A57969:1375
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. Acts 16. 4. they are called Apostles and Elders in, or at Jerusalem Acts 16. 4. for another cause, these were Elders from other Churches, from Antioch no less, then Elders of Jerusalem, they only sate in Synod at Jerusalem. 2. All Jerusalem was not converted to the Christian Faith, and therefore they may well be termed Elders at Jerusalem, as the Church at Ephesus, at, or in Thyatira. 3. I deny that the Scripture speaketh any other ways of the Elders of the Church of Jerusalem, then of the Elders of other Churches.
Answ. Acts 16. 4. they are called Apostles and Elders in, or at Ierusalem Acts 16. 4. for another cause, these were Elders from other Churches, from Antioch no lesse, then Elders of Ierusalem, they onely sate in Synod at Ierusalem. 2. All Ierusalem was not converted to the Christian Faith, and therefore they may well bee tearmed Elders at Ierusalem, as the Church at Ephesus, at, or in Thyatira. 3. I deny that the Scripture speaketh any other wayes of the Elders of the Church of Ierusalem, then of the Elders of other Churches.
2. Those Elders ought to meet for the governing of the Church of Jerusalem, for this was their duty; Ergo, they were one Presbytery. 2. They did meet Acts 15. 14. to receive Paul and Barnabas, and to hear what God had done by them for their edification; and Acts 21. Paul goeth to Jerusalem and is received v. 15. by the Brethren, but the next day, v. 18. The day following Paul went in with us unto James and all the Elders were present; and there the Elders do presbyterially act for the removing of a Church-scandal, v. 21. The believing Jews were informed that Paul taught all the Jews which were amongst the Gentiles to forsake Moses. This was a public scandal. 2. The offended multitude were to convene, v. 22. as plaintiffs. 3. The Eldership ordaineth Paul to remove the ⟨p. 453⟩scandal by satisfying the offended, by purifying himself after the manner of the Jews, and it is clear Paul should not have satisfied the scandalized Jews, except James and the Elders had enjoined him so to do. 4. This the very course of a presbytery, yea, our Brethren's doctrine, which a Congregational presbytery would, and doth take with any other person who doth give offence, yea though it be taken and not given, if the way of remedy be lawful and expedient, as this presbytery conceived Pauls purifying of himself to be, and if any scandalizing person should be disobedient to the voice of a Congregational eldership, such as our Brethren believe the Eldership of Jerusalem to be; they would say they are to censure him, and therefore if Paul should have been disobedient to this, he should have incurred a censure; It is true Lorinus saith that Chrysostom and Oecumenius will have this to be a Counsel, not a Synod, to command Paul, and they 1deny any Juridical power here, but v. 18. [Greek or Hebrew], to me it is, They were gathered together: Diodatus calleth them The college of the governors of the Church, Bede 2saith there were four Synods and he maketh the Synod Acts 1. at the choosing of Matthias the first, the second at the choosing of Deacons Acts 6. the third Acts 15. and this the fourth, Acts 21. 2
so the Eldership here taketh course that the infirm Jews be not scandalized, as is clear, v. 25. As touching the Gentiles which believe, we have written, &c. and to me they seem to do both Synodically, some think that this fact of the Elders and Paul was not lawful: but how ever, though it was not a general council, a presbytery I take it to be taking course to remove a scandal from the weak Jews in this place, as they had by a Synodical power removed it from the Gentiles, Act. 15.1
so the Eldership here taketh course that the infirme Iewes be not scandalized, as is cleare, v. 25. As touching the Gentiles which believe, we have written, &c. and to me they seeme to do both Synodically, some thinke that this fact of the Elders and Paul was not lawfull: but how ever, though it was not a generall councell, a presbytery I take it to be taking course to remove a scandall from the weake Iewes in this place, as they had by a Synodicall power removed it from the Gentiles, Act. 15.1
It is objected by Master Mather, that if a Church in an Island by Divine institution, and so this first founded congregation at Jerusalem which did meet in Solomons porch, had once an entire power of Jurisdiction within it self, though in an extraordinary ⟨p. 454⟩case. 1. The case is ordinary, as in the Dominion of Wales, there is scarce a congregation to be found within twenty or thirty miles. 2. Suppose the case were extraordinary and rare, may they violate the ordinary rules of Christ? for so some may think and say, that though according to ordinary Rules, Baptisms and the Lords Supper must be dispensed only by men and by Ministers, yet in the want of these, the one may be dispensed by a Woman, or Mid-wife, and both of them by such as are no Ministers.
