Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
6. Though no man resist the Magistrate in a matter of religion, except in a hypocritical way, save only he who thinketh he hath reason […], and is led by the judgement and indictment of conscience to resist, •et is not the in litement of conscience, but only the Word of God •et rule of mans obedience, or resisting in actions, purposes & conversation.
6. Though no man resist the Magistrate in a matter of religion, except in a hypocriticall way, save onely he who thinketh hee hath reason 〈…〉, and is led by the judgement and inditement of conscience to resist, •et is not the in litement of conscience, but onely the Word of God •et rule of mans obedience, or resisting in actions, purposes & conversation.
1. Conclusion. Fire and sword, or war, or the coactive power of a magistrate is not Gods way of planting the Gospel in a heathen nation, which never heard of the Gospel before. 1. Because the Apostles were commanded, by teaching the Gospel to all nations, Matth. 28. 19, 20. Mark. 16. 15. Act. 7. 8. and not by war, to spread the Gospel. 2. Because Christs Kingdom is not of this world, for then his servants would fight for him, Joh. 18. 36. nor are the weapons of our warfare carnal, 2 Cor. 10. 4. nor is Christs sword any other thing, then the Word of God,
. And in this meaning, and with relation to the internal acts of sound believing, have the learned taught us, that, religio suaderi potest, cogi non potest: if these be the constitutions of
Clemens, let it go for a truth in this sense, that God hath given liberty of will to men, not punishing them with temporal death, but calleth them to give an account of ••eir doings, in the life to come: which yet cannot be universally true, except that the Author with Anabaptists take away the power of the civill magistrate; and
Athanasius meant with us, when he citeth that, If any will come after me, let him take up his cross; to prove that the will cannot be compelled; and that of
Lactantius is approved by all, defendenda tamen religioest, non occidendo, sed moriendo, non saevitiâ, sed sapientiâ, non s••lere, sed fide; illa enim malorum sunt, baec bonorum; & necesse est bonum in religione versari, non malum: Nam si sanguine, si tormentis, si malo religionem defendere velis, jam non defendetur illa, fed polluetur, & violabitur. Nihil est tam voluntarium quam religio, in qua si animus sacrificantis est eversus, jam sublata, jam nulla est: all which tendeth to this, that religion is like freewill, and free-will like a Virgin which cannot be ravished. Let that of
Procopius saith that Justinian was blamed, because he compelled the Samaritans to embrace the Christian faith.
1. Conclusion. Fire and sword, or warre, or the coactive power of a magistrate is not Gods way of planting the Gospell in a heathen nation, which never heard of the Gospell before. 1. Because the Apostles were commanded, by teaching the Gospell to all nations, Matth. 28. 19, 20. Mark. 16. 15. Act. 7. 8. and not by warre, to spread the Gospel. 2. Because Christs Kingdome is not of this world, for then his servants would fight for him, Joh. 18. 36. nor are the weapons of our warfare carnall, 2 Cor. 10. 4. nor is Christs sword any other thing, then the Word of God, Rev. 19. 15. Gal. 6. 17. And in this meaning, and with relation to the internall acts of sound beleeving, have the learned taught us, that, religio suaderi potest, cogi non potest: if these bee the constitutions of aClemens, let it goe for a truth in this sense, that God hath given libertie of will to men, not punishing them with temporall death, but calleth them to give an account of ••eir doings, in the life to come: which yet cannot bee universally true, except that the Author with Anabaptists take away the power of the civill magistrate; and bAthanasius meaned with us, when hee citeth that, If any will come after me, let him take up his crosse; to prove that the will cannot bee compelled; and that of cLactantius is approved by all, defendenda tamen religioest, non occidendo, sed moriendo, non saevitiâ, sed sapientiâ, non s••lere, sed fide; illa enim malorum sunt, baec bonorum; & necesse est bonum in religione versari, non malum: Nam si sanguine, si tormentis, si malo religionem defendere velis, jam non defendetur illa, fed polluetur, & violabitur. Nihil est tam voluntarium quam religio, in qua si animus sacrificantis est eversus, jam sublata, jam nulla est: all which tendeth to this, that religion is like freewill, and free-will like a Virgin which cannot bee ravished. Let that of dTertullian stand, Lex nostra non se vindicat ultore gladio•eProcopius saith that Justinian was blamed, because hee compelled the Samaritans to imbrace the Christian faith.
aClemens in constitut. [Greek or Hebrew].Clemens in constitut. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
2. Conclusion. A Christian Prince subduing a heathen ⟨p. 354⟩Nation, may compel them to desist from a negative dishonouring of Christ, and from an external false worship. Dan. 3. 29. Therefore I make a Decree, that every People, Nation, and Language, which speak any thing amiss against the God of Shadrach and Abednego, shall be cut in pieces, and their houses shall be made a dunghill. 2. The Magistrate beareth not the sword for nothing, or in vain, for he is the minister of God, a revenger to execute wrath on those who do evil, Rom. 13. 4. Therefore he should be Gods Minister to execute wrath on those who dishonour Christ. Nor must we approve of that of Tiberius, fthat Gods take care of wrongs done to themselves: and that of the Emperor Alexander, git's sufficient that the breach of an oath hath God to be the revenger. Yet the Emperor hConstantine commanded all the Churches of the Pagan Gods to be closed up, and iAmbrose and kAugustine both commended the fact; and Ferdinand King of Spain, commanded all the Jews, who would not turn Christians, to remove out of Spain.
