Now though Soldiers, Lictors, or People join to the execution of a sentence, and have their doubtings anent the fidelity of the witnesses, yet when all diligence morally possible is given to try the matter, they may well be said to do in Faith, though they have not certainty of Faith concerning the fact,, because there cannot be certainty of Divine Faith in facts; mens confession, sense, the Testimony of witnesses cannot breed Divine Faith: yea here the Judge himself may condemn the innocent, and yet the sentence of the Judge may be most just because the witnesses are Liars, and the Judge giveth out that sentence in Faith, because Gods Word hath commanded him to proceed, secundum allegata & probata, he must give sentence under btwo or three witnesses; yea, though the Judge saw, with his Eyes, the guilty commit the fact, yet he cannot by Gods Law condemn him, but upon the testimony of witnesses▪ For the wise Lord seeth what confusion and tyranny should follow, if one might be both Index, actor, & testis, the Judge, the accuser, and the witness. And when the Judge giveth out a sentence to absolve the guilty and condemn the innocent, his sentence is judicially and formally just, and materially and by accident and contrary to his intention only unjust, if the Judge in that case should say (as Master Weemes observeth well) csuch a proposition is true when he knoweth it to be false, and being posed and urged in conscience, is this an innocent man or no? it he should answer and say he is not, he should then answer contrary to his knowledge? but as a Judge he must answer, he is not innocent, because witnesses being with all possible diligence examined, have condemned him, and it is no inconvenience here to say, that the Judge hath one conscience as a man, and another contrary conscience as a Judge, in the question of fact; for God hath tied his conscience, as a Judge, to the fidelity of witnesses, known not to be false. I desire the Reader ⟨p. 47⟩to see anent this more in aBonaventura bRichardus cOccam dAntoninus eAdrian, fand our Countryman John Weemes and gHenricus.
Now though Souldiers, Lictors, or People joyne to the execution of a sentence, and have their doubtings anent the fidelity of the witnesses, yet when all diligence morally possible is given to try the matter, they may well be said to doe in Faith, though they have not certainty of Faith concerning the fact,, because there cannot be certainty of Divine Faith in facts; mens confession, sense, the Testimony of witnesses cannot breed Divine Faith: yea here the Judge himselfe may condemne the innocent, and yet the sentence of the Judge may be most just because the witnesses are Lyers, and the Judge giveth out that sentence in Faith, because Gods Word hath commanded him to proceed, secundum allegata & probata, he must give sentence under btwo or three witnesses; yea, though the Judge saw, with his Eyes, the guilty commit the fact, yet he cannot by Gods Law condemne him, but upon the testimony of witnesses▪ For the wise Lord seeth what confusion and tyranny should follow, if one might be both Index, actor, & t•stis, the Iudge, the accuser, and the witnesse. And when the Judge giveth out a sentence to absolve the guilty and condemne the innocent, his sentence is judicially and formally just, and materially and by accident and contrary to his intention only unjust, if the Judge in that case should say (as Master Weemes observeth well) csuch a proposition is true when he knoweth it to be false, and being posed and urged in conscience, is this an innocent man or no? it he should answer and say he is not, he should then answer contrary to his knowledge? but as a Judge he must answer, he is not innocent, because witnesses being with all possible diligence examined, have condemned him, and it is no inconvenience here to say, that the Judge hath one conscience as a man, and another contrary conscience as a Judge, in the question of fact; for God hath tyed his conscience, as a Judge, to the fidelity of witnesses, known not to be false. I desire the Reader ⟨p. 47⟩to see anent this more in aBonaventura bRichardus cOccam dAntoninus
- bDeut. 19. 15. Mat. 18. 16. • Tim 5. 19. Exod. 23. 1.
- cJoh. Weemes 3. vel expos. of judicial Lars ch. 17. p. 69.Ioh. Weemes 3. vel expos. of judiciall Larres ch. 17. p. 69.
- aBonavent. 1. q9.
- bRich. a•t. 1. q 3.
- cOccam. q• 3. a•. 3.
- dAnton. 1. •. • act. 3. ca. 10. •. 4.
- eAdrian. quod. lib. 4 […]. ••.Adrian. quod. lib. 4 〈…〉. ••.
- fWeemes loc. cit.
- gHenricus 2•. q•••ll. 1. q. 8.