A57969:1340
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. But if you lay down our brethren's supposition, that the Apostles had no public meetings for the Word and Sacraments of the Christian Church, but the Temple, and that they ceased not daily in the Temple, and from house to house to teach and preach Christ, as is said, Act. 5. 42. then consider that they ⟨p. 437⟩preached not daily in the Synagogues, but in the Temple and i• houses, and their first conquest of five thousand was above three Congregations, beside those who daily came In: and certainly it the first was but one Congregation, yet one of the twelve preached to that Congregation, the other eleven b•hoor•d to have a Congregation also. 6. Our brethren acknowledge the Church of Jerusalem to be one Church, for it is called, even before the dispersion, one Church in the singular number, Act. 2. 47. And the Lord added to the Church daily. […] as should be saved, Act. 5. 11. Great fear came upon all the Church, and Act. 8 1. A• that time there was a great persecution […] Church. 2. They grant before the dispersion that it had a government, but they deny this government to be presbyterial, thy s•y it was Apostolic and extraordinary, and that it had not in Eldership, nor read we of any Elders till after the dispersion, Act. 8 1. When their number was diminished, so as it is clear they […] meet in one Congregation. 3. You must prove this government be one if you prove a Presbyterial Church at Jerusalem. 4. […] must prove divers formed and organical and several Con•••nions at Jerusalem, if you prove such presbyterial Churches as […] have in Scotland; but I pray you, The Apostles (you say) […] the Church of Jerusalem as Apostles, and so as extraordinary Elders, not as an ordinary Eldership and Presbytery, but give me leave to say this is a mere shift. 1. What reason to call the Apostles governing of the Church extraordinary, more then their preaching the Word and their administration of the Sacraments is extraordinary? and if Word and Sacraments do prove that this was the first visible Church and a type and pattern to all visible Churches, why should its government be extraordinary? 2. Why should the government be extraordinary, because the Apostles did govern it, in respect they were extraordinary officers, and should not the government be by the Apostles;
Answ. But if you lay downe our brethrens supposition, that the Apostles had no publick meetings for the Word and Sacraments of the Christian Church, but the Temple, and that they ceased not daily in the Temple, and from house to house to teach and preach Christ, as is said, Act. 5. 42. then consider that they ⟨p. 437⟩preached not daily in the Synagogues, but in the Temple and i• houses, and their first conquest of five thousand was above three Congregations, beside those who daily came In: and c•r•ainly it the first was but one Congregation, yet one of the twelve preached to that Congregation, the other eleven b•hoor•d to have a Congregation also. 6. Our brethren acknowledge the Church of Jerusalem to be one Church, for it is called, even before the dispersion, one Church in the singular number, Act. 2. 47. And the Lord added to the Church daily. 〈…〉 as should bee saved, Act. 5. 11. Great feare came upon all the Church, and Act. 8 1. A• that time there was a great persecution 〈…〉 Church. 2. They grant before the disportion that it had a government, but they deny this government to bee presbyterial, thy s•y it was Apostolick and extraordinary, and that it had not in Eldership, nor read wee of any Elders till after the dispersion, Act. 8 1. When their number was diminished, so as it is cleare they 〈…〉 meet in one Congregation. 3. You must prove this government bee one if you prove a Presbyteriall Church at Jerusalem. 4. 〈…〉 must prove divers formed and organicall and severall Con•••nions at Jerusalem, if you prove such presbyteriall Churches as 〈…〉 have in Scotland; but I pray you, The Apostles (you say) 〈…〉 the Church of Jerusalem as Apostles, and so as extraordinary Elders, not as an ordinary Eldership and Presbytery, but give mee leave to say this is a meere shift. 1. What reason to call the Apostles governing of the Church extraordinary, more then their preaching the Word and their administration of the Sacraments is extraordinary? and if Word and Sacraments doe prove that this was the first visible Church and a type and patterne to all visible Churches, why should its government bee extraordinary? 2. Why should the government bee extraordinary, because the Apostles did governe it, in respect they were extraordinary officers, and should not the government bee by the Apostles;
