A57969:910
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the…
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
[figure] › Chapter 9 › Section 9: Of the addition of Members to the Church.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. The Church with whom the covenant is made, and to whom the promises of the covenant are made, is the Spouse of Christ, his mystical body, the Sons and Daughters of the Lord God Almighty, a royal priest-hood, a chosen generation, Kings and Priests to God: but this is the invisible Church of elect believers, not the visible Church of visible professors. Therefore the invisible, and not the visible Church, is the first subject of all the privileges of Christians, and all the promises of the covenant. The proposition is not doubted. I prove the assumption; The visible Church as it is such, is a company of professors of the truth, and cannot be, as it is such, the Spouse of Christ and his Body. 1. Because then Professors, as Professors, should be Christs redeemed Body, which is openly false and against the Word of God: for Rom. 9. 6. for they are not all Israel, which are of Israel. 2. Our Brethren's argument is strong to prove, that the Church of Elders are not the true Church spoken of in the Word; For, say they, the true Church is a flock that Christ hath Redeemed with his Blood, Acts 20. 28. The Temple of the living God, 1 Cor. 3. But the Church of Elders is not a flock of redeemed ones, and Temples of the holy Spirit, but in so far as they believe, and are elected to glory, and not as a flock of Elders, are they redeemed: so they say, true Elders, as Elders, ⟨p. 247⟩are not a part of the true Church, nor the Church to whom Christ gave the keys, Mat. 16. But the Church making Peters confession. So say we, the Church of visible professors, as they are such, are not the redeemed of Christ, and Temples of the holy Spirit, but in so far as they are Believers and the elect of God. For if our Brethren say, the Church, as it is a company of visible Professors, is also essentially the Church of Redeemed ones, then only the Church of visible Professors, and all the Church of visible Professors are redeemed of God, but this is absurd and false. Quod convenit [Greek or Hebrew] convenit [Greek or Hebrew]. Our Brethren acknowledge there may be an hundred Believers and Temples of the holy Spirit, who are a flock of redeemed ones, and yet not be a company of visible Professors. 1. Because they are not united (say they) covenant ways into a Church-body. 2.
2. The Church with whom the covenant is made, and to whom the promises of the covenant are made, is the Spouse of Christ, his mysticall body, the Sons and Daughters of the Lord God Almighty, a royall priest-hood, a chosen generation, Kings and Priests to God: but this is the invisible Church of elect believers, not the visible Church of visible professors. Therefore the invisible, and not the visible Church, is the first subject of all the priviledges of Christians, and all the promises of the covenant. The proposition is not doubted. I prove the assumption; The visible Church as it is such, is a company of professors of the truth, and connot be, as it is such, the Spouse of Christ and his Body. 1. Because then Professors, as Professors, should be Christs redeemed Body, which is openly false and against the Word of God: for Rom. 9. 6. for they are not all Israel, which are of Israel. 2. Our Brethrens argument is strong to prove, that the Church of Elders are not the true Church spoken of in the Word; For, say they, the true Church is a flock that Christ hath Redeemed with his Blood, Acts 20. 28. The Temple of the living God, 1 Cor. 3. But the Church of Elders is not a flock of redeemed ones, and Temples of the holy Spirit, but in so far as they believe, and are elected to glory, and not as a flock of Elders, are they redeemed: so they say, true Elders, as Elders, ⟨p. 247⟩are not a part of the true Church, nor the Church to whom Christ gave the keyes, Mat. 16. But the Church making Peters confession. So say wee, the Church of visible professors, as they are such, are not the redeemed of Christ, and Temples of the holy Spirit, but in so far as they are Believers and the elect of God. For if our Brethren say, the Church, as it is a company of visible Professors, is also essentially the Church of Redeemed ones, then only the Church of visible Professors, and all the Church of visible Professors are redeemed of God, but this is absurd and false. Quod convenit 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 convenit 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Our Brethren acknowledge there may be an hundred Believers and Temples of the holy Spirit, who are a flock of redeemed ones, and yet not be a company of visible Professors. 1. Because they are not united (say they) covenantwayes into a Church-body. 2.
