A57969:2194
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. They object, He to whom every soul is subject, he hath a power to make Church Laws, about all good: but all and every soul, without exception of Apostles, or Church-men, is subject to the civill Magistrate. Ergo. The proposition is proved from the Law of relatives, for he to […] we are subject, he may give Laws unto us, for our g••d. See dPareus.
2. They object, He to whom every soule is subject, he hath a power to make Church Laws, about all good: but all and every soule, without exception of Apostles, or Church-men, is subject to the civill Magistrate. Ergo. The proposition is proved from the Law of relatives, for he to 〈…〉 we are subject, he may give Lawes unto us, for our g••d. See dPareus.
Answ. He to whom we are subject, may give any Laws, or command any manner of way, for our good. I deny the proposition in that sense; for then he might in the Pulpit preach the Commandments of God, for our good. He might give Laws under the pain of excommunication. It is enough that he may give Laws by sanction and civill enacting of Church Laws, and pressing us by the power of the Sword, to do our duty, for the attaining of a spiritual good. He to whom we are subject, he may give Laws, that is press, in a coactive way, obedience to Laws, that is most true, but it proveth not a nomothetic power in the King.
Answ. He to whom we are subject, may give any Lawes, or command any manner of way, for our good. I deny the proposition in that sense; for then he might in the Pulpit preach the Commandements of God, for our good. He might give Laws under the paine of excommunication. It is enough that he may give Laws by sanction and civill enacting of Church Laws, and pressing us by the power of the Sword, to doe our duty, for the attaining of a spirituall good. He to whom we are subject, he may give Laws, that is presse, in a coactive way, obedience to Laws, that is most true, but it proveth not a nomothetick power in the King.
3. They object, What ever agreeth to the Kingly power concerning the good of Subjects, by the Law of Nations, that doth far more agreeth Kings by the Law of God. For the Law of God doth not desir […] •e Law of Nations. But by the law of Nations, a care […] Religion belong th to the King, for Religion by the Law of nature is ind••ed and brought in by the Law of Nations. As eCicero saith. And therefore to a Christian Kingly power, the care of Religion must be due.
3. They object, What ever agreeth to the Kingly power concerning the good of Subjects, by the Law of Nations, that doth farre more agreeth Kings by the Law of God. For the Law of God doth not desir 〈…〉 •e Law of Nations. But by the law of Nations, a care 〈…〉 Religion belong th to the King, for Religion by the Law of nature is ind••ed and brought in by the Law of Nations. As eCicero saith. And therefore to a Christian Kingly power, the care of Religion must be due.
Answer: we grant all, for a care in a civill and politic way belongeth to the Christian Prince, but a care by any mean whatsoever, ⟨p. 444⟩by Preaching, or by making Church Canons, is not hence proved by no light of nature, or Law of Nations, in an ecclesiastical care of Religion due to the Christian Prince, but only in a politic and civill way.
Answer: we grant all, for a care in a civill and politick way belongeth to the Christian Prince, but a care by any meane whatsoever, ⟨p. 444⟩by Preaching, or by making Church Canons, is not hence proved by no light of nature, or Law of Nations, in an ecclesiasticall care of Religion due to the Christian Prince, but onely in a politick and civill way.
4. All believers, even private men, may judge of Religion, not only by a judgement of apprehension, but also of discretion, to try what 1Religion is true, and to be holden, and what is false, and to be rejected. Ergo, far more may the Christian Magistrate definitively judge of Religion, so he do it by convenient means, such as are sound and holy Divines, and the rule of Gods word. The consequence is proved, because the faithful Prince hath supreme power, which is n• mothetick, and a power to make Laws.
4. All beleevers, even private men, may judge of Religion, not onely by a judgement of apprehension, but also of discretion, to try what 1Religion is true, and to be holden, and what is false, and to be rejected. Ergo, farre more may the Christian Magistrate definitively judge of Religion, so he doe it by convenient meanes, such as are sound and holy Divines, and the rule of Gods word. The consequence is proved, because the faithfull Prince hath supreame power, which is n• mothetick, and a power to make Lawes.