It is objected by Master Mather, that if a Church in an Island by Divine institution, and so this first founded congregation at Jerusalem which did meete in Salomons porch, had once an entire power of Iurisdiction within it selfe, though in an extraordinary ⟨p. 454⟩case. 1. The case is ordinary, as in the Dominion of Wales, there is scarce a congregation to be found within twenty or thirty miles. 2. Suppose the case were extraordinary and rare, may they violate the ordinary rules of Christ? for so some may thinke and say, that though according to ordinary Rules, Baptisms and the Lords Supper must be dispensed only by men and by Ministers, yet in the want of these, the one may be dispensed by a Woman, or Mid-wife, and both of them by such as are no Ministers.
Answ. We think a Ministry and Discipline more necessary to a Congregation in a remote Island, or to the Church of Jerusalem before they increase to such a number as cannot meet for their numerous multitude in one Congregation, then the Sacraments, when there be no Ministers to dispense them. 1. That the Church be so in the Island its alone, may possibly be extraordinary, but that in such a case they have the Word preached and entire power of Discipline whole and entire within themselves to excommunicate scandalous persons is not extraordinary, when there be no consociated Churches, whom excommunication concerneth, that are in danger to be scandalized, for it floweth connaturally from a Church to which agreeth the essence of a Church, to exercise Jurisdiction over all its own members, if there be no more consociated with that Church, that is by accident and an extraordinary exigence of Gods providence. As a master of a Family is to do his duty to educate his children in the fear of God; but if God take all his children from him by death, he doth not transgress the ordinary rule of educating his children in the fear of God, when he hath none. This argument supposeth that a Congregation hath no power of excommunication at all either complete or incomplete, as the Mid-wife hath no power to Baptize at all either complete or incomplete: neither doth a Congregation transgress any rule of Christ at all when it exerciseth entire power of censures within it self, whereas there be no consociated Churches to share with it in that power. A Congregation is capable of entire Jurisdiction, because it is a Church; But a woman in no case is capable of administrating Baptism, or the Lords Supper, except she were extraordinarily ⟨p. 455⟩and immediately inspired to be a prophetess, but for the exercise of entire power of Jurisdiction by a Congregation in a remote Island, I hope, it hath no such need of immediate inspiration. 2. There is no such moral necessity of the Sacraments, as there is of the Ministry of the word and consequently of some use of the Keys, where a scandalous person may infect the Lords flock.
Answ. We thinke a Ministery and Discipline more necessary to a Congregation in a remote Island, or to the Church of Ierusalem before they increase to such a number as cannot meet for their numerous multitude in one Congregation, then the Sacraments, when there be no Ministers to dispense them. 1. That the Church be so in the Island its alone, may possibly be extraordinary, but that in such a case they have the Word preached and entire power of Discipline whole and entire within themselves to excommunicate scandalous persons is not extraordinay, when there be no consociated Churches, whom excommunication concerneth, that are in danger to be scandalized, for it floweth connaturally from a Church to which agreeth the essence of a Church, to exercise Jurisdiction over all its owne members, if there be no more consociated with that Church, that is by accident and an extraordinary exigence of Gods providence. As a master of a Family is to do his duty to educate his children in the feare of God; but if God take all his children from him by death, he doth not transgresse the ordinary rule of educating his children in the feare of God, when hee hath none. This argument supposeth that a Congregation hath no power of excommunication at all either compleat or incompleat, as the Mid-wife hath no power to Baptize at all either compleat or incompleat: neither doth a Congregation transgresse any rule of Christ at all when it exerciseth entire power of censures within it selfe, whereas there be no consociated Churches to share with it in that power. A Congregation is capable of entire Jurisdiction, because it is a Church; But a woman in no case is capable of administrating Baptisme, or the Lords Supper, except shee were extraordinarily
For where vision ceaseth the people perish, but it is never said, where Baptism ceaseth the people perish, and therefore uncalled Ministers in case of necessity, without ordination or calling from a presbytery may preach, and take on them the holy Ministry and exercise power of Jurisdiction, because the necessity of the Souls of a Congregation, in a remote Island requireth so, but I hope no necessity in any the most extraordinary case requireth that a Midwife may Baptize, or that a private man remaining a private man may celebrate the Lords Supper to the Church without any calling from the Church.