and exercised by them as a common ordinary presbytery, seeing this Church in its goods, was governed by seven ordinary and constant Church-officers, the seven Deacons? Act. 6. and seeing the people did exercise an act of ordination (say our brethren) but an act of popular election (say we) which cannot be denied ⟨p. 438⟩to be a politic act of divers Churches, Hebrews and Grecians choosing their own ordinary officers in relation to which they made one governed Church, under one common government, which is not congregational; because not of one Congregation, but of moe Congregations convened in their principal members (for they could not all meet in one, as we have proved) Ergo, it must be presbyterial. And that this government is one to me is evident, because these seven Deacons were officers in ordinary to them all. 3. We see not how we need to prove that the several Congregations were several formed, fixed and organical bodies; 1. Because it shall be hard to our brethren to prove a Parishionall Church in its local circuit in the Apostolic Church, and when Churches were moulded and framed first in local circuits of parishes, I will not undertake to determine. 2. Ten Congregations in a great City, though not moulded locally and formally in ten little distinct Churches organical, yet if sixteen or twenty Elders in common feed them all, with Word, Seals and common government, they differ not in nature from ten formed and fixed Congregations, and the government is as truly Aristocratical, and presbyterial, as if every one of them had their own fixed Eldership out of these sixteen Elders, for fixing of this or this Elder to this or this Congregation is but accidental to the nature of an organical Church; if ten little Cities have ten magistrates who ruleth them all in common, they are ten perfect political incorporations and societies, no less then if to every one of these ten were a fixed magistrate, to this or this city; Because the King and State might accuse them all for any misgovernment or act of unjustice done by the whole ten convened in one judicature to judge them all; for what unjustice is done by the major part is to be imputed to the whole college, in so far as the whole college hath hand in it. 2.
and exercised by them as a common ordinary presbytery, seeing this Church in its goods, was governed by seven ordinary and constant Chu•ch-officers, the seven Deacons?
The formal acts of a political Congregation not fixed are one and the same in nature and essence with the formal Church-acts of a fixed Congregation; For 1. the Word and Sacraments are one and the same: 2. their acts of government, in rebuking, accusing, and joint consenting to deliver to Satan an incestuous man are one and the ⟨p. 439⟩same, whether the Congregation be fixed, or not fixed; show us a difference.
The formall acts of a politicall Congregation not fixed are one and the same in nature and essence with the formall Church-acts of a fixed Congregation; For 1. the Word and Sacraments are one and the same: 2. their acts of government, in rebuking, accusing, and joynt consenting to deliver to Satan an incestuous man are one and the ⟨p. 439⟩same, whether the Congregation bee fixed, or not fixed; shew us a difference.
But it is said, they are different in a political or in a Church consideration, 1. Because this determinate Congregation is to subject their consciences in the Lord, to this fixed Eldership whom they have called and chosen to be their Elders, and not to the ministry of any others, as 1 Thess. 5. 12. Know them that labour amongst you, [Greek or Hebrew], (not those who are over others,) and that are over you, [Greek or Hebrew], and are over you in the Lord, not over others, [Greek or Hebrew] and admonish you, not others: and 2. The Pastors are to feed such a flock over which the holy Ghost hath set them, Acts 20. 28. and they are to feed the flock amongst them, 1 Pet. 5. 2. not any other, [Greek or Hebrew], therefore Pastors are fixed by the holy Ghost to a fixed congregation. 3. Pastors are not rebuked by the Spirit of God, for remiss exercise of jurisdiction and Church-power, but over their own fixed Congregation, not because they do not exercise their power over other Congregations over which they are not, and for whose souls they do not watch, as is evident in the several rebukes tendered by Christ to every Angel or Eldership of the seven Churches in Asia, Revel. 2. c. 3. where every Angel and Church is rebuked for their own omissions towards their own fixed and particular flocks.
