Answer, It is true, there is an unlawful communion of the faithful that is overseers and guides of the Church, to whom God hath committed the keys of the Kingdom of Heaven, with excommunicated persons, in that they retain one worthy to be excommunicated in the bosom of the Church: but communion with the Church in the holy things of God, is not hence concluded to be unlawful, because the guides of the people communicate with that Church where the excommunicated person is suffered, it is the sin of the Church-guides, that an excommunicated person is not cast out, and that he is suffered to communicate at the Lords Table, and to profane •, in not discerning the Lords body, but it is not the sin of either guides or the people, to communicate at one Table with the excommunicated person, or him that deserveth to be excommunicated; for not casting out is one thing, and to communicate with the excommunicated in the true visible Church is another thing; the former is a sin, not to use the power that Christ hath given, but to communicate with the excommunicated person, is not a sin, but a remembering of the Lords death at Christs commandment; for one sin maketh not another sin to be lawful, or to be no sin; to deliver one unto Satan is to debar one from the Lords Supper, and to repute him as a Publican, and to judge him not worthy of the communion in the holy things of God, with the Church; but this is not to repute the Church or guides or members as Publicans and Heathens, and as not worthy of Church-communion with the man who is cast out: we see the Church of Corinth ⟨p. 240⟩rebuked, for not excommunicating the incestuous man, but not forbidden to come and eat the Lords Supper with him, and these who came and did eat their own condemnation• 1 Cor. 11. yea they are commanded to come to the public meeting: Ergo, it is one thing not to excommunicate the scandalous, a sin, and another thing to communicate with the scandalous, which is not a sin directly, nor forbidden at all. Though Paul have an allusion to the Lords separating of the Jews from all other people, yet it followeth not that we are to separate from the wicked men and unrenewed, professing the truth that way; first, because there was a typical separation in marriage with Canaanites;
Answer, It is true, there is an unlawfull communion of the faithfull that is overseers and guides of the Church, to whom God hath committed the keyes of the Kingdome of Heaven, with excommunicated persons, in that they retaine one worthy to be excommunicated in the bosome of the Church: but communion with the Church in the holy things of God, is not hence concluded to be unlawfull, because the guides of the people communicate with that Church where the excommunicated person is suffered, it is the sinne of the Church-guides, that an excommunicated person is not cast out, and that he is suffered to communicate at the Lords Table, and to profane •, in not discerning the Lords body, but it is not the sinne of either guides or the people, to communicate at one Table with the excommunicated person, or him that deserveth to be excommunicated; for not casting out is one thing, and to communicate with the excommunicated in the true visible Church is another thing; the former is a sinne, not to use the power that Christ hath given, but to communicate with the excommunicated person, is not a sinne, but a remembring of the Lords death at Christs commandement; for one sinne maketh not another sinne to be lawfull, or to be no sinne; to deliver one unto Satan is to debarre one from the Lords Supper, and to repute him as a Publican, and to judge him not worthy of the communion in the holy things of God, with the Church; but this is not to repute the Church or guides or members as Publicans and Heathens, and as not worthy of Church-communion with the man who is cast out: we see the Church of Corinth ⟨p. 240⟩rebuked, for not excommunicating the incestuous man, but not forbidden to come and eate the Lords Supper with him, and these who came and did eate their owne condemnation• 1 Cor. 11. yea they are commanded to come to the publike meeting: Ergo, it is one thing not to excommunicate the scandalous, a sinne, and another thing to communicate with the scandalous, which is not a sinne directly, nor forbidden at all. Though Paul have an allusion to the Lords separating of the Jewes from all other people, yet it followeth not that we are to separate from the wicked men and unrenewed, professing the truth that way; first, because there was a typicall separation in marriage with Canaanites;