Answer: it is true, all private believers may try the Spirits, whether they be of God or not: but hence we may as well conclude, therefore Princes may preach and administer the Sacraments, as therefore the Prince may define matters ecclesiastical. For a eivill coactive power giveth to no man an ecclesiastical power, except he be called thereunto, as Aaron was. 2. The means alleged are the judgement of holy and pious Divines, and the word of God, but Moses whom they allege for a pattern of a civill ruler, who had a nomothetic power in Church matters, used not the advise of Divines, nor the rule of the written word, but as a Prophet immediately inspired of God, gave Laws to Gods people, and prescribed a Law to Aaron, and to the Priest-hood. Now if rulers have such a power of defining Laws, they need not follow the rule of Gods word. But how shall they prove that Moses gave the Law to the people and the Priesthood, as a King, and not as the Prophet of God, inspired immediately of God? For if Moses his Law came from the ordinary power of Kings, as it is such, then cometh Moses Law from a Spirit which may err, for the ordinary Spirit to Kings, is not infallible, but with reverence to Kings, obnoxious to erring. God save our King.
Answer: it is true, all private beleevers may try the Spirits, whether they be of God or not: but hence we may as well conclude, therefore Princes may preach and administer the Sacraments, as therefore the Prince may define matters ecclesiasticall. For a eivill coactive power giveth to no man an ecclesiasticall power, except he be called thereunto, as Aaron was. 2. The meanes alleadged are the judgement of holy and pious Divines, and the word of God, but Moses whom they alleadge for a patterne of a civill ruler, who had a nomothetick power in Church matters, used not the advise of Divines, nor the rule of the written word, but as a Prophet immediately inspired of God, gave Lawes to Gods people, and prescribed a Law to Aaren, and to the Priest-hood. Now if rulers have such a power of defining Lawes, they neede not follow the rule of Gods word. But how shall they prove that Moses gave the Law to the people and the Priesthood, as a King, and not as the Prophet of God, inspired immediately of God? For if Moses his Law came from the ordinary power of Kings, as it is such, then commeth Moses Law from a Spirit which may erre, for the ordinary Spirit to Kings, is not infallible, but with reverence to Kings, obnoxious to erring. God save our King.
5. It is a Princes part by office to defend Religion, and to banish false Religion, and to root out blasphemies and heresies. Ergo, he ought 1to know and judge by his office of all these. But if he be to use the sword at the nod only of the Church, without knowledge or judgement, he is the executioner and lictor of the Church, not a civill Judge.
5. It is a Princes part by office to defend Religion, and to banish false Religion, and to roote out blasphemies and heresies. Ergo, he ought 1to know and judge by his office of all these. But if he be to use the sword at the nodde onely of the Church, without knowledge or judgement, he is the executioner and lictor of the Church, not a civill Judge.
Answ. In a Church right constitute, we are to suppose, that the Laws of Synods are necessary and edificative, and that the Magistrate is obliged by his office to add his sanction to them not by an unfolded faith, and as blind; but he is to try them, not only by the judgement of discretion, as a Christian, (for so all Christians are to try them) but also (saving the judgement of some Learned) by a judicial cognition, as he trieth civill crimes, which he is to punish: but his judicial cognition is only in relation to his practise, as a Judge, to authorize these Laws, with his coactive power, not to determine truth in an ecclesiastical way, under the pain of Church censures. Neither do I believe, that the Magistrate is not subordinate to the Kingdom of Christ, as mediator, but subordinate to God as Creator only. Though some Divines teach, that there should have been Kings and supreme Powers in the world, though man had never fallen in sin, and a Saviour had never been in the World, and so that Kings are warranted by the Law of nature, and Nations, and not by any Law evangelic and mediatory: yet we think with reverence, this argument not strong, for generation and creation and multiplication of mankind should have been in the World, though never a sinner nor a Saviour thould have been in the world, yet are creation, generation and multiplication of mankind, by our divines, Junius, Trekatius, Gomaras, Calvin, Beza, Melanchthon, Polanus, Rollocus, and many others, and with warrant of the word of God, made means subordinate to the execution of the decree of predestination to Glory, which decree is executed in Christ, as the mean and meritorious cause of salvation purchased in his blood. What heathen Magistrates as Magistrates know not Christ the Mediator; Ergo, they are not means subordinate to Christs Mediatory Kingdom. It followeth not. For by Christ the wisdom of God, Kings do reign, though many of them know him not. As they are created by Christ, as the second person of the Trinity, though they know not the second person of the Trinity. It is their sin that they know him not.