2. Conclusion. A Christian Prince subduing a heathen ⟨p. 354⟩Nation, may compell them to desist from a negative dis•onouring of Christ, and from an externall false worship. Dan. 3. 29. Therefore I make a Decree, that every People, Nation, and Language, which speake any thing amisse against the God of Sadrach and Abednego, shall be cut in peeces, and their houses shall be made a dung•ill. 2. The Magistrate beareth not the sword for nothing, or invaine, for he is the minister of God, a revenger to execute wrath on those who doe evill, Rom. 13. 4. Therefore he should be Gods Minister to execute wrath on those who dishonour Christ. Nor must we approve of that of Tiberius, fthat Gods take care of wrongs dene to themselves: and that of the Emperour Alexander, git's sufficient that the breach of an oath hath God to be the revenger. Yet the Emperour hConstantine commanded all the Churches of the Pagan Gods to be closed up, and iAmbrose and kAugustine both commended the fact; and Ferdinand King of Spaine, commanded all the Jewes, who would not turne Christians, to remove out of Spaine.
fTacitus in Tiberio, De•rum in •u•iae D••s curae saint.Ta•itus in Tiberio, De•rum in •u•iae D••s curae sant.
gl. 2. God. de •eb. Ged. juris juran•ts contempia religio satis De•• ultorem habet.
3. Conclus. Where a Nation hath embraced the faith, and sworn thereunto in Baptism, it is lawful for the Magistrate to compel them to profess that truth to the which they have sworn in Baptism. 1. Because the Magistrate is a keeper of both Tables of the Law. Ergo, he may take care that these who are baptized, and sworn to be followers of Christ, should profess what they have sworn to profess. 2. Because the Magistrate may compell, ad actus imperatos, non ad actus elicitos, commanded and external acts of worship, though he have no power over the conscience to command the elicit acts of will and mind. 3. He may command to use the means of Religion, though he cannot force Religion it self: and this Jehoshaphat, Hezekiah, Asa, and Josiah, and other good Kings commanded, and in that are set forth to all Princes as patterns of zeal. 4. The most pungent argument of our brethren in the contrary is of no weight, because (say they) for one to adjoin himself to the visible Church in a profession of the faith, it is a supernatural work of Grace, and must be voluntary, else the Magistrate should compel men to hypocrisy, yea and he should, saith lGregorius de Valentia, following Cajetanus, indirectly concur to sacrilege, to profane the holy things of God; and fear of punishment maketh an ⟨p. 355⟩action against the will, secundum quid, in some respect, and for the point of supernaturality of professing, mDurandus handleth it. Now (I say) that this is of no weight, because (as nSuarez. saith) one may be compelled to hear the Word, who yet cannot be compelled to believe; so (say I) to make such a profession, as may constitute any one a member of the visible Church, is no supernatural act, though there be a moral obligation tying the professors to the supernatural sincerity of the act, yet there is no essential obligation, as touching the essence of a visible member tying him thereunto, and therefore the Magistrate may compel thereunto, and so oAntonius following pGregorius do teach that an indirect compulsion to the faith is lawful; and the compelling power of the Magistrate is terminated upon the profession, not upon the hypocrisy of the profession; else it were as good an argument to prove that the Magistrate by the sword cannot compel subjects to abstain from murder, sorcery, perjury;
3. Conclus. Where a Nation hath embraced the faith, and sworne thereunto in Baptisme, it is lawfull for the Magistrate to compell them to professe that truth to the which they have sworne in Baptisme. 1. Because the Magistrate is a keeper of both Tables of the Law. Ergo, he may take care that these who are baptized, and sworne to be followers of Christ, should professe what they have sworne to professe. 2. Because the Magistrate may compell, ad actus imperatos, non ad actus elicitos, commanded and externall acts of worship, though he have no power over the conscience to command the elicit acts of will and mind. 3. He may command to use the meanes of Religion, though he cannot force Religion it selfe: and this Jehoshaphat, Ezechiah, Asa, and Josiah, and other good Kings commanded, and in that are set forth to all Princes as patterns of zeale. 4. The most pungent argument of our brethren in the contrary is of no weight, because (say they) for one to adjoyn himself to the visible Church in a profession of the faith, it is a supernaturall worke of Grace, and must be voluntary, else the Magistrate should compell men to hypocrisie, yea and he should, saith lGregorius de Valentia, following Cajetanus, indirectly concurre to sacriledge, to profane the holy things of God; and feare of punishment maketh an ⟨p. 355⟩action against the will, secundum quid, in some respect, and for the point of supernaturality of professing, mDurandus handleth it. Now (I say) that this is of no weight, because (as nSuarez. saith) one may be compelled to heare the Word, who yet cannot be compelled to beleeve; so (say I) to make such a profession, as may constitute any one a member of the visible Church, is no supernaturall act, though there be a morall obligation tying the professours to the supernaturall sincerity of the act, yet there is no essentiall obligation, as touching the essence of a visible member tying him thereunto, and therefore the Magistrate may compell thereunto, and so oAntonius following pGregorius doe teach that an indirect compulsion to the faith is lawfull; and the compelling power of the Magistrate is terminated upon the profession, not upon the hypocrisie of the profession; else it were as good an argument to prove that the Magistrate by the sword cannot compell subjects to ab•taine from murther, sorcery, perjury;
lGregorius de Valentia to. 3. disp. 1. punc. 6. q. 10. de infidelita te arg. 4.
