A57969:2058
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the…
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
4. I desire that these two obligations of conscience be carefully kept in mind; hence I say, that conscience carrying the former obligation of Gods Law, from which formally the action hath its lawfulness, and in an eccentric and irregular discrepance from which, it hath its unlawfulness, it doth not oblige me to the action, because it is conscience simply; for when it offereth an action to me as lawful, which in very deed, and a part rei, in it self is unlawful, I am not obliged to that unlawful action: for as God hath given to no ruler made of clay, any royal power to be a tyrant and to destroy, where as his office is as a father to save and govern; so hath not God given to conscience any power to oblige me to sins; yea and conscience remaineth conscience, when it representeth forged and illegal mandates under the notion of things good, ⟨p. 381⟩even when men love to go to hell by reason, yet in that false representation conscience is not Gods deputy; therefore though if a man judge some doctrines to be errors, though they be in themselves truths, to him that so judgeth they are errors, yet are these truths not to be rejected simpliciter and absolutely, by him who judgeth so, any they are to be rejected [Greek or Hebrew], in some respect as they come in under the notion and garments of errors; & also, if any suffer death for an error which in conscience he conceiveth to be truth, that error is to him truth. Distinguo: it is to him truth, that is; he conceiveth and dreameth that it is truth; that is most true: but to him it is truth, that is, it ought to be believed by him as truth, and practised as lawful; that is most false: for it ought to be rejected both in point of belief, and in point of practise, and the erroneous opinion thereof should be rejected, and therefore if he receive it as truth, and profess it, and die for it, he dieth not for righteousness sake, but he dieth for error, and for the dreams of his own head, and so is not blessed as one who dueth for righteousness; for this vain reason saith, 1. that it is no sin for the mind to believe a lie, to be a divine truth: and it is righteousness upon the belief, whereby I believe a lie to be a truth, to suffer for a lie under the notion of a truth. Both these are false:
4. I desire that these two obligations of conscience bee carefully kept in mind; hence I say, that conscience carrying the former obligation of Gods Law, from which formally the action hath its lawfulnesse, and in an eccentrick and irregular discrepance from which, it hath its unlawfulnesse, it doth not obliege mee to the action, because it is conscience simply; for when it offereth an action to mee as lawfull, which in very deed, and a parte rei, in it selfe is unlawfull, I am not oblieged to that unlawfull action: for as God hath given to no ruler made of clay, any royall power to bee a tyrant and to destroy, where as his office is as a father to save and governe; so hath not God given to conscience any power to obliege me to sinnes; yea and conscience remaineth conscience, when it representeth forged and illegall mandates under the notion of things good,