Answ. In a Church right constitute, we are to suppone, that the Lawes of Synods are necessary and edificative, and that the Magistrate is obliged by his office to adde his sanction to them not by an unfolded faith, and as blind; but he is to try them, not onely by the judgement of discretion, as a Christian, (for so all Christians are to try them) but also (saving the judgement of some Learned) by a judiciall cognition, as he tryeth civill crimes, which he is to punish: but his judiciall cognition is onely in relation to his practise, as a Judge, to authorize these Lawes, with his coactive power, not to determine truth in an ecclesiasticall way, under the paine of Church censures. Neither doe I beleeve, that the Magistrate is not subordinate to the Kingdome of Christ, as mediator, but subordinate to God as Creator onely. Though some Divines teach, that there should have beene Kings and supreme Powers in the world, though man had never fallen in sinne, and a Saviour had never beene in the World, and so that Kings are warranted by the Law of nature, and Nations, and not by any Law evangelick and mediatory: yet we thinke with reverence, this argument not strong, for generation and creation and multiplication of mankind should have beene in the World, though never a sinner nor a Saviour thould have beene in the world, yet are creation, generation and multiplication of mankind, by our divines, Junius, Trekatius, Gomaras, Calvin, Beza, Melancthon, Polanus, Rollocus, and many others, and with warrant of the word of God, made meanes subordinate to the execution of the decree of predetination to Glory, which decree is executed in Christ, as the meane and meritorious cause of salvation purchased in his blood. What heathen Magistrates as Magistrates know not Christ the Mediator; Ergo, they are not means subordinate to Christs Mediatory Kingdome. It followeth not. For by Christ the wisedome of God, Kings doe reigne, though many of them know him not. As they are created by Christ, as the second person of the Trinity, though they know not the second person of the Trinity. It is their sinne that they know him not.
2. It is objected. The Magistrate is not given to the Church under the New Testament, by the calling of Christ, as an exalted Saviour, as all the gifts instituted for the government of the mediatory Kingdom are instituted for that end, Ephes. 4. 11. but it is instituted by ⟨p. 446⟩God, as governor of the World, rewarding good and ill, Rom. 13. 1.
2. It is objected. The Magistrate is not given to the Church under the New Testament, by the calling of Christ, as an exalted Saviour, as all the gifts instituted for the government of the mediatory Kingdome are instituted for that end, Ephes. 4. 11. but it is instituted by ⟨p. 446⟩God, as governer of the World, rewarding good and ill, Rom. 13. 1.
6. Answ. Neither is creation a gift of Christ as exalted mediator, therefore it is not a mean leading to the possession of that life purchased by the mediators blood, it followeth not. For the Magistracy is a nurse-father of the redeemed spouse of Christ with the sincere milk of the word. I mean a formal mean procuring, by a coactive power, that the Church shall be fed, and it procureth not only the Churches peace, which respecteth the second Table of the Law, but also godliness, which respecteth the first Table of the Law, 1 Tim. 2. 2. and Ephes. 4. 11. there be reckoned down only officers, which actibus elicitis, by formal elicit acts, procureth the intended end of Christs mediatory Kingdom. Not all the offices which procureth edification any way. Such as is in civill Governors, who are to see that the body of Christ be nourished, and grow in godliness, for that is an essential and specific act of the Churches nurse-father.
6. Answ. Neither is creation a gift of Christ as exalted mediator, therefore it is not a meane leading to the possession of that life purchased by the mediators bloud, it followeth not. For the Magistracy is a nurse-father of the redeemed spouse of Christ with the sincere milke of the word. I meane a formall meane procuring, by a coactive power, that the Church shall be fed, and it procureth not onely the Churches peace, which respecteth the second Table of the Law, but also godlinesse, which respecteth the first Table of the Law, 1 Tim. 2. 2. and Ephes. 4. 11. there be reckoned downe onely officers, which actibus elicitis, by formall elicit acts, procureth the intended end of Christs mediatory Kingdome. Not all the offices which procureth edification any way. Such as is in civill Governours, who are to see that the body of Christ be nourished, and grow in godlinesse, for that is an essentiall and specifick act of the Churches nurs-father.