mD••andus 4. santen. d. 4. q. 6. […]. 1.D••andus 4. santen. d. 4. q. 6. 〈…〉. 1.
nSuarez, de […] disp. 18. sect 2. n. 5.Suarez, de 〈…〉 disp. 18. sect 2. n. 5.
because many in an hypocritical and servile manner, for fear of the Magistrates wrath, not for fear of God, do abstain from these ills, nor is their abstinence from worshipping idols, a thing of it self, as the Magistrate commandeth it, supernatural. Neither would men by the Covenant of the Lord, which King Asa did cause the people to swear, to wit, that they should seek the Lord God of their fathers, 2 Chron. 15. 12. be compelled, so as their seeking of God, should not be willingly performed. 5. This opinion is the way to Arminian liberty of conscience, that men in a Christian Common-wealth, may be of any Religion, and the Magistrate is to behold men as an indifferent spectator, not caring what religion they be of, whether they be Papists, Jews, Pagans, Anabaptists, Socinians, Macedonians, &c. which should infer, that the Magistrate were no nurse-father of the true Church, nor yet a preserver of Religion, if men might be of any Religion. Neither is this the way (as saith qRobinson) to the Papists implicit faith, when men believeth, as the Church believeth, though they know not what it is: nor is it a compelling of men (as he saith) to blasphemy, and apparent wickedness, because the Magistrate is not to compel to profession of the truth immediately, and without any foregoing information of the ⟨p. 356⟩mind; for the Church is to teach and instruct in all the external acts of worship, before the Magistrate doth compel to these acts; yea and the same rRobinson acknowledgeth that Jehoshaphat made compulsive laws about Religion. Ergo, if he should execute these Laws, he should compel to some acts of Religion, and should compel to hypocrisy, as the same Mr. Robinson argueth against us.
because many in an hypocriticall and servile manner, for feare of the Magistrates wrath, not for feare of God, doe abstaine from these ils, nor is their abstinence from worshipping idols, a thing of it selfe, as the Magistrate commandeth it, supernaturall. Neither would men by the Covenant of the Lord, which King Asa did cause the people to sweare, to wit, that they should seeke the Lord God of their fathers, 2 Chron. 15. 12. be compelled, so as their seeking of God, should not be willingly performed. 5. This opinion is the way to Arminian liberty of conscience, that men in a Christian Common-wealth, may be of any Religion, and the Magistrate is to behold men as an indifferent spectator, not caring what religion they bee of, whether they be Papists, Jewes, Pagans, Anabaptists, Socinians, Macedonians, &c. which should inferre, that the Magistrate were no nurse-father of the true Church, nor yet a preserver of Religion, if men might be of any Religion. Neither is this the way (as saith qRobinson) to the Papists implicite faith, when men beleeveth, as the Church beleeveth, though they know not what it is: nor is it a compelling of men (as he saith) to blasphemy, and apparent wickednesse, because the Magistrate is not to compell to profession of the truth immediately, and without any foregoing information of the ⟨p. 356⟩mind; for the Church is to teach and instruct in all the externall acts of worship, before the Magistrate doth compell to these acts; yea and the same rRobinson acknowledgeth that Jehoshaphat made compulsive lawes about Religion. Ergo, if he should execute these Lawes, he should compell to some acts of Religion, and should compell to hypocrisie, as the same Mr. Robinson argueth against us.
4. Conclus. It is one thing to command acts of divine worship, under the pain of civill punishment, and another thing to punish, or inflict civill punishment, when these commandments are transgressed, Christian Princes may do both. And that they do the latter by Gods commandment and warrant is clear, in that Jehu destroyed all the house of Ahab for Idolatry, and killed Baals Priests. Good Josiah killed the Priests of 1the high places, and burnt their bones upon the Altar. Elijah, when the Magistrate would not do his duty, in an extraordinary way, killed Baals Priests; and if the Magistrate also in the New Testament have the sword given to him of God, for the punishing of evil doers, as Rom. 13. 4, 5. that same Law must now also have force, though in the use of the sword sundry heretics are here to be distinguished, as 1. seducing heretics, drawing others away, from the worship of the true God to idolatry, such are not to be pitied by the Magistrate, as Deut. 13. 5, 6, 7. Zach. 13. 4, 5, 6. whereas seduced, and drawn away souls, for simple heresy, cannot be put to death. 2. Heretics falling away in many particulars from the faith to Popery, or other heretical ways, are more severely to be punished, then those who are heretics in one or two fundamental points only. And those who are universal Apostates, and fall from the Christian faith to Judaism and Paganism, deserve no less then death. 3. Self-condemned heretics, after sufficient information, and malicious opposers of the truth, deserve harder dealing, then simply seduced heretics. 4. All who believe blasphemies to be truth, and hold them, are not to be reckoned amongst formal blasphemers, whose malice carrieth them on to rail upon the unspotted ways of God. 5. No heretics having false opinions of God, such as Antinomians and Libertines, who think that the regenerate cannot sin, or that the worshipping ⟨p. 357⟩of a creature is not idolatry, can be innocent, as if •••mply acts of the judgement and mind not conform to Gods will revealed in his word were not sins, (as Arminians teach) whereas all the faculties of the soul are under Gods Law. 2. Hardly doth the mind conceive false thoughts of God, or his worship, but there be wicked crooks in the will and affections inclining thereunto the mind, and smoking the mind with will-guiltiness.
