A57969:2183
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. 2 Chron. 8. 13. for so had David the man of God commanded, the man of God is the Prophet of God, not the King of ⟨p. 424⟩Israel as King, 2 Chron. 29. 25. and he set the Levites in the house of God with Cymbals and psalteries and •arpes according to the commandment of David, and of Gad the Kings Seer, and N•uh•n the Prophet, for so was the commandment of the Lord by his Prophets; they may prove then God the Prophet is the head of the Church, and hath power to make Church-Laws. But it is a great mistake. H••••iah, David, Solomon, commanded the people and the levites to do their duties according to Gods Word. Ergo, Kings may make Church-constitutions by a mixed power, it followeth in no so••; we deny not but the King may command in Gods worship, what is already of clear and evident divine institution, but that he may obtrude it, as a thing to be observed, by all Church men, and urge it, as a constitution come from authority, to b•e observed under the pain of ecclesiastical censures, we deny: now this formalists teach, that he may command in the external government, as a Church constitution to be in his royal name executed, by Church men with Church censures, though the Church never heard of it before.
Answ. 2 Chron. 8. 13. for so had David the man of God commanded, the man of God is the Prophet of God, not the King of ⟨p. 424⟩Israel as King, 2 Chron. 29. 25. and hee set the Levites in the house of God with Cymba's and psalteries and •arpes according to the commandement of David, and of Gad the Kings Seer, and N•uh•n the Prophet, for so was the commandement of the Lord by his Prophets; they may prove then God the Prophet is the head of the Church, and hath power to make Church-Lawes. But it is a great mistake. H••••iah, David, Solomon, commanded the people and the •evites to doe their duties according to Gods Word. Ergo, Kings may make Church-constitutions by a mixt power, it followeth in no so••; wee deny not but the King may command in Gods worship, what is already of cleare and evident divine institution, but that hee may obtrude it, as a thing to bee observed, by all Church men, and urge it, as a constitution come from authoritie, to b•e observed under the paine of ecclesiasticall censures, wee deny: now this formalists teach, that hee may command in the externall government, as a Church constitution to bee in his royall name executed, by Church men with Church censures, though the Church never heard of it before.
It is true that Jehoshaph •t, 2 Chron. 19 8, 9, 10, 11. set of the Levites and Priests, and the chief of the fathers of Israel, for the judgement of the Lord, and for controversies—and charged them, to do in the fear of the Lord, v. 11. and behold Amariah the chief Priest (saith he) is over you in all the matters of the Lord▪ and Zebadiah the son of Ismael, the ruler of the house of Judah, for all the Kings matters; also the Levites shall be officers before you; deal c•• ra•iously, and the Lord shall be with the good. Hence doth T•oker and other court parasites infer, 1. That the King constituting Levites, and Priests in a City, must be head of the Church, and 2. That Jehoshaph at having constitute two Vicars and Deputies under him, one in Church matters, to wit, Amariah, another in civill matters, to wit, Zebadiah, therefore hath the King a jurisdiction and headship in both Church and State.
It is true that Jehoshaph •t, 2 Chron. 19 8, 9, 10, 11. set of the Levites and Priests, and the chiefe of the fathers of Israel, for the judgement of the Lord, and for controversies—and charged them, to doe in the feare of the Lord, v. 11. and behold Amariah the chie•e Priest (saith hee) is over you in all the matters of the Lord▪ and Zebadiah the sonne of Ismael, the ruler of the house of Judah, for all the Kings matters; also the Levites shall bee officers before you; deale c•• ra•iously, and the Lord shall bee with the good. Hence doth Toker and other court parasites inferre, 1. That the King constituting Levites, and Priests in a Citie, must bee head of the Church, and 2. That Jehoshaph at having constitute two Vicars and Dputies under him, one in Church matters, to wit, Amariah, another in civill matters, to wit, Zebadiah, therefore hath the King a jurisdiction and headship in both Church and State.
