A57969:2221
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And because those who are most diligent observers of memorable antiquities speak nothing of this donation, as neither Eusebius, nor Hieronymus, nor Augustine, nor A•brase, nor Basilius, nor Chrysostom, nor Ammianus, nor Histeri• T•ip ••tita, nor Pope Damasus in his Chronicle, nor Bede, nor Oros•us, it is but a dream, yet it is certain that three hundred years after Constantine the Emperors kept Rome, and the Townes of Italy, by their presidents and deputies, as may be seen in dJustinian. And this they did to the time of Inn•••ntius the second, as Chronicles do bear.
And because those who are most diligent observers of memorable antiquities speake nothing of this donation, as neither Eusebius, nor Hieronymus, nor Augustine, nor A•brase, nor Basilius, nor Chrysostome, nor Ammianus, nor Histeri• T•ip ••tita, nor Pope Damasus in his Chronicle, nor Beda, nor Oros•us, it is but a dreame, yet it is certaine that three hundreth veares after Constantine the Emperours keeped Rome, and the Townes of Italy, by their presidents and deputies, as may be seene in dJustini•n. And this they did to the time of Inn•••ntius the second, as Chronicles doe beare.
6. We do not teach that Church-men are loosed from the positive Laws of Emperors and Kings. Bellarmine esaith that the Magistrate can neither punish Church-men, nor convene them before the tribunall• so Innocentius the third, saith fthe Empire is not above the Pope, but the Pope is above the Empire. And Bonifacin• the eighth gsaith, all upon hazard of their salvation, are subject to the Pope of Rome, who hath the power of both ⟨p. 455⟩swords, and judgeth all and is judged by no man. Now it is known to […] Nicanor, that the Prelates of England and Scotland in their high Commission, had the power of both swords, and that by Episcopal Laws, the Primate […] all the […], and is judged by none, and who but he? and who ever spake as hSuarez? That Church-m•n […] co[…] against Princes, even to dethrone them. And as he saith, […], by divine Law the Pope is eximed from a• Laws of Princes: and shall we in this believe iBellarmine, kSato, l•••etanus, mTurrecremata, nGr•g•rius de Valent.
Agatho Bishop of Rome writing to Constantius the Emperor, calleth himself imperii famulum, a Subject of the Empire, and ⟨p. 456⟩saith, pro obedientia quam debuimus. Leo submitted himself to Lodovick the Emperor. wThe Clergy of Constantinople may be convened before the Patriarch or President of the City. See the xLaw. And yand zBishops, Clerks, Monks, &c. for criminal causes are judged by the Presidents: If a man have a suit with a Clerk, for a money matter, if the Bishop refuse to heare, tunc ad civilem judicem, &c. asay they. Sigebertus, as also bLuitprandus doth witness that the Bishops of Rome were compelled to pay a certain sum of money to the Emperors, to be confirmed in their Bishopric, even till the year 700.
Agatho Bishop of Rome writing to Constantius the Emperour, calleth himselfe imperii famulum, a Subject of the Empire, and ⟨p. 456⟩saith, pro obedientia quam debuimus. Leo submitted himselfe to Lodovick the Emperour. wThe Clergy of Constantinople may be conveened before the Patriarch or President of the City. See the xLaw. And yand zBishops, Clerks, Monkes, &c. for criminall causes are judged by the Presidents: If a man have a suit with a Clerk, for a money matter, if the Bishop resuse to heare, tunc ad civilem judicem, &c.
Leo the fourth, who is canonized by Papists as a Saint, cwriteth to Lotharius the Emperor, that they will keep the Emperors Laws for ever, and that they are liars who say the contrary. Arcadius made a Law, that if a Priest were found to be seditious and troubling the public peace, he should be banished an hundred miles from that place. But how far Popes have surpassed bounds in these; see their blasphemies. As they say dGod should not have beene discreet, nisi potestatem Pontifici super principes contulisset, except he had given power to the Pope above Princes. Also ePapam superioritatem habere in imperatorem, & vacant imperatore, imperatori succedere. Also fPapa habet utriusque potestatis, temporalis nempe & spiritualis, Monarchiam. Also gQuanto sol lunam, tanto Papa superat Imperatorem. The Pope is above the Emperor and succeedeth to the Emperors throne, when it is vacant, and he is as far above the Emperor, as the Sun is above the Moon. The Pope also (h) in the Nativity night, blesseth a Sword, and giveth it to some Prince, in sign, that to the Pope is given all power in heaven and in earth.