4. Conclus. It is one thing to command acts of divine worship, under the paine of civill punishment, and another thing to punish, or inflict civill punishment, when these commandements are transgressed, Christian Princes may doe both. And that they doe the latter by Gods commandement and warrant is cleare, in that Jehu destroyed all the house of Ahab for Idolatry, and killed Baals Priests. Good Josiah killed the Priests of 1the high places, and burnt their bones upon the Altar. Elias, when the Magistrate would not doe his duty, in an extraordinary way, killed Baals Priests; and if the Magistrate also in the New Testament have the sword given to him of God, for the punishing of evill doers, as Rom. 13. 4, 5. that same Law must now also have force, though in the use of the sword sundry hereticks are here to be distinguished, as 1. seducing hereticks, drawing others away, from the worship of the true God to idolatry, such are not to be pitied by the Magistrate, as Deut. 13. 5, 6, 7. Zach. 13. 4, 5, 6. whereas seduced, and drawne away soules, for simple heresie, cannot be put to death. 2. Hereticks falling away in many particulars from the faith to Popery, or other hereticall wayes, are more severely to be punished, then those who are hereticks in one or two fundamentall points onely. And those who are universall Apostates, and fall from the Christian faith to Judaisme and Paganisme, deserve no lesse then death. 3. Selfe-condemned hereticks, after sufficient information, and malitious opposers of the truth, deserve harder dealing, then simply seduced hereticks. 4. All who beleeve blasphemies to be truth, and hold them, are not to be reckoned amongst formall blasphemers, whose malice carrieth them on to raile upon the unspotted wayes of God. 5. No hereticks having false opinions of God, such as Antinomians and Libertines, who thinke that the regenerate cannot sinne, or that the worshipping ⟨p. 357⟩of a creature is not idolatry, can be innocent, as if •••mply acts of the judgement and mind not conforme to Gods will revealed in his word were not sinnes, (as Arminians teach) whereas all the faculties of the soule are under Gods Law. 2. Hardly doth the mind conceive false thoughts of God, or his worship, but there be wicked crookes in the will and affections inclining thereunto the mind, and smoaking the mind with will-guiltinesse.
6. Except God was too rigorous and cruel in the Old Testament (God avert such blasphemous thoughts) what ever punishment even to blood and death was inflicted upon heretics, seducing Prophets, Idolaters, Apostates, these same stand yet in the plentitude of moral obligation against such as offend in the New Testament, if the Magistrate bear the Lords sword, as he doth in the New Testament, Rom. 13. 4, 5.
6. Except God was too rigorous and cruell in the Old Testament (God avert such blasphemous thoughts) what ever punishment even to bloud and death was inflicted upon hereticks, seducing Prophets, Idolaters, Apostates, these same stande yet in the plentitude of morall obligation against such as offend in the New Testament, if the Magistrate beare the Lords sword, as he doth in the New Testament, Rom. 13. 4, 5.
Monfortius the Anabaptist as sBeza saith, had no Scripture to say, because Christ is a meek Saviour, all corporal punishment inflicted upon heretics in the Old Testament, is turned over in spiritual punishment; only our brethren who deny that the Magistrate can compel any to an external profession of the Gospel, do herein follow Arminians and Socinians. So the tRe•onstrants, and wEpiscopius deny that the Magistrate can use any bodily punishment against heretics. The learned xProfessors of Leiden observe that Arminians here teach that same with the Socinians, and the same is refuted well by yVedelius, yea and Gerardus, and zMersnerus, and other pretended Disciples of Luther in this side with Arminians and Socinians: and Socinians teach in this, 1. that Heretics should not be molested nor punished with the sword. So aSocinus, bTheophilus Nicolaides, cOstorodius, because the tares are not to be rooted out till harvest. 2. dEpiscopius, eSlatius amongst Arminians, and fOstorodius, and gthe Catechise of Raccovia teach farther, that the Magistrate may punish by fines and pecuniall mulcts, ⟨p. 358⟩but he cannot shed blood, or punish to death any murderer, because the Commandment of our meek Saviour, doth not permit to take away any mans life; now it is certain meek Jesus, while he was on earth, did neither fine nor imprison, more then put to death. 3. So•inians teach that all wars under the new Testament are unlawful; for saith Smal•ius, hwars cannot consist with the […] of our enemy, commanded by Christ: iSocinus and Ostorodius say it is an old precept not to shed blood, and never retracted in the New Testament, and God licensed it to the Jews, because he promised to them an earthly kingdom, which he hath not now promised under the New Testament. Our Divines hold ringleading and seducing heretics are to be punished to death, for so kBeza, lJunius, mBucanus, nZanchius, oPerkinsius, pDaneus, qBullingerus, rthe Professors of Leiden teach.