Answer 1. The institution of Priests is one thing, and the calling of the persons to the Office another▪ the former was Gods due, who himself chose the tribe of Levi, and this the King did not. But it is another thing to constitute Priests and Levites, who were instituted and called of God, to serve in such a place at Jerusalem, rather then in any other place; this ⟨p. 441⟩is but to apply a person, who is jure divine, by Gods right in office, to such places and times. This is not a point of Ecclesiastical jurisdiction, for placing and timing Preachers belongeth to the people calling them, and in the time of Apostasy, as this was, Jehoshaphat sent Levites to teach, and commanded them to do their duty; but that the High Priest is the Kings Deputy or Vicar, as if the King offered sacrifices to God, as the principal and Church head, or by the Ministry and service of Amariah, as his instrument, deputy and servant, is most idly, and untruly spoken. Yet will I not use the argument of Be•anus the Jesuit, who saith, If Amariah was the Kings Vicar, then may the King by himself sacrifice, for what ever the Vicar o• deputy may d•e, that may the person above him, who giveth him power, d•e without the Vicar. The Kings royal commandment is formally terminated upon the quality and manner of Ecclesiastical acts, that they be done according to Gods Law, rather then upon the acts according to their substance.
Answer 1. The institution of Priests is one thing, and the calling of the persons to the Office another▪ the former was Gods due, who himselfe chused the tribe of Levi, and this the King did not. But it is another thing to constitute Priests and Levites, who were instituted and called of God, to serve in such a place at Jerusalem, rather then in any other place; this ⟨p. 441⟩is but to apply a person, who is jure divine, by Gods right in office, to such places and times. This is not a point of Ecclesiastical jurisdiction, for placing and timing Preachers belongeth to the people calling them, and in the time of Apostasy, as this was, Jehoshaphat sent Levites to teach, and commanded them to do their duty; but that the High Priest is the Kings Deputy or Vicar, as if the King offered sacrifices to God, as the principall and Church head, or by the Ministry and service of Amariah, as his instrument, deputy and servant, is most idly, and untruely spoken. Yet will I not use the argument of Beanus the Jesuite, who saith, If Amariah was the Kings Vicar, then may the King by himselfe sacrifice, for what ever the Vicar o deputy may de, that may the person above him, who giveth him power, de without the Vicar. The Kings royall commandement is formally terminated upon the quality and manner of Ecclesiasticall acts, that they bee done according to Gods Law, rather then upon the acts according to their substance.
It *is one thing for Ministers to Preach sound Doctrine, and administrate the Sacraments in obedience, and at the Kings commandment, which we acknowledge a truth, and another thing for Ministers to Preach in the name and authority of royal Majesty, as having a calling from him: this latter is false: as the King may do an act of justice, at the direction of a Minister, commanding him in Gods name to execute judgement impartially: yet the King doth not an act of justice in the name and authority of the Church. And that is true which Be•anus saith, What the instrument doth, the principal cause may do, where the Vicar or Deputy, and the principal substitut•r of the Vicar are both civill persons, or are both Ecclesiastical persons, for in a large and unproper sense, the nurse is a sort of deputy under the nurse father, the Father may take care that the nurse give milk, and wholesome milk to his child, yet cannot the Father give milk himself. The King may take care, actu imperato, as one intending, in a Kingly way, that Christs body be edified, that the Priests and Prophets feed with knowledge, the Church and sister of Christ, and so are the Priests under the King, and at his command to feed, and to feed with wholesome food the flock, and in obedience to the ⟨p. 442⟩King all are to do their duty, and his care is universal over all, and his end universal. That which is the end of Pastors, Doctors, Elders, Deacons, Lawyers, Judges, &c. is, in an universal intention, the Kings end, even Gods honour, by p•• curing in a regal way, that all do their duty in keeping the two Tables of the Law, and so is he the great politic wheel moving by his royal motions, all the under wheels toward that same end: yet cannot the King without sin, and being like a Bird wandering from her nest, do that which is properly Pastoral, so that the Office is not subordinate to him, but immediately from God, yet are the operations of the Office, and to Preach tali modo, diligently sound Doctrine subordinate to him, but in a general and universal way, as he is a kingly mover of all, to keep the two Tables of the Law. Neither did the King (as aSuarez saith) one and the same way appoint both the High Priest and the civill Judge.
And bCajetan saith, he decerneth the two chief heads of Church and Common-wealth, but he appointed not both, for God appointed Amariah, to be High Priest, and not the King, but here is nothing to prove the Kings headship.
And bCajetan saith, he decerneth the two chiefe heads of Church and Common-wealth, but hee appointed not both, for God appointed Amariah, to bee High Priest, and not the King, but here is nothing to prove the Kings headship.