But it is said, they are different in a politicall or in a Churchconsideration, 1. Because this determinate Congregation is to subject their consciences in the Lord, to this fixed Eldership whom they have called and chosen to bee their Elders, and not to the ministery of any others, as 1 Thess. 5. 12. Know them that labour amongst you, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, (not those who are over others,) and that are over you, , and are over you in the Lord, not over others, and admnish you, not others: and 2. The Pastors are to feed such a flocke over which the holy Ghost hath set them,
Answ. The places do not come up, to prove fixed Congregations in the Apostles times; for 1. we deny that the Church of Thessalonica was one single fixed Congregation, or the Church of Ephesus either, and far less can the Churches of Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia, to which Peter writeth, and whose Elders, 1 Pet. 5. 1. 2. he exhorteth to feed the flock of God, be one fixed Congregation, nor do they prove that fixed Congregations were, though I think it not unprobable that when Phoebe, Rom. 16. 1. is called a Deac•nisse of the Church, which is at Cenchrea, that there were fixed Congregations at that time, but many things not without apparent strength of much probability may be said by the learned, on the contrary. 2. The Eldership of Ephesus I dare not call the Eldership of one Congregation, far less of one fixed Congregation, and they are all commanded to feed the flock over which the holy Ghost had set them, and no other ⟨p. 440⟩Church that is most true. But how do our brethren infer a fixed Congregation at Ephesus from thence? far less I think can they in far that the formal Church-acts of a fixed, and a not fixed Congregation are different in nature; and therefore, if we can show that in the Apostolic Churches they had many Congregations though not fixed, under one common Eldership, which did feed them in common with Word, Sacraments and Discipline, as is clearly proved, then have we a pattern of a Presbyterial Church. 3. The Elders of Ephesus and these Elders, 1 Pet. 5. 1, 2, 3. had all of them a burden of the souls amongst them, and over which the holy Ghost had set them, and they had not a burden and charge in particular of others as watching in particular for the souls of others: but how fixed Congregations are hence inferred I see not, for I may have with other six Pastors, a Pastoral burden and charge to watch for three Congregations, according to my talent and strength, though I be not a fixed pastor to all the three collectively, or to any fixed one distributively, so as all the omissions of my six fellow-labourers shall be laid to my charge, in the Court of the Judge and Lord of all, if I do what I am able: which I demonstrate thus. 1.
That moral obligation of conscience which did oblige the Apostles as Pastors of the Christian world which was to be converted, is not temporary but perpetual and moral and did oblige the Apostles as Christians. Therefore this moral, obligation did lie upon the Apostles to feed the Catholic flock of the whole Christian world over which the holy Ghost had set them, just as the Elders of Ephesus, Act. 20. 28. are commanded to feed the whole flock of God which is at Ephesus: now I ask if every single Apostle is to make a reckoning to God for the souls of all the Christian world? 2. If Peter must be answerable to God, because Paul by negligence should incur the woe of not preaching the Gospel, 1 Cor. 9. 16? (3.) If upon this moral ground of an obligation lying on the Apostles to feed the Catholic flock of the whole world, amongst which they were, for the most part, by special commandment of Christ, to preach to all nations, Matth. 28. 19. to every creature, Mark. 16. v. 15. If (I say) the Apostles be tied to plant Churches in such determinate quarters and fixed kingdoms ⟨p. 441⟩of the habitable world, and if the dividing of the world into twelve several parts, and large parishes to the twelve Apostles, be juris divini, of divine institution? I believe this can hardly be proved by Gods Word. 2. Where there be six Elders in a Congregation supposed to be independent, every one of the six are obliged in their place to feed the whole flock, over which the holy Ghost hath set them, and that by the commandment of God, Act. 20. 28. 29. 1 Pet. 5. 1. as our brethren teach, but I hope by these places no humane logic would infer, nor could our brethren collect, that, 1. every one of these six should, by divine institution, be set over each of them the sixth determinate and sixth part of that Congregation. 2. That every one of the sixth were not to give a reckoning for the whole Congregation, and did not watch for the whole Congregation according to his Talent. 3. That one might not be accused, even one Archippus possibly at Coloss,
yea & we justly ask if all the Elders of Thyatira were guilty of remiss discipline against the false Prophetess Jezebel, and if all the Church of Sardis did become sleepy, and secure, and had a name that they were living, and yet were dead, though the Eldership under the name of the Angel of the Church, be indefinitely rebuked, Revel. 2. 20. c. 3. 1, 2, 3. 4. yea it is like to me that seeing the Lord Jesus commendeth the one for love, service, faith, patience, Revel. 2. 19. and the other, that c. 3. 4 they had a few names that had not defiled their garments, that only those who were guilty, were rebuked, I believe, and therefore this is to be proved that Elders are not rebuked, but for their remiss watching over an unfixed Congregation, the places to me, do not prove it.