Monfortius the Anabaptist as sBeza saith, had no Scripture to say, because Christ is a meeke Saviour, all corporall punishment inflicted upon hereticks in the Old Testament, is turned over in spirituall punishment; onely our brethren who deny that the Magistrate can compell any to an externall profession of the Gospel, doe herein follow Arminians and Socinians. So the tRe•onstrants, and wEpiscopius deny that the Magistrate can use any bodily punishment against hereticks. The learned xProfessors of Leiden observe that Arminians here teach that same with the Socinians, and the same is refuted well by yVedelius, yea and Gerardus, and zMersnerus, and other pretended Disciples of Luther in this side with Arminians and Socinians: and Socinians teach in this, 1. that Hereticks should not be molested nor punished with the sword. So aSocinus, bTheophilus Nicolaides, cOstorodius, because the tares are not to be rooted out till harvest. 2. dEpiscopius, eSlatius amongst Arminians, and fOstorodius, and gthe Catechise of Raccovia teach farther, that the Magistrate may punish by fines and pecuniall mulcts, ⟨p. 358⟩but he cannot shed bloud, or punish to death any murtherer, because the Commandement of our meeke Saviour, doth not permit to take away any mans life; now it is certaine meeke Jesus, while hee was on earth, did neither fine nor imprison, more then put to death. 3. Soinians teach that all warres under the new Testament are unlawfull; for saith Smalius,
sBeza de haeretic. a magist. pun. pag. 158. 159.
tRemonst. in confess. c. 24. Sect. 9. qui haereticidie aut simile tyrannidi aut persecution• ullo modo patrocinentur, a m••issimo Christi spiritu prorsus alieni sunt.Remonst. in confess. c. 24. Sect. 9. qui haereticidie aut simili tyrannidi aut persecution• ullo modo patrocinentur, a m••issimo Christi spiritu prorsus alieni sunt.
wEpis••pius. disp. 28. Thes. 25.
xProfessors Leidens. in sua cens. 16. id Socinianae doctrinae c•rsentaneum quidem est.Professores Leidens. in sua cens. 16. id Socinianae doctrinae c•rsentaneum quidem est.
yNicolaus Vedelius ar•a. Arminianis. par. 1. l. 2. c. 9.
zJoan. Gerard. 10. 6. de Magistrat. politico. n. q. 2. n. 314. pag. 743. 744.
aSocinus de off•c. •om. Christ. c. 1.
bNicolaides defe••. tract. de eccles. c 4. fol. 73. 93. 94.
All that can be said cometh to this, that Heretics should not be punished, 1. sCyprian saith to Demetrius that he was greater then his Gods, because he revenged the wrongs done to his Gods, and that it was a shame for him to hope for help from the Gods which he behooved to defend.
All that can be said commeth to this, that Hereticks should not bee punished, 1. sCyprian saith to Demetrius that hee was greater then his Gods, because he revenged the wrongs done to his Gods, and that it was a shame for him to hope for helpe from the Gods which hee behooved to defend.
sCyprian ad De[…]. Si quid […] tuis nu […] & poteslatis es•, ipsi in […] su•gent, ipsi see majestate sua defendant: pude•t te •os celere, quos ipse de sendis, pudeat tutelam ab ipsis sparare, quos tu […].Cyprian ad De〈…〉. Si quid 〈…〉 tuis nu 〈…〉 & poteslatis es•, ipsi in 〈…〉 su•gent, ipsi se majestate sua defendent: pude•t te •os celere, quos ipse de sendis, pudeat tutelam ab ipsis sparare, quos tu 〈…〉.
Answ. This proveth that the false Gods of Demetrius were but false Gods, because they were not able to revenge the wrongs done to themselves, as the true God, who made the heaven and the earth, can do, but nothing against the punishing of the Heretics, for then it should follow, that blasphemy against the holy Ghost, and no sins should be punished, for all sins are injuries done to God, and therefore neither Magistrates, nor parents, nor doctors, yea nor the Church should use any rod, either corporal or spiritual, against subjects, children, or scandalous persons, because God can revenge his own quarrel; yea excommunication is a revenging of a wrong done ⟨p. 359⟩to God. 2. They object the Apostles way was to watch against Heretics, Act. 20. 29. 31. and Rom. 16. 17. to eschew them, 2 Tim. 2. 25. the servant of the Lord must be gentle.
Answ. This proveth that the false Gods of Demetrius were but false Gods, because they were not able to revenge the wrongs done to themselves, as the true God, who made the heaven and the earth, can doe, but nothing against the punishing of the Hereticks, for then it should follow, that blasphemy against the holy Ghost, and no sinnes should bee punished, for all sinnes are injuries done to God, and therefore neither Magistrates, nor parents, nor doctors, yea nor the Church should use any rod, either corporall or spirituall, against subjects, children, or scandalous persons, because God can revenge his owne quarrell; yea excommunication is a revenging of a wrong done ⟨p. 359⟩to God. 2. They object the Apostles way was to watch against Hereticks, Act. 20. 29. 31. and Rom. 16. 17. to es•hew them, 2 Tim. 2. 25. the servant of the Lord must bee gentle.
