A57969:1923
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the…
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
[figure] › Chapter 5 › Section 3: The way of Church judging in New England.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. If to speak first in a Church meeting, prove that the Elders have authority over the Church; then one Elder hath authority over all the rest of the Elders, and must be a little Pope, or a great Prelate, for two or four Elders cannot all speak first. We seek now an act of authority due to Elders or Pastors, as they are such, and above the people; if you make this an act of authority, you then give us in every Church-meeting and Synod a Pastor of Pastors, and an Elder of Elders, and a Pope. 2. If this be an act of authority over the Church, then have Papists well proven that Peter hath an authority and power over all the Church, for cSuarez, and dBellarmine, and eHarding prove Peter to be a Pope, because he speaketh first in the council, Act. 13. 13. and the text that you cite, they cite also: But fWhittakerus, and gGerson saith, as also hLyran, and iCarthusian, It is like that James spake first as President of the Council. 3. The Author leaveth this act of authority, as weak, and saith, that the offended party may speak first. Ergo (say I) to speak first is not an authoritative act of Pastors as Pastors agreeing to them, by virtue of their office, seeing this act is communicated to those who are out of office. Ergo, they have not shown as yet any Pastoral act of office due to the Elders as Elders; and if it were most convenient that Elders should first speak, our brethren will not say that it is due to them by their office, but for their age and gifts, and so they say nothing.
Answ. If to speake first in a Church meeting, prove that the Elders have authority over the Church; then one Elder hath authority over all the rest of the Elders, and must be a little Pope, or a great Prelate, for two or foure Elders cannot all speake first. We seeke now an act of authority due to Elders or Pastors, as they are such, and above the people; if you make this an act of authority, you then give us in every Church-meeting and Synod a Pastor of Pastors, and an Elder of Elders, and a Pope. 2. If this be an act of authority over the Church, then have Papists well proven that Peter hath an authority and power over all the Church, for