(Say they) because of weakness and for fear of persecution, men may hide their profession as many do in the Church of Rome, and yet be the redeemed of God, and be the seven thousand who have not bowed their knees to Baal; and our Brethren cannot say, that all the visible Church are the flock redeemed of God, for then should there be no hypocrites in the visible Church. 3. In this our Brethren maintain one of the ••ossest points of the Arminian, Popish and Socinian Doctrine, even that all visible Professors are chosen to glory, redeemed of God, and the children of the promise, and that in Gods purpose, the covenant of grace and the promises of the covenant are made to all and every one in the visible Church, and that God hath an intention that Christ shall die for all and every one of the visible Church, and that he intendeth to save all and every one of the visible Church. This I prove, for if th• covenant and promises of the covenant, if the stiles of Christs Body, his Love, his Spouse, his Sister and D•ve, if the revelation of Christ made not by flesh and blood, but by Christs Father the ground of that blessed confession of Peter Mat. 16. 17. For which the keys were given to the visible Church, if I say all these be proper to the visible Church as visible, and due to her as to the first principal and prime subject, and not to the chosen redeemed and invisible Church as such, then the promises of the covenant, and all these styles belong to the visible ⟨p. 248⟩Church, and God promiseth and intendeth a new heart and a new spirit to all visible Professors as such, and so he intendeth redemption in Christ and salvation, and Christs Righteousness and Forgiveness of sins to all the visible Church. But our Brethren do not (I hope) think that Gods intentions, are castles in the Air, and new Islands beyond the Moon, as if his intentions could be frustrated, and he could miss the white of the scope he shooteth at; for certainly these to whom the covenant, and promises thereof belong as to the prime and first subject, these are his covenanted people; now the orthodox and reformed Church holdeth, that the covenant and promises are preached to the whole visible Church, but for the elects sake, and that howsoever externally, the covenant of grace and promises be promulgated to every one, and all within the lists of the visible Church;
(Say they) because of weakenesse and for feare of persecution, men may hide their profession as many doe in the Church of Rome, and yet be the redeemed of God, and be the seven thousand who have not bowed their knees to Baal; and our Brethren cannot say, that all the visible Church are the flock redeemed of God, for then should there be no hypocrites in the visible Church. 3. In this our Brethren maintaine one of the ••ossest poynts of the Arminian, Popish and Socinian Doctrine, even that all visible Professors are chosen to glory, redeemed of God, and the children of the promise, and that in Gods purpose, the cove•ant of grace and the promises of the covenant are made to all and every one in the visible Church, and that God hath an intention that Christ shall die for all and every one of the visible Church, and that he inteneth to save all and every one of the visible Church. This I prove, for if th• covenant and promises of the covenant, if the stiles of Christs Body, his Love, his Spouse, his Sister and D•ve, if the revelation of Christ made not by flesh and blood, but by Christs Father the ground of that blessed confession of Peter Mat. 16. 17. For which the keys were given to the visible Church, if I say all these be proper to the visible Church as visible, and due to her as to the first principall and prime subject, and not to the chosen redeemed and invisible Church as such, then the promises of the covenant, and all these styles belong to the visible ⟨p. 248⟩Church, and God promiseth and intendeth a new heart and a new spirit to all visible Professors as such, and so he intendeth redemption in Christ and salvation, and Christs Righteousnesse and Forgivenesse of sins to all the visible Church. But our Brethren do not (I hope) thinke that Gods intentions, are castles in the Aire, and new Ilands beyond the Moone, as if his intentions could be frustrated, and he could misse the white of the scope he shooteth at; for certainly these to whom the covenant, and promises thereof belong as to the prime and first subject, these are his covenanted people; now the orthodox and reformed Church holdeth, that the covenant and promises are preached to the whole visible Church, but for the elects sake, and that howsoever externally, the covenant of grace and promises be promulgated to every one, and all within the lists of the visible Church;
yet they belong in Gods Intention and gracious purpose only to the Elect of God, and his redeemed ones, to that invisible Body, Spouse, Sister, whereof Christ alone is Lord, Head, Husband, and Brother, and the first begotten amongst many Brethren. Hence let me reason thus. The Church whose gathering together, and whose unity of Faith, knowledge of the Son of God, and growth of the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ, the Lord intendeth by giving to them for that end, some to be Apostles, some Prophets, some Pastors and Teachers, Eph. 4. 11, 12, 13. must be the Church to which all the promises of the covenant and privileges do belong. But the Lord intendeth the gathering together, the unity of Faith, the knowledge of the Son of God and growth of the measure of the stature of Christ only of the invisible Elected and Redeemed Church, not of the visible professing or confessing Church, nor doth the Lord send Pastors and Teachers up-on a purpose and intention of gathering the visible Church, and visible Israel, except you fly to the Tents of Arminians. I conceive these arguments cannot be answered. If any say, that Christ in giving Prophets, Pastors and Teachers to his Church intendeth to save the true visible Church of the chosen and redeemed, in so far as they are chosen and redeemed, now they who answer thus, come to our hand and forsake the Doctrine of their visible Church, and say with us, that the Ministry ⟨p. 249⟩and the keys are given only upon a purpose on Gods part to save the invisible Church, and that all these promises of the covenant, the styles of Christs Spouse, Sister, Fair one, are not proper to the visible Church, nor any ground or argument to prove that the keys, the power of excommunication, ordaining of officers are given to the visible Church, as to the prime and principal subject.