Answ. This is objected by tGerardus, as also because they may be converted, Ergo, they are not to be killed, Christ would not have fire coming down from heaven to destroy the Sa[…], for afterward they were converted; but we think not any should be put to death for simple heresy, as uMus•u•us and Whittaker teach, they are to be instructed, censured, xrebuked, eschewed, but though Ananias and Sapphira might be converted, Peter strake them with death, and Paul did right in •iking Elymas the Sorcerer with blindness, Act. 13. because he laboured to turn away Sergius Paulus from the faith, these were extraordinary judgements, but yet they do well prove that where the Magistrate is armed with authority, he ought to inflict bodily punishment upon the seducing heretics, so it he done as yAugustine saith, Animo corrigendi, non vindicandi. See zBeza, aProfessors of Leiden, and what Elijah did by an extraordinary power in killing Baals Priests, that Ahab the then supreme Magistrate should have done. 3. They object that it is contrary to the meek spirit of Christ in the New Testament, that any should be punished for heresy, and that it is proper to enemies of the truth, and Antichrist so to do, as their bpractise declare. Nestorius being made Archbishop of Constantinople, said to the Emperor, I will give thee heaven O Emperor, if thou with free the earth of heretics; Dioscorus compelled, with armed soldiers, the Bishops to subscribe to the heresy of Entyches; Eud•xius the Arian obliged Valens the Arian Emperor to root out […] orthodox professors. The Turk in his Alcoran commandeth to kill all who obey not his law.
Answ. This is objected by tGerardus, as also because they may bee converted, Ergo, they are not to bee killed, Christ would not have fire comming downe from heaven to destroy the Sa〈…〉, for afterward they were converted; but wee thinke not any should be put to death for simple heresie, as uMus•u•us and Whittaker teach, they are to bee instructed, censured, xrebuked, eschewed, but though Ananias and Saphira might bee converted, Peter strake them with death, and Paul did right in •iking Elymas the Sorcerer with blindnesse, Act. 13. because he laboured to turne away Sergius Paulus from the faith, these were extraordinary judgements, but yet they doe well prove that where the Magistrate is armed with authority, hee ought to inflict bodily punishment upon the seducing hereticks, so it hee done as yAugustine saith, Animo corrigendi, non vindicandi. See zBeza, aProfessors of Leyden, and what Elias did by an extraordinary power in killing Baals Priests, that Achab the then supreme Magistrate should have done. 3. They object that it is contrary to the meeke spirit of Christ in the New Testament, that any should bee punished for heresie, and that it is proper to enemies of the truth, and Antichrist so to doe, as their bpractise declare. Nestorius being made Archbishop of Constantinople, said to the Emperour, I will give thee heaven O Emperour, if thou with free the earth of hereticks; Dioscorus compelled, with armed souldiers, the Bishops to subseribe to the heresie of Entyches; Eud•xius the Arrian obliged Valens the Arrian Emperour to root out 〈…〉 orthodox professors. The Turke in his Alcoran commandeth to kill all who obey not his law.
t[…].〈…〉.
u[…] in […] p. 13: 9〈…〉 in 〈…〉 p. 13: 9
x[…] ad Campian. pag 2▪ 4.〈…〉 ad Campian. pag 2▪ 4.
yAugustine cp•st. 47. •d […]. 50 ad […].Augustine cp•st. 47. •d 〈…〉. 50 ad 〈…〉.
zBeza de la […]. punten•. pag. 161, 162.Beza de la 〈…〉. punten•. pag. 161, 162.
aProfessors of I ciden in censur. confess. Remonst. c. 24. sect. 9.
b[…]. history. l. 12. c. 4〈…〉. histori. l. 12. c. 4
Answ. The sword is expressly given by God, Rom. 13. to Christian Magistrates, and this is not against the meekness of Christ, no more nor to deliver to Satan, or to curse and excommunicate Apostates with that great curse called Anath•ina Maranatha, 1 Cor. 16. 22. And though Heretics and Mahomet teach that Heretics, as also they teach that manslayers, adulterers, parricides should die the death, it followeth not that we are not to teach the same. Fourthly, The parable of letting ⟨p. 360⟩the Tares grow, while the day of judgement is alleged. It is true cChrysostom saith that many innocent persons are killed in the rooting out the tares by bloody wars; dChrysologus saith, Neither Matthew the publican, nor Paul should have been converted, if the Sword had been used, and Augustine eseemeth to call the tares haereticorum falsitates, and fTheophylact, Zizania sunt haereses. But I answer, Christ expoundeth the tares [Greek or Hebrew], Syriace [Greek or Hebrew] gBeza, filii illius improbi, hErasmus diaboli, the children of the devil, and Theophylact addeth, Zizania sunt h•reses, vel malae cogitationes, and Gerardus perverteth Theophylact, for he extendeth the tares not only to Heretics, but also to wicked men, to Matthew who was a publican, but not a Heretic properly. And first the field is the world of the visible Church, where the seed of the Word is sown, and it must be meant of all scandalous persons in Christs visible kingdom, so all shall be spared, and there shall neither be use of the Magistrates sword, nor of the Church discipline in the Church, as Anabaptists expone the place. 2. There should 7not so much as rebukes and threatenings been used, but wicked men should be permitted to grow, while the day of judgement, that the Angels root them out. Now it is known that the power of the word preached hath rooted out some tares, because it hath converted them. 3. Heretics are not all things which offend; the incestuous Corinthian offended also. 2. Only Heretics are not such as work iniquity, there be others also in the visible Church, as our brethren expone, Revel. 22. 15. nor are only heretics to be cast out in the furnace of fire, where there shall be weeping and gnashing of teeth. 3. Nor are only the good wheat those who are orthodox and opposite to heretics, who shall shine as the Sun in the kingdom of their father, p. 42. 43.