Leo the fourth, who is canonized by Papists as a Saint, cwriteth to Lotharius the Emperour, that they will keepe the Emperors Lawes for ever, and that they are lyars who say the contrary. Arcadius made a Law, that if a Priest were found to be seditious and troubling the publick peace, he should be banished an hundred miles from that place. But how farre Popes have surpassed bounds in these; see their blasphemies. As they say
7. The Pope may loose all Subjects from their oath of Loyalty and may command that a Jesuit stab or poison a King, when he turneth enemy to the Roman Faith. All these Satan and envy it self cannot impute to our doctrine. Let L•simachus the Jesuit hear this, and see if his own little Popes, the Prelates, do not teach or aim at all these points against the Kings of the earth.
7. The Pope may loose all Subjects from their oath of Loyalty and may command that a Jesuite stabbe or poyson a King, when he turneth enemy to the Roman Faith. All these Satan and envy it selfe cannot impute to our doctrine. Let L•simachus the Jesuite heare this, and see if his owne little Popes, the Prclats, doe not teach or aime at all these points against the Kings of the earth.
IN the first article, the Author acknowledgeth the Church of England was once rightly, and orderly gathered, either by Apostles •• apostolic men, whether Philip, or Joseph of Arimathea, or Simon Zealots, as we may read in Fox, &c. So that all the work now, is not to make them Churches which were none before, but to reduce and restore them to their primitive institution.
IN the first article, the Author acknowledgeth the Church of England was once rightly, and orderly gathered, either by Apostles •• apostolick men, whether Philip, or Joseph of Arimathea, or Simon Zelotes, as we may read in Fox, &c. Sothat all the worke now, is not to make them Churches which were none before, but to reduce and restore them to their primitive institution.
Answ. Though the Churches of England were planted by the Apostles, yet since Popery universally afterward prevailed, in both England and Scotland, as Bede and Nicephorus and ancient histories witness, we think by our brethren's grounds England loosed the very essence of a true Church. So that there be need of the constituting of a new Church, and not of simple restitution to the first restitution. 1. Because the Congregations wanteth the essential constitution of right visible Churches, as you say. 2. Because you receive none coming from the Church of New-England, to the seals of the Covenant, because they are members of no visible Church.
Answ. Though the Churches of England were planted by the Apostles, yet since Popery universally afterward prevailed, in both England and Scotland, as Beda and Nicephorus and ancient histories witnesse, we thinke by our brethrens grounds England losed the very essence of a true Church. So that there be neede of the constituting of a new Church, and not of simple restitution to the first restitution. 1. Because the Congregations wanteth the essentiall constitution of right visible Churches, as you say. 2. Because you receive none comming from the Church of New-England, to the seales of the Covenant, because they are members of no visible Church.
In the third or fourth Proposition the Author condemneth Laics Patronages.
In the third or fourth Proposition the Author condemneth Laicks Patronages.
2. Dedicating of Lands to the Ministry; to these add what the Ministers of New-England say ain their answer to the thirty two Questions sent to them from Old-England, where they condemn stinted maintenance. Though the right of Church Patronages were derived from Romulus, it is not for that of noble blood. •or bDionysius Halicarnasseus saith Romulus instituted Patronages, when he had divided the people in noble and ignoble, called, Patricii & Plebeii. But this Patronage was civill, and when servants and underlings were hardly used, it hath a ground in nature, that they choose Patrons ⟨p. 458⟩to defend them, therefore he who gave liberty to a a servant, amongst the Romans was called a Patron, and che who defended the cause of the accused, as Valla saith, was called a Patron. If it be said that the servant was the proper goods, and part of the Masters patrimony, because he might sell his servant, and therefore there could be no Law given to prove men may limit the dominion of the master over the servant.
