A57969:2209
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. Christ refused magistracy, not because it is not subordinate to edification, which is the end of Christs mediatory kingdom, but because it is not compatible with his spiritual kingdom, in one and the same person, and therefore this is a caption, à non causa pro causa, in one and the same person and subject; the civill and the Ecclesiastical power are inconsistent and incompatible, that is true. Ergo, in the kind of lawful means these two powers are unconsistent and uncompatible. I deny it to follow, for both royal power and Church power concur for the producing of one and the same end, to wit, edification and obedience to both Tables of the Law, but after different ways, carnal and spiritual. *I think it most considerable that though the Prince may by a coactive way, command that same which a Church Synod may command in an ecclesiastical way, yet differeth these same powers in their formal objects, because the King commandeth that which is good, religious, decent in Gods worship as a thing already taught and determined judicially, either expressly in Gods Word, or then by a pastoral or Synodical determination, and that not by way of teaching, informing the mind, exponing the Scripture, or by pastoral dealing with the conscience, as obliging to a Church Liturgy, and ceremonies, as one who intendeth formal edification and faith, repentance, and obedience to God; but the King commands that which is good and extra, as it is already taught, and expounded, and as it is an imperated act of external worship, or mercy and justice done by a coactive power.
Answ. Christ refused magistracie, not because it is not subordinate to edification, which is the end of Christs mediatory kingdome, but because it is not compatible with his spirituall kingdome, in one and the same person, and therefore this is a caption, à non causa pro causa, in one and the same person and subject; the civill and the Ecclesiasticall power are inconsistent and incompatible, that is true. Ergo, in the kind of lawfull meanes these two powers are unconsistent and uncompatible. I deny it to follow, for both royall power and Church power concurre for the producing of one and the same end, to wit, edification and obedience to both Tables of the Law, but after different wayes, carnall and spirituall. *I thinke it most considerable that though the Prince may by a coactive way, command that same which a Church Synod may command in an ecclesiasticall way, yet differeth these same powers in their formall objects, because the King commandeth that which is good, religious, decent in Gods worship as a thing already taught and determined judicially, either expressely in Gods Word, or then by a pastorall or Synodicall determination, and that not by way of teaching, informing the mind, exponing the Scripture, or by pastorall dealing with the conscience, as oblieging to a Church Liturgie, and ceremonies, as one who intendeth formall edification and faith, repentance, and obedience to God; but the King commands that which is good and extra, as it is already taught, and expounded, and as it is an imperated act of externall worship, or mercy and justice done by a coactive power.
Hence the Magistrates power is not to edify formally, but to procure that edification may be. 2. The Magistrates power is Lordly, the Churches power is only ministerial. 3. The Magistrates power may be in one, to wit, in the King, the Churches power of the keys is in the Church. 4. They differ in formal objects, as hath been said.
Hence the Magistrates power is not to edifie formally, but to procure that edification may bee. 2. The Magistrates power is Lordly, the Churches power is onely ministeriall. 3. The Magistrates power may bee in one, to wit, in the King, the Churches power of the keyes is in the Church. 4. They differ in formall objects, as hath been said.
Now to obviate what the Jesuit Lysimachus Nicanor saith, we are no ways of Papists mind in the matter of the Magistrates power, for Papists, 1. exclude Kings and Emperors ⟨p. 449⟩from any meddling with Church matters. Charles the fifth was upbraided by Paul the third, the Pope of Rome, because he did, as became a Prince, ordain meetings, conferences, and assemblies for composing of differences in Churches matters, not giving the power of convening councils, only to the Pope, acomparing his fact to the attempt of Uzzah, who put his hand to the Ark, and to C•rah, Dathan and Abirams conspiracy against Moses; yea and bNicolaus the first in his Epistle to Michael the Emperor, denieth that Emperors are to be present in Synods, except in general Synods, where both Church men and laics are present: we teach that the Magistrate is as the hand, the ministry as the eyes, and both are to concur for the spiritual good of the body of Christ.