3. It is objected. Magistracy compelleth men to the observance of Gods Law, Deut. 17. and doth not immediately, of it self, by spiritual gifts of the evangel, produce its effects. But all the mediatory Kingdom of Christ and the Government thereof, of its self and its own nature, produceth the saving effects of the evangel, by virtue of its institution, as faith, repentance, and salvation.
3. It is objected. Magistracy compelleth men to the observance of Gods Law, Deut. 17. and doth not immediately, of it selfe, by spirituall gifts of the evangell, produ•e its effects. But all the mediatory Kingdome of Christ and the Government thereof, of its selfe and its owne nature, produceth the saving effects of the evangel•, by vertue of its institution, as faith, repentance, and salvation.
Answ. A Magistracy as a Magistracy, of it self concurreth, but in a coactive way, for producing of peace, honesty, and godliness, and serveth to edification: but I grant, not in such a spiritual way, as a Church-ministry, therefore it is not a mean subservient to the end of Christs mediatory Kingdom. It followeth not. It is not a spiritual mean. Ergo, it is not a mean. The consequence is null, and it is false, that all the means of Christs mediatory Kingdom are of their own nature spiritual, for that is to beg the question, for the Magistrate procureth that the Church be fed, he punisheth blasphemers, that others may fear, and so abstain, and so be edified, though the way be coactive, yet is it a way and mean appointed of God, as the nurse-father is a mean for the child's nourishing, though the nurse-breasts be a more subordinate mean, immediate mean.
Answ. A Magistracy as a Magistracy, of it selfe concurreth, but in a coactive way, for producing of peace, honesty, and godlinesse, and serveth to edification: but I grant, not in such a spirituall way, as a Church-ministry, therefore it is not a meane subservient to the end of Christs mediatory Kingdome. It followeth not. It is not a spirituall meane. Ergo, it is not a meane. The consequence is null, and it is false, that all the meanes of Christs mediatory Kingdome are of their owne nature spirituall, for that is to begge the question, for the Magistrate procureth that the Church be fed, he punisheth blasphemers, that others may feare, and so abstaine, and so be edified, though the way be coactive, yet is it a way and meane appointed of God, as the nurse-father is a meane for the childs nourishing, though the nurse-breasts be a more subordinate meane, immediate meane.
4. It is objected. The Magistrate is not the Lords Ambassador and minister in name of the Mediator Christ, as the Minister is, but it is extron call to the government of Christs Mediatory Kingdom, and […] help only to those things, which concern the external man.
4. It is objected. The Magistrate is not the Lords Ambassadour and minister in name of the Mediator Christ, as the Minister is, but it is extron •call to the government of Christs Mediatory Kingdome, and 〈…〉 helpe onely to those things, which concerne the externall man.
Answ. He who is called God, and so is the vicegerent of God, is Gods Ambassador politic commanding in Gods name, but in another way then a preaching Ambassador commandeth: and though Christ as Mediator, may attain to his end without the King, as many were edified in the Apostolic Church where the civill Magistrate contributed no help, and was rather an enemy to the kingdom of Christ, and so Magistracy may be called accidental to Christs mediatory government: but if this be a good argument to prove that Magistracy is not subordinate to Christs mediatory kingdom, then Ecumenical and provincial Synods consisting only of Church men shall be no means subordinate to Christs kingdom, because Christs kingdom may subsist in one Congregation, without a provincial assembly, and circumcision is no mean subordinate to that kingdom in the Jewish Church, because that mediatory kingdom subsisted forty years in the Jewish Church in the Wilderness without circumcision; yea and Apostles and Evangelists are no means subordinate to that kingdom, because Christs mediatory kingdom subsisteth now without these officers. 2. Neither is it true that magistracy conferreth no help to this kingdom, but in these things which concern the external man, for in a politic and coactive way, the Magistracy taketh care by commandments, that the Church be fed with the pure Word of God; only this proveth that magistracy, and Church ministry have two different objects, and the way of proceeding of these two states, the one carnal and with the sword, Joh. 18. 36. Rom. 13. 3, 4. the other spiritual, to the manifestation of the truth to the conscience, 2 Cor. 4. 1, 2. Psal. 110. 1. 2. Es•y 11. 4. Heb. 4. 12. which we grant to be true.
