3. We are 1 Cor. 5. to avoid Fornicators, no less then Idolaters, true. Ergo, we are to separate from the Church, where there be Fornicators, seeing they make the Church to be false in its constitution, as we are to separate from a society of heathen Idolaters who worship a false God: do you love such consequences? men not forsaken of mother wit would say, I must separate from Aaron, and the whole Church of Israel, in the act of adoring the golden Calf, which is indeed a separation from the false worship of the Church, but not separate from the Church; but would you hence infer, because God punisheth fornication no less then Idolatry, that I am to separate from the Church, and all their persons and society in the very true worship of God, because some few persons there be fornicators and carnal? Surely then Paul did not his duty, who commanded communion with the Church of Corinth, 1 Cor. 5. wherein there were carnal men, and deniers of the resurrection, and such as for gain went to the Law, with their brethren, and that before Infidels; yea because all sin in the ⟨p. 245⟩demerit thereof (except you devise venials) exclude men out of the new Jerusalem, we must separate from all Churches on earth, for there be none so clean, but there be some sin in it, which excludeth out of the new Jerusalem, as Idolatry doth, though there be degrees of sin. But some ignorant ones say the place, 1 Cor. 5. 11. is to be expounded of eating at the Communion Table, or if it be of familiar eating and drinking, of civill conversing, then much more are we not to communicate with them at the Lords Table. But not to eat with such a one, is not to keep entire fellowship with him, as the phrase noteth, Psal. 4. 9. He that eat of my bread hath lift up his b•ele against me. Joh. 13. 18. Psal. 55 13. So doth Chrysostom, The•phylact us, Oecumenius expound this place, Bullinger, contub••nium & interiorem convictum prohibet; So Calvin, Peter Martyr, B•za, Piscator, Pareus; So Erasmus and Aquinas, Haymo, Gagneius. Nor is all eating whatsoever with Heathen persons forbidden, Paul practised the contrary, Act. 13. 14. 5. 6. Act. 14. 8. 9. Act. 17. 16, 17. Act. 27. 34, 35, 36. Act. 28. 11, 12. 1 Cor. 10. 27.
3. We are 1 Cor. 5. to avoyd Fornicators, no lesse then Idolaters, true. Ergo, we are to separate from the Church, where there be Fornicators, seeing they make the Church to bee false in its constitution, as we are to separate from a societie of heathen Idolaters who worship a false God: doe you love such consequences? men not forsaken of mother wit would say, I must separate from Aaron, and the whole Church of Israel, in the act of adoring the golden Calfe, which is indeed a separation from the false worship of the Church, but not separate from the Church; but would you hence inferre, because God punisheth fornication no lesse then Idolatry, that I am to separate from the Church, and all their persons and societie in the very true worship of God, because some few persons there bee fornicators and carnall? Surely then Paul did not his dutie, who commanded communion with the Church of Corinth, 1 Cor. 5. wherein there were carnall men, and deniers of the resurrection, and such as for gaine went to the Law, with their brethren, and that before Infidels; yea because all sinne in the ⟨p. 245⟩demerit thereof (except you devise venials) exclude men out of the new Hierusalem, we must separate from all Churches on earth, for there be none so cleane, but there bee some sinne in it, which excludeth out of the new Hierusalem, as Idolatry doth, though there bee degrees of sinne. But some ignorant ones say the place, 1 Cor. 5. 11. is to be expounded of eating at the Communion Table, or if it bee of familiar eating and drinking, of civill conversing, then much more are wee not to communicate with them at the Lords Table. But not to eate with such a one, is not to keepe intire fellowship with him, as the phrase noteth, Psal. 4. 9. He that eat of my bread hath lift up his b•ele against me. Joh. 13. 18. Psal. 55 13. So doth Chrysostome, The•phylact us, Oecumenius expound this place, Bullinger, contub••nium & interiorem convictum prohibet; So Calvin, Peter Martyr, B•za, Piscator, Pareus; So Erasmus and Aquinas, Haymo, Gagneius. Nor is all eating whatsoever with Heathen persons forbidden, Paul practised the contrary,