yet they belong in Gods Intention and gratious purpose only to the Elect of God, and his reseemed ones, to that invisible Body, Spouse, Sister, whereof Christ alone is Lord, Head, Husband, and Brother, and the first begotten amongst many Brethren. Hence let me reason thus. The Church whose gathering together, and whose unity of Faith, knowledge of the Son of God, and growth of the measure of the stature of the fulnes of Christ, the Lord intendeth by giving to them for that end, some to be Apostles, some Prophets, some Pastors and Teachers, Eph. 4. 11, 12, 13. must be the Church to which all the promises of the covenant and priviledges do belong. But the Lord intendeth the gathering together, the unity of Faith, the knowledge of the Son of God and growth of the measure of the stature of Christ only of the invisible Elected and Redeemed Church, not of the visible professing or consesing Church, nor doth the Lord send Pastors and Teachers up-on a purpose and intention of gathering the visible Church, and visible Israel, except you flie to the Tents of Arminians. I conceive these arguments cannot be answered. If any say, that Christ in giving Prophets, Pastors and Teachers to his Church intendeth to save the true visible Church of the chosen and redeemed, in so far as they are chosen and redeemed, now they who answer thus, come to our hand and forsake the Doctrine of their visible Church, and say with us, that the Ministery ⟨p. 249⟩and the keys are given only upon a purpose on Gods part to save the invisible Church, and that all these promises of the covenant, the styles of Christs Spouse, Sister, Faire one, are not proper to the visible Church, nor any ground or argument to prove that the keys, the power of excommunication, ordaining of officers are given to the visible Church, as to the prime and principall subject.
4. The invisible Church; and not the visible Church as it is such, hath right to the Sacraments, because these who have right to the covenant, have right to the seals of the covenant; and this is Peters argument to prove the baptizing of Infants to be lawful, Acts 2. 38, 39. But only the invisible Church hath right to the covenant. For God saith only of, and to the invisible Church. and not of the visible Church in his gracious purpose, Jerem. 32. 38. And I will be their God, and they shall be my people, Jer. 31. 33. I will put my Law in their inward parts, 34. They shall all know me (all within the covenant) I will forgive their iniquity. Now the visible Church as the visible Church is not within the covenant, therefore the visible Church as the visible Church, and being no more but the visible Church, hath not right to the Seals of the covenant, but in so far as they are within the covenant, and in so far as God is their God, and they his pardoned and sanctified people, as it is, Jerem. 31. 33 34.
4. The invisible Church; and not the visible Church as it is such, hath right to the Sacraments, because these who have right to the covenant, have right to the seales of the covenant; and this is Peters argument to prove the baptizing of Infants to be lawfull, Acts 2. 38, 39. But only the invisible Church hath right to the covenant. For God saith only of, and to the invisible Church. and not of the visible Church in his gratious purpose, Jerem. 32. 38. And I will be their God, and they shall be my people, Jer. 31. 33. I will put my Law in their inward parts, 34. They shall all know me (all within the covenant) I will forgive th•ir iniquity. Now the visible Church as the visible Church is not within the covenant, therefore the visible Church as the visible Church, and being no more but the visible Church, hath not right to the Seales of the covenant, but in so far as they are within the covenant, and in so far as God is their God, and they his pardoned and sanctified people, as it is, Ierem. 31. 33 34.
5. It is known that our Brethren here join with Papists, for Papists ignorant of the Doctrine of the visible Church, labour to prove that the visible Church on Earth, the Ministerial, Teaching and Governing Church, cannot err, but that she conver•ed in a visible Synod, and met in Christs Name, hath a promise of an infallible assistance. And by what arguments do they prove it? You know here Bellarmine, Pererius, Tolet, Stapleton, Bail••s, Suarez. Vasquez, Harding, Gretsirus, Costerus, Turrecremata, Salmoron, Locinus, Cajetan, and an host of them say, because the Church is builded on a Rock, and against it the Gates of Hell shall not prevail: because Christ saith, I have prayed to the Father that thy Faith fail thee not: because Christ saith, I will send you the holy Spirit, and he shall lead you into all truth. Now our Divines say, that the invisible Church of ⟨p. 250⟩Elect believers cannot fall off the Rock, and cannot fall from saving Faith, and cannot err by falling into fundamental heresies, but it followeth not; Ergo, the visible ministerial and Teaching Church, either out of a Synod, or convened in a Synod, have an infallible and Apostolic Spirit to lead them so, as in their determinations they cannot err. Just so our brethren take all the places for the privileges, covenant, promises, stiles of Sister, Love, Dove, Spouse, mystical Body of Christ, &c. Which are proper only to the invisible, redeemed, chosen, sanctified Church of God: and they give all these to their only visible ministerial and right constituted Church in the New Testament; and say that this visible church gathered in a church-state, because of the foresaid privileges and stiles, hath the supreme and independent power and authority of the keys, above all Teachers and Pastors whatsoever, and that the right visible church consisteth only of a Royal generation, Temples of the Holy Ghost, a people in covenant with God, taught of God, partakers of the Divine nature, &c. And that all visible churches that meet not in a material House, in a visible and conspicuous Society, as on visible Mount Zion, and not consisting of such a covenanted, sanctified, and separated people, are a false church, false in matter, not an ordinance of Christ, but an Idol, an antichristian device, a Synagogue of Satan void of the power of the Keys.
