Answ. It can not be denied, but Elders, that is, preaching Elders or Pastors, have authority over the people in preaching and rebuking with all authority; but 1. I ask at our brethren, by what authority of the Scripture is pastoral binding ⟨p. 318⟩and loosing an authoritative act of the preaching Elder only? for the concionall or preaching power of remitting and retaining sins, Joh. 20. 21. is all one with the power of the keys, Matth. 16. and that is given (saith our brethren) to the whole Church, and by these texts are not restricted to Pastors as they expone them. 2. Our brethren allege there is a two-fold power of preaching in Pastors, one by virtue of their gift, another by virtue of their office. By the first Pastors do preach to Infidels, Turks, and unconverted ones; now this preaching is not proper to Pastors as Pastors, nor is it any authority peculiar to Pastors over all the flock, for all gifted persons (as our brethren teach) may preach, and so the gifted ones amongst the people have authority over the Pastors in this meaning, as well as the Pastors have over them, and so the difference of rulers and ruled, of feeders and the fed, is taken away. Now for the power of Pastoral teaching, the Pastors have authority over the Church, but that is over the invisible Church of believers, and regenerated persons, for Pastors as Pastors do not convert Souls, and so they preach to the unconverted not as Pastors, or with any Pastoral care: for they teach that Pastors, Doctors, and Church-officers are given, Ephes. 4. 11. only for confirming of those who are already converted, not for converting of Souls, and by this means, 1. Pastors do not preach the Law, for the humbling of unconverted sinners, they do not as Pastors, or by virtue of the office open the eyes of the blind, nor are they Ministers by whom men believe, 1 Cor. 3. 5. nor are they Fathers who begot men in Christ Jesus, through the Gospel, as 1 Cor. 4. 25. Nor do they pray men in Christs stead to be reconciled unto God, as 2 Cor. 5. 20.
Answ. It can not be denied, but Elders, that is, preaching Elders or Pastors, have authoritie over the people in preaching and rebuking with all authoritie; but 1. I aske at our brethren, by what authoritie of the Scripture is pastorall binding ⟨p. 318⟩and loosing an authoritative act of the preaching Elder onely? for the concionall or preaching power of remitting and retaining sinnes, Joh. 20. 21. is all one with the power of the keyes, Matth. 16. and that is given (saith our brethren) to the whole Church, and by these texts are not restricted to Pastors as they expone them. 2. Our brethren alledge there is a two-fold power of preaching in Pastors, one by vertue of their gift, another by vertue of their office. By the first Pastors doe preach to Infidels, Turkes, and unconverted ones; now this preaching is not proper to Pastors as Pastors, nor is it any authority peculiar to Pastors over all the flocke, for all gifted persons (as our brethren teach) may preach, and so the gifted ones amongst the people have authority over the Pastors in this meaning, as well as the Pastors have over them, and so the difference of rulers and ruled, of feeders and the fed, is taken away. Now for the power of Pastorall teaching, the Pastors have authority over the Church, but that is over the invisible Church of beleevers, and regenerated persons, for Pastors as Pastors doe not convert Soules, and so they preach to the unconverted not as Pastors, or with any Pastorall care: for they teach that Pastors, Doctors, and Church-officers are given, Ephes. 4. 11. onely for confirming of those who are already converted, not for converting of Soules, and by this meanes, 1. Pastors doe not preach the Law, for the humbling of unconverted sinners, they doe not as Pastors, or by vertue of the office open the eyes of the blinde, nor are they Ministers by whom men beleeve, 1 Cor. 3. 5. nor are they Fathers who begot men in Christ Jesus, through the Gospell, as 1 Cor. 4. 25. Nor doe they pray men in Christs stead to be reconciled unto God, as 2 Cor. 5. 20.