2. Dedicating of Lands to the Ministry; to these adde what the Ministers of New-England say ain their answer to the thirty two Questions sent to them from Old-England, where they condemne stinted maintenance. Though the right of Church Patronages were derived from Romulus, it is not for that of noble blood. •or bDionysius Halicarnasseus saith Romulus instituted Patronages, when he had divided the people in noble and ignoble, called, Patricii & Plebeii. But this Patronage was civill, and when servants and underlings were hardly used, it hath a ground in nature, that they choose Patrons ⟨p. 458⟩to defend them, therefore hee who gave libertie to a a servant, amongst the Romans was called a Patron, and
I answer; the servant was a part of his masters patrimony, but a part thereof for sin, not as his Ox or his Ass, is a part of his patrimony; therefore by the Law of nature, whereby the weaker imploreth help of the stronger, as the Lamb seeketh help from the mother, and the young Eagle from the old, the slave might well have liberty to choose a Patron, and this is a ground that the Magistrate the Churches nurse-father by office should plead the Churches cause, as her Patron, and every one in power is to defend the Church in her liberties and patrimony; and therefore in the Apostles time, when holiness and the power of Religion did flourish, and was in court, there was not need of any positive, civill or Church Law, for a Patron to the Church, every believer in power is obliged to defend the Church: but when men became Vulturs and ravenous birds to pluck from the Church what was given them, the Council of Milan din the year of God 402. wherein some say Augustine was president, under Honorius and Arcadius, some holy and powerful men were sought from the Emperor to defend the Church in her patrimony, and rights against the power and craft of avaricious men, and they were called Patrons, and the same was desired ein the first Council of Carthage, but with the Bishops advice, cum provisione Episcoporum. Hence it is clear, patronages from their original were not Church privileges, and Bishops being a part of the Church, could not be the Patrons, quia nemo sibi ipsi potest esse patronus, and for this cause that learned fthinketh this was the original of Church Patronages, but the Patrons have been chosen with consent of the Church; hence they were not as our Patronages are now, which goeth 1. by birth, 2. and are a part of a mans patrimony, and civill thing, that the Patron hath right ⟨p. 459⟩unto, under the Kings great Seal; but as a Minister is not a Minister by birth, neither was a Patron a Patron by birth: and from this we may collect, that the Patrons right was but a branch of the Magistrates right, and accumulative, not primitive, and that he could take nothing from the Church, and […] less might the Patron forestall the free election of the people, by tying them and their free suffrages to a determinate man, whom he presented;
and it is not unlike which gA•entinus […], when Bishops gave themselves only to the Word of God, to preaching and writing books in defence of the truth, the Emperor took care that they should be furnished with food and •aiment, and therefore gave them a p•tronus quem […] patronum curatoremque vocabant, whom they called a patron; and here observe the Bishop of old was the client, and the son and Pupil, now he must be the Patron and Tutor, and therefore in time of Popery, Antichristian Prelates would be Patrons both to themselves and to the Churches.
and it is not unlike which gA•entinus 〈…〉, when Bishops gave themselves onely to the Word of God, to preaching and writing bookes in defence of the truth, the Emperour tooke care that they should bee furnished with food and •aiment, and therefore gave them a p•tronus quem 〈…〉 patronum curatoremque vocabant, whom they called a patron; and here observe the Bishop of old was the client, and the sonne and Pupill, now hee must bee the Patron and Tutor, and therefore in time of Popery, Antichristian Prelates would bee Patrons both to themselves and to the Churches.