Now to obviate what the Jesuite Lysimachus Nicanor saith, wee are no wayes of Papists mind in the matter of the Magistrates power, for Papists, 1. exclude Kings and Emperours ⟨p. 449⟩from any medling with Church matters. Charles the fift was upbraided by Paul the third, the Pope of Rome, because hee did, as became a Prince, ordaine meetings, conferences, and assemblies for composing of differences in Churches matters, not giving the power of conveening councells, onely to the Pope, acomparing his fact to the attempt of Uzzah, who put his hand to the Ark, and to C•rah, Dathan and Abirams conspiracie against Moses; yea and bNicolaus the first in his Epistle to Michael the Emperour, denyeth that Emperours are to bee present in Synods, except in generall Synods, where both Church men and laicks are present: wee teach that the Magistrate is as the hand, the ministry as the eyes, and both are to concurre for the spirituall good of the body of Christ.
2. Papists will have the Magistrates so to defend the faith, as they have not power to judge, not as Christians with the judgement of discretion what is right, or wrong, but they must, as blind servants, execute what Prelates decree, yea and see (non pr•priis (saith cHenr. Blyssemius) sed alienis Episcoporum ac p•aelatorum suorum oculis videre) not with their own eyes, but with the eyes of their Prelates, yea and the Magistrate should not read the Scripture, (say Papists and Nican•rs brethren the Jesuits) expressly contrary to Gods Word, Deut. 17. 17. He shall read in the book of the Law, all the days of his life, Joshua 1. 8. but only believe as the Church believeth, and this is blind obedience that they require of Princes; this faith or obedience we think abominable in all men, as in Princes.
2. Papists will have the Magistrates so to defend the faith, as they have not power to judge, not as Christians with the judgement of descretion what is right, or wrong, but they must, as blind servants, execute what Prelates decree, yea and see (non pr•priis (saith cHenr. Blyssemius) sed alienis Episcoporum ac p•aelatorum suorum oculis videre) not with their owne eyes, but with the eyes of their Prelates, yea and the Magistrate should not read the Scripture, (say Papists and Nican•rs brethren the Jesuits) expresly contrary to Gods Word,
Of old, Popes and Prelates were subject to Kings and Emperors, as we teach from the Word of God, Rom. 13. 1. and 1. we teach against the Jesuit Lysimachus Nicanor, that his Prelates should not invade the King and civill Magistrates sword, and be civill Judges, as Popes and Prelates are; against which writeth aTertullian, bOrigen, cHilarius dChrysostom, eAmbrosius, fAugustinus; The gauthor of the Survey ⟨p. 450⟩saith, that if every Eldership be the tribunal seat of Christ, what appellation can be made there from to either provincial or general council? and he meaneth, that there can be no appellation to the King, seeing the Presbytery in Churches causes is as immediately subject to Jesus Christ, and the highest Judicature on earth, as the King is Gods immediate vicegerent on earth, nearest to Jesus Christ, in civill causes.