yea & we justly aske if all the Elders of Thyatira were guiltie of remisse discipline against the false Prophetesse Jezabell, and if all the Church of Sardis did become sleepie, and secure, and had a name that they were living, and yet were dead, though the Eldership under the name of the Angel of the Church, bee indefinitely rebuked, Revel. 2. 20. c. 3. 1, 2, 3. 4. yea it is like to mee that seeing the Lord Jesus commendeth the one for love, service, faith, patience, Revel. 2. 19. and the other, that c. 3. 4 they had a few names that had not defiled their garments, that onely those who were guiltie, were rebuked, I beleeve, and therefore this is to bee proved that Elders are not rebuked, but for their remisse watching over an unfixed Congregation, the places to me, doe not prove it.
Now whereas our brethren say, that they read of no Eldership before the dispersion of the Church at Jerusalem, Act. 8. 1. and therefore of no presbyterial government, and after the dispersion, the number was so diminished as they might all meet in one Congregation, because it is said, Act. 8. 1. They were all scattered abroad through••• the regions of Judea and Samaria except the Apostles. It is easily answered.
Now whereas our brethren say, that they read of no Eldership before the dispersion of the Church at Jerusalem, Act. 8. 1. and therefore of no presbyteriall government, and after the dispersion, the number was so diminished as they might all meet in one Congregation, bec•use it is said, Act. 8. 1. They were all scattered abroad through••• the regions of Iudea and Samaria except the Apostles. It is easily answered.
1. To what effect should the twelve Apostles not also have followed their scattered flocks, and to what end did twelve Apostles stay at Jerusalem to preach to one single handful, that might all conveniently meet in one house, and a private house, for I think the persecution could as easily put them from public meetings in the Temple and Synagogues, as it could scatter them all to so few a number as one congregation? was the the harvest so great, and the Apostolic labourers so sparing in reaping, as eleven should be hearers in one Congregation? and one speak only at once?
1. To what effect should the twelve Apostles not also have followed their scattered flocks, and to what end did twelve Apostles stay at Jerusalem to preach to one single handfull, that might all conveniently meet in one house, and a private house, for I thinke the persecution could as easily put them from publick meetings in the Temple and Synagogues, as it could scatter them all to so few a number as one congregation? was the the harvest so great, and the Apostolick labourers so sparing in reaping, as eleven should bee hearers in one Congregation? and one speake onely at once?
2. Our brethren may know that we prove a Presbyterial government before the dispersion. 3. If our brethren elide the force of our argument from multitude of believers at Jerusalem, to prove a presbyterial Church, they must prove that this dispersion did so dissolve the Church as that three thousand, Act. 2. and some added daily, v. 47. and five thousand, Act. 4. 4. and believers more added, multitudes both of men and women, Act. 5. 14. and Jerusalem was filled with the doctrine of the Apostles, c. 5. 28. and yet the number of the Disciples multiplied, c. 6. 1. and the Word of God increased, and the number of the Disciples multiplied in Jerusalem greatly, and a great company of the Priests were obedient to the faith, they must (I say) prove (for affirmanti incumbit probatio) that all this number and all these thousands by the dispersion, Act. 8. 1. came to one thousand and to a handful of a single Congregation.
2. Our brethren may know that wee prove a Presbyterlall government before the dispersion. 3. If our brethren elide the force of our argument from multitude of beleevers at Jerusalem, to prove a presbyteriall Church, they must prove that this dispersion did so dissolve the Church as that three thousand, Act. 2. and some added daily, v. 47. and five thousand, Act. 4. 4. and beleevers more added, multitudes both of men and women, Act. 5. 14. and Jerusalem was filled with the doctrine of the Apostles, c. 5. 28. and yet the number of the Disciples multiplied, c. 6. 1. and the Word of God increased, and the number of the Disciples multiplied in Jerusalem greatly, and a great company of the Priests were obedient to the faith, they must (I say) prove (for affirmanti incumbit probatio) that all this number and all these thousands by the dispersion, Act. 8. 1. came to one thousand and to a handfull of a single Congregation.
