A57969:1723
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the…
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
[figure] › Chapter 4 › Section 6: The way of the Churches of Christ in New England.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
3. You say, it is not the seed of Faith that knitteth a man to a particular visible Church, but an holy profession. But in the excommunicate person, (if the seed of faith remain as you grant) this faith must be seen, by you, in a holy profession, else to you, he hath no seed of faith; and if his profession of faith remain entire, though it be violated in the particular obstinate, remaining in one scandal, for the which he is excommunicated, you have no reason to say, that to the particular Church, he is wholly cut off, since his profession remaineth.
3. You say, it is not the seede of Faith that knitteth a man to a particular visible Church, but an holy profession. But in the excommunicate person, (if the seede of faith remaine as you grant) this faith must be seene, by you, in a holy profession, else to you, he hath no seed of faith; and if his profession of faith remaine intire, though it bee violated in the particular obstinate, remaining in one scandall, for the which he is excommunicated, you have no reason to say, that to the particular Church, hee is wholly cut off, since his profession remaineth.
4. You say, It is not the seed of faith, nor faith it self that knitteth a man to this or that particular visible Church, but a holy profession of faith. Then I say, one may be knit to a particular visible Church, and a true member thereof, though he want both the seed of Faith, and Faith it self. I prove the connection. A man is a perfect and true member of a Church, though he want that which doth not knit him to the Church, this is undeniable: But without the seed of Faith or Faith it self, (as you say) he is knit to the true Church: Ergo. But this is contrary to your Doctrine, who require, chap. 3. sect. 3. that none must be admitted members of a visible Church, but those who are Christ his body, the habitation of God by the Spirit, the Temples of the Holy Ghost, &c. And that no• only by external• profession, but in some measure of sincerity and Truth. Now consider my Reverend Brethren, if there be a measure of sincerity and Truth, where there is neither the seed of Faith, nor Faith it self: and surely by this you cast down and mar the constitution of your visible Church, when you exclude from the members thereof, the seed of Faith, and Faith it self; and you come to our hand, and teach, that the seed of Faith, and Faith it self, is accidental to a visible Church as visible, which we also teach: and so there is no measure of truth and sincerity required to the essential constitution of a visible Church.