Of old, Popes and Prelates were subject to Kings and Emperors, as wee teach from the Word of God, Rom. 13. 1. and 1. wee teach against the Jesuit Lysimachus Nicanor, that his Prelates should not invade the King and civill Magistrates sword, and be civill Judges, as Popes and Prelates are; against which writeth aTertullian, bOrigen,
I answer: the cause that is merely ecclesiastical, as the formal act of preaching and ecclesiastical determining of truth in Pulpits, and the determining the truth in Church assemblies, in an ecclesiastical way in Synods, and the excommunicating of a scandalous person, are immediately subject to Jesus Christ, speaking in his own perfect Testament: and these causes lie not at the feet of Princes to be determined by them, as Kings, but in a constitute Church they are to be determined by the ordinary Church assemblies, and in this place there is no appeal from the Presbytery to a King; but it followeth not, that there can be no appellation from a Presbytery to a provincial, or to a national assembly; 1. Because though every Presbytery be the tribunal seat of Christ, yet it is but a part of the tribunal seat of Christ, and such a part as may easily err, and therefore appellation may be made from the weaker, and the part more inclined to err, to the stronger and maniest, or the whole, who may more hardlier err: and that is not denied by this author, who dare not deny, but they may appeal from a Bishop who doth, and may mislead souls, and empty purses, to a Metropolitan, and an Archbishop, who is as dexterous and happy in emptying of poor mens purses, and destroying souls, if not large better, as a petty Lord Prelate, from whom he appealed; yet is the one Lord Prelate the Vicar of Christ, as well as the other, by formalists books. And, 2. If the cause be proper to the Presbytery, they have just right to judge it, as well as the provincial assembly hath, but possibly not such knowledge, and if the party complain that he is wronged, or may be wronged, he may well appeal to a larger part of Christs tribunal, less obnoxious to erring, which is no wrong done to the Presbytery. This man laboureth to make a division amongst our Divines, because we know ⟨p. 451⟩not whether to make our Pastors, Doctors, and Elders immediate[…] to Christ, as Priests, because then they are Priests of the New Testament, or subject to Christ, as King, and then all our officers shall […] Kings, under Christ, and the Christian Magistrate shall be so thrust out of his kingdom and chair. And the ignorant railer maketh much ado in this matter, but the truth is stronger then this Popish scribbler; for 1.
I answer: the cause that is meerely ecclesiasticall, as the formall act of preaching and ecclesiasticall determining of truth in Pulpits, and the determining the truth in Church assemblies, in an ecclesiasticall way in Synods, and the excommunicating of a scandalous person, are immediatly subject to Jesus Christ, speaking in his owne perfect Testament: and these causes lie not at the feet of Princes to bee determined by them, as Kings, but in a constitute Church they are to bee determined by the ordinary Church assemblies, and in this place there is no appeale from the Presbytery to a King; but it followeth not, that there can bee no appellation from a Presbytery to a provinciall, or to a nationall assembly; 1. Because though every Presbytery bee the tribunall seate of Christ, yet it is but a part of the tribunall seat of Christ, and such a part as may easily erre, and therefore appellation may bee made from the weaker, and the part more inclined to erre, to the stronger and maniest, or the whole, who may more hardlier erre: and that is not denied by this author, who dare not deny, but they may appeal from a Bishop who doth, and may misleade soules, and emptie purses, to a Metropolitan, and an Archbishop, who is as dexterous and happy in emptying of poore mens purses, and destroying soules, if not large better, as a pettie Lord Prelate, from whom hee appealed; yet is the one Lord Prelate the Vicar of Christ, as well as the other, by formalists bookes. And, 2. If the cause bee proper to the Presbytery, they have just right to judge it, as well as the provinciall assembly hath, but possibly not such knowledge, and if the partie complaine that hee is wronged, or may bee wronged, hee may well appeale to a larger part of Christs tribunall, lesse obnoxious to erring, which is no wrong done to the Presbyterie. This man laboureth to make a division amongst our Divines, because we know
