A57969:1361
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. We must distinguish betwixt ordination comparative and absolute: ordination comparative is in relation to the place, if the question be, upon what ground do the Apostles ordain in all the world; I answer because they are Apostles, and every where, Ergo, they may ordain every where; but as for absolute ordination, here in Jerusalem, if the question be why they did ordain Stephen, Philip, &c. tali modo, by convening the Church; I answer, because the Apostles were Elders. But our brethren say, Then the Apostles in this act laid down their infallible Apostolic spirit. I answer, they laid down the infallible spirit, which they had as Apostles, and took them to • fallible spirit, but they did not operate and govern in this Act, ⟨p. 451⟩from this infallible spirit, but from an ordinary spirit, else you must say, 1. when the Apostles did eat and drink, they laid down an infallible and Apostolic spirit, and took an ordinary and fallible spirit, for they did not eat and drink by immediate inspiration and as Apostles, but as men; 2. because they were Apostles where ever they came, it shall follow by this that they did all by this Apostolic spirit; as if the question be upon what ground, Did the Apostles every where baptize, pray pasi•a••y, exhort as Pastors, govern in Corinth, deliver the incestuous man to Satan at Corinth? If you answer, because they were Apostles, then I say because they were Apostles always, and in every place, they never used the ordinary power of the keys given to them, as common to them and all Pastors to the end of the world, Matth. 18. 18. Matth. 16. 19. John 20. 23. and so they could not do any thing as ordinary Pastors, or ordinary Elders. 2. Christ gave to the Apostles an ordinary power which they could never put forth in Acts 3. we have no warrant from the Apostles preaching, baptizing, exhorting, governing, retaining and remitting sins, excommunicating, rebuking, to preach, baptize, exhort, govern, retain and remit sins, excommunicate and rebuke, because the Apostles, in Acts Apostolic and extraordinary, are no more to be imitated by us, then we are to imitate them in speaking with divers tongues, and raising the dead.
Answ. Wee must distinguish betwixt ordination comparative and absolute: ordination comparative is in relation to the place, if the question bee, upon what ground doe the Apostles ordaine in all the world; I answer because they are Apostles, and every where, Ergo, they may ordaine every where; but as for absolute ordination, here in Jerusalem, if the question bewhy they did ordaine Stephen, Philip, &c. tali modo, by conveening the Church; I answer, because the Apostles were Elders. But our brethren say, Then the Apostles in this act laid downe their infallible Apostolick spirit. I answer, they laid downe the ininfallible spirit, which they had as Apostles, and tooke them to • fallible spirit, but they did not operate and governe in this Act, ⟨p. 451⟩from this infallible spirit, but from an ordinary spirit, else you must say, 1. when the Apostles did eate and drinke, they laid downe an infallible and Apostolick spirit, and tooke an ordinary and fallible spirit, for they did not eate and drinke by immediate inspiration and as Apostles, but as men; 2. because they were Apostles where ever they came, it shall follow by this that they did all by this Apostolick spirit; as if the question bee upon what ground, Did the Apostles every where baptize, pray pasi•a••y, exhort as Pastors, governe in Corinth, deliver the incestuous man to Satan at Corinth? If you answer, because they were Apostles, then I say because they were Apostles alwayes, and in every place, they never used the ordinary power of the keyes given to them, as common to them and all Pastors to the end of the world, Matth. 18. 18. Matth. 16. 19. John 20. 23. and so they could not doe any thing as ordinary Pastors, or ordinary Elders. 2. Christ gave to the Apostles an ordinary power which they could never put forth in Acts 3. we have no warrant from the Apostles preaching, baptizing, exhorting, governing, retaining and remitting sinnes, excommunicating, rebuking, to preach, baptize, exhort, governe, retaine and remit sinnes, excommunicate and rebuke, because the Apostles, in Acts Apostolick and extraordinary, are no more to bee imitated by us, then wee are to imitate them in speaking with divers tongues, and raising the dead.
Hence upon these grounds we are certainly induced to believe that the Apostles did here ordain, not as Apostles, but as ordinary Elders; 1. Because in these Acts the Apostles are imitable, but in what they do as Apostles they are not imitable.
Hence upon these grounds wee are certainly induced to beleeve that the Apostles did here ordaine, not as Apostles, but as ordinary Elders; 1. Because in these Acts the Apostles are imitable, but in what they doe as Apostles they are not imitable.
