A57969:2165
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the…
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Because the judgement of private discretion, common to all Christians, is due to the King as a Christian, not as a King: but the cognition that the King is to take of heresy and blasphemy, whether it be heresy or blasphemy, that the Church ••• •eth heresy and blasphemy, is due to the King as King, because he is a civill Judge therein, and if the Church should call Christs doctrine blasphemy, Caesar and his deputy Pontius Pilate, as Judges civill, are to judge it truth. Neither would I ••i•••ly here contend; for whether the Kings knowledge of heresy in the major proposition be judicial, or the knowledge of discretion only, as some say, we agree in this against Papist•, that the King is not a blind servant to the Church, to punish what the Church calleth heresy, without any examination or trial▪ but though the Kings knowledge of heresy in the proposition and in Law, be judicial and kingly, yet because he is to cognosce only in so far as he is to compel and punish ⟨p. 430⟩with the sword, not by instructing and teaching. It would not hence follow that he is to make Church constitutions as King, but only that he may punish those who maketh wicked constitutions, because the Canon maker is a ministerial teacher, the King as King may command that he teach truth, and he may punish heretical teaching, but as King he is not a teacher, either in Synod or Senate, in Pulpit or on the Throne; now if the King by office ordain Pastors, and deprive them, by office he is to know who are able to teach others, a•d must be able also to stop the mouths of the adversaries, and to rebuke them sharply, that they may be sound in the faith, and this is required in Titus, Ch. 1. 5 9, 10, 11, 12, 13. as a Pastor, and as an ordainer of other Pastors; therefore that which is required of a Pastor by his office, must also be required to be in the King by his office.
Because the judgement of private discretion, common to all Christians, is due to the King as a Christian, not as a King: but the cognition that the King is to take of heresie and blasphemy, whether it bee heresie or blasphemy, that the Church eth heresie and blasphemy, is due to the King as King, because hee is a civill Judge therein, and if the Church should call Christs doctrine blasphemy, Caesar and his deputie Pontius Pilat, as Judges civill, are to judge it truth. Neither would I ily here contend; for whether the Kings knowledge of herese in the major proposition bee judiciall, or the knowledge of discretion onely, as some say, wee agree in this against Papist, that the King is not a blind servant to the Church, to punish what the Church calleth heresie, without any examination or tryall but though the Kings knowledge of heresie in the proposition and in Law, bee judiciall and kingly, yet because hee is to cognosce onely in so farre as hee is to compell and punish