Answ. Hee who is called God, and so is the vicegerent of God, is Gods Ambassador politick commanding in Gods name, but in another way then a preaching Ambassador commandeth: and though Christ as Mediator, may attaine to his end without the King, as many were edified in the Apostolick Church where the civill Magistrate contributed no helpe, and was rather an enemy to the kingdome of Christ, and so Magistracy may bee called accidentall to Christs mediatory government: but if this bee a good argument to prove that Magistracie is not subordinate to Christs mediatory kingdome, then Oecumenicall and provinciall Synods consisting onely of Church men shall be no meanes subordinate to Christs kingdome, because Christs kingdome may subsist in one Congregation, without a provinciall assembly, and circumcision is no meane subordinate to that kingdome in the Jewish Church, because that mediatory kingdome substisted fortie yeeres in the Jewish Church in the Wildernesse without circumcision; yea and Apostles and Evangelists are no meanes subordinate to that kingdome, because Christs mediatory kingdome subsisteth now without these officers. 2. Neither is it true that magistracie conferreth no helpe to this kingdom, but in these things which concerne the externall man, for in a politick and coactive way, the Magistracy taketh care by commandements, that the Church bee fed with the pure Word of God; onely this proveth that magistracie, and Church ministery have two different objects, and the way of proceeding of these two states, the one carnall and with the sword,
5. It is objected, Christ himself performed all the parts of his mediatory kingdom, and all the functions thereof, in his own person, and by his disciples, while he was on earth; but he refused all civill Magistracy, and did inhibit his disciples thereof, because it is not contained ⟨p. 448⟩under the administration of his mediatory office, as subordinate thereunto.
5. It is objected, Christ himselfe performed all the parts of his mediatory kingdome, and all the functions thereof, in his owne person, and by his disciples, while hee was on earth; but hee refused all civill Magistracy, and did inhibit his disciples thereof, because it is not contained ⟨p. 448⟩under the administration of his mediatory office, as subordinate thereunto.
Answ. Christ refused magistracy, not because it is not subordinate to edification, which is the end of Christs mediatory kingdom, but because it is not compatible with his spiritual kingdom, in one and the same person, and therefore this is a caption, à non causa pro causa, in one and the same person and subject; the civill and the Ecclesiastical power are inconsistent and incompatible, that is true. Ergo, in the kind of lawful means these two powers are unconsistent and uncompatible. I deny it to follow, for both royal power and Church power concur for the producing of one and the same end, to wit, edification and obedience to both Tables of the Law, but after different ways, carnal and spiritual. *I think it most considerable that though the Prince may by a coactive way, command that same which a Church Synod may command in an ecclesiastical way, yet differeth these same powers in their formal objects, because the King commandeth that which is good, religious, decent in Gods worship as a thing already taught and determined judicially, either expressly in Gods Word, or then by a pastoral or Synodical determination, and that not by way of teaching, informing the mind, exponing the Scripture, or by pastoral dealing with the conscience, as obliging to a Church Liturgy, and ceremonies, as one who intendeth formal edification and faith, repentance, and obedience to God; but the King commands that which is good and extra, as it is already taught, and expounded, and as it is an imperated act of external worship, or mercy and justice done by a coactive power.
Answ. Christ refused magistracie, not because it is not subordinate to edification, which is the end of Christs mediatory kingdome, but because it is not compatible with his spirituall kingdome, in one and the same person, and therefore this is a caption, à non causa pro causa, in one and the same person and subject; the civill and the Ecclesiasticall power are inconsistent and incompatible, that is true. Ergo, in the kind of lawfull meanes these two powers are unconsistent and uncompatible. I deny it to follow, for both royall power and Church power concurre for the producing of one and the same end, to wit, edification and obedience to both Tables of the Law, but after different wayes, carnall and spirituall. *I thinke it most considerable that though the Prince may by a coactive way, command that same which a Church Synod may command in an ecclesiasticall way, yet differeth these same powers in their formall objects, because the King commandeth that which is good, religious, decent in Gods worship as a thing already taught and determined judicially, either expressely in Gods Word, or then by a pastorall or Synodicall determination, and that not by way of teaching, informing the mind, exponing the Scripture, or by pastorall dealing with the conscience, as oblieging to a Church Liturgie, and ceremonies, as one who intendeth formall edification and faith, repentance, and obedience to God; but the King commands that which is good and extra, as it is already taught, and expounded, and as it is an imperated act of externall worship, or mercy and justice done by a coactive power.