Answ. The sword is expressely given by God, Rom. 13. to Christian Magistrates, and this is not against the meeknesse of Christ, no more nor to deliver to Satan, or to curse and excommunicate Apostats with that great curse called Anath•ina Maranatha, 1 Cor. 16. 22. And though Hereticks and Mahomet teach that Hereticks, as also they teach that manslayers, adulterers, paricides should die the death, it followeth not that we are not to teach the same. Fourthly, The parable of letting ⟨p. 360⟩the Tares grow, while the day of judgement is alleaged. It is true cChrysostome saith that many innocent persons are killed in the rooting out the tares by bloody warres; dChrysologus saith, Neither Matthew the publican, nor Paul should have beene comerted, if the Sword had beene used, and Augustine eseemeth to call the tares haereticorum falsitates, and fTheophylact, Zizania sunt haereses. But I answer, Christ exponeth the tares 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Syriace 〈non-Latin alphabet〉gBeza, filii illius improbi, hErasmus diaboli, the children of the devill, and Theophylact addeth, Zizania sunt h•reses, vel malae cogitationes, and Gerardus perverteth Theophylact, for he extendeth the tares not onely to Hereticks, but also to wicked men, to Matthew who was a publican, but not a Heretick properly. And first the field is the world of the visible Church, where the seed of the Word is sowne, and it must bee meaned of all scandalous persons in Christs visible kingdome, so all shall bee spared, and there shall neither bee use of the Magistrates sword, nor of the Church discipline in the Church, as Anabaptists expone the place. 2. There should 7
7Deus non per•ittit haeretico be llis consumi similiter neque propter mal•s cogitatienes vult Deus exscindi hominem: si Mattheus excisus esset ex hac vita, cum esset zizanium, simul etiam excisum esset fr•nent•n quod postea ex ipso erat oriturum.
except we would say that all sound in the faith and holding no heretical doctrine shall shine in the firmament as the Sun. 4. The casting out of Heretics out of the visible Church by excommunication is a rooting of them out of the field of the visible Church; Let more of this be seen and considered in those who have written thereof, as in G• rardus, loc. cit. Beza de puniend. Haeret. Bellarm. de laicis, c. 21. Costerus Enchirid. de mori•us haereticor. Pelr. Gregorius, lib. 12. de repub. c. 4. ⟨p. 361⟩Suarez. de tripl. virtut. theolog. disp. 18. sect. 2. Gregorius de Valent. […]. 3. disp. l. q. 10. punc. 6. Jus Canonicum C. Quid autem. dist. 49. Meiser. lib. 4. de legibus, sect. 1. •. 10, 11, 12. Lipsius l. 4. […]. c. 2. Co••d B•unus, l. 3. de haeretic. c. 13. Paulus Windeck. lib. de exs•irpandis haeretic.
except wee would say that all sound in the faith and holding no hereticall doctrine shall shine in the firmament as the Sun. 4. The casting out of Hereticks out of the visible Church by excommunication is a rooting of them out of the field of the visible Church; Let more of this be seen and considered in those who have written thereof, as in G• rardus, loc. cit. Beza de puniend. Haeret. Bellarm. de laicis, c. 21. Costerus Enchirid. de mori•us haereticor. Pelr. Gregorius, lib. 12. de repub. c. 4. ⟨p. 361⟩Suarez. de tripl. virtut. theolog. disp. 18. sect. 2. Gregorius de Valent. 〈…〉. 3. disp. l. q. 10. punc. 6. Jus Canonicum C. Quid autem. dist. 49. Meiser. lib. 4. de legibus, sect. 1. •. 10, 11, 12. Lipsius l. 4. 〈…〉. c. 2. Co••d B•unus, l. 3. de haeretic. c. 13. Paulus Windeck. lib. de exs•irpandis haeretic.
We still hold (as is already said) that Christian Magistrates cannot compel Pagans to embrace the Christian faith. Nor can the Church in a Church-way compel Pagans or Jews coming to remain amongst us Christians, because Pagans are to be gathered to a Church, by the preaching of the Word, and by that way that the Apostles planted Churches, which was by the sword of the Spirit only, as Matth. 28. 19, 20. 1 Cor. 2. 1. 2. 2 Cor. 10. 4, 5, 6. But the argument which the aJesuit Tannerus, & other Papists bring for it, I judge most weak, for they will not have them compelled to the faith, because, 1. faith is a voluntary and free act, 2. because it is a supernatural work of God, and so they are not under the stroke of the Magistrates sword; for freewill in supernatural acts is alike uncogible and free from all external violence, in both those who are baptized professors within the bosom of the visible Church, and in Pagans; and the truth is, neither the Magistrate nor the Church can censine opinions, even erroneous in fundamental points, as they are opinions; for no society, no humane authority can either judge of, or punish the internal acts of the mind, because as such they are indeed ⟨p. 362⟩offensive to God, but not offensive or scandalous to either Church or Commonwealth, and so without the Sphere of all humane coercive power: nor is Titus, Tit. 1. To rebuke gainsayers, v. 9. that they may be sound in the faith, v. 13. but in so far as that faith is visible, and as it cometh out of perverse mouths, which must be stopped, v. 11. Also punishments either civill or ecclesiastical do no other ways work upon the mind and heart, but by a moral & swasory influence, for it is a palpable contradiction, that freewill can physically be compelled, & therefore here (saith bPhilip Gamacheus) there is no need of an Emperors sword, but of a Fishers Angle. Let it go then, which is taught as a truth, 3in this point, by cCovarruvias, (e) Gregori. de Valent. eGamacheus, fTannerus, gMalderus, that Princes have neither from the Law of nature, or from any divine Law, a coercive power over the faith of Pagans; nor is hScotus in this to be heard, that the same divine law obligeth all Princes, and the Churches, that did lie upon Israel to destroy the Canaanites.