Asa reformed the Church and renewed the Covenant; Hezekiah reformed Religion also, and brake in pieces the Brazen Serpent, and all these in the case of universal apostasy, and the corruption of the Priest-hood did reform the Lords house, break in pieces graven Images, but all this giveth to them no mixed Ecclesiastical power of making Canons, of ordaining and depriving Pastors.
Asa reformed the Church and renewed the Covenant; Ezekia• reformed Religion also, and brake in peeces the Brazen Serpent, and all these in the case of universall apostasie, and the corruption of the Priest-hood did reforme the Lords house, breake in peeces graven Images, but all this giveth to them no mixt Ecclesiasticall power of making Canons, of ordaining and depriving Pastors.
Whereas some object, That the care both of temporal good, and spiritual good, belongeth to the Magistrate, therefore, he must have a power to make Church Laws. See cPareus. For his care cannot be supreme, if he must rule at the nod and beck of Church-men.
Whereas some object, That the care both of temporall good, and spirituall good, belongeth to the Magistrate, therefore, hee must have a power to make Church Laws. See cPareus. For his care cannot bee supreme, if hee must rule at the nod and beck of Church-men.
I Answer, the connection is weak: he who hath the care of both the temporal and spiritual good of the people, he hath a nomothetic power to procure both these two goods, it followeth no way, for then might he have a power in his own person to Preach, and administrate the Sacraments, this power procureth the spiritual good, but such as is the care, such is the power, the care is politic and civill, Ergo, the power to ⟨p. 443⟩procure the spiritual good, must be politic and civill.
I Answer, the connexion is weak: hee who hath the care of both the temporall and spirituall good of the people, hee hath a nomothetick power to procure both these two goods, it followeth no way, for then might hee have a power in his own person to Preach, and administrate the Sacraments, this power procureth the spirituall good, but such as is the care, such is the power, the care is politick and civill, Ergo, the power to ⟨p. 443⟩procure the spirituall good, must bee politick and civill.
2. Neither is the King to do all at the nod and direction of the Priesthood, blindly and without examination. That is the blind doctrine of Papists, we hold that he hath a regal power to examine, if the Decrees of the Church be just, Orthodox, and tend to edification, For he is the Minister of God, for good, and to take vengeance on evil doing. And there is no just obligation to sin, he is not obliged to punish with the sword, well-doing, but evil doing, and the Church can oblige the Magistrate to do nothing, but that which in case there were no Church Law, and in case of the Churches erring, he should do.
2. Neither is the King to do all at the nod and direction of the Priesthood, blindly and without examination. That is the blind doctrine of Papists, wee hold that hee hath a regall power to examine, if the Decrees of the Church bee just, Orthodox, and tend to edification, For hee is the Minister of God, for good, and to take vengeance on evill doing. And there is no just obligation to sinne, hee is not obliged to punish with the sword, well-doing, but evill doing, and the Church can oblige the Magistrate to do nothing, but that which in case there were no Church Law, and in case of the Churches erring, hee should doe.
2. They object, He to whom every soul is subject, he hath a power to make Church Laws, about all good: but all and every soul, without exception of Apostles, or Church-men, is subject to the civill Magistrate. Ergo. The proposition is proved from the Law of relatives, for he to […] we are subject, he may give Laws unto us, for our g••d. See dPareus.
2. They object, He to whom every soule is subject, he hath a power to make Church Laws, about all good: but all and every soule, without exception of Apostles, or Church-men, is subject to the civill Magistrate. Ergo. The proposition is proved from the Law of relatives, for he to 〈…〉 we are subject, he may give Lawes unto us, for our g••d. See dPareus.
Answ. He to whom we are subject, may give any Laws, or command any manner of way, for our good. I deny the proposition in that sense; for then he might in the Pulpit preach the Commandments of God, for our good. He might give Laws under the pain of excommunication. It is enough that he may give Laws by sanction and civill enacting of Church Laws, and pressing us by the power of the Sword, to do our duty, for the attaining of a spiritual good. He to whom we are subject, he may give Laws, that is press, in a coactive way, obedience to Laws, that is most true, but it proveth not a nomothetic power in the King.
Answ. He to whom we are subject, may give any Lawes, or command any manner of way, for our good. I deny the proposition in that sense; for then he might in the Pulpit preach the Commandements of God, for our good. He might give Laws under the paine of excommunication. It is enough that he may give Laws by sanction and civill enacting of Church Laws, and pressing us by the power of the Sword, to doe our duty, for the attaining of a spirituall good. He to whom we are subject, he may give Laws, that is presse, in a coactive way, obedience to Laws, that is most true, but it proveth not a nomothetick power in the King.