But this seemeth not to be the original of patronages, because this ground is common to all Churches, but not all, but only some certain Churches have patronages, therefore their ground seemeth rather to be that some religious and pious persons founded Churches, and dotted, and mortified to them benefices, and the Church by the Law of gratitude did give a Patronage over these founded Churches to the first foundators and their heirs, so as they should have power to nominate and present a Pastor to the Church. But there were two notable wrongs in this; for 1. If the fundator have all the Lands and Rents in those bounds, where the Church was erected, he is obliged to erect a Church, and furnish a ••pend, both by the Law of nature and so by Gods Law also. Ergo, the Church owe to him no gift of patronage for that, nor is he to keep that patronage in his hand, when he erecteth a Church; but and if he being Lord heritor of all the Lands and Rents, both erecteth a Church, and dotteth a stipend, sub modum eleemosynae, non sub modum debiti, by way of alms, not by way of debt, then is there no gratuity of honour, nor reward of Patronage due to him, for alms as alms ⟨p. 460⟩hath no real or bodily reward to be given by those on whom the alms is bestowed, but only the blessings of the poor, Joh 31. 20. it being a debt payed to God, he doth requite it. And hCalderword saith, no wise man would think that the Church men should allure men to found Churches, and to works of Piety, by giving them the right of presenting a man to the change: and also he would call it Simony, not piety or religion, if one should refuse to do a good work to the Church, except upon so dearest rate, and so hard a condition as to acquire to himself po•er over the Church of God.
But this seemeth not to bee the originall of patronages, because this ground is common to all Churches, but not all, but onely some certaine Churches have patronages, therefore their ground seemeth rather to bee that some religious and pious persons founded Churches, and dotted, and mortified to them benefices, and the Church by the Law of gratitude did give a Pat•onage over these founded Churches to the first foundators and their heires, so as they should have power to nominate and present a Pastor to the Church. But there were two notable wrongs in this; for 1. If the fundator have all the Lands and Rents in those bounds, where the Church was erected, hee is oblieged to erect a Church, and furnish a pend, both by the Law of nature and so by Gods Law also. Ergo, the Church owe to him no gift of patronage for that, nor is hee to keepe that patronage in his hand, when hee erecteth a Church; but and if hee being Lord heritor of all the Lands and Rents, both erecteth a Church, and dotteth a stipend, sub modum eleemosynae, non sub modum debiti, by way of almes, not by way of debt, then is there no gratuitie of honour, nor reward of Patronage due to him, for almes as almes
Though the •ight of presenting a man to benefice were a mere temporal thing, yet because it removeth the liberty of a free election of the fittest pastor, as iOrigen saith, it cannot be lawful, but it is not a temporal or civill right, but a spiritual right, though we should grant that the people have a free voice in choosing, and that the patron were obliged to present to the benefice, the man only whom the people hath freely chosen, and whom the Elders, by imposition of hands, have ordained. 1. Because the Pastors hath right to the benefice, as the workman is worthy of his hire, and he hath a divine right thereunto by Gods Law, 1 Cor. 9. 8, 9. & c. Gal. 6 6. Matth. 10. 10. Ergo, if the patron give any right to the Pastor to the benefice, it must be a spiritual right. If it be said, he may give him a civill right before men, that according to the Laws of the Commonwealth, he may legally brook and enjoy the benefice; this is but a shift, for the civill right before men is essentially founded upon the Law of God, that saith, the workman is worthy of his hire: and it is that fame right really that the Word of God speaketh of: now by no Word of God, hath the Patron a power to put the Preacher in that case, that he shall be worthy of his wages, for he being called, chosen as Pastor, he hath this spiritual right not of one, but of the whole Church. 2. It is true, Papists seem to be divided in judgements in this, whether the right of patronage be a temporal or a spiritual power; for some Canonists as we may see kin Abb. decius, land Rubio, and the Gloss msaith it is partly temporal, partly spiritual. Others say it is a spiritual power, as nAnton. de Butr. and o