2. What ever rules of the Word doth regulate the ordinary classical presbytery, the Apostles go along in all these acts here condescending to these rules, such as the meeting of the presbytery, the twelve do meet. 2. They tacitly acknowledge a neglect of the daily ministration to the widows which is an act of misgovernment of the Deaconry, which is an ordinary office of the presbytery, and therefore they desire of the Church to be freed of this office. 3. They refer the nomination and election of the seven men to the people. 4. They ordain seven constant and perpetual officers, as the presbytery doth, Ergo, they do not ordain by their transcendent power, as Apostles.
2. What ever rules of the Word doth regulate the ordinary classicall presbytery, the Apostles goe along in all these acts here condescending to these rules, such as the meeting of the presbytery, the twelve do meet. 2. They tacitely acknowledge a neglect of the daily ministration to the widowes which is an act of misgovernment of the Deaconrie, which is an ordinary office of the presbytery, and therefore they desire of the Church to bee freed of this office. 3. They referre the nomination and election of the seven men to the people. 4. They ordaine seven constant and perpetuall officers, as the presbytery doth, Ergo, they doe not ordaine by their transcendent power, as Apostles.
3. From this place our brethren prove their Congregational ⟨p. 452⟩presbytery, which they would not do, if the Apostles did here manage affairs as extraordinary officers. 4. This colle•ium of Apostles do nothing in all this, which by confession of both sides may not be done, and to the end of the world is not done in the transacting of the like business, by the ordinary presbytery. 4. What the Apostles do as Apostles agreeth only to Apostles, and can be done by none but Apostles, or by Evangelists, having their power, by special warrantable commission from them, as what a man doth as a man, what a Pastor doth as a Pastor, a Deacon as a Deacon, a Prophet as a Prophet, can be done by none but by a man only, a Pastor only, a Deacon only, except whereas one Act, as to teach, agreeth both to a Pastor and a Doctor, which yet have their own differences, but all here done the Apostles might have done, if we suppose, they had not been Apostles. 5. If as Apostles they ordain, any one of the twelve Apostles should completely and entirely ordain all the seven, and so the seven Deacons should have been twelve times ordained at this time, which needles multiplication of Apostolic actions were useless, served not for edification, and is not grounded in the Word, for the whole twelve, in collegio, do ordain, and what any one Apostle doth as an Apostle by the amplitude of a transcendent power, every Apostle doth it completely, and wholly his alone, as without help of another Apostle, Peter worketh a miracle, especially any one Apostle as Paul his alone might ordain Timothy an Evangelist. 6. If they did here act as Apostles, any one Apostle might have ordained the Deacons in an ordinary way, as here; but that we cannot conceive, for then one and the same action should have been ordinary, and not ordinary, for one man cannot be a Church or a society to do the ordinary Acts of an ordinary society, for it should be extraordinary to one to act that which is the formal Act of many as many, and should involve a contradiction, except it were an Act which cannot be performed by many, as when one Pastor speaketh for many, for a whole Church;
3. From this place our brethren prove their Congregationall ⟨p. 452⟩presbytery, which they would not doe, if the Apostles did here manage aff•ires as extraordinary officers. 4. This colleium of Apostles doe nothing in all this, which by confession of both sides may not bee done, and to the end of the world is not done in the transacting of the like businesse, by the ordinary presbytery. 4. What the Apostles doe as Apostles agreeth onely to Apostles, and can be done by none but Apostles, or by Evangelists, having their power, by speciall warrantable commission from them, as what a man doth as a man, what a Pastor doth as a Pastor, a Deacon as a Deacon, a Prophet as a Prophet, can bee done by none but by a man onely, a Pastor onely, a Deacon onely, except whereas one Act, as to teach, agreeth both to a Pastor and a Doctor, which yet have their owne differences, but all here done the Apostles might have done, if wee suppose, they had not beene Apostles. 5. If as Apostles they ordaine, any one of the twelve Apostles should compleatly and entirely ordaine all the seven, and so the seven Deacons should have beene twelve times ordained at this time, which needles multiplication of Apostolick actions were uselesse, served not for edification, and is not grounded in the Word, for the whole twelve, in collegio, doe ordaine, and what any one Apostle doth as an Apostle by the amplitude of a transcendent power, every Apostle doth it compleatly, and wholly his alone, as without helpe of another Apostle, Peter worketh a miracle, especially any one Apostle as Paul his alone might ordaine Timothy an Evangelist. 6. If they did here act as Apostles, any one Apostle might have ordained the Deacons in an ordinary way, as here; but that wee cannot conceive, for then one and the same action should have beene ordinary, and not ordinary, for one man cannot bee a Church or a societie to doe the ordinary Acts of an ordinary societie, for it should bee extraordinary to one to act that which is the formall Act of many as many, and should involve a contradiction, except it were an Act which cannot bee performed by many, as when one Paster speaketh for many, for a whole Church;
but that is ordinary and necessary, because a multitude as a multitude cannot speak, without confusion in a continuated discourse, for that all the people say one word (Amen) is not a multitude as a multitude using one continuated speech.
but that is ordinary and necessary, because a multitude as a multitude cannot speake, without confusion in a continuated discourse, for that all the people say one word (Amen) is not a multitude as a multitude using one continuated speech.
