A57969:2038
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the…
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
5. Let us take one point not fundamental, to wit this, (Every congregation hath absolute power of Church government within it self, without subjection to Classes, Presbyteries, and Synods) You are ⟨p. 370⟩so persuaded of the truth of this, that your present judgement and practice is no binding Law to you, for the morrow; but you leave room in your judgement to believe, to morrow, the contradicent, when new light shall appear. Well then to morrow, this non-fundamentall, and this contradicent is now to you true, (No congregation hath absolute power of Church-government within it self, but hath its power in dependence upon, and with subjection unto Classes, Presbyteries, and Synods.) Well, to morrow is come, and this you believe now to be Gods truth, yet so, as your present judgement, and practice is no binding Law to you, for the second morrow, but you leave room for light, which shall appear the second morrow; well, in the second morrow, new light appeareth and convinceth you, that the contradicent is true, and you recur in a circle, to believe your first proposition again is true, to wit, the contradicent of your second days proposition, and now to you this is true, as it was once, (Every congregation hath absolute power of Church-government within it self, without subjection to classes, Presbyteries, and Synods:) Now, on the third morrow, a new light appearing, you are to believe the contradicent; and because all circular motions are in credit to be deemed eternal, and your mind is always obliged to stoop and fall down before new light, and the conscience is to render her self captive to every emergent truth: what can you here say but there is no end of fluctuations and doubtings? But you say, Gods spirit, the revealer of all truth, doth not fluctuate, though I change, God Jehovah changeth not, he can reveal no contradictory truths, for one of them must be a lie, and he is the Lord who cannot lie.
5. Let us take one point not fundamentall, to wit this, (Every congregation hath absolute power of Church government within it selfe, without subjection to Classes, Presbyteries, and Synods) You are ⟨p. 370⟩so perswaded of the truth of this, that your present judgement and practice is no binding Law to you, for the morrow; but you leave roome in your judgement to beleeve, to morrow, the contradicent, when new light shall appeare. Well then to morrow, this non-fundamentall, and this contradicent is now to you true, (No congregation hath absolute power of Church-government within it selfe, but hath its power in dependance upon, and with subjection unto Classes, Presbyteries, and Synods.) Well, to morrow is come, and this you beleeve now to be Gods truth, yet so, as your present judgement, and practice is no binding Law to you, for the second morrow, but you leave roome for light, which shall appeare the second morrow; well, in the second morrow, new light appeareth and convinceth you, that the contradicent is true, and you recurre in a circle, to beleeve your first proposition againe is true, to wit, the contradicent of your second dayes proposition, and now to you this is true, as it was once, (Every congregation hath absolute power of Church-government within it selfe, without subjection to classes, Presbyteries, and Synods:) Now, on the third morrow, a new light appearing, you are to beleeve the contradicent; and because all circular motions are in credit to be deemed eternall, and your mind is alwayes obliged to stoop and fall downe before new light, and the conscience is to render her selfe captive to every emergent truth: what can you here say but there is no end of fluctuations and doubtings? But you say, Gods spirit, the revealer of all truth, doth not fluctuate, though I change, God Jebovah changeth not, he can reveale no contradictory truths, for one of them must be a lie, and he is the Lord who cannot lie.