the whole ten convened in one judicature to judge them all; for what unjustice is done by the major part is to be imputed to the whole college, in so far as the whole college hath hand in it. 2.
and exercised by them as a common ordinary presbytery, seeing this Church in its goods, was governed by seven ordinary and constant Chu•ch-officers, the seven Deacons?
The formal acts of a political Congregation not fixed are one and the same in nature and essence with the formal Church-acts of a fixed Congregation; For 1. the Word and Sacraments are one and the same: 2. their acts of government, in rebuking, accusing, and joint consenting to deliver to Satan an incestuous man are one and the ⟨p. 439⟩same, whether the Congregation be fixed, or not fixed; show us a difference.
The formall acts of a politicall Congregation not fixed are one and the same in nature and essence with the formall Church-acts of a fixed Congregation; For 1. the Word and Sacraments are one and the same: 2. their acts of government, in rebuking, accusing, and joynt consenting to deliver to Satan an incestuous man are one and the ⟨p. 439⟩same, whether the Congregation bee fixed, or not fixed; shew us a difference.
But it is said, they are different in a political or in a Church consideration, 1. Because this determinate Congregation is to subject their consciences in the Lord, to this fixed Eldership whom they have called and chosen to be their Elders, and not to the ministry of any others, as 1 Thess. 5. 12. Know them that labour amongst you, [Greek or Hebrew], (not those who are over others,) and that are over you, [Greek or Hebrew], and are over you in the Lord, not over others, [Greek or Hebrew] and admonish you, not others: and 2. The Pastors are to feed such a flock over which the holy Ghost hath set them, Acts 20. 28. and they are to feed the flock amongst them, 1 Pet. 5. 2. not any other, [Greek or Hebrew], therefore Pastors are fixed by the holy Ghost to a fixed congregation. 3. Pastors are not rebuked by the Spirit of God, for remiss exercise of jurisdiction and Church-power, but over their own fixed Congregation, not because they do not exercise their power over other Congregations over which they are not, and for whose souls they do not watch, as is evident in the several rebukes tendered by Christ to every Angel or Eldership of the seven Churches in Asia, Revel. 2. c. 3. where every Angel and Church is rebuked for their own omissions towards their own fixed and particular flocks.
But it is said, they are different in a politicall or in a Churchconsideration, 1. Because this determinate Congregation is to subject their consciences in the Lord, to this fixed Eldership whom they have called and chosen to bee their Elders, and not to the ministery of any others, as 1 Thess. 5. 12. Know them that labour amongst you, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, (not those who are over others,) and that are over you, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and are over you in the Lord, not over others, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 and adm•nish you, not others: and 2. The Pastors are to feed such a flocke over which the holy Ghost hath set them,
Answ. The places do not come up, to prove fixed Congregations in the Apostles times; for 1. we deny that the Church of Thessalonica was one single fixed Congregation, or the Church of Ephesus either, and far less can the Churches of Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia, to which Peter writeth, and whose Elders, 1 Pet. 5. 1. 2. he exhorteth to feed the flock of God, be one fixed Congregation, nor do they prove that fixed Congregations were, though I think it not unprobable that when Phoebe, Rom. 16. 1. is called a Deac•nisse of the Church, which is at Cenchrea, that there were fixed Congregations at that time, but many things not without apparent strength of much probability may be said by the learned, on the contrary. 2. The Eldership of Ephesus I dare not call the Eldership of one Congregation, far less of one fixed Congregation, and they are all commanded to feed the flock over which the holy Ghost had set them, and no other ⟨p. 440⟩Church that is most true. But how do our brethren infer a fixed Congregation at Ephesus from thence? far less I think can they in far that the formal Church-acts of a fixed, and a not fixed Congregation are different in nature; and therefore, if we can show that in the Apostolic Churches they had many Congregations though not fixed, under one common Eldership, which did feed them in common with Word, Sacraments and Discipline, as is clearly proved, then have we a pattern of a Presbyterial Church. 3. The Elders of Ephesus and these Elders, 1 Pet. 5. 1, 2, 3. had all of them a burden of the souls amongst them, and over which the holy Ghost had set them, and they had not a burden and charge in particular of others as watching in particular for the souls of others: but how fixed Congregations are hence inferred I see not, for I may have with other six Pastors, a Pastoral burden and charge to watch for three Congregations, according to my talent and strength, though I be not a fixed pastor to all the three collectively, or to any fixed one distributively, so as all the omissions of my six fellow-labourers shall be laid to my charge, in the Court of the Judge and Lord of all, if I do what I am able: which I demonstrate thus. 1.