as Christ is a Priest having a body to offer for the sins of the people, and a real Sacrifice, our Divines deny that Christ hath any substitute and demie Priests under him, or master Priests to offer sacrifices real to God: if this Author put any Priests under Christ in this meaning, he is upon an unbloody Mass-sacrifice, much good do it him; if hFenner make this prophetical office of Christ a part of Christs Priesthood, because the Priest was to teach the people, Matth. 2. 7. Hos. 4. 6. and iAbraham Henrick say the same, there is no absurd to make the officers of the New Testament subordinate to Christ, as to our high Priest teaching us Gods will, not to Christ as our high Priest offering a bloody or a real sacrifice to God, & this Author maketh much ado to cite kCartwright, lFenner, mBez••, nand Sonnius, men whose books he is not worthy to bear, making the officers of Christs kingdom subordinate to Christ as King, for as much as Christ as King prescribed the form of ecclesiastical government, and then saith the poor man othe Pastors under Christ •• King must be all Emperors, the Doctors Kings, the Elders Dukes, the Deacons Lords of the treasury, &c. and if they be Christs immediate vicegerents, within their own Kingdoms, who shall control any of them, on whithot shall an injured man appeal? Answ. 1. We 8are to bless God that these Officers, Pastors, Doctors, Elders & Deacons are expressly in the Word of God, and that this railers officers, to wit, Bishops, Archbishops, Metropolitans, Primates, Deans, Archdeanes, officials, &c. are in no place of Christs testament, only they are in the Popes Mass book: now if the man offend, because
nor are our officers little Kings under Christ, (for the man cannot hold of the sent of a Lord Bishop) but mere ministers and servants, and the Ambassadors of the King of Kings, who have no power to make laws, as if they were little Kings, but are to propound Christs laws; he is ignorant of Christs kingdom, for the officers of the New Testament are under Christ as their King; Ergo, they are under him as little deputy Kings to make Laws, as Judges earthly are under those whose kingdom is of this world, Joh. 18. 36. the man is both beside his book, and his wit, to infer this; Christ hath no Popes nor visible substitute Kings under him, but under him are mere servants and heralds.
nor are our officers little Kings under Christ, (for the man cannot hold of the sent of a Lord Bishop) but meere ministers and servants, and the Ambassadors of the King of Kings, who have no power to make lawes, as if they were little Kings, but are to propound Christs lawes; hee is ignorant of Christs kingdome, for the officers of the New Testament are under Christ as their King; Ergo, they are under him as little deputie Kings to make Lawes, as Judges earthly are under those whose kingdome is of this world, Joh. 18. 36. the man is both beside his booke, and his wit, to infer this; Christ hath no Popes nor visible substitute Kings under him, but under him are meere servants and heralds.
4. We are far from holding, that one Church man such as the Pope may excommunicate Kings; Gregorius the second excommunicated the Emperor Leo, and Gregorius the seventh, alias wicked Hildebrand, excommunicated Henry the fourth; Christ hath committed the power of excommunication to the whole Church, 1 Cor. 5. 4. Matth. 18. 17, 18. and therefore Lysimachus Nicanor cannot but side with Papists in laying this power upon one Prelate, as the Kings substitute, or rather the Popes Vicar.
4. Wee are farre from holding, that one Church man such as the Pope may excommunicate Kings; Gregorius the second excommunicated the Emperour Leo, and Gregorius the seventh, alias wicked Hildebrand, excommunicated Henry the fourth; Christ hath committed the power of excommunication to the whole Church, 1 Cor. 5. 4. Matth. 18. 17, 18. and therefore Lysimachus Nicanor cannot but side with Papists in laying this power upon one Prelate, as the Kings substitute, or rather the Popes Vicar.
5. We do not teach that the Pope or any Church man may dethrone Kings, and alienate their crowns to others. Gregory the first in a certain decree saith, Kings and Judges, who contraveneth the constitution of the Sea of Rome, are to be deprived of her honour; Gregory the second having excommunicated the Emperor Leo, discharged the Italians to pay him tribute, and that ⟨p. 453⟩because Leo was against the worshipping of Images; See pHaiminsfieldius, and qArniseus, and rBaleus saith the Pope drew the subjects of this Leo Isaurus, in apertam rebellionem, to […] rebellion, and so the Emperors of the east were deprived of the kingdom of Italy, per sanctissimum diabolum, by a most holy devil: Pope Zachariah, (not the Prophet) deprived Childericus King of France of his kingdom, and procured that Pipinus the father of Charles the great, should be created King, so saith sBaleus also.