3. I see no necessity that these (all) be the whole body of the Church, I grant Diod•tus saith so, and aBaronius conjectureth that there were fifteen thousand killed at this first persecution, bbut Dorotheus saith there were but two thousand killed, and (c) Salmeron saith of Dorotheus his relation, Quae si vera sunt, profecta magna fuit persecutio, if it be true, the persecution was indeed great, and we cannot but think, seeing the spirit of God saith 3this was a great persecution, but the Church was greatly diminished: but let us see if the Text will bear that so many thousands (for I judge at this time that the Church hath been above ten thousands) were partly killed, partly scattered, so that the Church of Jerusalem came to one single Congregation which might meet ordinarily for Word and Sacran•ents in ⟨p. 443⟩one private house, where the twelve Apostles came to them: for my part I cannot see it in the Text, only the persecution was great. 2. All were scattered except the Apostles. 3. Act. 26. Paul saith of himself at this time, 10. Many of the Saints did I shut up in prison, having received authority from the high Priests, and when they were put to death, I gave my voice against them. 11. And I punished them oft in every Synagogue, and compelled them to blaspheme, and being exceedingly mad against them, I persecuted them to strange Cities; all which saith many were imprisoned. 2. Some scattered, but the Text saith not that thousands were put to death, and it is not like that the holy Ghost who setteth down the other sort of persecution and the death of Steven, would have been silent of the killing of thousands. 3. Whereas it is said, they were all scattered except the Apostles, I see no ground of the Text to say that by ([Greek or Hebrew]) all scattered, he understandeth, all the Disciples as dLyranus saith, so saith
Amongst so many thousands of men and women, many for age, weakness and sickness, and having young 1children, and women with child were not able to flee, therefore ([Greek or Hebrew]) cannot be taken according to the letter every way. 3. Paul after this dispersion, Act. 26. 11. punished them in every Synagogue. What? punished he Jews? no Christians; Ergo, after the dispersion there were Christians left in Synagogues at Jerusalem which were not dispersed. 4. The Text saith that the scattered abroad were Preachers, and as I prove elsewhere here after, extraordinary Prophets, and therefore all were scattered except the Apostles, seemeth to imply that especially the whole teachers were scattered, except the Apostles; and gChrysostom, hAthanasius, iNissenus observes that God out of this persecution took occasion to spread the Gospel, by sending scattered Preachers to all the regions about, so kLorinus, lSanctius, mCornelius a Lapide, say they were not all scattered, and nCajetan expoundeth these (all) only of those upon ⟨p. 444⟩whom the holy Ghost descended. 4. Though this Church should come to one Congregation now, this is but by accident, and from extrinsical causes of persecution and scattering, but we have proved at the first founding of this Church Apostolic the Church of Jerusalem called one Church, the first draught and pattern of the visible Christian Church was such as could contain many Congregations, and could not all meet in one. 5. There is no ground to say that Apostles after this dispersion erected an ordinary Eldership in Jerusalem, whereas before there was an extraordinary, because the Apostles was present with them, and you read of no Elders while after the dispersion, because 1. you read not of the institution of ordinary Elders in the Church of Jerusalem after the dispersion, more then before, and so you are here upon conjectures. 2. There is no ground to say that the Apostles changed the government of the first pattern of the Christian Churches from extraordinary to ordinary. 3.
Nor is there ground that the government of the first sampler of Instituted Churches of the New Testament, should rather be extraordinary, then that first ordering of the Word and Sacraments should be extraordinary, seeing the Apostles the first founders of instituted Churches under the New Testament, had as ordinary matter to institute an ordinary presbytery and government, having believers in such abundance, upon whom, by the laying on of hands, they might give the Holy Ghost, as they had ordinary matter, to wit, a warrant, and command from Christ, to preach and administer the Sacraments. 4. The Apostles abode many years at Jerusalem, after there was an erected Eldership, Act. 15. 2. 22. Act. 16. 4. Act. 21. 18, 19, 20. Gal. 1. 18 After three years I went up to Jerusalem to see Peter, Gal. 2. 1. Then fourteen years after, I went up again to Jerusalem, &c. 9. And when James, Cephas, and John who seemed to be pillars, perceived the grace that was given unto me, they gave to me and Barnabas the right hands fellowship. 5. Though we should give, and not grant that this dispersion did bring the Church of Jerusalem to so low an ebb as to make it but one single Congregation, yet after the dispersion, all the Churches, Act. 9. 3. had peace, and were edified, and multiplied, and so the Church of Jerusalem also was multiplied, ⟨p. 445⟩if all France be multiplied, Paris which is a part of France must be multiplied, and if there were many thousands of the Jews that did believe, Act. 21. 20. though these many were for a great part come up to the feast at Pentecost, as some think, yet may we well think a huge number of these thousands were of the Church of Jerusalem: it is said, v. 21. They are informed of thee that thou teachest all the Jews which are amongst the Gentiles to forsake Moses, these belike were the Jews at Jerusalem who heard that Paul was come to Jerusalem, and
Our brethren object; 1. Though there be Elders at Jerusalem, Act. 15. 2. v. 4. and Act. 21. 18. yet that doth not prove an Eldership o• a formal presbytery, even a presbytery of a classical Church doth not prove that these Classical Elders are Elders of a Classical Church.