Answ. The place, Act. 4. 31. saith not, that all the five thousand beleevers were in that one place, which was shaken, for v. 21. that when the Apostles were let goe by the Priests and Captaines of the Temple they returned to their owne company 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, to their owne, but no circumstance in the Text doth inferre that they came backe to the whole five thousand, but onely to some few of the first beleevers, that were converted before the first Sermon of Peter was made, cap. 2, they returned, Lyra and Hugo Cardinalis, to their owne company, ad domesticos suos, and so saith Lorinus, who citeth the Syriack 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 hachaiehin ad fratres suos. Salmeron, ad suos •apostolos, sive condiscipulos & domesticos fidei, and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 doth not signifie the whole Church, but friends and domesticks, as, Mark. 5. 19. Goe home to thy own house and shew thy friends, Luke, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 compared with, Luk. 8. 39. and Gal. 6. 10, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and 1 Tim. 5. 8. therefore the place saith that the five thousand were gathered together in this one place which was shaken. 2. Giving and not granting that they were all conveened to prayer, it doth not follow that they did meet ordinarily in one place, for partaking of Word and Sacraments, as one Congregation, for •oe might conveene to prayer and hearing the Word, then could meet ordinarily in a Congregationall-way. Neither will any Text inforce us to ⟨p. 432⟩expone 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, collectively, but distributively, as wee say, all the Congregations in Scotland met, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, in one, every Lords day, that is, every one of the Congregations is in one place, but the sense is not that all the Congregations collectively are in one place. And wee may justly aske what this place was which was shaken, it is not like that it was the Temple, that which should have beene more prodigious like, and presaged a ruine to the Temple, would not have beene concealo• by the holy Ghost, for it would have more terrified the Jewes, and the Temple is never called 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 sine adjecto, without some other thing to make it bee knowne to bee the holy place, if it was a private house, give us leave to say it could not containe five thousand to heare prayer, farre lesse a more numerous multitude.
To which I answer. 1. Because our brethren consider that the Church of Jerusalem will not bee their independent Congregation, before wee obtaine it, for us, as a mould of a presb•t•riall Church, they had rather quit their part of it, and permit the Jewes to have it, for us both, but wee are content that their Congregations in some good sense bee given to them, and not to Jewes. 2. There is no reason, but the Church of Jerusalem bee a Christian Church; 1. The externall profession of a visible Church maketh it a visible Christian Church, but this Church professeth faith in Christ already come in the flesh and the Sacraments of the New Testament, baptisme, and the Sacramentall breaking of bread, Act. 22. 41, 42. wee desire to know how saving faith in a multitude constituteh an invisible Church, and the externall and blamelesse profession of that same saving faith doth not contitute a visible Church also? and how this is not a Christian visible Church not differing in essence and nature from the 〈…〉 Churches that now are, to which the essentiall note of a visible Church agreeth, to wit the preaching or profession of the sound faith: if it bee called an Apostolick and so an extraordinary Christian Church because the Apostles doth governe •it, that is not enough, if the Apostles governe it, according to the rule of the word framing the visible Churches of the New Testament, this way the Church of Corinth, 1 Cor. 5. shall bee an Apostolick and so an extraordinary Church, which our brethren cannot say. But wee desire to know wherein the frame of this first patterne Christian Church at Jerusalem is so extraordinary, ⟨p. 434⟩that it cannot bee a rule to us to draw the mould of our Churches according to it, for if the Apostles make it a patterne of an ordinary Christian Church in Word and Sacraments, to say it was extraordinary in the government, except you shew that that government was different from the rule that now is in government, is petitio principii, to begge what is in question, for these same keyes both of knowledge and jurisdiction that by your grant, were given to the Church, Matth. 18. 15, 16, 17. were given to the Apostles, Matth. 16, 17, 18. and Joh. 20. 21. If you say it is extraordinary, because as yet they had not Deacons, for the Apostles did as yet serve tables, where as afterward Act. 6.