6. Wee doe not teach that Church-men are loosed from the positive Lawes of Emperours and Kings. Bellarmine esaith that the Magistrate can neither punish Church-men, nor conveene them before the tribunall• so Innocentius the third, saith fthe Empire is not above the Pope, but the Pope is above the Empire. And Bonifacin• the eighth gsaith, all upon hazard of their salvation, are subject to the Pope of Rome, who hath the power of both ⟨p. 455⟩swords, and judgeth all and is judged by no man. Now it is knowne to 〈…〉 Nicanor, that the Prelats of England and Scotland in their high Commission, had the power of both swords, and that by Episcopall Lawes, the Primate 〈…〉 all the 〈…〉, and is judged by none, and who but he? and who ever spake as hSuarez? That Church-m•n 〈…〉 co〈…〉 against Princes, even to detbrane them. And as he saith, 〈…〉, by divine Law the Pope is eximed from a• Laws of Princes: and shall we in this beleeve iBellarmin•, kSato, l•••etanus, mTurrecremata, nGr•g•rius de Valent. oSua•••• and then forsooth they bring us their pCanon Law to judg the Law of God, & to prove it, because it is said by their Silvester, nemo judicabit primam •dem, and their qGratian learned this jus divinum, this divine Law from Innocentius the Pope. And what they alledge for Peters exemption from paying tribute, will exime all the disciples, and so all Church-men by divine right from the Lawes of Princes. Yea all Clergy-men (say they) by a divine positive Law are eximed from the Laws of Magistrates. So saith rSuarez, sBellarmine, and tthe 〈…〉 of Rbeimes, but with neither conscience, nor reason. And contrary to their owne practise and doctrine. For Paul will have every soule subject to superiour Powers, and except the Roman Clergy want Soules, they must also be subject. Salomon punished Abiathar, Josiah burnt the bones of the Priests upon the A•tar, Christ subjected himselfe to his Parents, payed tribute to Caes•r, and commanded Scribes and Pharisces to doe the like, Matth. 22. Willing that they should give to Cesar those things which are Caesars. Paul appealed to Caesars Tribunall, and Rom. 13. as many, as may doe evill, as many, as are in danger of resisting the power, are to be subject. Rom. 13. 4. 2. but Church-men are such, therefore they are subject.
Though the •ight of presenting a man to benefice were a meere temporall thing, yet because it removeth the libertie of a free election of the fittest pastor, as iOrigen saith, it cannot bee lawfull, but it is not a temporall or civill right, but a spirituall right, though wee should grant that the people have a free voyce in choosing, and that the patron were oblieged to present to the benefice, the man onely whom the people hath freely chosen, and whom the Elders, by imposition of hands, have ordained. 1. Because the Pastors hath right to the benefice, as the workeman is worthy of his hire, and hee hath a divine right thereunto by Gods Law, 1 Cor. 9. 8, 9. & c. Gal. 6 6. Matth. 10. 10. Ergo, if the patron give any right to the Pastor to the benefice, it must bee a spirituall right. If it bee said, hee may give him a civill right before men, that according to the Lawes of the Commonwealth, hee may legally brook and injoy the benefice; this is but a shift, for the civill right before men is essentially founded upon the Law of God, that saith, the workeman is worthy of his hire: and it is that fame right really that the Word of God speaketh of: now by no Word of God, hath the Patron a power to put the Preacher in that case, that hee shall bee worthy of his wages, for hee being called, chosen as Pastor, hee hath this spirituall right not of one, but of the whole Church. 2. It is true, Papists seeme to bee divided in judgements in this, whether the right of patronage bee a temporall or a spirituall power; for some Canonists as wee may see kin Abb. decius, land Rubio, and the Glosse msaith it is partly temporall, partly spirituall. Others say it is a spirituall power, as nAnton. de Butr. and oAndr. Barbat. ⟨p. 461⟩and pSuarez, and whereas Papists doe teach that the Church may lawfully give a right of presenting to Church benefices, even to those who are not Church men, the power must bee ecclesiasticall and spirituall, and cannot bee temporall; also Suarez saith, that the right of patronage may bee the matter of Sim•ny, when it is ••ld for m•ney. Ergo, they thinke it an holy and spirituall power.