Our brethren object; 1. Though there bee Elders at Jerusalem, Act. 15. 2. v. 4. and Act. 21. 18. yet that doth not prove an Eldership o• a formall presbytery, even a presbytery of a classicall Church doth not prove that these Classicall Elders are Elders of a Classicall Church.
Answ. Our brethren should give to us the measure which they take to themselves, for they prove from that which the Scripture, Act. 20. 28. do name the Elders of the Church of Ephesus that there was an Eldership at Ephesus, which governed all the people of Ephesus; and from Bishops and Deacons at Philippi, Phil. 1. 1. that there was an Eldership in that Church; and from the Angel of the Church of Smyrna, Pergamus, Thyrtira, &c. that there was a college of Elders or a Presbytery in those Churches: for if those Churches had elders in them, though they were in their meaning Elders of a particular Congregation, and so an Eldership and a presbytery, they must give us the favour of the like consequence, in many of those Churches, they had Elders; Ergo, they had a presbyterial or classical Eldership, and the word [Greek or Hebrew] is as seldom in Scripture to our brethren to prove their Congregational Eldership, as it is to us to prove our Presbyterial or classical Eldership, and in this, jam sumns ergo pares; and one government, and combination voluntary under one Congregational presbytery shall be as hardly proven, as one government, and one voluntary combination of many Congregations, ⟨p. 446⟩and where the multitude is so numerous, as that they cannot meet in one, it is unpossible to prove that so many thousands did all agree, and that according to Christs institution, to meet ordinarily in one for doctrine and discipline, whereas the meeting in one of so many thousands is most inconvenient. 2. An Eldership doth prove there is a relation of those that make up the Eldership to all the Church distributively to which they have the relation of Elders, but doth not prove that the Eldership is an Eldership in a Church-relation to any one single person, and that that single person hath a reciprocal Church relation to that Eldership; so here the classical Eldership carrieth a relation to a classical Church, and a classical Church doth retort and reflect a reciprocal relation to the Eldership, but it doth not follow that every Congregation of the Classical Church doth reflect a reciprocal relation of a Church classical to either the classical Eldership, or to any one Elder of the classical presbytery.
Answ. Our brethren should give to us the measure which they take to themselves, for they prove from that which the Scripture,
2. They affirm, that there was no presbyterial government exercised by the Apostles in the Church of Jerusalem; for they say, for the substance of the Act (it is true) The Apostles did govern as Elders, that is, their Acts of government were not different from the Acts of government of ordinary Elders: but the Apostles did not govern under this formal reduplication as ordinary Elders, but as Apostles, because as Apostles they were Elders both in the Church of Jerusalem, and in all Churches of the world: but this proveth not an ordinary Eldership, Titus at Crete did but the ordinary Acts of an ordinary Elder at Crete in appointing Elders in every city, yet this proveth not that there is in the successors of Titus an ordinary Episcopal government, for because of the extent of the Apostles power to all Churches on earth, you may from this prove as well an Episcopal power as a presbyterial power in an Eldership over many Congregations; and before you prove a presbyterial power you must prove an extent and an ordinary extent of an Eldership over many Congregations, which you shall never prove from the extent of the Apostles power, which was universal and alike in all Churches.