5. Wee doe not teach that the Pope or any Church man may dethrone Kings, and alienate their crownes to others. Gregory the first in a certaine decree saith, Kings and Judges, who contr•veneth the constitution of the Sea of Rome, are to bee deprived of her honour; Gregory the second having excommunicated the Emperour Leo, discharged the Italians to pay him tribute, and that ⟨p. 453⟩because Leo was against the worshipping of Images; See pHaiminsfieldius, and qArniseus, and rBaleus saith the Pope drew the subjects of this Leo Isaurus, in apertam rebellionem, to rebellion, and so the Emperors of the east were deprived of the kingdome of Italy, per sanctissimum diabolum, by a most holy devill: Pope Zachariah, (not the Prophet) deprived Childericus King of France of his kingdome, and procured that Pipinus the father of Charles the great, should bee created King, so saith
Let the third transferred the Empire from the Grecians to the Romans, and by the hand of Pope Leo (saith Sigebertus) Charles was crowned; See for this tShardius. Gregorius the fifth being the brother germane of Otho the Emperor, made a Law that the Emperor should be chosen by seven Princes electors, which fact weakened the majesty of the Empire, which went before by inheritance, hence An. 1350. Charles the fourth, that his son might succeed him in the Empire, laid in pledge the free Cities of the Empire, in the hands of the Prince electors, which to this day are not redeemed. So did the Pope shake the Empire, at his own will. Gregory the third began, and Leo the third finished the devise of erecting a new Empire in the West, and weakened the power of the Emperor of Constantinople.
Let the third transferred the Empire from the Grecians to the Romans, and by the hand of Pope Leo (saith Sigebertus) Charles was crowned; See for this tShardius. Gregorius the fift being the brother germane of Otbo the Emperour, made a Law that the Emperour should bee chosen by seven Princes electors, which fact weakned the majestie of the Empire, which went before by inheritance, hence An. 1350. Charles the fourth, that his sonne might succeed him in the Empire, laid in pledge the free Cities of the Empire, in the hands of the Prince electors, which to this day are not redeemed. So did the Pope shake the Empire, at his owne will. Gregory the third began, and Leo the third finished the devise of erecting a new Empire in the West, and weakned the power of the Emperour of Constantinople.
Gregorius the seventh, alias graceless Hildebrand, deprived Henry the fourth, and created another in his place, as uSleidan and xLampadius relateth. Innocentius the third dethroned Otho the fourth: and Innocentius the fourth dethroned Frederick the second, and the like did Clemens the sixth to Lodovick the fourth, by Bellarmines own confession. No Emperors can be created but by their consent, saith the yAuthor of that learned work, Catalogue. testium veritatis. They loose the subjects from the oath of fidelity. Lodovick the fourth answering the calumnies of John the 22. zsaith it is against all Law that the Emperor hath no imperial authority and power, except he be anointed, consecrated and crowned by the Pope; he citeth their own aLaw on the contrary. That Joannes the 22. (saith the Emperor) insinuateth in his Bull, that he is universal Lord in both temporal and spiritual matters. Bonifacius the eighth setteth out a Bull against Philip the Fair, Philippus Pulcher King of France (as ⟨p. 454⟩saith bStephanus Aufrerii) and speaketh thus, that he is universal Lord of the earth in both temporal and spiritual thing• Bonifacius Episcopus servus ser•orum dei, Philippo Fr•n […] regi, deum time & mandata ejus serva, seire te volumus quod in spritualibus & temporalibus nobis su•es, benificiarum & pre•end••• ad te c•• •io nuda spectet, &c. Believe if ye will, that Constan gave to the Popes of Rome freedom and immunity from the imperial Laws, and that he gave to the Pope the territories of Rome, and the City of Rome the Seat of the Empire to be Peter the fishers patrimony, and this (say they) Constantine gave to Sylvester, which is the Patrimony of the Crown, and the very Empire it self given to Peter, we teach no such Kingly power given to Church-men, and judge this donation to be a forged lye, invented by Papists, because they are their own witnesses of this donation. For
And because those who are most diligent observers of memorable antiquities speak nothing of this donation, as neither Eusebius, nor Hieronymus, nor Augustine, nor A•brase, nor Basilius, nor Chrysostom, nor Ammianus, nor Histeri• T•ip ••tita, nor Pope Damasus in his Chronicle, nor Bede, nor Oros•us, it is but a dream, yet it is certain that three hundred years after Constantine the Emperors kept Rome, and the Townes of Italy, by their presidents and deputies, as may be seen in dJustinian. And this they did to the time of Inn•••ntius the second, as Chronicles do bear.