Answ. The consequence is nought, if they had not done all things, which by virtue of their Apostolical Office they were commanded to do, they had not then fulfilled their commission given to them by Christ. That is true, but now the assumption is false, they were under no commandment of Christ to do all their Ministerial Acts as Apostles, prove that they did neither Preach, nor Baptize as Apostles; but only as Apostles they did preach infallibly. 2. In all places of the world, as Catholic Pastors. 3. With the gift of Tongues. 4. Working of Miracles, which by divine institution were annexed to their preaching, but their preaching according to the substance of the act was ordinary.
Answ. The consequence is nought, if they had not done all things, which by vertue of their Apostolicall Office they were commanded to doe, they had not then fulfilled their commission given to them by Christ. That is true, but now the assumption is false, they were under no commandement of Christ to doe all their Ministeriall Acts as Apostles, prove that they did neither Preach, nor Baptize as Apostles; but only as Apostles they did preach infallibly. 2. In all places of the world, as Catholick Pastors. 3. With the gift of Tongues. 4. Working of Miracles, which by divine institution were annexed to their preaching, but their preaching according to the substance of the act was ordinary.
Answ. The consequence is null, Paul went by revelation up to Jerusalem, and there Gal. 2. he rebuked Peter, as an Apostle? no, as a Brother, for then Paul should have exercised Apostolic Authority over Peter, which is popish.
Answ. The consequence is null, Paul went by revelation up to Jerusalem, and there Gal. 2. hee rebuked Peter, as an Apostle? no, as a Brother, for then Paul should have exercised Apostolick Authority over Peter, which is popish.
Answ. It followeth upon the denied principles of an independent Congregation only, for a Church without Elders hath no Presbyterial power, and therefore such a power can not be taken from it, you cannot take from a Church, that which by Law it hath not. If the Acts of the government in the Apostles, are according to the substance of the Acts all one with the Acts of government, in the ordinary presbytery; Ergo, say I, those Acts come not from an Apostolical and extraordinary power, even as the Apostles preaching and baptizing are not different in nature and essence, from the Acts of preaching and baptizing in ordinary Pastors, though they had power to preach and baptize every where, and we only where we have an ordinary calling of the Church, and from the Apostles preaching and baptizing every where, we ⟨p. 454⟩may infer, it is lawful for the ordinary Elders their successors to preach and baptize in some place, why may we not infer because the Apostles, in collegio, in one presbytery did ordain ordinary officers, that we have thence a pattern for an ordinary presbytery?
Answ. It followeth upon the denyed principles of an independent Congregation onely, for a Church without Elders hath no Presbyteriall power, and therefore such a power can not bee taken from it, you cannot take from a Church, that which by Law it hath not. If the Acts of the government in the Apostles, are according to the substance of the Acts all one with the Acts of government, in the ordinary presbytery; Ergo, say I, those Acts come not from an Apostolicall and extraordinary power, even as the Apostles preaching and baptizing are not different in nature and essence, from the Acts of preaching and baptizing in ordinary Pastors, though they had power to preach and baptize every where, and wee onely where wee have an ordinary calling of the Church, and from the Apostles preaching and baptizing every where, wee ⟨p. 454⟩may inferre, it is lawfull for the ordinary Elders their successors to preach and baptize in some place, why may we not inferre because the Apostles, in collegio, in one presbytery did ordaine ordinary officers, that we have thence a patterne for an ordinary presbytery?