2. They affirme, that there was no presbyteriall government exercised by the Apostles in the Church of Jerusalem; for they say, for the substance of the Act (it is true) The Apostles did governe as Elders, that is, their Acts of government were not different from the Acts of government of ordinary Elders: but the Apostles did not governe under this formall reduplication as ordinary Elders, but as Apostles, because as Apostles they were Elders both in the Church of Jerusalem, and in all Churches of the world: but this proveth not an ordinary Eldership, Titus at Crete did but the ordinary Acts of an ordinary Elder at Crete in appointing Elders in every citie, yet this proveth not that there is in the successors of Titus an ordinary Episcopall government, for because of the extent of the Apostles power to all Churches on earth, you may from this prove as well an Episcopall power as a presbyteriall power in an Eldership over many Congregations; and before you prove a presbyteriall power you must prove an extent and an ordinary extent of an Eldership over many Congregations, which you shall never prove from the extent of the Apostles power, which was universall and alike in all Churches.
That morall obligation of conscience which did obliege the Apostles as Pastors of the Christian world which was to bee converted, is not temporary but perpetuall and morall and did obliege the Apostles as Christians. Therefore this morall, obligation did lie upon the Apostles to feed the Catholick fiocke of the whole Christian world over which the holy Ghost had set them, just as the Elders of Ephesus, Act. 20. 28. are commanded to feed the whole flock of God which is at Ephesus: now I aske if every single Apostle is to make a reckoning to God for the soules of all the Christian world? 2. If Peter must bee answerable to God, because Paul by negligence should incurre the woe of not preaching the Gospell, 1 Cor. 9. 16? (3.) If upon this morall ground of an obligation lying on the Apostles to feed the Catholick flock of the whole world, amongst which they were, for the most part, by speciall commandement of Christ, to preach to all nations, Matth. 28. 19. to every creature, Mark. 16. v. 15. If (I say) the Apostles bee tied to plant Churches in such determinate quarters and fixed kingdomes ⟨p. 441⟩of the habitable world, and if the dividing of the world into twelve severall parts, and large parishes to the twelve Apostles, bee juris divini, of divine institution? I believe this can hardly bee proved by Gods Word. 2. Where there bee six Elders in a Congregation supposed to bee independent, every one of the six are oblieged in their place to feed the whole flocke, over which the holy Ghost hath set them, and that by the commandement of God, Act. 20. 28. 29. 1 Pet. 5. 1. as our brethren teach, but I hope by these places no humane logick would inferre, nor could our brethrèn collect, that, 1. every one of these six should, by divine institution, bee set over each of them the sixt determinate and sixt part of that Congregation. 2. That every one of the sixt were not to give a reckoning for the whole Congregation, and did not watch for the whole Congregation according to his Talent. 3. That one might not be accused, even one Archippus possibly at Colosse, Col. 4. 17▪ for his owne particular neglect to the whole flock, though others were also joyned with Archippus who fulfilled their part of their ministery, Col. 2. v. 5.
3. I see no necessitie that these (all) be the whole body of the Church, I grant Diod•tus saith so, and aBaronius conjectureth that there were fifteene thousand killed at this first persecution, bbut Dorotheus saith there were but two thousand killed, and (c) Salmeron saith of Dorotheus his relation, Quae si vera sunt, profecta magna fuit persecutio, if it bee true, the persecution was indeed great, and wee cannot but thinke, seeing the spirit of God saith 3this was a great persecution, but the Church was greatly diminished: but let us see if the Text will beare that so many thousands (for I judge at this time that the Church hath been above ten thousands) were partly killed, partly scattered, so that the Church of Jerusalem came to one single Congregation which might meet ordinarily for Word and Sacran•ents in ⟨p. 443⟩one private house, where the tewelve Apostles came to them: for my part I cannot see it in the Text, onely the persecution was great. 2. All were scattered except the Apostles. 3. Act. 26. Paul saith of himselfe at this time, 10. Many of the Saints did I shut up in prison, having received authoritie from the high Priests, and when they were put to death, I gave my voyce against them. 11. And I punished them oft in every Synagogue, and compelled them to blaspheme, and being exceedingly mad against them, I persecuted them to strange Cities; all which saith many were imprisoned. 2. Some scattered, but the Text saith not that thousands were put to death, and it is not like that the holy Ghost who setteth downe the other sort of persecution and the death of Steven, would have beene silent of the killing of thousands. 3. Whereas it is said, they were all scattered except the Apostles, I see no ground of the Text to say that by (〈non-Latin alphabet〉) all scattered, hee understandeth, all the Disciples as dLyranus saith, so saith eEusebius, though fSanctius saith hee meaneth of the 70. Disciples. And my reasons are, 1. The Text saith, v. 3. Saul entering into every house, •aling men and women committed them to prison, as you may read, Act. 26. 10, 11. Ergo, all and every one without exception of any, save the Apostles, were not scattered. 2.
