A57969:1526
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the…
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Other arguments that I find in Papers from New England are these: First, There is not a Church (say they) under the New Testament, but a Congregational Church, so it will follow, that as City privileges belong only to the Citizens and their children, so baptism and the Lords Supper, being Church privileges, belong only to the Members of particular Churches, and their seed; and that seeing sigillum sequitur donum, to apply them to any other, is to abuse them. As the scale of an Incorporation is abused, when it is added to confirm a gift to one who is not a Free man of that Incorporation, he being incapable thereof.
Other arguments that I find in Papers from New England are these: First, There is not a Church (say they) under the New Testament, but a Congregationall Church, so it will follow, that as City priviledges belong onely to the Citizens and their children, so baptisme and the Lords Supper, being Church priviledges, belong onely to the Members of particular Churches, and their seed; and that seeing sigillum sequitur donum, to apply them to any other, is to abuse them. As the scale of an Incorporation is abused, when it is added to confirme a gift to one who is not a Free man of that Incorporation, he being incapable thereof.
Answ. First, The case is not here, as in earthly Cities, a man who is a free Citizen in one borough is not for that a free Citizen of all the Burroughs and Cities on earth; nor is he who is civilly excommunicated and cast out of his City privileges in one City, cast out of his City privileges in all other Cities, whereof he is a free member: and the reason is, there is not one common owner, and Lord of all the Cities on earth, who can give, or take away, in a Law-way, City privileges; but the case is far otherwayes in the privileges of visible Churches, for he who is a member of one visible Congregation, is by his baptism, and sincere profession, and his professed standing in Covenant with God, a Member of all visible Congregations on ⟨p. 195⟩earth, as he is baptized in all Congregations on earth; and if he be excommunicated out of a single Congregation, he is excommunicated out of all, and loseth right to the Scale of the Lords Supper, in all visible Congregations, as his sins are bound in heaven to all also, for that one common head and Saviour, who giveth him right to the Seals of Christs body and blood in one, giveth him right to these Seals in all. For we worthily communicate with Christ in his body and blood, […] his body was broken, and his blood shed for one single visible Congregation, but as broken and shed for the whole […] universal. But this form of reasoning utterly abolisheth all Communion of Churches, nor can a member of one Noble Church be capable of the Seals of grace in another visible Church, because he is not a Member of that visible Church, no more then one is capable of the Privileges of Paris, who is only a Citizen of London, and not a Citizen of Paris. If it be said, one who is a member of a visible Church, may receive the Seals in another Congregation, if he be recommended by Letters, as a sound Professor, to that other Congregation. I Answer, Recommendatory Letters can never give a Church-right to the Church-Privileges of the Seals of the Covenant, they do but only notify, manifest, and declare the Church-right, which the man had before.