But I answer, yet the question is begged, for though it bee unlawfull for a setled Eldership not to reside where their charge is, yet the question is now of a government in the hands of those who are oblieged to reside and give personall attendance to the flock, and the government in the hands of the Apostles, who were not oblieged to personall attendance over this and this particular flock, which they did governe; were governments so different in nature, as the one is a patterne to us, not the other, and the one followeth rules different in nature and spirit from the other; for though it were granted that the Apostles did governe many Congregations as Apostles, not as Elders, yet there was no extraordinary reason why these many Congregations should bee called one Church, and the beleevers added to them, said to bee added to the Church, as it is said, Act. 2. 47. And the Lord added to the Church daily such as should bee saved, except this Church bee one entire body governed and ruled according to Christs Lawes. 2. There bee seven Descons chosen to this Church, Act. 6. and Deacons are officers of the Church of Philippi which our brethren calleth Phil. 1. 1. a Congregationall Church, and Pnebe was a Deaconisse (say they) of the Church of Cenchrea, Rom. 16. 1. and if they had Deacons, they could not want Elders, who are as necessary. 3. This Church could not bee so extraordinary as that it cannot bee a patterne to us of the constant government of Churches by Elders, which wee call Aristocraticall, seeing it is brought as a patterne of the Churches government by the voices of the people, which is called by Divines, in some respect, democraticall, and this place is alledged by our brethren, and by all Protestant Divines against Bishops and Papists to prove that the people have some hand in government, to wit, in election of officers, and so the words are cleare, Act. 6. 5. And this saying pleased the whole multitude, and they choosed Steven, &c. so this multitude did not make one Congregationall Church, but it was a company of the multiplied disciples, both of Grecians and Hebrews, as is clearely related to these spoken of, v. 1. c. 6. Now Hebrewes and Grccians were directly one Church having one government, and seven Deacons, ⟨p. 436⟩common to both, now that could not bee a single independent Congregation, as is already proved. 4.
Answ. But if you lay downe our brethrens supposition, that the Apostles had no publick meetings for the Word and Sacraments of the Christian Church, but the Temple, and that they ceased not daily in the Temple, and from house to house to teach and preach Christ, as is said, Act. 5. 42. then consider that they ⟨p. 437⟩preached not daily in the Synagogues, but in the Temple and i• houses, and their first conquest of five thousand was above three Congregations, beside those who daily came In: and c•r•ainly it the first was but one Congregation, yet one of the twelve preached to that Congregation, the other eleven b•hoor•d to have a Congregation also. 6. Our brethren acknowledge the Church of Jerusalem to be one Church, for it is called, even before the dispersion, one Church in the singular number, Act. 2. 47. And the Lord added to the Church daily. 〈…〉 as should bee saved, Act. 5. 11. Great feare came upon all the Church, and Act. 8 1. A• that time there was a great persecution 〈…〉 Church. 2. They grant before the disportion that it had a government, but they deny this government to bee presbyterial, thy s•y it was Apostolick and extraordinary, and that it had not in Eldership, nor read wee of any Elders till after the dispersion, Act. 8 1. When their number was diminished, so as it is cleare they 〈…〉 meet in one Congregation. 3. You must prove this government bee one if you prove a Presbyteriall Church at Jerusalem. 4. 〈…〉 must prove divers formed and organicall and severall Con•••nions at Jerusalem, if you prove such presbyteriall Churches as 〈…〉 have in Scotland; but I pray you, The Apostles (you say) 〈…〉 the Church of Jerusalem as Apostles, and so as extraordinary Elders, not as an ordinary Eldership and Presbytery, but give mee leave to say this is a meere shift. 1. What reason to call the Apostles governing of the Church extraordinary, more then their preaching the Word and their administration of the Sacraments is extraordinary? and if Word and Sacraments doe prove that this was the first visible Church and a type and patterne to all visible Churches, why should its government bee extraordinary? 2. Why should the government bee extraordinary, because the Apostles did governe it, in respect they were extraordinary officers, and should not the government bee by the Apostles;