For where vision ceaseth the people perish, but it is never said, where Baptisme ceaseth the people perish, and therefore uncalled Ministers in case of necessity, without ordination or calling from a presbytery may preach, and take on them the holy Ministery and exercise power of Jurisdiction, because the necessity of the Soules of a Congregation, in a remote Island requireth so, but I hope no necessity in any the most extraordinary case requireth that a Midwife may Baptize, or that a private man remaining a private man may celebrate the Lords Supper to the Church without any calling from the Church.
But Mr. Mather, if the power of Jurisdiction flow immediately and 1necessarily from the essence of a Church, and a congregation be essentially a Church, then this power agreeth to all Churches, whether consociated, or not consociated, and without respect of what neighbours they have, whether many, or few, whether any, or none. 2. A congregation its alone cannot have sole power of jurisdiction, and then be deprived of it, when God sendeth neighbour Churches; for then neighbouring Churches which are given for help, should be given for loss, the contrary whereof Ames 2saith. Nor do Synods (saith he) constitute a new form of a Church.
But Mr. Mather, if the power of Iurisdiction flow immediately and 1necessarily from the essence of a Church, and a congregation be essentially a Church, then this power agreeth to all Churches, whether consociated, or not consociated, and without respect of what neighbours they have, whether many, or few, whether any, or none. 2. A congregation its alone cannot have sole power of jurisdiction, and then be deprived of it, when God sendeth neighbour Churches; for then neighbouring Churches which are given for helpe, should be given for losse, the contrary whereof Ames 2saith. Nor doe Synods (saith he) constitute a new forme of a Church.
Answ. Power of Jurisdiction floweth from the essence of a congregation in an Island; Ergo, a total and complete power of jurisdiction, floweth from the essence of a Church or congregation consociated; it followeth no ways, so a pastor of a Congregation hath as a pastor power to rebuke sin, and to administrate the Sacraments, Ergo, when three pastors are added to help him, he hath the sole power of rebuking sin, and the sole and entire power to administrate the Sacraments, and none of these three pastors hath power with him, it followeth not; and because these three pastors are added to help him and ⟨p. 456⟩their pastoral power added to him is cumulative and auxiliary, but not privative or destructive of his pastoral power, therefore the first pastor suffereth loss by the addition of these three to him: who will say this? our Brethren do conceive the power of Congregations, in its kind and essence, to be Monarchical, so as if any power from consociated Congregations be added thereunto, the Congregations power Monarchical is d minished; and the essence of it changed. 2. Complete and entire power to rule both the Congregation and the Members of consociated Churches in so far as they do keep communion with that Congregation, and may either edify, or scandalize them, floweth not immediately and necessarily from the essence of every Congregation even in remote Islands not consociated with others, that we never said. 3. A power to govern well, and according to the rule of the word added to another power to govern well and according to the word, is an auxiliary power and no way destructive of that power, to which it is added, indeed a power to govern well, added to a power of male administration in a Congregation is destructive of that power, and reason it should be so, because Christ never gave any such power of male administration to a Congregation; but a power of right governing, added to a power of right governing is neither destructive thereof, nor doth it constitute a new form of a Church, or a Church-power, but only enlarge the preexistent form to extend it self farther, for the edification of more souls.
Answ. Power of Iurisdiction floweth from the essence of a congregation in an Iland; Ergo, a totall and compleat power of jurisdiction, floweth from the essence of a Church or congregation consociated; it followeth no wayes, so a pastor of a Congregation hath as a pastor power to rebuke sinne, and to administrate the Sacraments, Ergo, when three pastors are added to help him, he hath the sole power of rebuking sinne, and the sole and entire power to administrate the Sacraments, and none of these three pastors hath power with him, it followeth not; and because these three pastors are added to help him and
But (saith Mr. Mather) if it be against the light of nature that the adverse party be the sole judge which must be, if the s•le 1power of Jurisdiction be in the Congregation (as we grant in an extraordinary case, when a Congregation is in an Island its alone) and so it shall be lawful for a single Congregation to do that which is against all equity and the very light of nature, it must then follow that it is not against the light of nature that a Congregation (though consociated with other Congregations) have entire jurisdiction within it self.