5. It is knowen that our Brethren here joyne with Papists, for Papists ignorant of the Doctrine of the visible Church, labour to prove that the visible Church on Earth, the Ministeriall, Teaching and Governing Church, cannot erre, but that she conver•ed in a visible Synod, and met in Christs Name, hath a promise of an infallible assistance. And by what argumunts do they prove it? You know here Bellarmine, Pererius, Tolet, Stapleton, Bail••s, Suarez. Vasquez, Harding, Gretsirus, Costerus, Turrecremata, Salmoron, Locinus, Cajetan, and an host of them say, because the Church is builded on a Rock, and against it the Gates of Hell shall not prevaile: because Christ saith, I have prayd to the Father that thy Faith faile thee not: because Christ saith, I will send you the holy Spirit, and he shall leade you into all truth. Now our Divines say, that the invisible Church of ⟨p. 250⟩Elect believers cannot fall off the Rock, and cannot fall from saving Faith, and cannot erre by falling into fundamentall heresies, but it followeth not; Ergo, the visible ministeriall and Teaching Church, either out of a Synod, or convened in a Synod, have an infallible and Apostolick Spirit to lead them so, as in their determinations they cannot erre. Just so our brethren take all the places for the priviledges, covenant, promises, stiles of Sister, Love, Dove, Spouse, mysticall Body of Christ, &c. Which are proper only to the invisible, redeemed, chosen, sanctified Church of God: and they give all these to their only visible ministeriall and right constituted Church in the New Testament; and say that this visible church gathered in a church-state, because of the foresaid priviledges and stiles, hath the supreame and independent power and authority of the keys, above all Teachers and Pastors whatsoever, and that the right visible church consisteth only of a Royall generation, Temples of the Holy Ghost, a people in covenant with God, taught of God, partakers of the Divine nature, &c. And that all visible churches that meet not in a materiall House, in a visible and conspicious Society, as on visible Mount Zion, and not consisting of such a covenanted, sanctified, and separated people, are a false church, false in matter, not an ordinance of Christ, but an Idoll, an antichristian device, a Synagogue of Satan voyd of the power of the Keys.
6. A church in covenant with God, and the Spouse of Christ, and his mystical Body, and a church which he redeemed with the Blood of God, Acts 20. 28. Eph. 5. 25. 26. Col. 1. 18. 1 Cor. 12. 12. Is a church whereof all the members without exception are taught of God. Jerem. 31. 34. They shall all know me (saith the Lord) from the least, unto the greatest. Esa. 54. 13. All thy children shall be taught of the Lord. And therefore they all having heard and learned of the Father, come to Christ, John 6. 45. and therefore have all the anointing within them which teacheth them all things, 1 John 1. 27. And so they have all Ears to hear. Yea among such a company, Isaiah. 35. 9. 10. there is no Lyon, no ravenous beast, but the Redeemed and Ransomed of the Lord. But so it is that no visible congregation on Earth, that are visible Professors of any competent number, is such ⟨p. 251⟩a Church whereof all the members are taught of God, all ransomed and redeemed, and therefore no visible church, as such is a people or Church in covenant with God. See aRodgers Catechism.
6. A church in covenant with God, and the Spouse of Christ, and his mysticall Body, and a church which he redeemed with the Blood of God, Acts 20. 28. Eph. 5. 25. 26. Col. 1. 18. 1 Cor. 12. 12. Is a church whereof all the members without exception are taught of God. Jerem. 31. 34. They shall all know me (saith the Lord) from the least, unto the greatest. Esa. 54. 13. All thy children shall be taught of the Lord. And therefore they all haveing heard and learned of the Father, come to Christ, Iohn 6. 45. and therefore have all the anointing within them which teacheth them all things, 1 Iohn 1. 27. And so they have all Eares to heare. Yea among such a company, Esai. 35. 9. 10. there is no Lyon, no ravenous beast, but the Redeemed and Ransomed of the Lord. But so it is that no visible congregation on Earth, that are visible Professors of any competent number, is such ⟨p. 251⟩a Church whereof all the members are taught of God, all ransomed and redeemed, and therefore no visible church, as such is a people or Church in covenant with God. See aRodgers Catechisme.
- aRodger. Catechism part. 2. art. 6. p. 176, 177.