3. They object, What ever agreeth to the Kingly power concerning the good of Subjects, by the Law of Nations, that doth far more agreeth Kings by the Law of God. For the Law of God doth not desir […] •e Law of Nations. But by the law of Nations, a care […] Religion belong th to the King, for Religion by the Law of nature is ind••ed and brought in by the Law of Nations. As eCicero saith. And therefore to a Christian Kingly power, the care of Religion must be due.
3. They object, What ever agreeth to the Kingly power concerning the good of Subjects, by the Law of Nations, that doth farre more agreeth Kings by the Law of God. For the Law of God doth not desir 〈…〉 •e Law of Nations. But by the law of Nations, a care 〈…〉 Religion belong th to the King, for Religion by the Law of nature is ind••ed and brought in by the Law of Nations. As eCicero saith. And therefore to a Christian Kingly power, the care of Religion must be due.
Answer: we grant all, for a care in a civill and politic way belongeth to the Christian Prince, but a care by any mean whatsoever, ⟨p. 444⟩by Preaching, or by making Church Canons, is not hence proved by no light of nature, or Law of Nations, in an ecclesiastical care of Religion due to the Christian Prince, but only in a politic and civill way.
Answer: we grant all, for a care in a civill and politick way belongeth to the Christian Prince, but a care by any meane whatsoever, ⟨p. 444⟩by Preaching, or by making Church Canons, is not hence proved by no light of nature, or Law of Nations, in an ecclesiasticall care of Religion due to the Christian Prince, but onely in a politick and civill way.
4. All believers, even private men, may judge of Religion, not only by a judgement of apprehension, but also of discretion, to try what 1Religion is true, and to be holden, and what is false, and to be rejected. Ergo, far more may the Christian Magistrate definitively judge of Religion, so he do it by convenient means, such as are sound and holy Divines, and the rule of Gods word. The consequence is proved, because the faithful Prince hath supreme power, which is n• mothetick, and a power to make Laws.
4. All beleevers, even private men, may judge of Religion, not onely by a judgement of apprehension, but also of discretion, to try what 1Religion is true, and to be holden, and what is false, and to be rejected. Ergo, farre more may the Christian Magistrate definitively judge of Religion, so he doe it by convenient meanes, such as are sound and holy Divines, and the rule of Gods word. The consequence is proved, because the faithfull Prince hath supreame power, which is n• mothetick, and a power to make Lawes.
It *is one thing for Ministers to Preach sound Doctrine, and administrate the Sacraments in obedience, and at the Kings commandement, which wee acknowledge a truth, and another thing for Ministers to Preach in the name and authority of royall Majesty, as having a calling from him: this latter is false: as the King may do an act of justice, at the direction of a Minister, commanding him in Gods name to execute judgement impartially: yet the King doth not an act of justice in the name and authority of the Church. And that is true which Be•anus saith, What the instrument doth, the principall cause may do, where the Vicar or Deputy, and the principall substitut•r of the Vicar are both civill persons, or are both Ecclesiasticall persons, for in a large and unproper sense, the nurse is a sort of deputy under the nurse father, the Father may take care that the nurse give milke, and wholsom milke to his child, yet cannot the Father give milke himself. The King may take care, actu imperato, as one intending, in a Kingly way, that Christs body bee edifyed, that the Priests and Prophets feed with knowledge, the Church and sister of Christ, and so are the Priests under the King, and at his command to feed, and to feed with wholsome food the flocke, and in obedience to the ⟨p. 442⟩King all are to do their duty, and his care is universall over all, and his end universall. That which is the end of Pastors, Doctors, Elders, Deacons, Lawyers, Judges, &c. is, in an universall intention, the Kings end, even Gods honor, by p•• curing in a regall way, that all do their duty in keeping the two Tables of the Law, and so is hee the great politick wheel moving by his royall motions, all the under wheeles toward that same end: yet cannot the King without sinne, and being like a Bird wandring from her nest, do that which is properly Pastorall, so that the Office is not subordinate to him, but immediately from God, yet are the operations of the Office, and to Preach tali modo, diligently sound Doctrine subordinate to him, but in a generall and universall way, as hee is a kingly mover of all, to keep the two Tables of the Law. Neither did the King (as aSuarez saith) one and the same way appoint both the High Priest and the civill Judge.