WEe still hold (as is already said) that Christian Magistrates cannot compell Pagans to embrace the Christian faith. Nor can the Church in a Church-way compell Pagans or Jewes comming to remaine amongst us Christians, because Pagans are to bee gathered to a Church, by the preaching of the Word, and by that way that the Apostles planted Churches, which was by the sword of the Spirit only, as Matth. 28. 19, 20. 1 Cor. 2. 1. 2. 2 Cor. 10. 4, 5, 6. But the argument which the aJesuit Tannerus, & other Papists bring for it, I judge most weake, for they will not have them compelled to the faith, because, 1. faith is a voluntary and free act, 2. because it is a supernaturall worke of God, and so they are not under the stroake of the Magistrates sword; for freewill in supernaturall acts is alike uncogible and free from all externall violence, in both those who are baptized professors within the bosome of the visible Church, and in Pagans; and the truth is, neither the Magistrate nor the Church can censine opinions, even erronious in fundamentall points, as they are opinions; for no societie, no humane authoritie can either judge of, or punish the internall acts of the mind, because as such they are indeed ⟨p. 362⟩offensive to God, but not offensive or scandalous to either Church or Commonwealth, and so without the Spheare of all humane coercive power: nor is Titus, Tit. 1. To rebuke gainesiyers, v. 9. that they may be sound in the faith, v. 13. but in so farre as that faith is visible, and as it commeth out of perverse mouthes, which must be stopped, v. 11. Also punishments either civill or ecclesiasticall do no other wayes worke upon the mind and heart, but by a morall & swasory influence, for it is a palpable contradiction, that freewil can physically be compelled, & therefore here (saith bPhilip Gamacheus) there is no need of an Emperours sword, but of a Fishers Angle. Let it goe then, which is taught as a truth, 3in this point, by cCovarruvias, (e) Gregori. de Valent.
aTannerus, 22. • 10 7 87.
bPhil. Gamachaeus come. in 12. q. 10. c. 3. Non hic opus gladio imperatoris, sed hamo piscatoris.Phil. Gamachaeus com. in 12. q. 10. c. 3. Non hic opus gladio imperatoris, sed hamo piscatoris.
3(a) Quicunque et l. haeretic•. et l. Manichei God. de haeretic. as Tertullian in Scorpiac. c. 2. haeetict compelli debent, non alli ci, et duritia vincenda, non suadenda; which saith, that heretics are otherwise to be dealt with then those who never embraced the Christian faith.(a) Quicunque et l. haeretic•. et l. Manichei God. de haeretic. as Tertullian in Scorpiac. c. 2. haeetict compelli debent, non alli ci, et duritia vincenda, non suadenda; which saith, that hereticks are otherwise to be delt with then those who never imbraced the Christian faith.
Socinus and Ostorodius say it is an old precept not to shed blood, and never retracted in the New Testament, and God licenced it to the Jewes, because he promised to them an earthly kingdome, which hee hath not now promised under the New Testament. Our Divines hold ringleading and seducing hereticks are to bee punished to death, for so
gCateches. Ra•cov•ens. de proph. Mun. I. Christi c. 1. f. 136.
hSmal•ius […]. disp. 7. pig. 241. acute ejus•nadi d•lectio est quae interficere ali u•n permit•• et jubet.Smal•ius 〈…〉. disp. 7. pig. 241. acut• ejus•nadi d•lectio est quae interficere ali u•n permit•• et jubet.
iv•d. Socin. in defens. sent V••es. p. • Raccoviensi adversus Jac. Paeleol. de mag. p •n pag. 1 fol. 13.
kBeza. […]. de […] is a magist. puniend. advers Martin ••lling vol. 1. •pus pag. 85. & se•.Beza. 〈…〉. de 〈…〉 is a magist. puniend. advers Ma•tin ••lling vol. 1. •pus pag. 85. & se•.
lJunius advers. […]. edit. Heidelbu•. an. 15 91. p. 40.Junius advers. 〈…〉. edit. Heidelbu•. an. 15 91. p. 40.
mBucanus loc. come. 49.Bucanus loc. com. 49.
nZanchius, 10. 2. m•s•. de […].Zanchius, 10. 2. m•s•. de 〈…〉.
oPerkias. in cath•l. reformat. convo. 21. c. 2. pag. 367.
rProfesso. Leiden •s c•nsa Re non. c: 24 sect. 9.Professo. Leyden •s c•nsa Re non. c: 24 sect. 9.
not so much as rebukes and threatnings beene used, but wicked men should bee permitted to grow, while the day of judgement, that the Angels root them out. Now it is knowne that the power of the word preached hath rooted out some tares, because it hath converted them. 3. Hereticks are not all things which offend; the incestuous Corinthian offended also. 2. Onely Hereticks are not such as worke iniquitie, there bee others also in the visible Church, as our brethren expone, Revel. 22. 15. nor are onely hereticks to be cast out in the furnace of fire, where there shall bee weeping and gnashing of teeth. 3. Nor are onely the good wheat those who are orthodox and opposite to hereticks, who shall shine as the Sunne in the kingdome of their father, p. 42. 43.