3. Conclus. A visible profession of the Truth and Doctrine of godliness, is that which essentially constituteth a visible church, and every member of the visible church; only our Brethren and we differ much about the nature of this profession which is required in members added to the Church. Our Brethren will have none members of the visible Church, but such as are satisfactory to the consciences of all the visible church, and give evidences so clear, as the judgement of discerning men can attain unto, that they are truly regenerated. We again do teach, that the scandalously wicked are to be cast out of the Church by excommunication, and these of approved piety are undoubtedly members of the visible Church, so these of the middle sort are to be acknowledged members of the Church, though the Church have not a positive certainty of the judgement of charity, that they are regenerated, so they be known. 1 To be Baptized. 2. That they be free of gross scandals. 3. And profess that they be willing hearers of the Doctrine of the Gospel. Such a profession, as giveth evidences to the positive certainty of the judgement of charity, of sound conversion, is not required to make and constitute a true visible Church.
3. Conclus. A visible profession of the Truth and Doctrine of godlinesse, is that which essentially constituteth a visible church, and every member of the visible church; onely our Brethren and we differ much about the nature of this profession which is required in members added to the Church. Our Brethren will have none members of the visible Church, but such as are satisfactory to the consciences of all the visible church, and give evidences so cleare, as the judgement of discerning men can atraine unto, that they are truly regenerated. We againe do teach, that the scandalously wicked are to be cast out of the Church by excommunication, and these of approved piety are undoubtedly members of the visible Church, so these of the middle sort are to be acknowledged members of the Church, though the Church have not a positive certainty of the judgement of charity, that they are regenerated, so they be knowen. 1 To be Baptized. 2. That they be free of grosse scandals. 3. And professe that they be willing hearers of the Doctrine of the Gospell. Such a profession, as giveth evidences to the positive certainty of the judgement of charity, of sound conversion, is not required to make and constitute a true visible Church.
1. Argu. Israel entered in covenant with God, Deut. 29. was a true visible Church, as our Brethren Teach, because that they conceive to be a Church-covenant, Deut. 29, but Churches by that Oath were not such, as to the satisfaction of Moses, and the whole people their consciences gave positive certainty of sound conversion. Because v. 4. The Lord (saith the Text) hath not given you an heart to perceive, nor eyes to see, nor Ears to hear to this day, Deut. 31. 27. for I know thy Rebellion and thy stiffneck, behold, while I am yet alive with you this day, ye have been rebellions against the Lord. ver. 21. Deut. 32. v. 5. v. 15, 16, 17. Josh. 24. 23.
1. Argu. Israel entered in covenant with God, Deut. 29. was a true visible Church, as our Brethren Teach, because that they conceive to be a Church-covenant, Deut. 29, but Churches by that Oath were not such, as to the satisfaction of Moses, and the whole people their consciences gave positive certainty of sound conversion. Because v. 4. The Lord (saith the Text) hath not given you an heart to perceive, nor eyes to see, nor Eares to heare to this day, Deut. 31. 27. for I know thy Rebellion and thy stifneck, behell, while I am yet alive with you this day, yee have been rebellions against the Lord. ver. 21. Deut. 32. v. 5. v. 15, 16, 17. Josh. 24. 23.
2. Argu. Christ would not seven times have said. He that hath Ears to hear, let him hear what the Spirit saith to the ⟨p. 252⟩Churches, if he had not supposed that in these seven Churches, there were blind, obdurate, and carnal hearers, as there were when, Mat. 13. upon occasion of the like hearers, he uttereth these same words in substance. Now Christ would have blamed their ill discerning in admitting such to be the materials of a visible Church, as he reproveth their other faults in government. Neither could Christ reprove these Churches, for not exercising the Church-censures against liars, false Apostles, fleshly Nicolaitans, followers of Balaam's wicked Doctrine, Jezebel and other ill doers and seducers, if these had not been Churchmembers, as our Brethren teach, how can we conceive, that Christ would call these Churches, who were false in the matter, or give his presence and communion by walking among the golden candlesticks, and holding the stars, the Ministry, in his right hand? And if every one of these Churches were approved to the consciences one of another, that they positively knew they were all of them, a royal Priest-Hood, an holy Generation, all taught of God, all sons and daughters of the Lord God Almighty, how are there such gross scandals put upon them by Jesus Christ?
2. Argu. Christ would not seven times have said. He that hath Eares to heare, let him heare what the Spirit saith to the ⟨p. 252⟩Churches, if he had not supposed that in these seven Churches, there were blind, obdurate, and carnall hearers, as there were when, Mat. 13. upon occasion of the like hearers, he uttereth these same words in substance. Now Christ would have blamed their ill discerning in admitting such to be the materialls of a visible Church, as hee reproveth their other faults in government. Neither could Christ reprove these Churches, for not exercising the Church-censures against liers, false Apostles, fleshly Nicolaitans, followers of Balaams wicked Doctrine, Jezebed and other ill doers and seducers, if these had not been Churchmembers, as our Brethren teach, how can we conceive, that Christ would call these Churches, who were false in the matter, or give his presence and communion by walking among the golden candlestickes, and holding the starres, the Ministery, in his right hand? And if every one of these Churches were approved to the consciences one of another, that they positively knew they were all of them, a royall Priest-Hood, an holy Generation, all taught of God, all sonnes and daughters of the Lord God Almighty, how are there such grosse scandals put upon them by Jesus Christ?