Answ. Show us an institution for preaching and baptizing then, for that which we allege is an institution, Matth. 28. 19, 20. Mark. 14. v. 15. to you is a commandment given to the Apostles as Apostles, as you said, in the 1. objection proponed by you, and therefore we have no more warrant to preach and baptize from the Apostles example, then we have to work miracles, and because by the same reason of yours, Christs command to his Apostles to preach before his death, Matth. 10. is not ordinary presbyterial preaching, but conjoined also with the power of casting out devils, Matth. 10. 1, 2, 3. it must also upon the same ground be a Commandment given to the Apostles not as ordinary Pastors, but as Apostles, if we compare Matth. 10. 1, 2, 3. with Mark. 16. 15, 16, 17, 18. If you flee to John Baptist his practise of baptism, 1. you are farther off then you were; 2. What warrant more that John Baptist his practise should warrant preaching and baptizing, if it want an institution, then the Apostles preaching and baptizing when it is separated from an institution? 2. This argument pincheth you as much as us, for a thousand times in your books, a warrant for our ordinary Elders to preach and baptize is fetched from the sole practise of the Apostles. 3. By this the argument for the Christian Sabbath, from the Apostles observing that day, shall also fall. 4. This also shall make us loose in fundamentals of Church government which are grounded upon the Apostles practise. 5. The Apostles had no Apostolic and extraordinary ground which moved them to preach and baptize, according to the substance of the Acts, for they did preach and baptize upon these moral and perpetual motives and grounds which do oblige ordinary Elders to preach and baptize even to Christs second coming, Ergo, their very practise, not considered with the institution, is our pattern and rule.
Answ. Shew us an institution for preaching and baptizing then, for that which we alledge is an institution,
It is as evident that there was a Presbyterial Church at Jerusalem after the dispersion, seeing the dispersion, as we have proved did not retrench them to one Congregation, because our Brethren do conclude from a company of Elders of the Church of Ephesus, Acts 20. of Jerusalem, from the Angel of the Church of pergamus, of Thyatira a formal ordinary Presbytery of Ephesus, of Jerusalem, of Thyatira. Let us have the favour of the same argument, upon the supposal of many Congregations which the word doth warrant, and upon the supposal that it is called one Church always, as Acts 2. 47. The Lord added to the Church, Acts 5. 11. fear came upon all the Church, Acts 8. 1. there arose a great persecution against the Church, Acts 12. 1. Herod stretched forth his hand to vex certain of the Church, v. 5. prayer was made without ceasing of the Church unto God. Acts 15. 4. and when they were come to Jerusalem they were received of the Church, and of the Apostles and Elders, Acts. 21. 15. Paul went up to Jerusalem, and v. 18. The day following Paul went in with us, into James, and all the Elders were present. Here be Elders of the Church of Jerusalem, and Jerusalem is named one Church frequently, and always before and after the dispersion; it is called a Church in the singular number, not only in relation to persecutors, but also in relation to government, and because they were a political society to which there were many added Acts 2. 47. and which hath Elders Acts 15. 4. Acts 21. 15. 18. And a Church-union in a constituted body hearing the Word and receiving the Sacraments, as this Church did, Acts 2. 42
It is as evident that there was a Presbyteriall Church at Ierusalem after the dispersion, seeing the dispersion, as we have proved did not re•rench them to one Congregation, because our Brethren doe conclude from a company of Elders of the Church of Ephesus, Acts 20. of Ierusalem, from the Angell of the Church of pergamus, of Thyatira a formall ordinary Presbytery of Ephesus, of Ierusalem, of Thyatira. Let us have the favour of the same argument, upon the supposall of many Congregations which the word doth warrant, and upon the supposall that it is called one Church alwayes, as Acts 2. 47. The Lord added to the Church, Acts 5. 11. feare came upon all the Church, Acts 8. 1. there arose a great persecution against the Church, Acts 12. 1. Herod stretched forth his hand to vex certaine of the Church, v. 5. prayer was made without ceasing of the Church unto God. Acts 15. 4. and when they were come to Jerusalem they were received of the Church, and of the Apostles and Elders, Acts. 21. 15. Paul went up to Jerusalem, and v. 18. The day following Paul went in with us, into James, and all the Elders were present. Here be Elders of the Church of Ierusalem, and Ierusalem is named one Church frequently, and alwayes before and after the dispersion; it is called a Church in the singular number, not onely in relation to persecuters, but also in relation to government, and because they were a politicall society to which there were many added Acts 2. 47. and which hath Elders Acts 15. 4. Acts 21. 15. 18. And a Church-union in a constituted body hearing the Word and receiving the Sacraments, as this Church did, Acts 2. 42. is not a Church but in regard of Church-policy, and Church-government. They reply, That enemies doe persecute the Church, Acts 8. 1. Acts 12. 1. Acts 8. 3. Saul made havock of the Church, that is, of the faithfull of the Church, for Saul had no regard in his persecution, to a Church in their government, or Church-combination, therefore the enemies are said to persecute the Church materially.