Amongst so many thousands of men and women, many for age, weakenesse and sicknesse, and having young 1children, and women with child were not able to flee, therefore (〈non-Latin alphabet〉) cannot bee taken according to the letter every way. 3. Paul after this dispersion, Act. 26. 11. punished them in every Synagogne. What? punished hee Jewes? no Christians; Ergo, after the dispersion there were Christians left in Synagogues at Jerusalem which were not dispersed. 4. The Text saith that the scattered abroad were Preachers, and as I prove elsewhere here after, extraordinary Prophets, and therefore all were scattered except the Apostles, seemeth to imply that especially the whole teachers were scattered, except the Apostles; and gChrysostome, hAthanasius, iNissenus observes that God out of this persecution tooke occasion to spread the Gospell, by sending scattered Preachers to all the regions about, so kLorinus, lSanctius, mCornelius a Lapide, say they were not all sattered, and nCajetan exponeth these (all) onely of those upon ⟨p. 444⟩whom the holy Ghost descended. 4. Though this Church should come to one Congregation now, this is but by accident, and from extrinsecall causes of persecution and scattering, but wee have proved at the first founding of this Church Apostolick the Church of Jerusalem called one Church, the first draught and patterne of the visible Christian Church was such as could containe many Congregations, and could not all meet in one. 5. There is no ground to say that Apostles after this dispersion erected an ordinary Eldership in Jerusalem, whereas before there was an extraordinary, because the Apostles was present with them, and you read of no Elders while after the dispersion, because 1. you read not of the institution of ordinarie Elders in the Church of Jerusalem after the dispersion, more then before, and so you are here upon conjectures. 2. There is no ground to say that the Apostles changed the government of the first patterne of the Christian Churches from extraordinary to ordinary. 3.
Nor is there ground that the government of the first samplar of Instituted Churches of the New Testament, should rather bee extraordinarie, then that first ordering of the Word and Sacraments should bee extraordinary, seeing the Apostles the first founders of instituted Churches under the New Testament, had as ordinary matter to institute an ordinary presbytery and government, having beleevers in such abundance, upon whom, by the laying on of hands, they might give the Holy Ghost, as they had ordinary matter, to wit, a warrant, and command from Christ, to preach and administer the Sacraments. 4. The Apostles abode many yeares at Jerusalem, after there was an erected Eldership, Act. 15. 2. 22. Act. 16. 4. Act. 21. 18, 19, 20. Gal. 1. 18 After three yeares I went up to Jerusalem to see Peter, Gal. 2. 1. Then foureture yeeres after, I went up againe to Jerusalem, &c. 9. And when James, Cephas, and John who seemed to bee pillars, perceived the grace that was given unto mee, they gave to mee and Barnabas the right hands fellowship. 5. Though wee should give, and not grant that this dispersion did bring the Church of Jerusalem to so low an ebbe as to make it but one single Congregation, yet after the dispersion, all the Churches, Act. 9. 3. had peace, and were edified, and multiplyed, and so the Church of Jerusalem also was multiplied, ⟨p. 445⟩if all France be multiplied, Paris which is a part of France must bee multiplied, and if there were many thousands of the Jewes that did beleeve, Act. 21. 20. though these many were for a great part come up to the feast at Pentecost, as some thinke, yet may wee well thinke a huge number of these thousands were of the Church of Jerusalem: it is said, v. 21. They are informed of thee that thou teachest all the Jewes which are amongst the Gentiles to forsak Moses, these belike were the Jewes at Jerusalem who heard that Paul was come to Jerusalem, and Act. 12. 24. The Word of God grew and multiplied; it is the same phrase that is used, Act. 6. v. 7. to expresse the multiplying of the Church, by the multiplying of the Word, for there is no other multiplication of the Word but in the hearts of numbers who receive the Word in faith.