And because those who are most diligent observers of memorable antiquities speake nothing of this donation, as neither Eusebius, nor Hieronymus, nor Augustine, nor A•brase, nor Basilius, nor Chrysostome, nor Ammianus, nor Histeri• T•ip ••tita, nor Pope Damasus in his Chronicle, nor Beda, nor Oros•us, it is but a dreame, yet it is certaine that three hundreth veares after Constantine the Emperours keeped Rome, and the Townes of Italy, by their presidents and deputies, as may be seene in dJustini•n. And this they did to the time of Inn•••ntius the second, as Chronicles doe beare.
6. We do not teach that Church-men are loosed from the positive Laws of Emperors and Kings. Bellarmine esaith that the Magistrate can neither punish Church-men, nor convene them before the tribunall• so Innocentius the third, saith fthe Empire is not above the Pope, but the Pope is above the Empire. And Bonifacin• the eighth gsaith, all upon hazard of their salvation, are subject to the Pope of Rome, who hath the power of both ⟨p. 455⟩swords, and judgeth all and is judged by no man. Now it is known to […] Nicanor, that the Prelates of England and Scotland in their high Commission, had the power of both swords, and that by Episcopal Laws, the Primate […] all the […], and is judged by none, and who but he? and who ever spake as hSuarez? That Church-m•n […] co[…] against Princes, even to dethrone them. And as he saith, […], by divine Law the Pope is eximed from a• Laws of Princes: and shall we in this believe iBellarmine, kSato, l•••etanus, mTurrecremata, nGr•g•rius de Valent.
Agatho Bishop of Rome writing to Constantius the Emperor, calleth himself imperii famulum, a Subject of the Empire, and ⟨p. 456⟩saith, pro obedientia quam debuimus. Leo submitted himself to Lodovick the Emperor. wThe Clergy of Constantinople may be convened before the Patriarch or President of the City. See the xLaw. And yand zBishops, Clerks, Monks, &c. for criminal causes are judged by the Presidents: If a man have a suit with a Clerk, for a money matter, if the Bishop refuse to heare, tunc ad civilem judicem, &c. asay they. Sigebertus, as also bLuitprandus doth witness that the Bishops of Rome were compelled to pay a certain sum of money to the Emperors, to be confirmed in their Bishopric, even till the year 700.
Agatho Bishop of Rome writing to Constantius the Emperour, calleth himselfe imperii famulum, a Subject of the Empire, and ⟨p. 456⟩saith, pro obedientia quam debuimus. Leo submitted himselfe to Lodovick the Emperour. wThe Clergy of Constantinople may be conveened before the Patriarch or President of the City. See the xLaw. And yand zBishops, Clerks, Monkes, &c. for criminall causes are judged by the Presidents: If a man have a suit with a Clerk, for a money matter, if the Bishop resuse to heare, tunc ad civilem judicem, &c.
