4. Concl. It is not enough that some say, if the question be negatively just, then Soldiers and executioners, and people may execute the sentence, that is, if they see no unlawfulness in the fact, I mean unlaw fullness in materiâ juris, in a matter of Law; hence some say, subjects and common Soldiers not admitted to the secrets of the council of war, may fight lawfully, when there is this negative justice in the war; but foreign Soldiers who are conduced, may not do so afor the Law saith he is not free of a fault who intermedleth with matters which belong not to him, to the hurt of others; so Teacheth bSuarez cD. Bannes dAndr. Duvallius, yet the command of the Prince can remove no doubt of conscience, also that the cause of the war in the matter of Law, so far as it is agreeable to Gods word is not manifest to executioners, is there culpable ignorance no less then the ignorance of a sentence manifestly unjust, Ergo, the practise of these who execute a sentence negatively only just, is not lawful, I prove the antecedent, because the practical ⟨p. 44⟩ignorance of what we do which is not warranted by Gods Word is always culpable, whether the cause be clear or dark: for no obscurity of Gods Law doth excuse our ignorant practise, when the Word of God can sufficiently resolve us. 2. It is not enough that our moral actions in their lawfulness be just negatively; because actions moral which are beside the Word of God (praeter dei verbum) to us, who hold Gods Word perfect in faith and manners, are also, contra dei verbum, against the Word of God, and so unlawful. 3. Because actions moral having no warrant but the sole will and Commandment of superiors, are undertaken upon the sole faith: that what superiors command, if it seem not to us unjust, though it be in it self unjust, may lawfully be done. Now we condemn this in Schoolmen and Popish casuists, that the Commandment of superiors (as sayth Gregor. de Valent. Bannes, Suarez, Sylvester, Navarre) may take away and remove all doubting of conscience, and make the action lawful.
4. Concl. It is not enough that some say, if the question be negatively just, then Souldiers and executioners, and people may execute the sentence, that is, if they see no unlawfulnesse in the fact, I meane unlaw fulnesse in materiâ juris, in a matter of Law; hence some say, subjects and common Souldiers not admitted to the secrets of the councell of war, may fight lawfully, when there is this negative justice in the war; but forraine Souldiers who are conduced, may not doe so afor the Law sayth he is not free of a fault who intermedleth with matters which belonge not to him, to the hurt of others; so Teacheth bSuarez cD. Bannes dAndr. Duvallius, yet the command of the Prince can remove no doubt of conscience, also that the cause of the war in the matter of Law, so far as it is agreeable to Gods word is not manifest to executioners, is there culpable ignorance no lesse then the ignorance of a sentence manifestly unjust, Ergo, the practise of these who execute a sentence negatively only just, is not lawfull, I prove the antecedent, beacuse the practicall ⟨p. 44⟩ignorance of what we doe which is not warranted by Gods Word is alwayes culpable, whether the cause be cleare or darke: for no obscurity of Gods Law doth excuse our ignorant practise, when the Word of God can sufficienty resolve us. 2. It is not enough that our morall actions in their lawfulnes be just negatively; because actions morall which are beside the Word of God (praeter dei verbum) to us, who hold Gods Word perfect in faith and manners, are also, contra dei verbum, against the Word of God, and so unlawfull. 3. Because actions morall having no warrant but the sole will and Commandement of superiors, are undertaken upon the sole faith: that what superiors command, if it seeme not to us unjust, though it be in it selfe unjust, may lawfully be done. Now we condemne this in Schoolemen and Popish casuistes, that the Commandement of superiors (as sayth Gregor. de Valent. Bannes, Suarez, Silvester, Navarre) may take away and remove all doubting of conscience, and make the action lawfull.
- aRegula juris 19. in 6. and 38. in ff. non est sine culpa, qui, rebus, quae ad ipsum non spectant, se immiscet, cum periculo alterius.
- bSuarez, de tripl. virt dis. 13. de bello sect. 6. n. 8.
- cBannes in 22. q. 40. concl. 1.
- dAn. Duvallius in 22. tract. de charit. art. 3.