Answ. 1. The Church is indeed the Church mystical and the invisible body of Christ before baptism, but this proveth not but baptism is a seal of our entry in the visible Church, for if this be a good argument, your Church-covenant, which to you is an ordinance of God, falleth to the ground; for persons are the true Churches of Christ before all the ordinances of Christ; Ergo, by your Church-covenant men do not become Christs visible Church. 2. The argument hath no feet, for the ordinance of preaching the Word is a privilege of the Church and ordinance of God, yet is not the Church before the preaching of the Word; for birth is not before the seed, but the seed before the birth; the preaching of the Word is the seed of the Church, 1 Pet. 1. 23. and a mean of gathering the Church, Rom. 10. 14. and it is also a privilege of the Church, for he dealeth not so with every nation to send his Gospel to them, Psal. 147. 19, 20. 3. When you say that a Seal doth not make a thing that ⟨p. 217⟩was not, but confirm a thing that was; while you would seem to refute Papists, who vainly teach that Sacraments do confe•re grace ex opere op•rato, by the deed done; yet do you make the Sacrament but a naked sign, and take part with Arminians and Socinians, whose very arguments in express words you use; for aSocinius goeth before you in this argument, and so doth bSmalcius follow him. […] and sealing there is required the trying of the thing, and some •••hing or document; but that ceremony (a baptism) and that rite, though it be ••ly, doth nothing to the remission of sins, but it doth only shadow out, and as it […] deline•ue and point forth remission of sins by the washing of water •xp•ned in the Word of God. You say, Sacraments […] make a thing that was not, but confirm a thing that was before; you can have no other meaning then to deny all causality and all real exhibition of grace in the Sacraments: for if a Sacrament make not a thing that was not before, or if God give n•t, and really produce, confer and exhibit grace, and a stronger measure of faith, and assurance of remission of sins, at the due and right use of the Sacrament, the Sacrament is a naked sign, and not an exhibitive Seal.
Answ. 1. The Church is indeed the Church mysticall and the invisible body of Christ before baptisme, but this proveth not but baptisme is a seale of our entry in the visible Church, for if this be a good argument, your Church-covenant, which to you is an ordinance of God, falleth to the grrund; for persons are the true Churches of Christ before all the ordinances of Christ; Ergo, by your Church-covenant men doe not become Christs visible Church. 2. The argument hath no feet, for the ordinance of preaching the Word is a priviledge of the Church and ordinance of God, yet is not the Church before the preaching of the Word; for birth is not before the seed, but the seed before the birth; the preaching of the Word is the seed of the Church, 1 Pet. 1. 23. and a meane of gathering the Church, Rom. 10. 14. and it is also a priviledge of the Church, for hee dealeth not so with every nation to send his Gospell to them, Psal. 147. 19, 20. 3. When you say that a Seale doth not make a thing that ⟨p. 217⟩was not, but confirme a thing that was; while you would seeme to refute Papists, who vainely teach that Sacraments doe confe•re grace ex opere op•rato, by the deed done; yet doe you make the Sacrament but a naked signe, and take part with Arminians and Socinians, whose very arguments in expresse words you use; for aSocinius goeth before you in this argument, and so doth bSmalcius follow him. 〈…〉 and sealing there is required the trying of the thing, and some •••hing or document; but that ceremony (a baptisime) and that rite, though it bee ••ly, doth nothing to the remission of sins, but it doth onely shadow out, and as it 〈…〉 deline•ue and point forth remission of sinnes by the washing of water •xp•ned in the Word of God. You say, Sacraments 〈…〉 make a thing that was not, but confirme a thing that was before; you can have no other meaning then to deny all cansalitie and all reall exhibition of grace in the Sacraments: for if a Sacrament make not a thing that was not before, or if God give nt, and really produce, conferre and exhibite grace, and a stronger measure of faith, and assurance of remission of sinnes, at the due and right use of the Sacrament, the Sacrament is a naked signe, and not an exhibitive Seale.
- aSocinus, Per baptismum non confirmatur •ides (uti dicunt Evangelia) cum per baptismum non quidem obsignetur, sed tantum adu•nbre•ur peccato•um •emissio• ad obsignationem e••n requi••tur rei pr•batis & d•cumentum aliqu•d, •ujusm• li nihil praestat ceremonia, & r••us iste. quantumvis sacer, quod ad pe••ato•um […] a••tnet, sed tantum ill•m ve••is i•n exp sita ablution sua adu•nbrat & quodam••d• del••a•.Socinus, Per baptismum non confirmatur •ides (uti dicunt Evangelia) cum per baptismum non quidem obsignetur, sed tantum adu•nbre•ur peccato•um •emissio• ad obsignationem e••n requi••tur rei pr•batis & d•cumentum aliqu•d, •ujusm• li nihil praestat ceremonia, & rus iste. quantumvis sacer, quod ad peatoum atnet, sed tantum illm veis in exp sita ablutione sua adunbrat & quodamd dela.