But (saith Mr. Mather) if it be against the light of nature that the adverse party be the sole judge which must be, if the s•le 1power of Iurisdiction be in the Congregation (as we grant in an extraordinary case, when a Congregation is in an Island its alone) and so it shall be lawfull for a single Congregation to doe that which is against all equity and the very light of nature, it must then follow that it is not against the light of nature that a Congregation (though consociated with other Congregations) have entire jurisdiction within it selfe.
Answ. None of us do teach that it is against the light of nature that the adverse party be the judge, it might fall out in a general council lawfully convened, from which there is no provocation, ⟨p. 457⟩yea and in a national council, (for all councils may err) the adverse party may judge, as it was a lawful council according to a Church-constitution that condemned Christ of blasphemy, and they were also his enemies; but we teach that it is not congruous to the wisdom of Christ, nor to the light of nature, that Christ should have appointed all the ordinary Church courts, so many thousand congregations, who may rather err then extraordinary and higher Synods, to be the only ordinary judges in their own cause; Nor doth any thing more follow from this argument, that when there is one congregation its alone in an Island destitute of the help of consociated Churches (which is a defect of an extraordinary providence of Christ in that one singular exigence) that that congregation shall be both judge and party in its own cause, if we suppose that one Micaiah shall contend for the truth, and all the rest of the Prophets and people of that congregation to be against the truth, and to judge and condemn one man, who seeketh the Lord in truth.
Answ. None of us do teach that it is against the light of nature that the adverse party be the judge, it might fall out in a generall councell lawfully convened, from which there is no provocation, ⟨p. 457⟩yea and in a nationall councell, (for all councels may erre) the adverse party may judge, as it was a lawfull councell according to a Church-constitution that condemned Christ of blisphemy, and they were also his enemies; but we teach that it is not congruous to the wisdome of Christ, nor to the light of nature, that Christ should have appointed all the ordinary Churchcourts, so many thousand congregations, who may rather erre then extraordinary and higher Synods, to be the onely ordinary judges in their owne cause; Nor doth any thing more follow from this argument, that when there is one congregation its alone in an Iland destitute of the helpe of consociated Churches (which is a defect of an extraordinary providence of Christ in that one singular exigence) that that congregation shall be both judge and party in its owne cause, if we suppose that one Micaiah shall contend for the truth, and all the rest of the Prophets and people of that congregation to be against the truth, and to judge and condemne one man, who seeketh the Lord in truth.
It is a wonder to me that Thessalonica was but one single congregation, all hearing one Word, partakers of one Lords Supper at one Table; yet the Apostle ascribeth to them that which is a note to worthy Baynes of the numerous multitude of the Church of Jerusalem, from whence went the Word of God to all 1the world, 1 Thes. 1. 8. For from you sounded out the Word of the Lord, not only in Macedonia and Achaia, but also in every place your faith to God-ward is spread abroad. I deny not what Mr. Mather and Thomson say, but 5000 may meet to hear the word, and many thousands were gathered together Luke 12. to hear Christ; but these reverend brethren do leave out, 1. The inconvenience of thronging so all at once; for, they trod one upon another. 2. Christ preached not to all those thousand at once, for it is expressly said, v. 1. He began to say to his Disciples. So Christ refusing to preach to such a disorderly confluence of people, who could not hear, and his doctrine being all for his Disciples, the very Sermon being preached to his Disciples only, Matth. 10. 2, 3, 4, &c. and the Parable of the rich man v. 22. he applieth to his Disciples, Then he said to his Disciples, therefore I say unto you, take no thought for your life, &c. It evidenceth to ⟨p. 458⟩me that Christ condemneth a numerous multitude in one congregation to hear at once. And whereas Chrysostom saith, 5000 persons did hear his voice, at once, in one congregation, by means of Scaffolds and Galleries; and Mr. Mather is willing to yield eight thousand an hundred and twenty were all assembled in one place to 2hear the Word, and that all the multitude of converts at Jerusalem were together in Solomons porch, Act. 5. 12. I grant three thousand could hear one at once; but alas, this is a great uncertainty for independent congregations. But 1. this is to be proved that eight thousand (Mr. Mather hath not added many other multitudes mentioned,