3. Argu. Paul clearly teacheth, 1 Cor. 5. That the Church of Corinth convened had the power of the Lord Jesus amongst them, and was a betrothed Bride espoused in a Church covenant, even all of the visible Church as one chaste Virgin to God, as our Brethren prove from the, 1 Cor. 11. 1, 2, 3. Who had received the Spirit and the Gospel, their minds being knit thereunto, in the simplicity of Jesus Christ; now if the matter of this betrothed Church was such, as our Brethren say, then Christs Power, and Presence and Spirit, were in these as the Temples of the Holy Ghost, and these were betrothed to Christ Jesus, and had received the Spirit and were Saints by calling, were justified, washen, sanctified, who were incestuous, Fornicators, Drunkards, Railers, carnal, Schismatics, going to the Law one with another before Infidels, partakers of the Table of Christ and of devils, deniers of the Resurrection, to whom the Word was the savour of Death, and the Gospel as it is to these, whom the God of this world, Satan, hath blinded. What can be more repugnant to the truth and to the Gospel of Christ? It cannot ⟨p. 253⟩be answered, that these in Corinth who were hypocrites and walked so contrary to the Gospel were not members of the Church of Corinth. For only the truly converted were such. I answer. 1. Then Paul writeth not to the visible Church and to all whom he doth rebuke, the contrary whereof is clear. 1 Cor. 2. 11. 2 Cor. 3. 22. 1 Cor. 5. 1. 2. 1 Cor. 6. 1. 2. 3. 1 Cor. 11. 17 18 19, 30. 1 Cor. 15. 12. 1 Cor. 10. 21. 1 Cor. 8. and in many other places.
3. Argu. Paul clearely teacheth, 1 Cor. 5. That the Church of Corinth convened had the power of the Lord Iesus amongst them, and was a betrothed Bryde espoused in a Church covenant, even all of the visible Church as one chaste Virgin to God, as our Brethren prove from the, 1 Cor. 11. 1, 2, 3. Who had received the Spirit and the Gospell, their minds being knit thereunto, in the simplicity of Iesus Christ; now if the matter of this betrothed Church was such, as our Brethren say, then Christs Power, and Presence and Spirit, were in these as the Temples of the Holy Ghost, and these were betrothed to Christ Iesus, and had received the Spirit and were Saints by calling, were justified, washen, sanctified, who were incestuous, Fornicators, Drunkards, Railers, carnall, Schismaticks, going to the Law one with another before Infidells, partakers of the Table of Christ and of divells, deniers of the Resurrection, to whom the Word was the savour of Death, and the Gospell as it is to these, whom the God of this world, Satan, hath blinded. What can be more repugnant to the truth and to the Gospell of Christ? It cannot ⟨p. 253⟩be answered, that these in Corinth who were hypocrites and walked so contrary to the Gospell were not members of the Church of Corinth. For only the truly converted were such. I answer. 1. Then Paul writeth not to the visible Church and to all whom he doth rebuke, the contrary whereof is cleare. 1 Cor. 2. 11. 2 Cor. 3. 22. 1 Cor. 5. 1. 2. 1 Cor. 6. 1. 2. 3. 1 Cor. 11. 17 18 19, 30. 1 Cor. 15. 12. 1 Cor. 10. 21. 1 Cor. 8. and in many other places.
2. Then the visible church was not betrothed to Christ as a chaste Virgin: contrary to this our Brethren alleged, 1 Cor. 11. 1 2, 3. 3. Not only is conversion professedly true in the judgment of charity, but also in the judgement of verity, essential to a visible church as you teach; and so none can be a member of the visible church, but he who is a member of the invisible Church, which is Anabaptism. 4. Three thousand in one day were added to the visible church, who could not (as I have proved) all be approved to the conscience one of another, as true converts, Acts 2. Since amongst them were Ananias and Sapphira, and the time was short. 5. If we are to bear one another's burdens, and so fulfil the Law of Christ, and if grace may be beside many and great sins, as we see in Asa, in Solomon who remained the children of God, under many out breakings, if the children of God may be the children of God, and yet some of them habitually proud, passionate, some of them worldly minded, some talkative and imprudently rash in zeal, some lustful, some slothful, some ambitious, yea and if Simon Magus his profession, though false, was esteemed sufficient, for to give him baptism, the Seal of the covenant, Acts 8. 9. Then it is not required that all the members of the visible church be such as positively we know (so far as humane knowledge can reach) that they are converted, yea if this were true, then special commandments would be given, that as we are to examine and try our selves, 1 Cor. 11. 28. 2 Cor. 13. 5. And to try officers before they be admitted, 1 Tim. 3. 10. 1 Tim. 5 22. and to try the spirits of Prophets and their Doctrine, 1 John 4. 1. and, 1 Thess. 5. 21. Acts 17. 13. So would God in his Word give a charge, that we try, examine and judge carefully one another, and that every man labour to be satisfied in conscience ⟨p. 254⟩anent the regeneration one of another. But such commandments we read not of. 6. If many be brought and called into the visible church, of purpose both on Gods revealed intention in his Word to convert them, and on the churches part that they may be converted; Then doth not the church consist of these who are professedly converted, but the former •• true; Ergo, so is the latter.