Leo the fourth, who is canonized by Papists as a Saint, cwriteth to Lotharius the Emperor, that they will keep the Emperors Laws for ever, and that they are liars who say the contrary. Arcadius made a Law, that if a Priest were found to be seditious and troubling the public peace, he should be banished an hundred miles from that place. But how far Popes have surpassed bounds in these; see their blasphemies. As they say dGod should not have beene discreet, nisi potestatem Pontifici super principes contulisset, except he had given power to the Pope above Princes. Also ePapam superioritatem habere in imperatorem, & vacant imperatore, imperatori succedere. Also fPapa habet utriusque potestatis, temporalis nempe & spiritualis, Monarchiam. Also gQuanto sol lunam, tanto Papa superat Imperatorem. The Pope is above the Emperor and succeedeth to the Emperors throne, when it is vacant, and he is as far above the Emperor, as the Sun is above the Moon. The Pope also (h) in the Nativity night, blesseth a Sword, and giveth it to some Prince, in sign, that to the Pope is given all power in heaven and in earth.
Leo the fourth, who is canonized by Papists as a Saint, cwriteth to Lotharius the Emperour, that they will keepe the Emperors Lawes for ever, and that they are lyars who say the contrary. Arcadius made a Law, that if a Priest were found to be seditious and troubling the publick peace, he should be banished an hundred miles from that place. But how farre Popes have surpassed bounds in these; see their blasphemies. As they say dGod should not have beene discreet, nisi potestatem Pontifici super principes contulisset, except he had given power to the Pope above Princes. Also e
as Christ is a Priest having a body to offer for the sinnes of the people, and a reall Sacrifice, our Divines deny that Christ hath any substitute and demie Priests under him, or master Priests to offer sacrifices reall to God: if this Author put any Priests under Christ in this meaning, hee is upon an unbloody Masse-sacrifice, much good doe it him; if hFenner make this propheticall office of Christ a part of Christs Priesthood, because the Priest was to teach the people, Matth. 2. 7. Hos. 4. 6. and iAbraham Henrick say the same, there is no absurd to make the officers of the New Testament subordinate to Christ, as to our high Priest teaching us Gods will, not to Christ as our high Priest offering a bloody or a reall sacrifice to God, & this Author maketh much ado to cite kCartwright, lFenner, mBez••, nand Sonnius, men whose bookes hee is not worthy to beare, making the officers of Christs kingdome subordinate to Christ as King, for as much as Christ as King prescribed the forme of ecclesiasticall government, and then saith the poore man othe Pastors under Christ •• King must bee all Emperors, the Doctors Kings, the Elders Dukes, the Deacons Lords of the treasury, &c. and if they bee Christs immediat vicegerents, within their owne Kingdomes, who shall controll any of them, on whithot shall an injured man appe•le? Answ. 1. Wee 8are to blesse God that these Officers, Pastors, Doctors, Elders & Deacons are expresly in the Word of God, and that this railers officers, to wit, Bishops, Archbishops, Metropolitans, Primats, Deanes, Archdeanes, officials, &c. are in no place of Christs testament, onely they are in the Popes Masse book: now if the man offend, because ⟨p. 452⟩they are subordinate to Christ as King, hee must make his Primates, his Metropolitans, his Diocesan Lords, his Deans, Officials, and such wild Officers, Emperours, Kings, Dukes and Lord Treasurers under Christ, for some roome these creatures must have, else they must bee put out at the Church doors, and if a man bee injured by the Primate, to whom shall hee appeale, but to some above him, a Cardinall? and if that creature be a Christ, who cannot do wrong, well and good it is, wee rest, but if hee bee a man like the rest of the world, surely poor folk must appeale to his high holines the Pope. 2. Deacons are not men of ecclesiastick authoritie in our account, but are to serve tables, Acts 6. 3.