14. 23. for my part I think such a miraculous Church cannot be the first mould of independent Churches to be established congregations meeting in one place, for to be edified by word, seals and censures. Yea Mr. Mather will have the whole convening as one independent congregation Act. 6. 2, 3, 4. and the many myriads or thousands of believing Jews, Act. 21. 21, 22, 23. to meet as one congregation. Certainly the Apostles practice must be our rule, and then five hundred or a thousand being so far beneath ten or eight thousand, may well seem a number for fewness not competent; and what shall we then think of seven only, or ten? Now let it be considered, if Rome being granted to be one Church, and in which to me there was a congregation and Church in the very family of Aquila and Priscilla, Rom. 16. v. 5. and whose faith was spread through all the world, Rom. 1. 8. so as famous writers say the half of the City believed, if they be but one single congregation meeting all in one place? hard to me it is clear, there was a single congregation in the very house of Aquila and Priscilla, Act. 18. 1, 2, 3 4. v. 26 27, 28. and that Paul preached when he was there daily, beside his disputing in the Synagogue; when he was at Rome there was a Church ⟨p. 459⟩at his house, Rom. 16. 5. So Diodati saith on the place, That the Church at Aquila his house was the assembly of believers, who assembled themselves in their house; for there were divers small assemblies in one and the self same City, 1 Cor. 16. 19. Col. 4. 15. Greet the Church that is at their house. Col. 1. 15. Salute Nymphus, and the Church at his house. Where Paul speaketh of believers only in a house, he giveth them not the name of a Church, as Ro. 16. 10. Salute them that are of Aristobulus household. V. 11. Greet them that are of the household of Narcissus.
2. Those Elders ought to meete for the governing of the Church of Jerusalem, for this was their duty; Ergo, they were one Presbytery. 2. They did meet Acts 15. 14. to receive Paul and Barnabas, and to heare what God had done by them for their edification; and Acts 21. Paul goeth to Ierusalem and is received v. 15. by the Brethren, but the next day, v. 18. The day following Paul went in with us unto James and all the Elders were present; and there the Elders doe presbyterially act for the removing of a Church-scandall, v. 21. The believing Jewes were informed that Paul taught all the Iewes which were amongst the Gentiles to forsake Moses. This was a publick scandall. 2. The offended multitude were to convene, v. 22. as plaintiffs. 3. The Eldership ordaineth Paul to remove the ⟨p. 453⟩scandall by satisfying the offended, by purifying himselfe after the manner of the Jewes, and it is cleare Paul should not have satisfyed the scandalized Iewes, except Iames and the Elders had injoyned him so to doe. 4. This the very course of a presbytery, yea, our Brethrens doctrine, which a Congregationall presbytery would, and doth take with any other person who doth give offence, yea though it be taken and not given, if the way of remedy be lawfull and expedient, as this presbytery conceived Pauls purifying of himselfe to be, and if any scandalizing person should be disobedient to the voyce of a Congregationall eldership, such as our Brethren believe the Eldership of Jerusalem to be; they would say they are to censure him, and therefore if Paul should have beene disobedient to this, he should have incurred a censure; It is true Lorinus saith that Chrysostome and Oecumenius will have this to be a Counsell, not a Synod, to command Paul, and they 1deny any Juridicall power here, but v. 18. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, to mee it is, They were gathered together: Diodatus calleth them The colledge of the governours of the Church, Beda 2saith there were foure Synods and hee maketh the Synod Acts 1. at the chusing of Matthias the first, the second at the chusing of Deacons Acts 6. the third Acts 15. and this the fourth, Acts 21. 2. The Text seemeth to mee to say it, for as Acts 15. there was course taken for the Gentiles that they should abstaine from blood, lest they should either scandalize, or bee scandalized;