2. Then the visible church was not betrothed to Christ as a chaste Virgin: contrary to this our Brethren alleadged, 1 Cor. 11. 1 2, 3. 3. Not only is conversion professedly true in the judgment of charity, but also in the judgement of verity, essentiall to a visible church as you teach; and so none can be a member of the visible church, but he who is a member of the invisible Church, which is Anabaptisme. 4. Three thousand in one day were added to the visible church, who could not (as I have proved) all be approved to the conscience one of another, as true converts, Acts 2. Since amongst them were Ananias and Saphira, and the time was short. 5. If we are to beare one anothers burdens, and so fulfill the Law of Christ, and if grace may be beside many and great sinnes, as we see in Asa, in Salomon who remained the children of God, under many out breakings, if the children of God may be the children of God, and yet some of them habitually proud, passionate, some of them worldly minded, some talkative and imprudently rash in zeale, some lustfull, some slothfull, some ambiticus, yea and if Simon Magus his profession, though false, was esteemed sufficient, for to give him baptisme, the Seale of the covenant, Acts 8. 9. Then it is not required that all the members of the visible church be such as positively wee know (so farre as humane knowledge can reach) that they are converted, yea if this were true, then speciall commandements would be given, that as we are to examine and try our selves, 1 Cor. 11. 28. 2 Cor. 13. 5. And to try officers before they be admitted, 1 Tim. 3. 10. 1 Tim. 5 22. and to try the spirits of Prophets and their Doctrine, 1 Iohn 4. 1. and, 1 Thess. 5. 21. Acts 17. 13. So would God in his Word give a charge, that we try, examine and judge carefully one another, and that every man labour to be satisfied in conscience ⟨p. 254⟩anent the regeneration one of another. But such commandements we reade not of. 6. If many be brought and called into the visible church, of purpose both on Gods revealed intention in his Word to convert them, and on the churches part that they may be converted; Then doth not the church confist of these who are professedly converted, but the former •• true; Ergo, so is the latter.
The proposition is sure, these whom God purposeth to convert by making them Church-members, they are not Church-members because they are already converted. I prove the assumption, because. 1. The contrary doctrine, to wit, that none are under a pastors care till they be first converted, maketh to the eversion of the public Ministry, and gratifieth Arminians and Socinians, as before I observed, because Faith cometh not by hearing of sent pastors, as Gods ordinance is, Rom. 10. 14. but by the contrary, we ask a warrant from the Testament of Christ, that now since the Apostles are not in the Earth, private men not sent to preach, should be ordinary Fishers of men, and gatherers of Christs church and Kingdom. 2. That Christ hath provided no Pastors nor Teachers to watch over the Elect, yet remaining in the Kingdom of darkness, and that Christ ascending on high, as a victorious King hath not given Pastors and Teachers by office to bring in his redeemed flock, which he hath bought with his blood, Acts 20. 28. 3. It is against the nature of the visible Kingdom of Christ which is a d•aw-net and an offici••, a workhouse of external calling into Christ, even such as are serving their honour, buying a Farm; and their gain, buying five yoke of Oxen; and their lusts, having married a Wife. Luk. 14. 16, 17 18. 4. It is against the nature of the Ministry, and Wisdoms maids, sent out to compel them to come in. Luke 14. 23. Matthew 22. 4, 5, 6. Prov. 9. 2, 3, 4, 5. who are yet without.
The proposition is sure, these whom God purposeth to convert by making them Church-members, they are not Church-members because they are already converted. I prove the assumption, because. 1. The contrary doctrine, to wit, that none are under a pastors care till they be first converted, maketh to the eversion of the publick Ministery, and gratifieth Arminians and Socinians, as before I observed, because Faith commeth not by hearing of sent pastors, as Gods ordinance is, Rom. 10. 14. but by the contrary, we aske a warrant from the Testament of Christ, that now since the Apostles are not in the Earth, private men not sent to preach, should be ordinary Fishers of men, and gatherers of Christs church and Kingdome. 2. That Christ hath provided no Pastors nor Teachers to watch over the Elect, yet remaining in the Kingdome of darknesse, and that Christ ascending on high, as a victorious King hath not given Pastors and Teachers by office to bring in his redeemed flock, which he hath bought with his blood, Acts 20. 28. 3. It is against the nature of the visible Kingdome of Christ which is a d•aw-net and an offici••, a workehouse of externall calling into Christ, even such as are serving their honour, buying a Farme; and their gaine, buying five yoke of Oxen; and their lusts, having married a Wife. Luk. 14. 16, 17 18. 4. It is against the nature of the Ministery, and Wisdomes maides, sent out to compell them to come in. Luke 14. 23. Matthew 22. 4, 5, 6. Prov. 9. 2, 3, 4, 5. who are yet without.
