A57969:470
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the…
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
4. The most that these arguments of our Brethren do prove, is but that it is lawful to go, and dwell in a Congregation where Christ is worshipped in all his Ordinances, rather then to remain in that Congregation, where he is not worshipped in all his Ordinances; and where the Church censures are neglected, which to us is no separation from the visible Church, but a removal from one part of the visible Church to another, as he separateth not out of the house, who removeth from the Gallery, to remain and lie and eat in the Chamber of the same House, because the Gallery is cold and smoky, and the Chamber not so, for he hath not made a vow never to set his foot in the Gallery. But to our Brethren to separate or remove from a Congregation, is to be dismembered from the only visible Church on Earth, for to them there is not any visible Church on Earth, except a congregation. And our Brethren's mind in all these arguments, is to prove, that not only it is unlawful to stand in the Parish assemblies of Old England, because of Popish ceremonies (and we teach separation from these ceremonies to be lawful, but not from the Churches) but also that it is necessary, to adjoin to independent Congregations, as to the only true visible Churches on Earth, and to none others, except we would sin against the second Commandment, which I conceive is proved by not one of these arguments. And to them all I answer, by a denial of the connex proposition. As this, These who must do all which Christ commandeth, and seek Christ in all his necessary Ordinances, though superiors will not do their duties, these must separate from true visible Churches, where all Christs Ordinances are not, and join to independent Congregations, as to the only true visible Churches on Earth. This proposition I deny. 5. If our Brethren's argument hold sure that we are to separate from a Church, in which we want some Ordinances of Christ, through the Officers negligence, because (say theya) The Spouse of Christ will not rest, seeking Her beloved until she find him, in the fullest manner, Cant. 1. v. 7. & 3. 1, 2. then the Spouse Cant. 1. 7. & 3. 1, 2. is separating