A57969:1587
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the…
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. 1. Anabaptists deny that any ought to be baptized while thy come to age, and while they believe and be regenerated: and they say not far from your selves in this, who teach it to be absurd, to put a blank seal upon a falsehood, and so you presuppone all to be regenerated, and truly within the Covenant before they can be sealed to be within the Covenant by baptism; and yet you do not think all Infants of believing parents to be regenerated and truly within the Covenant, then is the seal blank. Also you say, baptism is not to be administrated to those who are without, but only to those who are within the Church, you mean not within the Church by profession, for Infants have no profession, and you say the Sacrament cannot be put on a blank or a falsehood, Ergo, you think all that are baptized ought to be within the Church really, and not in profession only; Ergo they must all come to age and believe before they can be baptized. 2. We say not that baptism maketh a Church mystical, and the true and lively body and Spouse of Christ, but that it is a seal confirming us of our entry in the visible Church. 3. The ⟨p. 216⟩placing of the Font at the Church door as a mystical sign of our entry in the Church is an Antichristian ceremony of mens devising, which we disclaim. 4. If Infants baptized must be within the Church, before they can be baptized, how deny you to receive them to the Lords Supper when they come to age, while they be again, by your Church-oath, received within the Church? then are they both within the Church, because they are baptized, and without the Church, because they are not received in by your Church-oath again. 5. If baptism be a seal of grace to confirm the Covenant of grace to those who are within the Church, that is, only a single Congregation, (for you deny that there be any visible Churches in the New Testament save these only) then are persons baptized persons, and confirmed in the Covenant of grace only within a single Congregation. I would know if baptism should not then be repeated and reiterated in every ones person, as they come to a new Congregation; for they are confirmed in the Covenant of grace, by baptism only in one single Congregation, as you teach.
Answ. 1. Anabaptists deny that any ought to be baptized while thy come to age, and while they beleeve and be regenerated: and they say not farre from your selves in this, who teach it to bee absurd, to put a blanke seale upon a falshood, and so you presuppone all to be regenerated, and truly within the Covenant before they can be sealed to be within the Covenant by baptisme; and yet you do not think all Infants of beleeving parents to be regenerated and truly within the Covenant, then is the seale blanck. Also you say, baptisme is not to be administrated to those who are without, but onely to those who are within the Church, you meane not within the Church by profession, for Infants have no profession, and you say the Sacrament cannot be put on a blanke or a falshood, Ergo, you thinke all that are baptized ought to be within the Church really, and not in profession ouely; Ergo they must all come to age and beleeve before they can be baptized. 2. We say not that baptisme maketh a Church mysticall, and the true and lively body and Spouse of Christ, but that it is a seale confirming us of our entry in the visible Church. 3. The