7. If none can be members while they be first converted. 1. The church visible is made a church visible without the Ministry of the church. 2. These who are baptized are not by baptism entered in the visible Church contrary to Gods Word, 1 Cor. 12. 13. and the sound judgement of all Divines. 3. All these who are baptized. 2. Who write as Doctors for the defence ⟨p. 255⟩of the Orthodox Faith. 3. Who seal the Truth with their sufferings and blood. 4. Who keep communion with visible Churches, in hearing, partaking of the Word and Seals, as occasion serveth, if they be not professedly and notoriously to the consciences of a particular parish converted to Christ, are no members of the visible church.
7. If none can be members while they be first converted. 1. The church visible is made a church visible without the Ministery of the church. 2. These who are baptized are not by baptisme entered in the visible Church contrary to Gods Word, 1 Cor. 12. 13. and the sound judgement of all Divines. 3. All these who are baptized. 2. Who write as Doctors for the defence ⟨p. 255⟩of the Orthodox Faith. 3. Who seale the Truth with their sufferings and blood. 4. Who keepe communion with visible Churches, in hearing, partaking of the Word and Seales, as occasion serveth, if they be not professedly and notoriously to the consciences of a particular parish converted to Christ, are no members of the visible church.
8. All our Brethren's arguments to prove this Doctrine do only prove the truly regenerate to be members of the invisible Church, and not of the visible Church. And if the arguments be naught, the conclusion must be naught and false.
8. All our Brethrens arguments to prove this Doctrine doe onely prove the truly regenerate to be members of the invisible Church, and not of the visible Church. And if the arguments bee naught, the conclusion must bee naught and false.
9. It is against the Doctrine of Fathers, as aAugustine bCyprian cGregorius dChrysostom eNazianzen fEusebius. Who all accord that the visible church is a company of professors, consisting of good and bad, like the Ark of Noah as gHierome maketh comparison.
9. It is against the Doctrine of Fathers, as aAugustine bCyprian cGregorius dChysostome eNazianzen fEusebius. Who al accord that the visible church is a company of professors, consisting of good and bad, like the Arke of Noah as gHierome maketh comparison.
- aAugustin. contr. Crescom. l. 1. 6. 29 de baptis. l. 7. c. 51. contr. donati•. coll. 20.
- bCyprian. l. Eph. 6.Cyprian•. l. Eph. 6.
- cGregror. hom. 11, 12 & 35. in evang.
- dChrysost. in Psal. 39. & l. 3. de sacerd.
- eNazianzen, orat. 1. in Julia.
- fEusebius de • praep. evang. l. 6. c. 18.
- gHierom contr. Pelag. & Luciser. dialog.
I might cite Ireneus, Tertullian, Origen, Cyrillus, Basilius, Hilarius, Prosper, Ambrosius, Primasius, Sedulius, Just. Martyr, Clemens Alexandrinus, Euthymius, Theophylact, Epiphanius, Theodoret, and Luther, Melanchthon, Chemnitius, Meisnerus, Hunius, Hemingius, Gerardus, Crocius, Calvin, Beza, Voetius, Sadeel, Plesseus, Whittakerus, Joannes White, Fransc. White, Reynoldus, Ivellus, Rich. Feildus, Perkinsius, Pau. Baynes, Trelcatius, Tilenus, Piscator, Ursinus, Paraeus, Sibrandus, Professors Leydenses, Antonius Wallaeus, And. Rivetus, Pet. Molineus, Dam. Tossanus, Mercorus, Fest. Hommius, Bullingerus, Mnsculus, Rollocus, Davenantius, Mortonus.
I might cite Ireneus, Tertullian, Origen, Cyrillus, Basilius, Hilarius, Presper, Ambrosius, Primasius, Sedulius, Just. Martyr, Clemens Alexandrinus, Euthymius, Theophylact, Epiphanius, Theodoret, and Luther, Melanchton, Chemnitius, Meisnerus, Hunius, Hemingius, Gerardus, Crocius, Calvin, Beza, Voetius, Sadeel, Plesseus, Whittakerus, Ioannes Whyte, Fransc. Whyte, Reynoldus, Iuellus, Rich. Feildus, Perkinsius, Pau. Baynes, Trelcatius, Tilenus, Piscator, Ursinus, Paraeus, Sibrandus, Professores Leydenses, Antonius Wallaeus, And. Rivetus, Pet. Molineus, Dam. Tossanus, Mercorus, Fest. Hommius, Bullingerus, Mnsculus, Rollocus, Davenantius, Mortonus.