It is a wonder to me that Thessalonica was but one single congregation, all hearing one Word, partakers of one Lords Supper at one Table; yet the Apostle ascribeth to them that which is a note to worthy Baynes of the numerous multitude of the Church of Ierusalem, from whence went the Word of God to all 1the world, 1 Thes. 1. 8. For from you sounded out the Word of the Lord, not onely in Macedonia and Achaia, but also in every place your faith to God-ward is spread abroad. I deny not what Mr. Mather and Thomson say, but 5000 may meet to heare the word, and many thousands were gathered together Luke 12. to heare Christ; but these reverend brethren doe leave out, 1. The inconvenience of thronging so all at once; for, they trode one upon another. 2. Christ preached not to all those thousand at once, for it is expresly said, v. 1. He began to say to his Disciples. So Christ refusing to preach to such a disorderly confluence of people, who could not heare, and his doctrine being all for his Disciples, the very Sermon being preached to his Disciples onely, Matth. 10. 2, 3, 4, &c. and the Parable of the rich man v. 22. he applieth to his Disciples, Then he said to his Disciples, therefore I say unto you, take no thought for your life, &c. It evidenceth to ⟨p. 458⟩me that Christ condemneth a numerous multitude in one congregation to heare at once. And whereas Chrysostome saith, 5000 persons did heare his voyce, at once, in one congregation, by meanes of Scaffolds and Galleries; and Mr. Mather is willing to yeeld eight thousand an hundred and twenty were all assembled in one place to 2heare the Word, and that all the multitude of converts at Ierusalem were together in Salomons porch, Act. 5. 12. I grant three thousand could heare one at once; but alas, this is a great uncertainty for independent congregations. But 1. this is to be proved that eight thousand (Mr. Mather hath not added many other multitudes mentioned, Act. 5. 14. Act. 6. 1. v. 7. and elsewhere) did meet daily in the Temple. 2. Daily and ordinarily from house to house. 3. To celebrate the Lords Supper daily in the Temple and in every private house (there were need of many Scaffolds and Galleries) to sit at one Table. 4. To make one judicature, and have more then power of consenting in Church. censures, as our brethren prove the whole Church of beleevers had, from Matth. 18. 17. 1 Cor. 5. 4. Act. 15. 22. 1 Cor.
14. 23. for my part I thinke such a miraculous Church cannot be the first mould of independent Churches to be established congregations meeting in one place, for to be edified by word, seales and censures. Yea Mr. Mather will have the whole convening as one independent congregation Act. 6. 2, 3, 4. and the many myriades or thousands of beleeving Jewes, Act. 21. 21, 22, 23. to meet as one congregation. Certainly the Apostles practice must be our rule, and then five hundred or a thousand being so farre beneath ten or eight thousand, may wel seem a number for fewnesse not competent; and what shall we then thinke of seven onely, or ten? Now let it be considered, if Rome being granted to be one Church, and in which to me there was a congregation and Church in the very family of Aquila and Priscilla, Rom. 16. v. 5. and whose faith was spread through all the world, Rom. 1. 8. so as famous writers say the halfe of the City beleeved, if they be but one single congregation meeting all in one place? ard to me it is cleare, there was a single congregation in the very house of Aquila and Priscilla, Act. 18. 1, 2, 3 4. v. 26 27, 28. and that Paul preached when he was there daily, beside his disputing in the Synagogue; when he was at Rome there was a Church ⟨p. 459⟩at his house, Rom. 16. 5. So Diodati saith on the place, That the Church at Aquila his house was the assembly of beleevers, who assembled themselves in their house; for there were divers small assemblies in one and the selfe same City, 1 Cor. 16. 19. Col. 4. 15. Greet the Church that is at their house. Col. 1. 15. Salute Nymphus, and the Church at his house. Where Paul speaketh of believers only in a house, he giveth them not the name of a Church, as Ro. 16. 10. Salute them that are of Aristobulus houshold. V. 11. Greet them that are of the houshold of Narcissus. Phil. 4. 22. All the Saints salute you, especially those that are of Caesars house. I desire to know a reason of the difference of this Grammar, if there were no constituted Church in the house of Aquila and Priscilla, why in one Chapter the Apostle should change the phrase? and I desire know what reason we have to goe from the literall meaning of the word, that is, a Church at Aquila his house, as well as a Church at C•rinth. For whereas some say that Rom. 1. 6. he saluteth not all of the house of Narcissus, but onely v. 11. those which are is the Lord; 1.