Gregorius the seventh, alias gracelesse Hildebrand, deprived Henry the fourth, and created another in his place, as uSleidan and xLampadius relateth. Innocentius the third dethroned Otho the fourth: and Innocentius the fourth dethroned Frederick the second, and the like did Clemens the sixth to Lodovick the fourth, by Bellarmines owne confession. No Emperours can bee created but by their consent, saith the yAuthor of that learned worke, Catalog. testium veritatis. They loose the subjects from the oath of fidelitie. Lodovick the fourth answering the calumnies of John the 22. zsaith it is against all Law that the Emperour hath no imperiall authoritie and power, except hee bee anointed, con•e•rated and crowned by the Pope; he citeth their owne aLaw on the contrary. That Joannes the 22. (saith the Emperour) insinuateth in his Bull, that hee is universall Lord in both temporall and spirituall matters. Bonifacius the eighth setteth out a Bull against Philip the Faire, Philippus Pulcher King of France (as ⟨p. 454⟩saith bStephanus Aufrerii) and speaketh thus, that he is universall Lord of the earth in both temparall and spirituall thing• Bonifacius Episcopus servus ser•orum dei, Philippo Fr•n 〈…〉 regi, deum time & mandata ejus serva, seire te volumus quod in spritualibus & temporalibus nobis su•es, benificiarum & pre•end••• ad te c•• •io nuda spectet, &c. Beleeve if ye will, that Constan•••• gave to the Popes of Rome freedome and immunity from the imperiall Laws, and that he gave to the Pope the territories of Rome, and the City of Rome the Seat of the Empire to be Peter the fishers patrimony, and this (say they) Constantine gave to Silvester, which is the Patrimony of the Crowne, and the very Empire it selfe given to Peter, we teach no such Kingly power given to Church-men, and judge this donation to be a forged lye, invented by Papists, because they are their owne witnesses of this donation. For cHieronymus Pa•••us Cath•lanus, a Lawyer, and Chamberlaine to Pope Alexand•r the sixth, saith exprelly there was no such donation made by Constantine.
6. Wee doe not teach that Church-men are loosed from the positive Lawes of Emperours and Kings. Bellarmine esaith that the Magistrate can neither punish Church-men, nor conveene them before the tribunall• so Innocentius the third, saith fthe Empire is not above the Pope, but the Pope is above the Empire. And Bonifacin• the eighth gsaith, all upon hazard of their salvation, are subject to the Pope of Rome, who hath the power of both ⟨p. 455⟩swords, and judgeth all and is judged by no man. Now it is knowne to 〈…〉 Nicanor, that the Prelats of England and Scotland in their high Commission, had the power of both swords, and that by Episcopall Lawes, the Primate 〈…〉 all the 〈…〉, and is judged by none, and who but he? and who ever spake as hSuarez? That Church-m•n 〈…〉 co〈…〉 against Princes, even to detbrane them. And as he saith, 〈…〉, by divine Law the Pope is eximed from a• Laws of Princes: and shall we in this beleeve iBellarmin•, kSato, l•••etanus, mTurrecremata, nGr•g•rius de Valent. oSua•••• and then forsooth they bring us their pCanon Law to judg the Law of God, & to prove it, because it is said by their Silvester, nemo judicabit primam •dem, and their qGratian learned this jus divinum, this divine Law from Innocentius the Pope. And what they alledge for Peters exemption from paying tribute, will exime all the disciples, and so all Church-men by divine right from the Lawes of Princes. Yea all Clergy-men (say they) by a divine positive Law are eximed from the Laws of Magistrates. So saith rSuarez, sBellarmine, and tthe 〈…〉 of Rbeimes, but with neither conscience, nor reason. And contrary to their owne practise and doctrine. For Paul will have every soule subject to superiour Powers, and except the Roman Clergy want Soules, they must also be subject. Salomon punished Abiathar, Josiah burnt the bones of the Priests upon the A•tar, Christ subjected himselfe to his Parents, payed tribute to Caes•r, and commanded Scribes and Pharisces to doe the like, Matth. 22. Willing that they should give to Cesar those things which are Caesars. Paul appealed to Caesars Tribunall, and Rom. 13. as many, as may doe evill, as many, as are in danger of resisting the power, are to be subject. Rom. 13. 4. 2. but Church-men are such, therefore they are subject.