Answ. This argument proveth that the visible Church is not a visible Church, except it consist of only holy and gracious persons, without any mixture; and so not only holiness in profession, but holiness real and before God is required essentially to a visible Church. Then Pastors, Doctors and Professors, binding and loosing, clave non errante, are not a visible Church. Yea, this is down right Anabaptism that no visible Churches are on Earth, but such as consist of real Saints only. 2. It is most ignorantly reasoned, that God in creating Man and Angels good, did not intend that they should fall by his permission, but that they should continue holy and then God was frustrated of his end, as Arminians and Socinians Teach. So saith aArminius Antiperk. bCorvinus. The Remonstrants ⟨p. 259⟩cat Dort, and dSocinus, that God intendeth and purposeth many things which never come to pass. 2. His Decrees fail and are changed. 3. Men may make Gods Decrees of election fast and sure, or loose and unsure, as they please. 3. Here is much ignorance that God intendeth nothing that may be against the glory of obedience due to him, as Law-giver; as if sinners and hypocrites being in the Church because they are dishonourable to God, should cross Gods end, and purpose: so Tertullian ebringeth in some whom he calleth dogs, thus reasoning against providence, which suffereth sin to be in the World so contrary to his Will and goodness: And who denieth but Christ commanded Judas to preach, and that the Apostles according to Gods Will and Commandment received Ananias, Sapphira, Simon Magus in the visible Church by baptizing them (for I hope the Apostles sinned not against Gods revealed Will in admitting them to the visible Church.) And shall we say that God directly in that crosseth himself and his own ends, because God gathered hypocrites into his Church, and yet they dishonour and blaspheme the Name of God? Whiles Robinson saith, Gods main end in gathering a visible Church is, that they being separated ffrom the World, may glorify his Name, he speaketh gross Arminianism, that God faileth in his ends. Lastly, he saith that God cannot will that persons notoriously wicked should be in his visible Church, for then he should cross himself and his own ends advert (notoriously) is vainly added, seeing we teach that notoriously wicked ought to be cast out of the visible Church;
Answ. This argument proveth that the visible Church is not a visible Church, except it consist of onely holy and gratious persons, without any mixture; and so not only holinesse in profession, but holinesse reall and before God is required essentially to a visible Church. Then Pastors, Doctors and Professors, binding and loosing, clave non errante, are not a visible Church. Yea, this is downe right Anabaptisme that no visible Churches are on Earth, but such as consist of reall Saints only. 2. It is most ignorantly reasoned, that God in creating Man and Angells good, did not intend that they should fall by his permission, but that they should continue holy and then God was frustrated of his end, as Arminians and Socinians Teach. So sayth aArminius Antiperk. bCorvinus. The Remonstrants ⟨p. 259⟩cat Dort, and dSocinus, that God intendeth and purposeth many things which never come to passe. 2. His Decrees faile and are changed. 3. Men may make Gods Decrees of election fast and sure, or loose and unsure, as they please. 3. Here is much ignorance that God intendeth nothing that may be against the glory of obedience due to him, as Law-giver; as if sinners and hypocrites being in the Church because they are dishonorable to God, should crosse Gods end, and purpose: so Tertullian ebringeth in some whom he calleth dogges, thus reasoning against providence, which suffereth sinne to be in the World so contrary to his Will and goodnesse: And who denieth but Christ commanded Judas to preach, and that the Apostles according to Gods Will and Cammandement received Ananias, Saphira, Simon Magus in the visible Church by baptizing them (for I hope the Apostles sinned not against Gods revealed Will in admitting them to the visible Church.) And shall we say that God directly in that crosseth himselfe and his own ends, because God gathered hypocrites into his Churcch, and yet they dishonour and blaspheme the Name of God? Whiles Robinson saith, Gods maine end in gathering a visible Church is, that they being separated ffrom the World, may glorifie his Name, he speaketh grosse Arminianisme, that God faileth in his ends. Lastly, he saith that God cannot will that persons notoriously wicked should be in his visible Church, for then he should crosse himselfe and his owne ends advert (notoriously) is vainely added, seeing we teach that notoriously wicked ought to be cast out of the visible Church;
- aArm. Antip. p. 60.
- bCorvinus ep. ad Wallachros p. 19.
- cRemonst. in script. Synod. art. 2. p. 256. in apolog. c. 9. sol. 105.
- dSocinus contra puticum. c: 10 sol. 32•.
- eTertullian contra Marcionem. O ca•es &c. Si Deus bonus & praescius futuri & potens, cur hominem possus est lahi?
- fRobins. p. 98.